Table 5: Significant values for load and strain at ultimate state.

Ultimate loadStrain at ultimate load
ColumnMeasuredAverageRatioMeasuredAverage
(kN)(kN)( )( ) Ratio
-

ControlM1555.1558.012079.12013.2
M2560.91947.2 1

G-D-D1-1513.9513.90.9213121312.00.65
G-D-D1-2554.1554.10.992235.52235.51.11
Repaired (ground)G-D-D2-1518.7518.70.931466.71466.70.73
G-D-D2-2544.3544.30.982223.32223.31.10
G-D-F-D1-1567.8568.81.022740.52798.6
G-D-F-D1-2569.82856.6 1.39
G-D-F-D2-1551.1549.20.982211.12235.3
G-D-F-D2-2547.22259.5 1.11

U-W-F-D1-1514.8517.80.931899.91875.4
U-W-F-D1-2520.71850.9 0.93
U-W-F-D2-1527.6529.60.951851.81851.4
U-W-F-D2-2531.51850.9 0.92
U-D-F-D1-1N.A.519.80.93N.A.2115.3
Repaired (underwater)U-D-F-D1-2519.82115.3 1.05
U-D-F-D2-1506509.50.912139.32164.3
U-D-F-D2-2512.92189.3 1.08
U-D,S-F-D1-1578.6564.91.012319.22409.6
U-D,S-F-D1-2551.12499.9 1.20
U-D,S-F-D2-1567.8565.41.012043.22091.3
U-D,S-F-D2-2562.92139.3 1.04