- About this Journal
- Abstracting and Indexing
- Aims and Scope
- Annual Issues
- Article Processing Charges
- Articles in Press
- Author Guidelines
- Bibliographic Information
- Citations to this Journal
- Contact Information
- Editorial Board
- Editorial Workflow
- Free eTOC Alerts
- Publication Ethics
- Reviewers Acknowledgment
- Submit a Manuscript
- Subscription Information
- Table of Contents
Advances in Mechanical Engineering
Volume 2012 (2012), Article ID 863731, 7 pages
Numerical Model on Frost Height of Round Plate Fin Used for Outdoor Heat Exchanger of Mobile Electric Heat Pumps
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Dong-A University, 37 Nakdong-Daero 550beon-gil saha-gu, Busan 604-714, Republic of Korea
Received 30 October 2012; Accepted 27 November 2012
Academic Editor: Bo Yu
Copyright © 2012 Moo-Yeon Lee. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The objective of this study is to provide the numerical model for prediction of the frost growth of the round plate fin for the purpose of using it as a round plate fin-tube heat exchanger (evaporator) under frosting conditions. In this study, numerical model was considering the frost density change with time, and it showed better agreement with experimental data of Sahin (1994) than that of the Kim model (2004) and the Jonse and Parker model (1975). This is because the prediction on the frost height with time was improved by using the frost thermal conductivity reflecting the void fraction and density of ice crystal with frost growth. Therefore, the developed numerical model could be used for frosting performance prediction of the round plate fin-tube heat exchanger.
Frost formation and growth of the evaporator operated under frosting conditions are very essential phenomena because it acts as a thermal resistance with decreasing the frosting heat transfer performances in many refrigeration systems, air conditioning systems, and heat pump systems [1, 2]. Especially, numerous experimental and numerical studies on frosting and its growth have been reported for a long time. Padhmanabhan et al.  studied the semiempirical model to predict the nonuniform frost growth on fin-tube heat exchangers and validated with the experimental data. The considered fin configuration is rectangular type. Hong et al.  studied frost growth on louvered folded fins of microchannel heat exchangers. They provided several new data for frost growth on louvered fins and experimentally demonstrated the feasibility of the frost mass and frost height measurements. Xia and Jacobi  studied exact solution to steady heat conduction in a two-dimensional slab on a one-dimensional fin for the purpose of application to frosted heat exchangers. They mentioned that the exact solution is useful in gaining physical insights into the problem, and it is simple, accurate, and less costly to use than numerical solutions. Shao et al.  showed the comparison of heat pump performance using fin and tube and microchannel heat exchangers under frosting conditions. Lee et al.  studied the air-side heat transfer characteristics of spirally-coiled circular fin-tube heat exchanger operating under frosting conditions. They suggested the useful heat transfer correlation to predict the frosting heat transfer coefficient of the fin-tube heat exchanger. In summary, frosting including the frost height and growing is a key factor related to the previously mentioned thermal systems because it is a transient phenomenon and not easy to predict.
In these days, concerns of frosting performances of the round plate fin-tube heat exchanger in zero emission vehicles that do not use fossil fuels have been also increased because it considers as outdoor heat exchanger of the electric-driven heat pump system for cabin both heating and cooling. Lee et al.  studied experimentally frost height of round plate fin-tube heat exchangers under cold weather conditions for mobile heat pumps which have relatively large fin pitches. They mentioned that frosting problem is very important in adoption of the heat exchanger used in the electric-driven heat pump system for zero emission vehicles such as electric vehicles, fuel cell electric vehicles, and hybrid electric vehicles and So, the round plate fin-tube heat exchangers with large fin pitches might be used for zero emission. Also, Cho et al.  mentioned that the use of heat pumps instead of a PTC (positive temperature coefficient) heater is more effective for the longer driving ranges of the previously mentioned vehicles. However, there is a limited amount of data available on the frosting and its performance on the round plate fin. Therefore, the various studies for predictions of the frosting performances including frost height and growing are generally necessary for usages of the outdoor heat exchangers (especially, an evaporator) as applications in the zero emission vehicles.
