Research Article

Study on Similarity among Indian Languages Using Language Verification Framework

Table 1

Average EER values of verification systems of 16 languages using the four systems (sec = second).

Language MFCC + SDC + GMM MFCC + SDC + SVM SFCC + SDC + GMM SFCC + SDC + SVM
3 sec 10 sec 30 sec 3 sec 10 sec 30 sec 3 sec 10 sec 30 sec 3 sec 10 sec 30 sec

Assamese 28.17 17.43 15.97 23.63 14.20 4.77 24.37 22.20 22.73 18.73 7.47 1.83
Bengali 12.73 7.43 3.30 20.00 10.73 6.57 9.63 4.03 0.00 23.30 7.07 2.93
English 15.60 8.53 9.63 28.70 17.07 6.37 11.10 4.03 5.83 32.93 14.90 6.73
Gujarati 34.37 29.63 29.63 40.73 30.73 28.53 34.90 28.53 29.63 35.97 26.70 20.00
Hindi 29.27 23.67 23.10 26.33 25.80 26.33 21.83 18.37 16.70 27.07 26.17 24.37
Kannada 16.53 11.83 10.00 17.07 5.83 4.93 19.83 14.37 14.90 18.53 10.00 7.80
Kashmiri 22.93 10.00 2.93 16.53 3.67 2.20 19.47 3.63 1.47 19.10 4.40 1.83
Konkani 24.00 29.27 36.33 21.83 14.37 10.00 19.80 23.63 31.10 20.00 11.10 4.93
Malayalam 25.07 25.07 22.73 30.37 23.83 14.53 25.80 23.63 21.80 29.63 25.80 15.43
Marathi 28.17 28.53 27.80 28.00 21.10 17.07 25.27 28.90 23.83 30.37 18.53 18.53
Odia 30.73 26.17 24.73 26.33 13.67 8.90 38.17 27.80 26.53 28.53 22.93 12.73
Punjabi 18.53 13.80 7.43 32.90 28.90 26.73 21.83 16.17 12.20 36.90 29.27 30.00
Sanskrit 26.70 24.53 22.53 27.80 17.27 11.47 22.37 18.53 14.90 24.20 19.27 11.83
Tamil 19.10 10.73 7.80 33.63 29.83 21.63 18.73 10.37 8.17 30.00 26.17 21.10
Telugu 15.63 14.53 8.53 24.00 16.90 7.10 15.27 12.57 6.37 28.17 21.47 13.10
Urdu 30.00 33.43 21.47 38.37 38.90 28.90 37.80 41.47 27.07 37.80 43.63 34.90