Abstract
This paper reviews the topic of microstructured polymer fibres in the fields in which these have been utilised: microstructured optical fibres, terahertz waveguides, and fibre-drawn metamaterials. Microstructured polymer optical fibres were initially investigated in the context of photonic crystal fibre research, and several unique features arising from the combination of polymer and microstructure were identified. This lead to investigations in sensing, particularly strain sensing based on gratings, and short-distance data transmission. The same principles have been extended to waveguides at longer wavelengths, for terahertz frequencies, where microstructured polymer waveguides offer the possibility for low-loss flexible waveguides for this frequency region. Furthermore, the combination of microstructured polymer fibres and metals is being investigated in the fabrication of metamaterials, as a scalable method for their manufacture. This paper will review the materials and fabrication methods developed, past and current research in these three areas, and future directions of this fabrication platform.
1. Introduction
Polymers have been investigated as a platform for the fabrication of microstructured optical fibres (MOFs) since 2001 [1–5] in the context of the photonic crystal fibre (PCF) research that had begun five years earlier [6–9]. The original work on PCF was based on silica fibres and the key innovation of using holes running the length of an optical fibre to control light in unprecedented ways [9]. The interest in using polymers arose from the difference in material properties between polymers and silica and the possibilities this entailed [1]. This initial work on microstructured polymer optical fibres (mPOFs) aimed to investigate the implications of these differences in material properties on the fabrication methods, fibre designs, optical properties, and potential applications of these fibres. These new fibres would be compared to the two related established areas of silica-based PCF, having the microstructure in common, and conventional polymer optical fibres (POFs) [10], having the material in common. The underlying theme was to identify situations where the combination of these two elements, the polymer and microstructure, was more beneficial than either element alone.
Over the next decade, the work on mPOF matured, as with work on PCF in general. The fabrication techniques were formalised, and performance matching and exceeding those of commercial POF was achieved in comparable cases [11–13]. The limitations and possible applications were identified, analysed, and understood to a great extent. Whilst this shifted the work on mPOF to the realm of technological development rather than scientific research, new areas were continually being identified in which the knowledge developed in the context of the optical fibre work could be applied to conduct new research. Two such areas are the emerging fields of terahertz frequency radiation and experimental investigations of metamaterials.
Work at terahertz frequencies, generally considered to cover the range of 0.1–10 THz or wavelengths between 3 mm and 30 μm, has been increasing due to the relatively recent availability of affordable and practical terahertz sources and detectors, bridging the so-called “terahertz gap” which had previously resulted in this part of the spectrum being underutilised. Interest in terahertz radiation arises from many potential spectroscopy and imaging applications for medical imaging and security [14–18]. It is nonionising radiation that can easily penetrate ordinary packaging materials like plastics, leather, and cardboard. Whilst the availability of sources and detectors has enabled recent work in this area, other optical components remain primitive in comparison to optics (i.e., for the visible and infrared).
Polymers were identified as a material of interest for work at terahertz frequencies [19], and particularly in work relating to waveguides [20]. The connection to microstructured polymer optical fibres was obvious, both in terms of the physics of waveguides and in terms of the material processing and fabrication techniques that had been developed. This is an area of active research aiming to deliver optical fibre-like waveguides for use at terahertz frequencies, as currently no such equivalent exists. This is a challenging prospect due to the differences between common material properties at terahertz frequencies as compared to the visible and infrared, and the broader spectral range and larger wavelengths of terahertz radiation.
The connection to metamaterials research was made by identifying that microstructured fibres produce large volumes of material with micron-sized features (the holes inside the fibre). Metamaterials, meaning “beyond” materials, are man-made composites with structure on a subwavelength scale that derive their properties from this structure rather than the materials from which that structure is constructed [21–25]. These composites are considered to consist of artificial “meta-atoms,” and just as the individual atoms or molecules of an ordinary material determine its bulk properties, so these meta-atoms determine the bulk properties of metamaterials. As a result, unprecedented control of the relevant properties can be achieved through appropriate control of the structure of these meta-atoms.
For electromagnetic metamaterials, the properties of interest are the response to electric and magnetic fields, quantified by the permittivity and permeability, respectively. Hence, control over the permittivity and permeability is achieved through the structure, and a variety of properties not observed in naturally occurring materials have been demonstrated as a result. These include a magnetic response from nonmagnetic materials, and at high frequencies [22], and a negative refractive index [21, 23]. Electromagnetic metamaterials can in principle produce any combination of permittivity and permeability, and hence refractive index, potentially leading to other important applications such as lenses with resolution beyond the Rayleigh limit [26–28], and cloaking [29, 30], although the feasibility of some extreme applications remains unclear.
Electromagnetic metamaterials typically consist of metal-dielectric composites. The subwavelength requirement on the size of the structure poses a practical problem, as metamaterials for the visible, infrared, or terahertz parts of the electromagnetic spectrum require structure on the scale of approximately 100 nm to 100 μm. Although fabrication methods capable of such resolutions exist, such as lithography techniques at the 100nm scale [31], or inkjet printing on the 100 μm scale [32], they produce planar (2D) metamaterials and are not capable of the inexpensive large-volume fabrication that may be required in the future for any practical applications. The extension of mPOF research to metamaterials aims to address this by combining metals with the large volumes of microstructure that is produced by drawing fibre. This allows metamaterials to be explored through a fabrication method that is intrinsically scalable and can lead to 3D bulk metamaterials.
This paper aims to present a review of the progression of microstructured polymer fibres, through the essentially mature field of PCF to the current areas of interest in terahertz waveguides and metamaterials fabrication. The paper is organised as follows. Section 2 will outline the materials used and highlight the properties that make their use appropriate. Section 3 will outline the fabrication methods; the materials and fabrication methods are mostly common to the three areas of research. Sections 4, 5, and 6 will then focus on the individual research areas of microstructured polymer optical fibres, terahertz waveguides, and drawn metamaterials, giving an overview of the research to date in each area. This will be followed by a conclusion in Section 7, where the future directions of this work will be outlined.