In this respect, this study aims to predict the frosting behavior on round plate fin under cold weather conditions. The predicted result was then compared with the experimental data suggested by Lee et al. . In addition, the predicted data could be effectively used for designing the round plate fin-tube heat exchanger of the electric-driven heat pumps for zero emission vehicles.
2. Numerical Model
Figure 1 shows the schematic diagram of the round plate fin used in this study. The heat transfer rate on the frost was divided into the latent and sensible heat transfer as a function of the temperature and humidity ratio difference between the passing air and frost surface on the cold round plate fin. Based on the numerical modeling results of other researchers Jones and Parker , Kim , the heat and mass transfer rates were calculated by
However, they calculated with an assumption of a constant frost density on the frost with time. This assumption is unrealistic because the process of the frost growth on the cold plate was a very slow but unsteady process. So, it was treated in an unsteady state in this study. The density changes of the frost surface of the newly developed frost layer were considered with time. Namely, whenever a frost was transferred to a new environment, the continued frost growth assumed a new habit characteristic of the new conditions. The frost density of the newly developed frost layer was calculated from
In order to reflect the density changes of newly developed frost layer, the sublimation density of ice crystals was expressed like (3) as a function of crystal formation temperature, based on the experimental studies of Fukuta  and Miller and Young . The least squares approximation of the experimental data that is used for frost growth model is performed by Sahin . This is because the frost layer is assumed to be consisted of the several frost columns.
Frost columns also consist of ice crystals. The conductivity of frost columns () only is a function of the frost column density (). consider
Volumetric ratio () of the frost column considering the void fraction was expressed as functions of plate temperature, air temperature, and humidity ratio of moist air like (4) based on the experimental results of Sahin  as follows:
Equation (5) calculated the internal energy changes in control volume, as the humid air was changed into the frost crystal and a saturated air of the frost layer inside. As the humid air is infiltrated into the frost, a part of the humid air was used for formations of the new frost layer, and the rest of humid air was used to increase the densification of the previous frost layer. consider
Equation (6) indicated the energy transfer rate by the saturated humid air infiltrated into the previous frost layer as follows:
The diffusivity of water vapor in air () is calculated from (8), and thermal conductivity of the air-side can be approximated to (9) suggested by Tso et al.  and Pruppacher and Klett  as follows:
Thus, thermal conductivity of the frost layer can be expressed as (10) suggested by Sahin . The first term is the effect of the diffusion and sublimation of water vapor in the frost layer. This term is apparently a function of temperature; therefore, the contribution of this term to the frost thermal conductivity varies with the location in the frost layer. The second and third terms are the thermal conductivity contributions of the frost column and the moist air around the frost columns, respectively, as mentioned in Sahin . Consider where is the partial pressure of water vapor at .
In order to calculate the heat transfer coefficient of the round plate fin-tube heat exchanger, (11) is used because the flow pattern between the fins could be considered as an internal flow . Thus, (11) for an internal flow is the modified form of the heat transfer coefficient suggested by Holman , and the mass transfer rate is calculated by (12)  as follows: Therefore, the heat transfer rate through frost layer and mass transfer rate inside the frost layer were calculated, then surface temperature and density of new developed frost layer were finally calculated. Figure 2 shows the block diagram of the frost growth model in this study. As Step 1 was converged with Step 2, surface temperature and density of new developed frost layer were calculated.
3. Results and Discussion
The developed numerical model reflects the various environmental parameters and unsteady processes of the frost formation and growth. Especially, the density changes of the newly developed frost layer were considered with time reflecting a new habit characteristic of the new conditions whenever a frost was transferred to a new environment. These points make the present numerical model more realistic than the existing numerical model for prediction of the frost growth.
