Review Article

Confocal Laser Endomicroscopy in Gastrointestinal and Pancreatobiliary Diseases: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 2

Summary of the studies applying CLE for gastric and duodenal lesion screening and diagnosis (“per biopsy” analysis or “per patient” analysis).

Author and yearCountryMean age or range Sensitivity (%)Specificity (%)PPV (%)NPV (%)Accuracy (%)Main findings

Polyps and neoplastic lesions of the stomach
Kakeji et al. 2006 [37]Japan 9 patientsn/a n/an/an/an/an/aCLE could be a new screening tool for early detection of malignancy.
Kitabatake et al. 2006 [38]Japan 27 patients7081.897.6 n/an/a97.4CLE may allow virtual biopsy in the future with more stable imaging condition.
Liu et al. 2008 [39]China24 patientsn/a n/an/an/an/an/aCLE observations of vascular architecture may be assistant in the identification of early gastroesophageal cancer.
Gheorghe et al. 2009 [40]Romania11 patients 59.7n/an/an/an/an/aCLE and endoscopic ultrasound are successfully associated for histological assessment, disease staging, and optimal therapeutic decision.
Banno et al. 2010 [41]Japan29 patients 68.6 86.483.3n/an/a85The CLE diagnosis of the mucin phenotype in gastric cancers was limited to intestinal and mixed phenotypes but may be useful for the diagnosis of mucin phenotype and differential diagnosis.
Li et al. 2010 [42]China66 patients 17–81 n/an/an/an/a90CLE demonstrates high accuracy of differentiating hyperplastic polyps and adenomas.
Li et al. 2010 [43]China108 patients 5777.881.8n/an/an/aCLE is an acceptable and potentially useful technology for the identification and grading of gastric intraepithelial neoplasia in vivo. The diagnostic accuracy needs to be improved.
Jeon et al. 2011 [44]Korea31 patients61.6n/an/an/an/a94.2CLE demonstrates a high diagnostic accuracy for gastric epithelial neoplasia. The use of CLE could possibly reduce the number of unnecessary biopsies and mistaken diagnoses before endoscopic submucosal dissection.
Ji et al. 2011 [45]China24 patients61.2 10089.5n/an/a91.7CEL has high accuracy for prediction of remnant tissue after endoscopic mucosal resection and may lead to significant improvements in clinical surveillance after endoscopic resection.
Li et al. 2011 [46]China1572 patients58.1 88.999.385.399.598.8CLE can be used to identify gastric superficial cancer/HGIN lesions with high validity and reliability.
Lim et al. 2011 [47]China36 patients >5095.293.3n/an/an/aExperience in CLE was associated with greater accuracy in the diagnosis of gastric intestinal metaplasia.
Wang et al. 2012 [48]China59 patients 63.190.684.6n/an/a88CLE demonstrates high diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity for diagnostic classification of gastric intraepithelial neoplasia.
Bok et al. 2013 [49]Korea46 patients65.3n/an/an/an/a91.7pCLE can provide an accurate diagnosis for superficial gastric neoplasia, and it has the potential to compensate for the inherent limitations of a conventional endoscopic biopsy.

Gastritis and gastric metaplasia
Guo et al. 2008 [50]China53 patients
267 biopsies
51.2n/a
98.1
n/a
95.3
n/a
96.9
n/a
97.14
n/a
n/a
CLE is a useful and potentially important method for the diagnosis and classification of gastric intestinal metaplasia in vivo.
Ji et al. 2011 [51]China76 patients
145 biopsies
48.8n/a
86.2
n/a
97.4
n/a
89.3
n/a
96.6
n/a
92.8
CLE is useful for identifying gastric metaplasia. These findings could have potential applicability for duodenal screening and suggest a possible targeting therapy in functional dyspepsia.
Ji et al. 2012 [52] China42 patients50.4n/an/an/an/an/aCLE allows functional imaging of mucosal barrier defects. Gastric intestinal metaplasia is associated with an impaired paracellular barrier irrespective of H. pylori eradication.
Lim et al. 2013 [53]China20 patients
125 biopsies
62.5n/a
90.9
n/a
84.7
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
88
pCLE was superior to autofluorescence imaging and white-light endoscopy for diagnosing gastric intestinal metaplasia. Off-site review improved performance of pCLE.
Pittayanon et al. 2013 [54]Thailand 60 patients
120 biopsies
62.8n/a
96
n/a
90
n/a
86
n/a
97
n/a
92
Combining pCLE with magnifying flexible spectral imaging color enhancement (ME-FICE) provides high sensitivity and NPV for gastric intestinal metaplasia detection. The prompt histology reading by this technique may avoid unnecessary biopsy.
Li et al. 2014 [55]China 168 patients
492 biopsies
55n/a
91.6
n/a
96.7
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
CLE with targeted biopsies is superior to white-light endoscopy with standard biopsies for the detection and surveillance of gastric intestinal metaplasia. The number of biopsies needed to confirm gastric intestinal metaplasia is about one-third of that needed with white-light endoscopy with standard biopsies.
Liu et al. 2015 [56]China87 patients
130 biopsies
49.7n/a
91.9
n/a
96.8
n/a
90.4
n/a
97.3
n/a
95.6
CLE is reliable for real-time assessment of atrophic gastritis and is also able to differentiate metaplastic from nonmetaplastic atrophy.

Helicobacter pylori related gastritis
Ji et al. 2010 [57]China103 patients48.489.295.794.391.792.8CLE during endoscopy can accurately identify specific cellular and subcellular changes of the surface gastric mucosa induced by H. pylori infection.
Wang et al. 2010 [58]China118 patients 49.882.990.9n/an/an/aCLE can accurately show the histological severity of H. pylori infection-associated gastritis.

Duodenal inflammatory bowel disease
Lim et al. 2014 [59]Germany
Japan
UK
25 patientsn/an/an/an/an/an/aCLE can detect epithelial damage and barrier loss in the duodenum of Crohn’s Disease and Ulcerative Colitis patients that is not apparent on conventional endoscopy or histology.

Celiac disease
Leong et al. 2008 [60]Australia31 patients 419492n/an/an/aCLE can effectively diagnose and evaluate celiac disease severity in vivo with potential to improve endoscopy efficiency.
Günther et al. 2010 [61]Germany60 patients5773100n/an/an/aThe assessment of duodenal histology by CLE in patients with celiac disease is sensitive and specific in determining increased numbers of intraepithelial lymphocytes and villous atrophy but insufficient in respect of crypt hyperplasia. For routine use of CLE in patients with celiac disease, the technique would need to be improved.
Venkatesh et al. 2010 [62]UK19 patients 8.3510080 81n/an/aCEL offers the prospect of diagnosis of celiac disease during ongoing endoscopy. It also enables targeting biopsies to abnormal mucosa and thereby increasing the diagnostic yield, especially when villous atrophy is patchy in the duodenum.

stands for the number of patients enrolled in the study; n/a, not available or not applicable; pCLE, probe-based confocal laser endomicroscopy; CLE, confocal laser endomicroscopy; PPV, positive predictive value; NPV, negative predictive value; and BE, Barrett’s esophagus.