2. Materials
Conventional (step-index or graded-index) plastic optical fibres (POFs) are based on polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA). It is widely available, inexpensive and has a low loss in the visible, typically quoted as 0.15 dB/m at 650 nm [10]; a summary of the properties of PMMA and other selected polymers is presented in Table 1 and Figure 1. Commercially available POF products are typically highly multimode optical fibres with a 1 mm core diameter, targeting short distance data transmission, and illumination applications. Several suppliers of such fibres exist including Mitsubishi Rayon (ESKA product line) [33], Optimedia (GigaOptics) [34], and Luceat (LiteWire) [35]. Given PMMA’s established use in optical fibres and the consequent availability of optical grade material, the first microstructured polymer optical fibres were also made from PMMA [1]. The first mPOF demonstrated single-mode operation in the visible using the endlessly single-mode PCF design [36] and was the first such demonstration of a single-mode PCF in a material other than silica.
(a)
(b)
(c)
PMMA remains in extensive use for work in microstructured polymer fibres, but as the scope of the work broadened, other commercially available polymers began to be used so as to take advantage of their specific properties (Table 1). Polycarbonate (PC), polystyrene (PS), and polyvinyl difluoride (PVDF) have been used for their refractive index. PC and PS have higher indices approaching 1.6 [10], and PVDF has a lower index of 1.4 [37] compared to PMMA which has an index of 1.49 [10]. PC also has a higher glass transition temperature () than that of PMMA [38], 150°C compared to 115°C. PMMA, PC, and PS also have comparable material absorption in the visible as shown in Figure 1(a) [5, 39, 40], although PC is known to degrade in high temperature humid environments [10, 38]. The cyclo-olefin polymers/copolymers Zeonex [41, 42] and Topas [43, 44] have also been used, presenting an index between that of PMMA and PC/PS of around 1.53 and virtually no moisture absorption [42, 44].
At terahertz frequencies, PMMA has a rather low transparency and is outperformed by many other polymers. Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE/Teflon) [19, 45], high density polyethylene (HDPE) [19, 46], Zeonex [47], and Topas [48] have losses of one to two orders of magnitude lower than PMMA, as shown in Figure 1(c). In some cases such as PTFE and HDPE, widely varying values of loss have been reported in the literature as is seen in Table 1, most likely attributed to different grades of the polymer, but also possibly influenced by the details of the measurement.
In addition to the commercially available polymers mentioned previously, other proprietary, customised, or novel polymers have also been investigated. The use of cyclic transparent optical polymer (CYTOP) was demonstrated in an optical fibre context [10, 49–51] and also at terahertz frequencies in a photonic crystal planar waveguide [52]. CYTOP is a perfluorinated polymer, meaning all the hydrogen in the polymer is replaced by fluorine. The heavier fluorine atoms reduce the frequency of molecular vibrations and shift the associated absorption lines to longer wavelengths, increasing the transparency in the visible and near infrared [49]. A similar increase in transparency can be achieved by replacing the hydrogen atoms with deuterium, as in deuterated PMMA (PMMA-d8) [10, 53]. A comparison of PMMA, PMMA-d8, and CYTOP is presented in Figure 1(b). Whilst PMMA-d8 and CYTOP offer an advantage at 650 nm, the improvement in the infrared is far more striking, with the loss of CYTOP being three orders of magnitude lower than PMMA. This allows CYTOP fibres to operate at the 850 nm and 1300 nm telecommunications windows, and thus be compatible with components developed for silica-based systems [49]. Theoretical loss values for fluorinated polymers are an order of magnitude lower than shown in Figure 1(b) and are comparable to the loss of silica glass; however, such low values have never been achieved for a variety of reasons, including difficulties in ensuring an amorphous structure [10] (e.g., PTFE is polycrystalline, resulting in high scattering losses in the visible and a white opaque appearance). The performance of CYTOP at terahertz frequencies is also good, as seen in Figure 1(c).
Despite the real and potential advantages, fluorinated and deuterated polymers are proprietary and/or expensive and difficult to manufacture, so their use has been limited. Materials such as CYTOP have the potential to make the use of mPOF much more widespread through reducing the loss to allow longer lengths of fibre to be used and through allowing operation in the infrared and compatibility with telecommunications components.
Several demonstrations with novel polymers have also been reported. These include chiral polymers using a copolymer of methyl methacrylate, from which PMMA is derived, and (−)-menthyl methacrylate derived from (−)-menthol, a chiral compound [54]. The availability of chiral material, and hence optical activity (circular birefringence), adds an interesting new dimension to optical waveguides [55]. The use of cellulose for a biodegradable fibre [56] was also demonstrated with potential biomedical applications.
Doping offers an additional route to modifying the polymer. Doping can be achieved by using solvents to swell the polymer and allow the dopant to diffuse into it [57]. Alternatively, the dopant may be added at the monomer phase prior to polymerisation [58, 59]. Particulate dopants such as doped nanoparticles [60], magnetic nanoparticles [61], and quantum dots [60, 62, 63] can be incorporated by dry mixing of the dopants and the polymer in powder form, and then consolidation under pressure at higher temperature (e.g., as would occur in an extrusion process). The lower processing temperature of polymers allows dopants such as quantum dots and organic molecules to survive the draw process without degrading.
As a final note on the materials, it should be explicitly stated that the criterion any polymer must satisfy for use in microstructured fibres is compatibility with the fibre drawing process. This places constraints on the molecular weight, polydispersity, degree of cross-linking, and level of impurities. Too high degree of cross-linking or molecular weights that are too large will prevent the polymer chains from sliding past each other and will make the polymer rubbery upon heating, preventing it from being stretched to fibre. Any volatile impurities such as remnant monomer, initiator, or absorbed moisture may evaporate during the draw process and create bubbles. For PMMA, molecular weights in the range of 50,000 to 100,000 are required, and the polydispersity of material used ranged between 2.0 and 2.3. Volatile impurities may be extracted by annealing the polymers (heating below , e.g., at 90°C for PMMA and Zeonex, or 110°C for PC) for a sufficient time of between a few days and a month, depending on size, prior to processing or drawing. Polymers that have already been processed by extrusion are generally compatible with the draw process given the similarity between the two; however, polymers prepared by casting are not always able to be drawn.
