Do Nuclear Star Clusters and Supermassive Black Holes Follow the Same Host-Galaxy Correlations?
Table 1
Galaxies with well-determined SMBH masses.
Name
Source
Total (err)
Bulge (err)
(Mpc)
Milky way
4
0.01
6.63 (+0.03, −0.04)
1
10.74 (0.09)
10.00 (0.13)
M31
3
0.77
8.15 (+0.22, −0.10)
2
10.92 (0.06)
10.27 (0.21)
M32
−5
0.79
6.45 (+0.08, −0.10)
3
9.00 (0.06)
9.00 (0.06)
NGC524
−1
23.3
8.92 (+0.04, −0.02)
4
11.14 (0.09)
10.42 (0.12)
NGC821
−5
23.4
7.92 (+0.15, −0.23)
5
10.84 (0.08)
10.84 (0.08)
NGC1023
−1
11.1
7.62 (+0.04, −0.04)
6
10.85 (0.08)
10.42 (0.09)
NGC1068
3
14.3
6.90 (+0.14, −0.21)
7
11.22 (0.49)
10.71 (0.50)
NGC1300
4
18.9
7.82 (+0.29, −0.29)
8
10.74 (0.37)
9.86 (0.37)
NGC1316
−5
21.3
8.23 (+0.10, −0.13)
9
11.66 (0.06)
11.66 (0.06)
NGC1399
−5
21.1
9.11 (+0.15, −0.29)
10
11.38 (0.06)
11.38 (0.06)
NGC2549
−2
12.3
7.15 (+0.02, −0.16)
4
10.21 (0.12)
9.88 (0.13)
NGC2748
4
23.1
7.64 (+0.25, −0.74)
8
10.43 (0.30)
9.80 (0.31)
NGC2787
−1
7.28
7.59 (+0.04, −0.06)
11
10.08 (0.15)
9.70 (0.22)
NGC3031
1
3.63
7.85 (+0.11, −0.07)
12
10.83 (0.06)
10.51 (0.07)
NGC3227
1
22.9
7.30 (+0.13, −0.35)
13
10.89 (0.11)
9.72 (0.13)
NGC3245
−1
20.3
8.30 (+0.10, −0.12)
14
10.72 (0.09)
10.38 (0.12)
NGC3368
2
10.5
6.88 (+0.09, −0.12)
15
10.75 (0.09)
9.91 (0.11)
NGC3377
−5
10.9
7.99 (+0.28, −0.05)
5
10.34 (0.06)
10.34 (0.06)
NGC3379
−5
10.3
8.00 (+0.20, −0.31)
5
10.77 (0.07)
10.77 (0.07)
NGC3384
−1
11.3
7.20 (+0.03, −0.05)
5
10.65 (0.08)
10.19 (0.10)
NGC3393
1
48.3
7.48 (+0.03, −0.03)
16
10.99 (0.15)
10.38 (0.16)
NGC3489
−1
11.7
6.76 (+0.04, −0.04)
15
10.43 (0.08)
10.08 (0.13)
NGC3585
−3
19.5
8.49 (+0.16, −0.09)
17
11.15 (0.09)
10.84 (0.19)
NGC3607
−5
22.2
8.11 (+0.13, −0.19)
17
11.15 (0.08)
11.15 (0.08)
NGC3608
−5
22.3
8.28 (+0.02, −0.16)
5
10.71 (0.08)
10.71 (0.08)
NGC3998
−2
13.7
8.34 (+0.27, −0.56)
18
10.58 (0.09)
10.22 (0.12)
NGC4026
−3
13.2
8.26 (+0.12, −0.09)
17
10.45 (0.12)
10.10 (0.13)
NGC4151
2
14.5
7.52 (+0.10, −0.56)
19
10.59 (0.13)
10.10 (0.15)
NGC4258
4
7.18
7.59 (+0.04, −0.04)
20
10.73 (0.08)
9.77 (0.26)
NGC4261
−5
30.8
8.70 (+0.08, −0.10)
21
11.33 (0.09)
11.33 (0.09)
NGC4291
−5
25.5
8.48 (+0.10, −0.57)
5
10.70 (0.14)
10.70 (0.14)
NGC4342
−1
16.7
8.52 (+0.20, −0.18)
22
10.09 (0.07)
9.80 (0.08)
NGC4374
−5
18.5
8.97 (+0.04, −0.04)
23
11.30 (0.06)
11.30 (0.06)
NGC4473
−5
15.3
8.04 (+0.13, −0.56)
5
10.76 (0.06)
10.76 (0.06)
NGC4486
−5
16.7
9.56 (+0.11, −0.14)
24
11.37 (0.06)
11.37 (0.06)
NGC4486A
−5
18.4
7.16 (+0.13, −0.25)
25
10.06 (0.06)
10.06 (0.06)
NGC4564
−3
15.9
7.77 (+0.02, −0.07)
5
10.48 (0.06)
10.24 (0.07)
NGC4649
−5
16.4
9.30 (+0.08, −0.15)
26
11.39 (0.06)
11.39 (0.06)
NGC4697
−5
12.5
8.26 (+0.05, −0.09)
5
10.90 (0.06)
10.90 (0.06)
NGC5077
−5
37.5
8.83 (+0.21, −0.23)
27
11.12 (0.19)
11.12 (0.19)
NGC5128
−5
3.42
7.64 (+0.06, −0.03)
28
10.75 (0.07)
10.75 (0.07)
NGC5252
−2
92.9
8.98 (+0.40, −0.27)
29
11.31 (0.09)
10.97 (0.11)
NGC5576
−5
24.8
8.20 (+0.09, −0.08)
17
10.90 (0.08)
10.90 (0.08)
NGC5845
−5
25.2
8.36 (+0.07, −0.41)
5
10.42 (0.15)
10.42 (0.15)
NGC6251
−5
95.9
8.73 (+0.12, −0.18)
30
11.80 (0.09)
11.80 (0.09)
NGC7052
−5
67.9
8.58 (+0.23, −0.22)
31
11.49 (0.12)
11.49 (0.12)
NGC7457
−1
12.9
6.53 (+0.12, −0.23)
5
10.19 (0.10)
9.32 (0.13)
IC1459
−5
28.4
9.38 (+0.05, −0.04)
32
11.44 (0.12)
11.44 (0.12)
IC4296
−5
53.2
9.15 (+0.06, −0.07)
33
11.70 (0.08)
11.70 (0.08)
A1836-BCG
−5
155.6
9.55 (+0.05, −0.06)
33
11.65 (0.07)
11.65 (0.07)
(1) Galaxy name. (2) Hubble type from RC3. (3) Adopted distance in Mpc. (4) Logarithm of SMBH mass and uncertainties; masses have been rescaled using the distances column 2, if necessary. Uncertainties are 1- values. (5) Source of SMBH measurement. (6) Logarithm of total galaxy stellar mass and uncertainty (see text for details). (7) Logarithm of bulge stellar mass and uncertainty, based on 2D decompositions in Erwin and Gadotti (2012b, in prep).
