Research Article

[Retracted] A Comparison between Three-Dimensional Visualization Guided Hepatectomy and Ultrasonography Guided Radiofrequency Ablation in the Treatment of Small Hepatocellular Carcinoma within the Milan Criteria

Table 4

Overall survival and recurrence-free survival for patients in subgroups.

Subgroups5-year overall survival rate5-year recurrence-free survival
SR (n)RFA (n)p valueSRRFAp value

Solitary > 3 cm51.0% (39)38.4% (44)0.03143.2%26.7%0.037
Multiple tumors 38.8% (25)17.6% (34)0.02410.6%7.0%0.164
Solitary ≤ 3 cm92.6% (28)70.2% (24)0.02664.3%36.2%0.007
AFP < 400 μg/L73.6% (50)47.8% (60)0.00250.9%27.6%0.002
AFP ≥ 400 μg/L46.9% (42)28.5% (42)0.00826.8%14.4%0.027
Noncirrhosis67.7% (43)46.0% (53)0.00645.4%25.5%0.005
Cirrhosis55.4% (49)31.5% (49)0.00535.5%17.9%0.013
Child-Pugh A64.8% (69)45.2% (73)0.00242.3%25.5%0.002
Child-Pugh B49.9% (23)22.8% (29)0.03433.6%11.9%0.089
Age ≤ 60 years63.2% (77)36.8% (82)<0.00141.2%22.2%<0.001
Age > 60 years60.0% (15)51.0% (20)0.81435.6%22.9%0.709

AFP: α-fetoprotein.