3. Fabrication Methods
The common element of the work under review here is the fabrication of microstructured polymer fibres by fibre drawing methods. Fibre drawing entails at least two stages of fabrication, beginning with the construction of a preform which is a scaled-up (larger in diameter, shorter in length) version of the fibre that contains its essential features such as the necessary structure and material. The second stage is drawing this preform to fibre using a draw tower. The basic draw process involves heating the preform to a temperature sufficiently larger than to reduce its viscosity such that it can be drawn to fibre (e.g., at around 200°C for PMMA). The process may also involve intermediate stages, such as drawing the initial preform to an intermediate size called “cane,” sleeving to increase diameter, or combining several canes to form a new preform [5, 64].
Polymers lend themselves to a wider range of fabrication techniques than silica glass owing to the lower processing temperatures and ease of machining; as a result, a variety of methods have been demonstrated as summarised in Figure 2. The first mPOF was made from a preform formed by drilling the desired hole structure into a PMMA cylinder 8 cm in diameter (Figure 2(a)) [1, 65]. Extrusion (Figure 2(b)) [66] and polymerisation/casting of preforms (Figure 2(c)) [59] have also been demonstrated and in common with drilling produce monolithic preforms. The extrusion (and to a lesser extent, casting) may begin with the monomer, resin or a polymer billet. Stacking is shown in Figure 2(d) in which the preform is assembled from rods, tubes or capillaries [67]; incidentally, this is the method used most commonly for producing silica PCF [9]. The necessary prefabricated tubes, and rods are assembled into the desired arrangement and placed into a consolidating tube to hold the arrangement securely in place. The advantage of this method, although prone to contamination from the larger surface area of the constituent pieces, is that very large air fractions can be achieved by using very thin-walled tubes. Such air fractions cannot be achieved by the other methods and may be necessary for some fibre designs, such as hollow-core optical fibres [67–69].
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
These methods (or combinations thereof) are generally versatile, allowing many fibre geometries to be achieved. Their use in isolation (except for stacking) is mostly limited to single-material fibres. Multimaterial fibres are also of interest, requiring these methods to be modified and/or new methods to be employed. Multimaterial optical fibres were initially demonstrated for guiding radiation from CO2 lasers (10.6 μm wavelength), resulting in commercial products for laser surgery called OmniGuide fibres [70]. These consist of a hollow core surrounded by a dielectric stack (a Bragg fibre) made of polyethersulfone and arsenic triselenide. The dielectric stack is initially made in planar form and then rolled into a cylinder to make the preform. This method was also used to make similar Bragg fibres using solvent deposition, as shown in Figure 2(e), and a combinations of PMMA/PS and PVDF/PC were used to maximise the index contrast between the layers of the Bragg reflector [37, 71]. The OmniGuide work was extended to include semiconductors and metals in the fibres, demonstrating fibres (and materials woven from these fibres) that were photosensitive, as well as having other functionalities [72, 73]. Multimaterial microstructured polymer fibres can similarly be made through combinations of the methods noted previously, such as drilling a structure and inserting another material into the holes (Figure 2(a)) [41], stacking different materials or stacking tubes containing different materials (Figure 2(d)) [74]. In particular, this has been used for including metals in the fibres for work in drawn metamaterials [75–77]. In fact, the principle of drawing metals in a dielectric fibre dates back to the Taylor wire process [78].
Once the initial preform is constructed using any of these methods or combinations thereof, the preform can be drawn to fibre, possibly through the intermediate cane stage. Additional processing such as filling holes or increasing the overall diameter through sleeving may be done at this cane stage. An example of sleeving to increase the fibre diameter can be seen in Figure 3(a), where two additional layers of polymer can be seen. During the fibre draw, the microstructure may change due to the interplay between surface tension and viscosity. This can be controlled through the draw temperature, and the speeds with which the preform is fed into the furnace and the fibre is drawn. Variation of these parameters can encourage hole collapse (e.g., hotter draw) or relative hole expansion (e.g., colder draw). The details of the draw process and roles of the material parameters have been well understood through a series of numerical and experimental studies on PMMA (and silica) fibres [79–83]. Pressure and/or vacuum may also be used to control the microstructure during drawing.
(a)
(b)
4. Microstructured Polymer Optical Fibres
A large fraction of the work on silica PCF focused on nonlinear optics. The unprecedented control of dispersion and the high degree of confinement that could be achieved led to a very successful study of nonlinear optics in fibres with enhanced nonlinearity [9, 84]. On the other hand, the ability to fabricate large mode area single-mode fibres with very low nonlinearity allowed higher power operation without encountering nonlinear effects or damaging the fibres [85–87]. These investigations led to two commercial outcomes of PCF—supercontinuum sources and fibre lasers. The initial interest in mPOF was inspired by the work in silica PCF, and the investigations into mPOF began with the aim of seeing what could be achieved from the combination of microstructure and polymers. Similar work into fibre dispersion, nonlinear optics, or high power fibre lasers was not possible owing to the lower damage threshold of PMMA and the higher loss, which prevented the use of high powers and long interaction lengths. The only exceptions to this were demonstrations of mPOF fibre lasers based on organic dyes and the observation of stimulated Raman scattering in PMMA fibres [58, 88, 89]. This section will focus on three main outcomes of mPOF research, namely the ability to make single-mode fibres for the visible and the gratings-based sensing approaches that enables, high-bandwidth multimode fibres, and mPOF used for liquid-based sensing. Finally, other novel fibres directed in part towards understanding the physics of microstructured fibres will also be discussed.
4.1. Single-Mode Polymer Fibres and Gratings-Based Sensing
Although single-mode fibres are ubiquitous when dealing with silica, the POF world is dominated by large 1 mm core multimode fibres estimated to support of order 107 modes at 650 nm [10, 33–35]. Single-mode mPOF have been reported since the first mPOF paper of 2001 [1], using the familiar hexagonal array of holes that is almost synonymous with PCF. More recently, an all-solid version was reported in which the core consisted of a sparse array of subwavelength Zeonex rods (index of 1.53), giving the core an average index slightly above the PMMA background (index of 1.49) [41]. Examples of these single-mode fibres are shown in Figure 3.
