Review Article

The Reporting Quality of Acupuncture-Related Infections in Korean Literature: A Systematic Review of Case Studies

Table 1

Reporting status on the information of patients and adverse events (AEs) or complications related to acupuncture practice in the included studies.

Study IDInfection agents (numbers of the cases) Final diagnosisInclusion of acupuncture specialist among the authorsPatient’s informationAEs (or complications) information
Patient’s characteristicsPreceding conditions or reasons for seeking acupunctureDescription on the risk factors for AEs (or complications)Features of AEs (or complications)Clinical outcome (follow-up)Time relation between acupuncture and AEs (or complications)Laboratory or pathological findingsConsideration of the other possible causes of AEs (or complications)Explanation on the association between needling site and affected lesion

Bang and Lim 
2006 [25]
Escherichia coli (1)Psoas abscesses; epidural abscess; infectious spondylitis; sepsisNoneWDWDNDWDWDWDWDNDDE

Cho et al.
2003 [33]
Klebsiella pneumonia (1)Retroperitoneal abscessNoneWDDEDEWDWDWDWDDEND

Cho et al.
2010 [21]
Mycobacterium abscessus (1)Mycobacterium abscessus cutaneous infectionNoneWDNDDEWDWDDEWDDEND

Cho et al.
2015 [31]
Gemella morbillorum (1)Mediastinitis, osteomyelitisNoneWDWDDEWDWDWDWDWDND

Choi et al.
2013 [13]
Streptococcus intermedius (1)Pyogenic liver abscessNoneWDWDWDWDWDDEWDWDDE

Choi 2014 [17]Serratia liquefaciens complex and Staphylococcus intermedius (1)Cervical necrotizing fasciitisNoneWDWDNDWDWDWDWDWDWD

Ha et al.
1999 [30]
Bifidobacterium longum (1)SepsisNoneWDWDNDWDWDWDWDDEND

Ha and Kim
2003 [26]
No organism growth (1)Chronic inflammatory epidural granulomaNoneWDWDDEWDWDDEWDNDDE

Han et al.
2012 [18]
Staphylococcus aureus (1)Pericardial abscess; sepsisNoneDEWDDEWDWDWDWDDEND

Kang et al.
2012 [14]
Streptococcus pneumonia (1)Psoas abscess; diabetic foot ulcerNoneWDWDWDWDWDWDWDWDDE

Jung et al.
2011 [32]
Herpes simplex virus (1)Skin infectionNoneWDWDDEWDNDWDWDDEWD

Jung et al.
2014 [22]
Mycobacterium massiliense (1)Localized cutaneous infectionNoneWDWDNDWDWDDEWDDEDE

Kang and Jeong
2006 [15]
Streptococcus pyogenes (1)Necrotizing fasciitisNoneWDWDWDWDWDWDWDDEND

Kim et al.
2003 [35]
Spirochetes (1)Secondary syphilisNoneWDWDWDWDWDDEWDWDND

Kim et al.
2010 [23]
Mycobacterium tuberculosis (3)Primary inoculation tuberculosisNoneWDDEDEWDWDWDWDNDDE

J. W. Kim and
Y. S. Kim
2010 [27]
Unidentified (1)Psoas abscessNoneWDWDWDWDWDWDWDDEND

Kim et al.
2015 [29]
Actinomyces species (1)Abdominal wall actinomycosisNoneWDNDNDWDWDDEWDWDWD

Lee et al.
1994 [24]
Mycobacterium fortuitum (1)Cutaneous mycobacterial infection and abscessesNoneWDWDNDWDWDDEWDWDDE

Lee et al.
2008 [19]
Escherichia coli; MRSA (1)Necrotizing aortitisNoneWDNDDEWDWDDEWDNDDE

Lee et al.
2012 [28]
Unidentified (1)Cervical epidural abscessIncludedWDWDNDWDWDWDWDWDWD

Lim et al.
2013 [34]
Non-O1, Non-O139 Vibrio cholera (1)SepticemiaNoneWDWDWDWDWDWDWDDEND

Song et al.
2006 [16]
Streptococcus pyogenes (1)Necrotizing fasciitisNoneWDWDWDWDWDDEWDDEDE

Yu et al.
2013 [20]
Staphylococcus aureus (1)Multiple epidural abscessNoneDENDNDWDNDWDDENDDE

AEs: adverse events, MRSA: methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus, WD: well documented, DE: documented but not enough for the judgment, ND: not documented, and NA: not applicable; inclusion of acupuncture specialist among the authors was assessed based on the author’s affiliation.