3.1. Numerical Results
The present numerical model on frosting prediction was compared with Jones and Parker model , the experimental data of Sahin , and the Kim model [11, 22]. The present model showed a similar prediction to those of other models for the beginning of the frost formation but better agreement with the experimental data during the processing of the frost growth with time than the other models. The Jones and Parker model  has been the most commonly used frost growth model until now. However, the Jones and Parker model makes an important assumption to simplify the development of the model. There was assumed to be no spatial variation of frost density even though it varies with time. Accordingly, their model did not consider density changes on the frost surface with frost growth. The Kim model [11, 22] considered the frost thermal conductivity with frost density changes with frost growth. This model made good predictions at the beginning of the frost formation but not so good predictions as the frost growth progressed. The present numerical model considered the frost thermal conductivity according to the humidity ratio, surface temperature, density change, and void fraction of the frost surface with time. This will be shown to make good predictions for the frost growth.
Figure 3 shows the comparisons of the present model with experimental data provided by Sahin , the Jones and Parker model , and the Kim model [11, 22] under specified conditions with an air temperature of 18.0°C, plate temperature of −28.0°C, air velocity of 2.1 m/s, and humidity ratio of 0.007 kg/. The newly developed model in this study showed better agreement with the experimental data of Sahin  than the Kim model [11, 22], which considered the frost thermal conductivity as a function of the frost density, as well as the Jones and Parker model , which assumed the frost density to be constant with time.
Generally, fin configuration and space of the outdoor heat exchanger used in heat pump system for zero emission vehicles such as hybrid electric vehicles, electric vehicles, and fuel cell electric vehicles should be simple and large because of the frosting problem and easy defrosting water disposal. So, the round plate fin configuration is a good option to adapt as an outdoor heat exchanger for mobile electric heat pumps as mentioned in Lee et al. .
3.2. Validation with Experimental Data of Lee et al. 
The predicted data using numerical model were compared with the experimental results obtained using a round fin-tube heat exchanger suggested by Lee et al. . Figure 4 shows the comparisons between the numerical data and the experimental data for frost height of the round fin-tube heat exchanger with a fin space of 10.0 mm. It is simulated under an ethylene glycol-water mixture inlet temperature of −15.0°C, air flow rate of 1.0 m3/min, air temperature of 5.0°C, and relative humidity of 70.0%. The considered fin-tube specifications are expressed in Table 1. Table 1 shows the simulation conditions and specifications of the considered heat exchanger.
The numerical result was validated against the experimental result; both results matched on average to within −3.4%. The numerical data is underpredicted on average 5.8% at first 40 minutes and then overpredicted on average −7.9% after 40 minutes. The frost height predicted from numerical model showed good agreement with the experimental data during the first 40 minutes because the air flow rate was almost unchanged with frost growth. Moreover, the boundary layer interruption between the fins theoretically did not occur until the frost height on the fin surface reached 2.0 mm. However, the agreement between the numerical data and the experimental data after the frost height reached 2.0 mm at 40 minutes showed a slight difference because the numerical model did not consider the boundary layer interruption and pressure drop increase between the fins with frost growth. Based on the theoretical results of the boundary layer analysis using the techniques of Lee  and Mon and Gross , the velocity boundary layer thickness on one side of the fin surface was approximately 3.5 mm at the fin diameter of 23.0 mm with the tube diameter of 8.2 mm. Therefore, boundary layer interruption between fins can occur theoretically for a fin space of 7.0 mm at an air flow rate of 1.0 m3/min. That is, the boundary layer interruption for a fin space of more than 7.0 mm can be avoided under the given conditions because the boundary layer interruption is largely dependent on the fin space .
This is consistent with the results of Kim . The error on frost height between experimental data and numerical data is decreased as boundary layer interruption in the fins is considered with time. Namely, based on his results, errors between numerical data and experimental data were on average 1.4% with boundary layer interruption but were on average 5.5% without boundary layer interruption. In addition, in our next work, the effects of frost height on boundary layer interruption between the fins with frost growth will be studied because the boundary layer thickness and interruption are important factors in the design of heat exchangers.