A single-mode plastic fibre is of no interest for communications, given the relatively high attenuation of PMMA and the resulting short-distance data links it implies. Having single-mode (and also few-moded) fibres does have important outcomes, however, including the possibility of inscribing gratings [90, 91]. It is in this context of gratings that the different material properties found in polymers can be most effectively utilised. A summary of the relevant properties of PMMA compared to silica is presented in Table 2. Gratings turn single-mode mPOF into sensors with thermal, humidity, and strain responses. PMMA has an elastic limit of 4%–10%, a breaking strain beyond 20%, and a thermo-optic coefficient of −1.1 ×10−4 [4]. The most striking advantage over silica fibres is the ability to achieve large strains (see inset of Figure 4(a)).
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Work into long period gratings (LPG) in PMMA single-mode mPOF has resulted from these differences in material properties. LPGs can be easily inscribed by physical imprinting with a pitch of order 1 mm [91], to give resonance features in the 500–750 nm range where PMMA-based mPOFs are the most transparent, allowing up to 10m of fibre to be used. An example of such an LPG spectrum is shown in Figure 4(a). Demonstrations of strain [92–96], humidity [94, 97, 98], temperature [94] and pressure [99] sensing, and biosensing [100] with these LPGs, have been reported. Typical responses observed were −11 nm/% strain, 0.5 nm/10% relative humidity, and 0.2 nm/°C [92–98], as shown in Table 3.
One particularly interesting use of mPOF LPG is the demonstration of a heart rate sensor [101]; the response of the LPG is sensitive enough to detect a person’s heart beat when the fibre is placed around the torso. This has potential applications in personal protective equipment and medical settings in which metallic components cannot be used. The biocompatibility of PMMA is an additional advantage in this case.
In addition to LPG, fibre Bragg gratings (FBGs) have also been demonstrated in single-mode and smaller core multimode mPOF [90]. This work has been carried out at telecommunications wavelengths (dictated by silica-oriented FBG inscription techniques), using PMMA [90, 102–106] and Topas fibres [106–108]. Such wavelengths are not particularly favourable due to the material loss restricting fibre lengths to approximately 10 cm (see Figure 1(b)), requiring interfacing with silica fibres for characterisation. More recently, FBGs with wavelengths approaching 800 nm have been reported [102, 107], aiming to move towards the transparency windows of those polymers. An example of such an FBG inscribed in a multimode PMMA fibre is shown in Figure 4(b). These gratings have similarly been characterised for strain, humidity, and temperature sensing, with typical responses as shown in Table 3. In particular, Topas FBGs were demonstrated to be insensitive to humidity, given the negligible water absorption of Topas [107], shown in Figure 4(d).
The comparison between FBG and LPG and polymer and silica combinations in Table 3 shows that mPOF LPGs have the largest response to all three stimuli considered, in addition to the advantage of operating in the visible in the transparency window of the polymers. The loss of the fibres is <2 dB/m (discussed in Section 4.5 and Figure 8), the temperature response is 2.5 to 5 larger than all the other options, and the humidity response is larger compared to PMMA POF FBG, but can be eliminated with the use of Topas. Furthermore, the strain response for FBG is proportional to the wavelength of the grating. Scaling the FBG results to the visible gives an estimated response of 5 nm/%, which is less than half of reported values for LPG.
A comparison reported in [109] showed that the strain response of mPOF FBG is identical to step-index POF FBG, as seen in Figure 4(c). This is to be expected given PMMA was used in both cases. An important difference, however, is that the few-moded step-index POF in [109] had losses approaching 550 dB/m at 700 nm, compared of <2 dB/m for the single-mode mPOF. Compared to silica FBG [110, 111], the polymer FBGs have the same strain response, but with a much larger elastic limit of ~4% and maximum strain exceeding 20%. Polymer FBGs also have a temperature response that is 3-4 times larger and in the opposite direction compared to silica. This is attributed to a larger and negative thermo-optic coefficient (Table 2). It should be noted that the strain response is dominated by changes to the grating pitch, whereas temperature response is dominated by the thermo-optic coefficient, and humidity response by the material absorbing water and changing refractive index as a result. Silica fibres nominally have no humidity response.
The potential sensing applications of mPOF gratings are still being investigated, whether for FBG or LPG. The large strains possible, larger temperature and humidity responses, and the biocompatibility of polymers will be important advantages in any future applications. Requirements of any particular deployment will also contribute to the choice between characterisations of the fibre in transmission, which is compatible with both FBG and LPG, or in reflection which is compatible with FBG only.
4.2. High-Bandwidth Fibres
Another outcome of mPOF research was high-bandwidth mPOF, which arose from initial investigations into the main application of conventional POF: short-range data transmission using 650 nm light over lengths up to 100 m [10]. Although complex structures were initially sought to achieve an azimuthally averaged graded profile (e.g., hole radii and/or filling fraction increasing outwards from the centre of the core) [112], it was eventually realised that a single ring of holes was all that was required to achieve high data rates [12, 13]. This has produced multimode mPOF with approximately 150 μm core diameters and 500 μm outer diameters that have achieved 9.5 Gb/s data rates using on-off keying and a relatively complex light source based on telecommunications sources in the infrared and four-wave mixing to convert the signal to the visible [12], as well as 7.3 Gb/s using inexpensive laser diodes in combination with a more complex modulation format (discrete multitone modulation, DMT) [13], both over 50 m. Examples of the fibre structure and data transmission measurements are shown in Figure 5. These data rates are compared to the 100 Mb/s to 1 Gb/s data rates typical of conventional polymer step- and graded-index fibres targeting fibre-to-the-premises and fibre-in-the-premises applications. Comparable data rates have been achieved over conventional fibres but have required additional complexity in the system. For example, 10 Gb/s was achieved only over 35 m using a graded-index POF using DMT and a specialised receiver [113], whilst measurements over 50 m were limited to 6 Gb/s and required complex equalisation circuits [114].
