Research Article

A Proxy Outcome Approach for Causal Effect in Observational Studies: A Simulation Study

Table 3

Effect of on and based on the fact model, conventional approach, and the alternative approach.

Fact modelConventional approach Alternative approach (%)
causal to A but not B (%) causal to A and B (%) causal to A but not B (%) causal to A and B (%)

causal to A but not B 93 (18.6%)394 (78.8%)347 (69.4%)140 (28.0%)
causal to A and B 1 (0.2%)12 (2.4%)4 (0.8%)9 (1.8%)