Performance Evaluation of Manual and Automated (MagNA Pure) Nucleic Acid Isolation in HPV Detection and Genotyping Using Roche Linear Array HPV Test

Table 3

Analysis of cases with discrepant results.

Cytological findings	Histological findings	AmpliLute	MagNA Pure
#1 WNL	HPV	33, 67, 70	67, 70
#2 WNL	HPV	33, 45	(−)
#3 WNL	No biopsy	16, 31, 33, 45	(−)
#4 WNL	No biopsy	(−)	18
#5 WNL	Negative	33, 45	45
#6 WNL	No biopsy	(−)	6, 58
#7 WNL	No biopsy	(−)	16, 33, 35
#8 WNL	No biopsy	(−)	16, 62
#9 WNL	Negative	31, 33, 42	45
#10 ASCUS	HPV	35, 53	35, 53, 54
#11 ASCUS	HPV	39, 42, 52, 84	52
#12 ASCUS	HPV	6, 16, 52	52
#13 ASCUS	HPV	16	(−)
#14 LSIL	HPV	16	(−)
#15 LSIL	CIN 1	16, 31, 33, 45	16, 31
#16 LSIL	CIN 1	16, 31, 33, 45	(−)
#17 LSIL	CIN 1	42	Invalid
#18 LSIL	CIN 1	31, 16	(−)
#19 LSIL	Negative	(−)	59
#20 LSIL	HPV	16	(−)
#21 LSIL	CIN 1	6, 16, 33, 45	(−)
#22 LSIL	CIN 1	52, 82	52
#23 LSIL	CIN 1	16, 31	(−)
#24 LSIL	HPV	16	(−)
#25 LSIL/HSIL	CIN 2	16, 33, 51	(−)