The frost height and growing on the round plate fin, which could be used as the outdoor heat exchanger of an electric-driven heat pump in zero emission vehicles, were numerically predicted and validated with the published experimental data. The fundamental equation used for the calculation of the heat and mass transfer rate was simple enough to minimize the iteration time. This feature is important when numerical model is used for designing heat exchangers for low temperature heat pumps under cold weather conditions. The present model showed better predictions than the Jones and Parker model  and the Kim model [11, 22] for the frost height and growing with time. The following points summarize the current study.(1) The present model developed in this study considered the frost thermal conductivity with the humidity ratio, surface temperature, density change, and void fraction of the frost surface with time.(2) The frost height for 10.0 mm of fin space showed a similar rate of increase during the 40 minutes because the boundary layer interruption theoretically did not occur for a fin space of during the tests.(3) The frost height predicted by using the frost growth model showed good agreement with published experiment data suggested by Lee et al. . This is because the prediction of the frost height with time was improved by using an expression for the frost thermal conductivity that reflects the variation of the void fraction and density of ice crystals with the frost growth.(4) The numerical result was validated against the experimental result; both results matched on average to within −3.4% during the tests.
|Surface area ()|
|:||Area of frost column ()|
|:||Area of air ()|
|:||Thermal diffusivity in air (/s)|
|:||Hydraulic diameter (mm) ()|
|:||Tube diameter (m)|
|:||Mass flux (kg/ s)|
|:||Heat transfer coefficient (W/ K)|
|:||Mass transfer coefficient (kg/ s)|
|:||Heat transfer coefficient of frost layer (W/ K)|
|:||Enthalpy of the frost crystal (kJ/kg)|
|:||Air enthalpy (kJ/kg)|
|:||Saturated air enthalpy of the frost layer inside (kJ/kg)|
|:||Latent heat of vapor (kJ/kg)|
|:||Thermal conductivity of the air (W/m K)|
|:||Thermal conductivity of the frost column (W/m K)|
|:||Thermal conductivity of the frost layer (W/m K)|
|:||Core depth or appropriate characteristic length (mm)|
|:||Mass flux (kg/ s)|
|:||Atmospheric pressure (kPa)|
|:||Partial pressure of the water vapor at (kPa)|
|:||Reynolds number based on the tube diameter ()|
|:||Gas constant (J/Kg K)|
|:||Schmidt number ()|
|:||Crystal formation temperature ()|
|:||Air temperature ()|
|:||Plate temperature ()|
|:||Surface temperature ()|
|:||Wall temperature ()|
|:||Dynamic viscosity coefficient (N s/)|
|:||Humidity ratio of the moist air (kg/)|
|:||Humidity ratio of the air at the frost surface (kg/)|
|:||Frost layer height (m)|
|:||Volumetric ratio of frost columns considering void fraction|
|:||Frost layer density (kg/)|
|:||Density of the air (kg/)|
|:||Sublimation density of the frost crystal (kg/).|
This work was supported by the Dong-A University research fund (2012).
- W. M. Yan, H. Y. Li, Y. J. Wu, J. Y. Lin, and W. R. Chang, “Performance of finned tube heat exchangers operating under frosting conditions,” International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 46, no. 5, pp. 871–877, 2003.
- M. Lee, T. Kang, and Y. Kim, “Air-side heat transfer characteristics of spiral-type circular fin-tube heat exchangers,” International Journal of Refrigeration, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 313–320, 2010.
- S. K. Padhmanabhan, D. E. Fisher, L. Cremaschi, and E. Moallem, “Modeling non-uniform frost growth on a fin-and-tube heat exchanger,” International Journal of Refrigeration, vol. 34, no. 8, pp. 2018–2030, 2011.