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
The fact that these fibres are multimode and yet achieve such high data rates indicates that the microstructure is responsible for reducing the modal dispersion. Earlier studies into these fibres observed that the bandwidth-length product was not constant, indicating that the modal dispersion was not resulting in pulse spreading as expected, but in fact, the width of pulses propagating in the fibre approached a constant value after certain propagation lengths, about 40 m in that case [115]. This suggests the presence of a small group of modes with low modal dispersion and low loss that are observed after long lengths of fibre and a second group of higher order, higher loss modes that result in pulse spreading over shorter length scales, but do not survive to the longer lengths. Such a description in terms of two mode groups is consistent with observed bending loss behaviour for similar fibres [116]. Higher bend loss was observed for short bent lengths of fibre (when the higher order modes are being lost), with the bend loss reducing for longer bent lengths (where the lower order, lower loss modes remain). The use of polymer allows the large diameters to be achieved in a flexible fibre, which are important for the targeted applications such as fibre-in-the-premises, where easy handling and low connector costs are essential [10].
4.3. Liquid-Based Sensing
Apart from the grating-based sensing discussed previously, another body of work on mPOF has focused on liquid-based sensing. In many of these cases, the compatibility of the polymer with various fabrication methods and/or chemical processes has enabled this work. The theme here (and of optical fibre sensors in general) is to increase the overlap between the guided mode of the fibre and the material to be sensed. This has been approached through various fibre geometries, creating structures where both the light and material are in the same place, and through chemical approaches that result in an increased interaction.
A notable example of using the chemical approach is coating the holes of a Topas mPOF with a binding agent to selectively bind a particular antibody to the hole surface [43]. Although the light is confined to the core, there are evanescent fields in the holes, and these are the strongest at the hole surface at the edge of the core, where the antibodies would now be bound. This enhances the interaction of only that particular antibody with the evanescent field of the guided mode and results in enhanced selective detection as seen in Figure 6(a). Other examples include modifying the inner surface of PMMA mPOF with a titanium oxide film to sensitise the fibres to hydrogen peroxide [117], and with cellulose to sensitise them to nitrites [118]. A structure-based approached was to add holes to the core itself and create more opportunities for overlap of the light and material filling the holes, as seen in Figure 6(b) [119].
The previous examples required the holes of the fibre to be filled in order for the sensor to work. Side trenches in the fibre and an exposed core, as in Figure 6(c), remove this requirement and allow the fibre to sense the environment in which it is immersed [120]. The exposed core could also be coated with gold to allow for sensing through surface plasmons [121]. Metallic coatings on the inside of the holes have also been reported, to increase the interaction between the metal and the light and any material filling the holes [122]. Such coatings can increase phenomena like surface-enhanced Raman scattering. (Interest in using metal in the fibre for the fabrication of metamaterials is a separate topic covered in Section 6.)
Finally, the possibility of making hollow-core mPOF (HC-mPOF) allows the material to be placed in the core itself, completely overlapping with the propagating light. Demonstrations of filling the core with a chiral solution and measuring the resulting optical rotation have been reported [123]. Filling the core with a suspension of nanoparticles allowed spectroscopy based on surface-enhanced Raman scattering to be conducted inside the fibre [124]. In this case, the fibre contains the sample and guides both the pump and signal wavelengths to and from the laser source/detector. Finally, individual microparticles were trapped inside the core of a HC-mPOF using an optical trapping beam incident transversely through the fibre cladding. These individual particles could be held in place and interrogated through fluorescence spectroscopy [125]. In this demonstration, the pump beam was incident on the particles transversely through the cladding, and the fluorescence was collected by the fibre core and guided to a detector. The results are shown in Figure 6(d).
In many of these cases, the chemistry and ability to machine the polymer made the investigations possible. The exposed core fibres could be fabricated by machining a trench at the preform or cane stage, and the anti-body-specific sensing relied on a chemical process involving the polymer. In other cases, particularly involving HC-mPOF, the use of polymer was incidental, but, nevertheless, these demonstrations were first made using microstructured polymer fibres.
4.4. Other Novel Fibres
Other work on mPOF focused on understanding the guidance mechanisms that occur in PCF due to the presence of the holes or high-index inclusions in the fibre cross-section. The use of polymer in many such cases served to make the investigation possible through easier fabrication or through material availability and/or compatibility.
This work focused on studying the guidance mechanisms in low-index core fibres, such as hollow-core fibres. The initial idea behind PCF was that the photonic crystal and resulting photonic bandgap (absence of propagating modes in the cladding of the fibre for particular wavevectors) would prevent light from propagating in the cladding and confine it to the core—the core being a defect in the crystal. This removed the condition that the core has a higher index than the cladding, required for total internal reflection as in conventional fibres. This type of PCF (hollow core, HC-PCF) was developed and understood using silica as the base material and can achieve low-loss guidance in a hollow core but over a narrow wavelength range [126, 127] corresponding to the photonic bandgap.
It was eventually realised that a second mechanism existed by which light could be confined to a hollow core, without the cladding supporting a photonic bandgap. This was first noted in cladding structures consisting of a web of thin solid struts, called a kagome lattice, with the characteristic of wider transmission windows but with higher loss compared to bandgap fibres [67, 69, 128–130]; the fibre in Figure 6(d) is such an example. Qualitatively identical results were also obtained for a square lattice fibre [68, 131]. This work in the context of polymer fibres contributed to the understanding of this “inhibited coupling” guidance mechanism. The observed guidance was attributed to light inefficiently coupling to the cladding modes (rather than there being no cladding modes to couple to as in the case of a bandgap) [67–69, 130–133]. A solid version of an inhibited coupling fibre consisting of isolated thin high-index rings (made of PC) in a lower-index background (PMMA) is shown in Figure 7 and was studied to explore the limits of this guidance mechanism [74]. The availability of compatible polymers with such an index contrast (of 0.09) made this work possible.
