Review Article

Excessive Daytime Sleepiness and Epilepsy: A Systematic Review

Table 1

Adult-based studies addressing EDS in PWE.

Author/place/yearStudy designPopulation InstrumentsFindings on EDS

Zanzmera et al.
India, 2012 [17]
Prospective cohort40 patients
(20 with refractory and 20 with controlled epilepsy)
Medical history;
sleep prestructured
questionnaire;
ESS; PSG.
ESS scores higher in The medically refractory group, but the number of patients with ESS > 10 was similar in both groups.
Average TST is shorter in the refractory group in contrast to self-reported sleep. Also this group had more abnormal arousals, sleep efficiency, and awakenings.
20% in the refractory group with AHI > 5 and none in the controlled group.

Zhou et al.
China, 2012 [27]
Prospective cohort11 patients
10 controls
Athens Insomnia Scale;
ESS; MSLT; PSG
Levetiracetam reduced TST and increased daytime sleepiness compared to baseline.
Reduced REM sleep on PSG.
Increase in ESS score but no changes in MSLT after levetiracetam treatment.

Krishnan et al.
India, 2012 [16]
Cross-sectional50 with JME, on VPA only, and 38 controlsMedical and family history and neurological examination.
EEG, neuroimaging;
ESS; PSQI; NIMHANS sleep disorders questionnaire.
ESS score 11 in 34% of patients.
PSQI score 6 in 48% of patients.
Mean ESS and PSQI scores significantly high in the JME group and a high prevalence of EDS and insomnia.

Chen et al. Taiwan, 2011 [15] Cross-sectional117 patients
30 controls
Medical record
ESS; PSQI.
ESS score 10 in 20% of patients and 7% of controls.
PSQI total scores were higher in patients (6.5 versus 3.7).
Patients had higher sleep latency (1.2 versus 0.6).

Giorelli et al.
Brazil, 2011 [19]
Cross-sectional99 patientsMedical record;
BNSQ; ESS;
Beck Depression and Anxiety Inventory.
Prevalence of EDS (ESS > 10) was 47.5% and showed relationship with anxiety and neck circumference.

Venturi et al. Brazil, 2011 [20]Cross-sectional98 patientsMedical record;
Berlin clinical questionnaire;
ESS; Beck Depression and Anxiety Inventory.
Patients with epilepsy have a high risk of obstructive sleep apnea (55 %) which is related to neck circumference, anxiety, arterial hypertension, and high body mass index.

Carrion et al. Brazil, 2010 [34]Prospective cohort48 patients
43 controls
Seizure frequency scale;
ESS; PSQI.
PSQI was high before epilepsy surgery and decreased after the procedure. ESS scores reduced after surgery, but no score was in the pathological range.
TLE patients have poor subjective sleep quality that improves after epilepsy surgery.

Klobučníková et al. 
Slovak Republic, 2009 [18]
Cross-sectional83 patients
80 controls
Medical record;
ESS; PSG; MSLT.
ESS > 9 in 37.3% of patients and in 11.2% of controls.
Mean ESS was higher in patients (7.1 versus 5.5).
Patients had lower sleep efficiency and more stage N2 and less N3 and REM than controls.
MSLT performed only in epilepsy group (mean latency 13 min.).

Kwan et al. China, 2009 [25]Cross-sectional247 patients Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale;
Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale; Medical Outcomes Study Sleep Scale;
ESS; QOLIE-31.
Subjective anxiety, depression, and sleep disturbance correlated with QOLIE-31. High ESS score, polytherapy, psychiatric comorbidity and seizures in the last month were related with lower QOLIE-31 score.

Romigi et al.
Italy, 2009 [30]
Prospective cohort12 patientsESS;
blood chemistry (plasma level of pregabalin);
EEG; PSG.
Pregabalin reduced seizures, increased REM sleep, and decreased stage 2 sleep. Significant increase in ESS score without reaching the pathological cut-off (ESS < 10).

Piperidou et al.
Greece, 2008 [14]
Cross-sectional124 patientsMedical record
ESS; SA-SDQ;
Athens Insomnia Scale;
QOLIE-31.
Prevalence of EDS was 16.9%.
28.2% had OSA, based on SA-SDQ.
No correlation with EDS and OSA.
Prevalence of insomnia was 24.6%.
Patients with EDS had lower score on QOLIE-31, and patients with OSA had lower score in cognitive functioning.
Insomnia correlated with seizure frequency and was an independent predictor of reduced quality of life.

Wood et al. Canada, 2008 [44]Cross-sectional 52 mothers of children with intractable epilepsy Beck Depression Inventory;
PSQI;
Maternal Quality of Life;
Impact of Pediatric Epilepsy Scale;
Child Behavior Checklist;
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Rating Scale-IV;
Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised.
45% of mothers scored as depressed (25% in the severe range). Sleep disruption in 67%.
Maternal depression correlated with child behavior disorders, but not with epilepsy-related variables, autism, adaptive delay, or family income.

Chihorek et al.
USA, 2007 [21]
Prospective cohort21 (>50 years with late-onset or worsening seizures and seizure-free or/with improvement)Medical record;
ESS; SA-SDQ;
PSG. CPAP treatment for patients diagnosed with OSA.
The late-onset group had higher AHI, ESS score, and SA-SDQ score,
Mean ESS of 11.6 in the late-onset group and 5.9 in seizure-free group.
Correlation between the ESS scores and AHI.
Patients with CPAP treatment had improvements in seizure control and EDS.

