Table 5: Interaction parameter/parameters for various models and standard deviation (SD) determined by least square method.
(a)

ModelConstantsEthanoic acid (1) + benzene (2)Propanoic acid (1) + benzene (2)Butanoic acid (1) + benzene (2)
298.15 K308.15 K318.15 K298.15 K308.15 K318.15 K298.15 K308.15 K318.15 K

McAllister (11) 0.63360.52910.64080.82860.73900.82451.08080.98250.9409
0.59430.53470.39800.61630.52210.42680.72270.61290.6406
SD0.00920.01610.02890.01050.01280.01280.01460.01080.0088

Heric (13) −0.8692−0.8380−0.4591−0.2946−0.29160.0521−0.2445−0.12710.4815
−0.2173−0.30690.45820.17630.26400.74800.13900.28140.2095
SD0.13570.20150.31850.15240.22690.33560.32580.21690.2614

Krishnan and Laddha (17) 0.92750.96060.70310.36200.38590.05280.31730.1913−0.5399
0.25360.3832−0.3062−0.1643−0.2472−0.7294−0.1430−0.2849−0.2063
−0.4145−0.8715−1.7348−0.4654−0.6512−0.7241−0.5103−0.44990.4099
SD0.14680.12250.07010.05590.05020.06290.05950.03780.1101

Auslander (14) −0.0168−0.09010.05231.84041.48981.91093.93222.54790.1292
6.45858.20077.32146.57316.55025.67649.92616.09370.2803
0.44090.2966−0.09960.09970.0271−0.27350.08960.09991.7186
SD0.00410.01160.01210.00430.00510.00380.00740.00480.0010

Teja and Rice (15) 111111111
SD0.03060.02240.01320.01010.00830.01310.00560.01390.0279

Zihao and Jufu (18) 0.93770.90990.89850.94310.94130.90160.93430.81780.8038
1.06841.10081.11621.06241.06361.11141.07091.22591.2473
SD0.00810.00550.00490.02520.02560.00710.08580.01930.0111

Two-parameter model (21) 0.03020.03040.0305−0.0053−0.0056−0.0069−0.0121−0.01180.0079
0.00720.00610.00570.00610.00520.00380.00670.00960.0079
SD0.00230.00190.00240.00550.00790.00230.00880.00880.0041

Rice and Teja (19) 111111111
SD0.06430.01280.00390.14230.11830.11830.22100.18620.1874

(b)

ModelConstantsEthanoic acid (1) + acetophenone (2)Propanoic acid (1) + acetophenone (2)Butanoic acid (1) + acetophenone (2)
298.15 K308.15 K318.15 K298.15 K308.15 K318.15 K298.15 K308.15 K318.15 K

McAllister (11) 1.60721.47951.34031.50611.41961.33771.71391.62091.3511
1.69101.41861.17941.70241.50971.30281.74711.62081.5934
SD0.00060.00060.00690.00340.00710.00820.00130.00340.0120

Heric (13) 0.71410.90271.23140.68550.95601.34760.28170.70891.2371
0.12710.25020.34060.05840.12140.19760.01340.0417−0.2198
SD0.36710.15780.26540.39630.1814021200.68210.37610.0201

Krishnan and Laddha (17) −0.7161−0.9048−1.1986−0.6742−0.9286−1.3101−0.2854−0.7014−1.1893
−0.1293−0.2525−0.3052−0.0511−0.1036−0.1733−0.0147−0.03920.2360
0.01490.0160−0.2399−0.0803−0.1955−0.26790.0262−0.0528−0.3361
SD0.30710.34780.41620.29040.37310.48190.13010.30970.4936

Auslander (14) −0.0265−0.8582−3.1960−0.1986−0.9382−3.3948−1.9043−7.8002−21.0019
1.58192.06651.25310.56030.61510.91081.21631.03090.5851
1.22061.34434.55323.35674.79336.07892.89989.520539.1308
SD0.00020.00080.0020.00020.00050.00010.00010.00260.0029

Teja and Rice (15) 1.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.05
SD0.02840.00700.01460.00290.03240.04110.08260.01370.0178

Zihao and Jufu (18) 0.83330.93190.81980.45860.43170.32881.23671.26531.3189
1.04680.95441.00821.50471.52560.43040.80740.78990.7593
SD0.07790.03950.04050.04740.04650.27860.12610.12090.1292

Two-parameter model (21) 0.39680.41670.45570.30960.33290.35090.22150.23650.2478
0.06430.08650.0764−0.0738−0.0893−0.10250.09890.10330.1075
SD0.06660.05990.04020.02980.04030.09830.04930.05570.0513

Rice and Teja (19) 1.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.051.05
SD0.18020.11310.07640.20900.17560.16780.16040.10240.1126