Review Article

Disinfection of the Access Orifice in NOTES: Evaluation of the Evidence Base

Table 1

Randomised controlled trials of methods of infection prevention for transgastric NOTES procedures.

StudySubjectInterventionControlClosureOutcome measuresConclusion

Ramamoorthy et al. [11] 30 ratsPPI prior to gastrotomyGastrotomyDirect suturedSerial WBC and CRP, day 14 necropsy and culture of peritoneumHigher rate of peritoneal contamination and abscess formation with PPI
Buck et al. [16]37 pigsNOTES with mesh placement following gastric irrigation with saline and antibioticsNOTES without mesh or endoscopy with PPI followed by laparoscopic mesh (both control groups with antibiotics and saline irrigation)Jumbo clipsDay 14 necropsy, gastric aspirate cultures36% NOTES mesh infection, significantly higher than laparoscopic mesh infection rate. No infection in NOTES-only control.
Giday et al. [14]16 pigsSystemic antibiotics and povidone-iodine gastric irrigation, NOTES liver biopsy or ovarian biopsyNOTES biopsies without antibiotics or irrigation using disinfected but nonsterile equipmentT-bar devicesDay 7 necropsy and cultures100% gross infection rate in control group, 0% in study group
McGee et al. [15]19 pigsHigh volume (6 L) saline or antibiotic gastric irrigation followed by NOTES peritoneoscopy and sterile foreign body placementNOTES peritoneoscopy with 50 mL saline irrigation, sterile foreign body placementPEGDay 14 necropsy, gastric aspirate culturesNo differences in rate of abscess, positive culture or foreign body infection rate
Eickhoff et al. [13]16 pigsPPI, oral and IV antibiotics, chlorhexidine and antibiotic irrigation, NOTES gallbladder exploration and tubal ligationSaline irrigation only, NOTES as in trial groupPlicator deviceDay 14 necropsy and cultures, serial WBC and CRP1/8 study group and 6/8 control positive cultures, significantly higher CFU load in control group

WBC: White blood cell count, CRP: C-reactive protein, PPI: proton pump inhibitor, PEG: percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy, CFU: colony forming units.