Nobili et al.
Italy, 2007 [32]
Case series21 NFLEESS;
video-EEG; stereo-EEG;
MRI; PSG.
6 months surgery EDS was resolved in the 9 patients with this complaint preoperatively.

de Haas et al.
The Netherlands, 2007 [31]
Double-blind randomized prospective cohort17 patients
(8 in placebo group and 9 in pregabalin group)
Medical Outcomes Study Sleep Scale;
seizure diary;
Groningen Sleep Questionnaire;
Sleep Diagnosis List;
PSG.
Pregabalin was associated with a reduction in the number of awakenings and improvement in wake time after sleep onset. It was also associated with improvements in sleep disturbance scales and sleep quantity subscales compared with placebo.

Vignatelli et al.
Italy, 2006 [26]
Cross-sectional33 NFLE
27 controls
ESS;
Bologna questionnaire on sleepiness-related symptoms;
questionnaire on nocturnal sleep quality;
Berlin questionnaire.
EDS did not differ between groups.
NFLE group being more “tired after awakening” (36% versus 11%) and having “spontaneous mid-sleep awakenings” (50% versus 22%).

Nobili et al.
Italy, 2006 [33]
Case report 1 female patient with drug-resistant NFLEESS;
video-EEG;
stereo-EEG.
Periodic leg movements during sleep and EDS were associated with enhanced arousal instability induced by epileptic discharges not detectable on scalp EEG.

Höllinger et al. Switzerland, 2006 [22]Cohort study 29 with OSA and epilepsyESS;
PSG;
CPAP.
In 21 patients, the appearance of OSA coincided with an increase in seizure frequency or status epilepticus. Four patients with good CPAP compliance had reduction of ESS scores and seizure frequency.

Khatami et al.
Switzerland, 2006 [13]
Cross-sectional100 patients
90 controls
Clinical interview;
ESS; SA-SDQ;
Ullanlinna Narcolepsy Scale.
Sleep complaints in 30% of patients and 10% of controls.
Maintenance insomnia more frequent in patients (52% versus 38%).
EDS, sleep apnea, and restless legs symptoms with no difference between groups.

Khatami et al. Switzerland, 2005 [28]Case reportA 36-year old woman ESS; MSLT; PSG;
MRI; PET.
Present a severe but potentially reversible hypersomnia with levetiracetam as add-on treatment in epilepsy patients and consider objective sleep-wake tests in epilepsy patients complaining of daytime fatigue/somnolence.

de Weerd et al.
The Netherlands, 2004 [12]
Cross-sectional486 patients
492 controls
WHO epilepsy questionnaire; Sleep Diagnosis List;
Medical Outcomes Study Sleep Scale;
Groningen Sleep Questionnaire; ESS;
SF-36 Health Survey.
Sleep disturbance is in patients more prevalent than controls (38.6% versus 18%).
Patients had more EDS (relation observed with SDL but not with the ESS).
Patients with more impairment in quality of life.

Bonanni et al.
Italy, 2004 [29]
Prospective cohort14 with focal epilepsy and 14 controlsESS;
MSLT;
Simple and choice visual reaction times;
ambulatory PSG.
No change in baseline ESS score and mean latencies in MSLT after 2 months of monotherapy with topiramate 200 mg/day.

de Almeida et al. Brazil, 2003 [24]Cross-sectional39 with temporal lobe epilepsyMedical and sleep habits record; ESS;
MSLT; PSG.
85% with EDS, 75% with seizures during sleep, and 26% with insomnia. Parasomnia was the most common sleep disorder (67%). PSG showed sleep fragmentation, reduction in REM sleep, and increase in wake time after sleep onset. ESS correlated with MSLT.

Weatherwax et al. USA, 2003 [23]Cross-sectional 125 patientsSA-SDQ; PSG.45% had AHI > 5. SA-SDQ score of 29 with 75% sensitivity and 65% specificity for men. Score of 26 with 80% sensitivity and 67% specificity for women.

Galli et al.
Italy, 2003 [35]
Prospective cohort8 patientsVisual analog scale of quality of life;
visual reaction times;
MSLT.
VNS at low intensities stimulus improved daytime vigilance in epileptic patients, with an improvement of quality of life.

Manni et al.
Italy, 2000
[3]
Cross-sectional244 cases, 205 controls Medical record;
ESS; Sleep Habits Questionnaire.
ESS score was similar in both groups (5.6 versus 5.7).
ESS score > 10 in 11% of patients and 10% of controls.

Malow et al.
USA, 1997 [2]
Cross-sectional158 cases, 68 controls ESS; SA-SDQ;
PSG in only 27 patients.
28% of patients and 18% of controls with ESS score > 10. SA-SDQ scores and RLS were independent predictors of ESS score > 10.

ESS: Epworth sleepiness scale; TST: total sleep time; AHI: apnea-hypopnea index; EEG: electroencephalography; PSG: polysomnography; PET: positron emission tomography; PSQI: Pittsburgh sleep quality index; JME: juvenile myoclonic epilepsy; VPA: valproic acid; BNSQ: basic nordic sleep questionnaire; MSLT: multiple sleep latencies test; REM: rapid eye movement; SA-SDQ: sleep apnea section of the sleep disorders questionnaire; QOLIE-31: quality of life in epilepsy; OSA: obstructive sleep apnea; CPAP: continuous positive airway pressure; NFLE: nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy; WHO: World Health Organization.