International Journal of Hepatology / 2011 / Article / Tab 1 / Review Article
Early Hepatocellular Carcinoma: Transplantation versus Resection: The Case for Liver Resection Table 1 Series comparing RSX and LT for HCC on cirrhosis.
First author [ref] Year N RSX N LT Mb (%) RSX Mb (%) LT Mt (%) RSX Mt (%) LT Overall 5-YS RSX Overall 5-YS LT Rec (%) RSX Rec (%) LT Iwatsukiwi/o [46 ] 1991 17** 71** NR NR NR NR 0% 41% 50 43 Ringewi/o [47 ] 1991 131** 61** NR NR
36% 15% NR NR Vargaswi [48 ] 1995 35 11 NR NR NR NR 58% 1-YS 81% 1-YS 40 0 Tanwi/o [49 ] 1995 12 15 33NR 13NR 8.3NR 6.7NR 33% 3-YS 63% 3-YS 45 15 Michelwi/o [50 ] 1997 102 113 39NR 38NR 8.8NR 22NR 31% 32% 86 30 Philosophewi/o [51 ] 1998 67** 58** NR NR
38% 45% 55 20 Colellawi/o [52 ] 1998 41 55 NR NR NR NR 44% 68% NR NR MazziottiNR [53 ] 1998 238 41 42NR 80NR
41% 69% NR NR Ottowi/o [54 ] 1998 52 50 NR NR
37% 44% 21 8.0 WeimannNR [55 ] 1999 32 31 NR NR
34% 63% 19 0 Yamamotowi/o [25 ] 1999 294 270 NR NR
47% 54% NR NR Llovetwi [19 ] 1999 77 87 NR NR
51% 69% 57 3.4 Figueraswi/o [56 ] 2000 35 85 NR 6.7NR NR NR 51% 60% 65 7.0 De Carliswi/o [57 ] 2001 131 91 NR NR
38% 65% 62 7.0 ShabahangNR [58 ] 2002 44 65 NR NR 7.0NR 7.0NR 57% 3-YS 66% 3-YS NR NR Bigourdanwi [59 ] 2003 20 17
36% 71% 30 18 PierieNR [60 ] 2005 81 33*** NR NR
10% 19% NR NR Margaritwi [61 ] 2005 37 36 NR NR
78% 50% 59 11 Poonwi [62 ] 2007 204 43
3.4H 0H 68% 81% NR NR Cillowi/o [63 ] 2007 131 40 NR NR
31% 63% 53 5.0 Del Gaudiowi [22 ] 2008 80 293 NR 79NR 0NR 5.0NR 66% 58% 59 46 Bellavancewi [64 ] 2008 245 134
46% 66% 50 14 Sotiropoulowi/o [65 ] 2009 61 60
23% 59% NR NR Zhouwi [66 ] 2010 1018 89 NR NR 0.69NR 4.5NR 70% 89% NR NR
Abbreviations: RSX: resection; LT: liver transplantation; YS: year-survival; Mb: morbidity; MT: mortality; Rec: recurrence.
*RSX and LT combined.
**Cirrhotic and noncirrhotic livers combined.
***33 wait-list patients (22 transplanted patients).
wi All patients within Milan criteria.
wi/o Some patients within and some outside of Milan criteria.
NR Milan criteria not reported.
H Hospital mortality (during same admission for same treatment).