Review Article

Progress in EEG-Based Brain Robot Interaction Systems

Table 1

Preprocessing methods in different EEG paradigms.

EEG paradigmsAuthorsPreprocessing methods

SSVEPBevilacqua et al. [66]2–60 Hz for band-pass filter, notch filter at 50 Hz
Müller-Putz and Pfurtscheller [21]0.5–30 Hz for band-pass filter, notch filter at 50 Hz
Ortner et al. [67]0.5–100 Hz for band-pass filter, notch filter at 50 Hz
Wu et al. [65]0.3–40 Hz for band-pass filter
Muller et al. [37]3–60 Hz for band-pass filter, CAR
Júnior et al. [68]CCA
Wang et al. [69]CCA
Zhang et al. [70]Multiset CCA
Nan et al. [71]MEC, CCA
Pouryazdian and Erfanian [72]PCA

P300Rakotomamonjy and Guigue [73]8-order, 0.1–10 Hz band-pass Chebyshev Type I filter
El Dabbagh and Fakhr [74]8 order, 0.1–20 Hz band-pass Chebyshev Type I filter
Mak et al. [75]0.5–30 Hz band-pass
Panicker et al. [38]3 order, 0.5–12 Hz Butterworth filter
Lugo et al. [76]0.1–30 Hz band-pass filter
Lotte et al. [77]25 Hz low-pass filter
Li et al. [25]1–10 Hz band-pass filter
Spüler et al. [78]0.5–16 Hz band-pass filter, CAR
Casagrande et al. [79]CAR
Syan and Harnarinesingh [80]10-order low-pass Hamming-window filter with 6 dB cutoff at 30 Hz, CAR, PCA

MIPark et al. [81]5-order, 8–30 Hz Butterworth filter
Coyle et al. [22]R2CA with a standard 8–26 Hz band
Wang et al. [82]FB (Filter Bank) with  Hz
Devlaminck et al. [83]A set of spatial filters
Ang et al. [84]FB
Li et al. [85]8–30 Hz band-pass filter
Yao et al. [29]8–26 Hz band-pass filter
Song et al. [39]4-order Butterworth IIR filter, Laplacian filter
Wu and Ge [86]CAR, FIR (Finite Impulse Response) filter
Zhou et al. [87]8–35 Hz band-pass filter, ICA
Sharma and Baron [88]PCA, tensor ICA
Bashar et al. [89]Autocorrelation