(a)
(b)
A final point worth noting on hollow-core fibres is that the light propagates in air and not in the solid material, which at first glance indicates that material loss can be eliminated. This was investigated as a means of using PMMA and PC fibres in the infrared [38, 67], and indeed losses of 2 to 10 dB/m were achieved for wavelengths where the material loss was 3000 dB/m. However, this does not offer a better option than using a simple multimode fibre at 650 nm, which will have a loss <0.2 dB/m. The reason is that scattering losses play a larger role in hollow-core fibres [126]. As a result, single-mode hollow-core photonic bandgap fibres will have losses of order 1 dB/m in the visible and will guide over a narrow wavelength range. Inhibited coupling fibres will guide over a larger wavelength range, but losses of 0.18 dB/m have only recently been reported for silica fibres [134]. Furthermore, defects in the microstructure are detrimental in both hollow-core fibre types. These types of fibres are of particular interest for use at terahertz frequencies, and this comparison will be discussed in more detail in Section 5.
4.5. Limitations
The limitations of mPOF arise ultimately from loss and temperature stability (which both compare unfavourably to silica). For the larger core multimode fibres, such as the high-bandwidth fibres, the loss and temperature stability specifications of commercially available conventional POF have been matched [11]. The lowest loss achieved in this case is 0.16 dB/m at 650 nm, shown in Figure 8, and the loss is generally <0.2 dB/m at 650 nm. Operation up to 90°C can be achieved with losses <0.24 dB/m. These limits are determined by the material itself, PMMA, and other loss mechanisms such as microbending, defects, and surface roughness on the inner surface of the holes appear to make negligible contributions in these cases [11]. In addition, bending losses can be greatly reduced [116].
As the core diameter is reduced, the light increasingly interacts with the surface of the holes, and roughness thereon begins to become problematic as it increases the loss through scattering. A very clear dependence of loss on core diameter is seen in Figure 8(a). This results in the loss of the single-mode fibres increasing to 1.6 dB/m at 650 nm and limits the use of such fibre to lengths of around 10 m as noted earlier. As the diameter of the entire fibre is reduced, the lower Young’s modulus of the polymer (Table 2) means that microbending becomes a problem, seen in Figure 8(b). To minimise this, the diameter of fibres must be kept above 250 μm, whilst microbending is eliminated at 500 μm diameters. The silica fibre standard of 125 μm is thus highly impractical [11].
There is no clear way to overcome these limitations, especially all of them simultaneously. As noted previously, a material like CYTOP has a significantly lower loss than PMMA, particularly in the infrared, and would result in reducing the loss of the fibres. However, CYTOP has lower temperature stability than PMMA, and materials with higher such as PC have a higher loss (see Table 1 and Figure 1). Hollow-core fibres can reduce material loss in the infrared where it is very high, but offer no real advantage in the visible as other loss mechanisms like scattering dominate, as discussed in Section 4.4. It is unclear if the surface roughness problem on the internal surface of the holes is a fabrication issue or an intrinsic property of the polymer (studies of roughness in silica HC-PCF found roughness to have thermodynamic origins in surface capillary waves on the molten glass and thus could not be eliminated [126]). A suitable jacketing material may help with microbending losses, although they are eliminated with a sufficiently thick fibre [11].
5. THz Waveguides
The guidance of THz radiation with a waveguide equivalent to an optical fibre remains an unsolved problem. Several challenges must be managed, beginning with the broader spectrum of THz radiation that one would want to guide, ideally ~6.5 octaves of frequency to cover the nominal range of 0.1 to 10 THz compared to ~2.5 octaves through the visible and near infrared. The larger wavelengths lead towards equivalently larger waveguides which become impractically thick and inflexible. Finally, there has been no sufficiently transparent material identified, meaning absorption losses would also need to be managed. As seen in Table 1 and Figure 1(c), Zeonex and Topas have amongst the lowest losses, but these are nevertheless at the level of ~1 dB/cm or 0.2 cm−1 at 1 THz. Other transparent materials like high-resistivity silicon would be rigid and not compatible with fibre fabrication.
There have been many demonstrations of THz waveguides based on both metallic microwave waveguides (approaching the problem from lower frequencies) and on dielectric waveguides (optical fibres, approaching from higher frequencies). Metal-based waveguides include metal wires [135], parallel metal plates [136], and metal or metal-coated tubes [137, 138] and have reported losses of order 0.01 to 1 cm−1. Dielectric-based waveguides initially relied on total internal reflection at the interface between the waveguide itself and the surrounding air, for example, using plastic (HDPE) ribbons to obtain losses of 1 cm−1 [20]. Most of this work to date has been limited to demonstrating appropriately scaled waveguides that are known to work at other frequency ranges, without specifically addressing the requirements of working with terahertz frequency radiation.
The role of polymers here begins with identifying that polymers will remain flexible at relatively large diameters (on the mm scale), and the polymers with higher transparency have indices in the range commonly used in optics, meaning known waveguide designs could be easily adapted, as a start. This has led to investigations into solid-core, porous-core, and hollow-core terahertz waveguides based on microstructured polymer fibres.
5.1. Solid-Core Waveguides
HDPE and PTFE with losses as discussed in Section 2 and Table 1 were amongst the first polymers to be used in the context of microstructured polymer terahertz waveguides. Solid-core microstructured waveguides based on these polymers and the common hexagonal hole array were reported with losses of order 0.1 cm−1 and propagation lengths of 10 cm for the PTFE case [45], and losses of 0.5 cm−1 and propagation over 2 cm for the HDPE case [46]. More recently, Zeonex and Topas polymers which have lower loss were used. The Topas waveguide used the common hexagonal hole array as shown in Figure 9(a) and demonstrated propagation lengths of 9 cm [48]. The Zeonex waveguide used a suspended core design with five holes surrounding the core as shown in Figure 9(b) and demonstrated propagation lengths of 7 cm [47]. The Zeonex waveguide loss spectrum is shown in Figure 9(e), showing losses of order 0.1 cm−1, essentially matching the material loss. Indeed, the material loss ultimately determines the loss of such solid core waveguides and limits their use to short lengths.