- T. Hong, L. Cremaschi, E. Moaellem, and D. E. Fisher, “Measurements of frost growth on louvered folded fins of microchannel heat exchangers part 1: experimental methodology,” ASHRAE Transactions, vol. 118, no. 1, pp. 1101–1115, 2012.
- Y. Xia and A. M. Jacobi, “An exact solution to steady heat conduction in a two-dimensional slab on a one-dimensional fin: application to frosted heat exchangers,” International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 47, no. 14–16, pp. 3317–3326, 2004.
- L. L. Shao, L. Yang, and C. L. Zhang, “Comparison of heat pump performance using fin-and-tube and microchannel heat exchangers under frost conditions,” Applied Energy, vol. 87, no. 4, pp. 1187–1197, 2010.
- M. Lee, T. Kang, Y. Joo, and Y. Kim, “Heat transfer characteristics of spirally-coiled circular fin-tube heat exchangers operating under frosting conditions,” International Journal of Refrigeration, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 328–336, 2011.
- M. Y. Lee, Y. Kim, and D. Y. Lee, “Experimental study on frost height of round plate fin-tube heat exchangers for mobile heat pumps,” Energies, vol. 5, no. 9, pp. 3479–3491, 2012.
- C. W. Cho, H. S. Lee, J. P. Won, and M. Y. Lee, “Measurement and evaluation of heating performance of heat pump systems using wasted heat from electric devices for an electric bus,” Energies, vol. 5, pp. 658–669, 2012.
- B. W. Jones and J. D. Parker, “Frost formation with varying environmental parameters,” Journal of Heat Transfer, vol. 97, no. 2, pp. 255–259, 1975.
- Y. H. Kim, Study on the frosting and defrosting performance of finned tube heat exchangers [Ph.D. thesis], Korea University, 2004.
- N. Fukuta, “Experimental studies on the growth of small ice crystals,” Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, vol. 26, pp. 521–531, 1969.
- T. L. Miller and K. C. Young, “A numerical simulation of ice crystal growth from the vapor phase,” Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, vol. 36, pp. 458–469, 1979.
- A. Z. Sahin, “Effective thermal conductivity of frost during the crystal growth period,” International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 43, no. 4, pp. 539–553, 2000.
- A. Z. Sahin, “An experimental study on the initiation and growth of frost formation on a horizontal plate,” Experimental Heat Transfer, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 101–119, 1994.
- C. T. Sanders, The influence of frost formation and defrosting on the performance of air coolers [Ph.D. thesis], Delft Technical University, 1974.
- C. P. Tso, Y. C. Cheng, and A. C. K. Lai, “An improved model for predicting performance of finned tube heat exchanger under frosting condition, with frost thickness variation along fin,” Applied Thermal Engineering, vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 111–120, 2006.
- H. R. Pruppacher and J. D. Klett, “Microphysics of clouds and precipitation,” Nature, vol. 284, no. 5751, p. 88, 1980.
- Y. Kim and Y. Kim, “Heat transfer characteristics of flat plate finned-tube heat exchangers with large fin pitch,” International Journal of Refrigeration, vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 851–858, 2005.
- J. P. Holman, Heat Transfer, McGraw-Hill, Berkshire, UK, 7th edition, 1992.
- F. P. Incropera and D. P. DeWitt, Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, USA, 4th edition, 1996.
- Y. H. Kim, Study on the frosting and defrosting performance of finned tube heat exchangers [Ph.D. thesis], Korea University, 2004.
- M. Y. Lee, Heat and mass transfer characteristics of a spirally-coiled circular fin-tube heat exchanger [Ph.D. thesis], Korea University, 2010.
- M. S. Mon and U. Gross, “Numerical study of fin-spacing effects in annular-finned tube heat exchangers,” International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 47, no. 8-9, pp. 1953–1964, 2004.
- H. Lee, M. Lee, Y. Kim, and Y. Kim, “Air-side heat transfer characteristics of flat plate finned-tube heat exchangers with large fin pitches under frosting conditions,” International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 53, no. 13-14, pp. 2655–2661, 2010.