Review Article

Are Classification Criteria for IgG4-RD Now Possible? The Concept of IgG4-Related Disease and Proposal of Comprehensive Diagnostic Criteria in Japan

Table 3

International Consensus Diagnostic Criteria (ICDC) for autoimmune pancreatitis [13].

DiagnosisPrimary basic for diagnosisImaging EvidenceCollateral evidence

Definitive type 1 AIPHistologyTypical/indeterminateHistologically confirmed LPSP (level 1 H)
ImagingTypicalAny non-D level 1/level 2
IndeterminateTwo or more from level 1 (+level 2 D*)
Response to steroidIndeterminateLevel 1 S/OOI + Rt or level 1 D + level 2 S/OOI/H + Rt

Probable type 1 AlPIndeterminateLevel 2 S/OOI/H + Rt

*Level 2 D is counted as level 1 in this setting.

CriterionLevel 1Level 2

PParenchymal imagingTypical: diffuse enlargement with delayed enhancement (sometimes associated with rim-like enhancement)Indeterminate (including atypical): segmental/focal enlargement with delayed enhancement

DDuctal imaging (ERP)Long (>1/3 length of the main pancreatic duct) or multiple strictures without marked upstream dilatationSegmental/focal narrowing without marked upstream dilatation
(duct size, <5 mm)

SSerologyIgG4, >2× upper limit of normal value a or bIgG4, 1-2× upper limit of normal value a or b
OOIOther organ involvement
(a) Histology of extrapancreatic organs:(a) Histology of extrapancreatic organs including endoscopic biopsies of bile duct:
any three of the following:both of the following:
 (1) marked lymphoplasmacytic infiltration with  fibrosis and without granulocytic infiltration;  (1) marked lymphoplasmacytic infiltration without granulocytic  infiltration;
  (2) storiform fibrosis;  (2) abundant (>10 cells/HPF) IgG4-positive cells.
  (3) obliterative phlebitis;
  (4) abundant (>10 cells/HPF) IgG4-positive cells.
(b) Typical radiological evidence(b) Physical or radiological evidence:
at least one of the following:at least one of the following:
  (1) segmental/multiple proximal  (hilar/intrahepatic) or proximal and distal bile duct  stricture;  (1) symmetrically enlarged salivary/lachrymal glands;
  (2) retroperitoneal fibrosis;  (2) radiological evidence of renal involvement described in  association with AIP.

HHistology of the pancreasLPSP (core biopsy/resection):LPSP (core biopsy):
at least 3 of the following:any 2 of the following:
(1) periductal lymphoplasmacytic infiltrate without granulocytic infiltration;  (1) periductal lymphoplasmacytic infiltrate without granulocytic  infiltration;
(2) obliterative phlebitis; (2) obliterative phlebitis;
(3) storiform fibrosis;  (3) storiform fibrosis;
(4) abundant (>10 cells HPF) IgG4-positive cells.  (4) abundant (>10 cells/HPF) IgG4-positive cells.

Diagnostic steroid trial
Response to steroid (Rt)* Rapid (≤2 wk) radiologically demonstrable resolution or marked improvement in pancreatic/extrapancreatic manifestations