5.2. Porous Waveguides
The first approach to managing the material loss resulted in the use of so-called porous fibres, which consisted of a structured (porous) core with the surrounding air as the cladding [139–144]; an example is shown in Figure 9(c). The benefit arises from reducing the amount of solid material in the core, owing to the presence of the holes, and hence reducing the material absorption (and also affecting the average refractive index of the core and group velocity of the guided modes). Such an approach can potentially lead to a reduction in material loss by an order of magnitude, with predicted losses of order 0.01 cm−1 for cyclo-olefin-based waveguides at low frequencies [144].
The limitation here is that the waveguide consists of a bare core, and an exposed core is sensitive to external perturbations. However, this would be an advantage in some sensing applications, as discussed previously in the context of exposed core mPOF in the visible.
5.3. Hollow-Core Waveguides
The second approach to managing the material loss is to use a hollow core fibre and thus remove the material from the core altogether. This was discussed previously in Section 4.4 in the context of visible and infrared transmission. Unlike at higher frequencies, scattering losses are negligible for terahertz frequencies and material losses are sufficiently high that hollow-core waveguides offer a real advantage. The first such HC-mPOF for terahertz was made of PMMA with a Bragg fibre-like structure consisting of concentric rings of holes around the core [145] as shown in Figure 9(d), fabricated by drilling. The reported loss was 1-2 dB/cm (approximately 0.25–0.5 cm−1) at around 1–1.3 THz, a factor of 30–60 times below the PMMA material loss at those frequencies [145]. The design of this waveguide was not optimised, and the total diameter was approximately 6 mm. Other Bragg fibres were subsequently reported using TiO2-loaded HDPE for the high-index layers, and PTFE for the low-index layers, and the rolling fabrication technique of Figure 2(e) [146, 147]. An example of such fibres is shown in Figure 10(a). These had a total diameter of around 12 mm, and estimated losses were of order 0.1 cm−1 within the transmission windows [147].
(a)
(b)
There are two further options for hollow-core microstructured waveguides beyond the Bragg fibres [145, 147] discussed previously: to use photonic bandgap guidance or the inhibited coupling mechanism. As discussed in Section 4.4, hollow-core bandgap waveguides will have a narrow spectral width of approximately 20% of the centre frequency (30% of an octave) [148], but can achieve a lower loss of <20 dB/km in the infrared. Inhibited coupling based guidance in hollow-cores has been demonstrated over a wider spectrum of 70% of the centre frequency (approximately 1 octave) with higher losses of 180 dB/km [134]. The limits of this mechanism explored in a solid-core arrangement are shown in Figure 7 and predict transmission windows exceeding an octave [74]. The wider transmission bandwidth makes inhibited coupling waveguides an appealing option, and with their hollow core, they appear promising for two of the three criteria noted earlier. The “higher” loss is already orders of magnitude lower than any terahertz waveguide demonstrations.
The third criterion is the diameter of the waveguide, and inhibited coupling waveguides offer more flexibility to reduce the overall diameter for two important reasons. Firstly, inhibited coupling waveguides demonstrated thus far have consisted of a lattice of thin struts with a large pitch compared to the guided wavelength (and also to the lattice pitch of bandgap fibres operating at the same wavelength) [67–69, 128–134]. However, the critical parameter of the lattice that contributes to the inhibited coupling mechanism is the thickness of the struts and not the pitch. It is resonances across this thickness, rather than along the length of the struts, that determine the transmission windows of the fibre to a first approximation [68, 130, 133]. This means that the thickness of the waveguide can be reduced by reducing the pitch, whilst keeping the strut thickness constant. However, this may come at the cost of reducing the core size and increasing the loss as a result, and a study of this trade-off was reported in [149].
Secondly, it is not necessary to have a very thick cladding (i.e., many rings of holes surrounding the core) as the dominant loss mechanism in inhibited coupling fibres is coupling to cladding modes, and not tunnelling through the cladding as in bandgap fibres. Tunnelling can be reduced by extending the cladding outwards from the core, however, as this is not relevant to inhibited coupling fibres, the overall thickness of the cladding can be minimised to just a few rings of holes [67, 149].
An experimental demonstration of such an inhibited coupling waveguide using PMMA was also reported [150]. This was of a kagome lattice waveguide with a relatively short lattice pitch and thick struts, a core diameter of 2.2 mm and an overall diameter of 6.8 mm. A transmission loss below 0.6 cm−1 was measured between 0.65 and 1 THz, which was approximately 20 times below the material loss of the PMMA. The near field of the output was also characterised to show single-mode operation.
Another approach utilising the inhibited coupling mechanism is to move away from a connected lattice, as in the original kagome fibre demonstrations [128], and towards a lattice of touching but disconnected circular tubes (such a design would be similar to the isolated PC tubes in a PMMA background shown in Figure 7 [74]). These fibres are called tube lattice fibres (TLFs) and have been demonstrated using silica for guidance in the infrared [151, 152]. The important characteristic here is the potentially wide transmission windows; transmission over two octaves of frequency was reported across several transmission windows in the near and mid-infrared [151]. A thorough theoretical investigation of these fibres for terahertz frequencies has shown them to be potentially low loss with wide transmission windows, one octave or greater, whilst larger bandwidths may again be guided across multiple transmission windows [153–155]. This has been accompanied by a study of the guidance mechanisms specific to TLF to increase understanding of their operation, and hence aid with future designs [156, 157]. The circular individual tubes also contribute to lower the loss as compared to a usual kagome lattice, which consists of straight segments in the cladding [134, 151, 158]. Predicted dimensions for such waveguide designs are of order 1 cm, thus they also remain promising in terms of flexibility.
5.4. Outlook
Work on microstructured polymer terahertz waveguides continues, and progress has been made towards overcoming the material losses, broadening transmission windows, and reducing the diameter of the waveguides to achieve flexibility. The combination of Zeonex or Topas with hollow-core TLF waveguides seems like a promising avenue to achieve low-loss flexible waveguides. The limitations in this work are the material loss, large frequency range, and large wavelengths; the field is still new, and whilst work has aimed at overcoming these latter three limitations, the limitations of the approaches taken remain unclear at this early stage. Research into terahertz waveguides in general is still ongoing, and any work using the options discussed here must ultimately be compared to other approaches not confined to microstructured polymer waveguides, such as hollow metal-coated tube waveguides, for example. Currently, there is no single approach that clearly outperforms others.
6. Drawn Metamaterials
Metamaterials are man-made composites that obtain their properties from their structure. This structure can be composed of individual meta-atoms, metal-dielectric structures that are designed to have specific properties. In particular, a metamaterial will have electromagnetic properties (permittivity and permeability) that arise from the properties of these meta-atoms, such as their resonances, in the same way as regular materials derive their properties from the resonances of real atoms [22, 24, 25]. This allows metamaterials to have engineered electric and magnetic responses, and most interestingly, this allows responses not found in nature to be achieved. Naturally occurring materials are generally summarised as having large negative relative permittivity for metals, small positive relative permittivity for dielectrics, and a relative permeability of 1 in the frequency range concerning this paper. The properties of metamaterials can deviate significantly from these values.
This paper does not in any way seek to cover the vast field of metamaterials in its entirety. One aspect of metamaterials is that the meta-atoms and the structures within them are subwavelength. This requires fabrication on a small scale (100 nm and below for the visible, to 100 μm scales for THz), which is usually incompatible with fabrication in large volumes. The area that will be addressed in this paper is the use of fibre drawing techniques based on microstructured polymer fibres, to fabricate metamaterials. Fibre drawing (as in mPOF) produces micron-scaled features in large quantities and offers a potentially scalable method for the fabrication of metamaterials when the microstructure is filled with metal. There are two basic meta-atoms which are easily understood: wire arrays which control the permittivity [159], and resonators which are similar to LC circuits with a magnetic resonance, and control permeability [22]. Both wire arrays and resonators are compatible with fibre drawing and the resulting longitudinally invariant geometry.
6.1. Wire Arrays: Electric Metamaterials
The electromagnetic properties of metals can be described by a Drude model and characterised by a plasma frequency in the UV. Below this plasma frequency, metallic behaviour is observed, characterised by negative permittivity, , and strong reflection. Above it, dielectric behaviour is observed with and transmission. The plasma frequency corresponds to and depends on the electrons’ effective mass in the metal and the electron density. If a metal is broken up into subwavelength wires, self and mutual inductance of the wires results in a change to the electrons’ effective mass, and the average electron density (averaged on the scale of a wavelength) is reduced in comparison to the bulk metal. These effects (predominantly the former) result in the plasma frequency shifting to lower frequencies. This approach allows the permittivity at a particular frequency to be adjusted by adjusting the size and spacing between the wires in such a subwavelength wire array [159, 160]. Furthermore, such a wire array will have a highly anisotropic permittivity tensor, with only being described by such a modified Drude model (electric field parallel to the wires). For electric field oriented transverse to the wires, the permittivity will be very close to that of the dielectric medium in which the wires are embedded.
Wire arrays are obviously compatible with fibre drawing and are intrinsically longitudinally invariant. Fibre drawing to fabricate wires was investigated since the 1920s in the Taylor wire process [78], and more recently optical fibres with wires were investigated in the study of surface plasmons [161, 162]. In terms of wire array metamaterials, wire arrays have been made using PMMA as the base material and the general methods described in Section 3 [75]. Indium metal was used in this work as it melts at 156.6°C and is thus liquid at the fibre drawing temperatures of approximately 200°C. Indium wire was inserted into PMMA tubes, which were drawn to a smaller diameter. The resulting wires were stacked together inside a larger tube to form the array and drawn a second time to achieve the desired dimensions. The final fibres were assembled into an array and characterised. The reported case in [75] had wires of approximately 8 μm diameter at 100 μm spacing, which resulted in a plasma frequency in the vicinity of 0.2–0.3 THz, depending on the exact dimensions of the fibre. An example of this wire array fibre and its transmittance are shown in Figure 11. The plasma frequency is inferred from the transition from dielectric behaviour observed at higher frequencies indicated by high transmittance, to metallic behaviour at low frequencies, indicated by poor transmittance. Excellent agreement with simulations was noted [75, 159, 160].
6.2. Resonators: Magnetic Metamaterials
To achieve a magnetic response, an open loop of wire in the shape of a “C” (a split ring resonator, SRR) or two such concentric loops rotated 180° relative to each other (a double split ring resonator, DSSR) can be used, as seen in Figure 12. The gap in the open ring of the SRR or between the two rings in a DSRR creates a capacitance, and the curved shape creates an inductance. As a result, these structures have an LC resonance and will result in a magnetic response at high frequencies and from nonmagnetic materials [22, 163]. This resonance will be driven by a magnetic field perpendicular to the plane of the resonator (and also electric fields parallel to the gap in a SRR). Such resonators will continue to work in the longitudinally invariant case that would result from fibre drawing. The resulting metamaterial will also be anisotropic, having a permeability described by a resonance in the component (magnetic field parallel to the fibre axis), whilst will correspond to the free space value for transverse magnetic field components. Interestingly, apart from achieving a magnetic response at high frequencies, if the resonance is strong enough, it will result in a negative permeability and a magnetic plasma frequency, where .
Such resonators were also fabricated using drawing methods and combinations of PMMA, PC, and Zeonex [76, 77]. The preforms were assembled by rolling indium sheet around a PMMA tube, with a PMMA rod filling a gap in the sheet to create the split in the ring (twice for DSRRs). This assembly was then inserted inside a PC tube to form the preform and drawn to fibre in several stages. A PMMA tube was used in the inner sections of the resonator as the inner sections are shielded by the metal and remain slightly colder compared to the outer part of the preform. Hence, using a PMMA tube (hollow, and with a lower ) inside and PC (higher ) outside helped to ensure that the viscosity of the polymer was uniform across the preform [76].
In the SRR case, the resonators were further stacked inside a rectangular Zeonex slab [76]. Zeonex was used for its transparency in the THz as discussed in Sections 2 and 5. This created “sheets” of resonator arrays that could be assembled, a first step towards forming bulk 3D metamaterials from this method, as shown in Figure 12(b). The final resonators were 100–350 μm in diameter and had magnetic resonances between 0.1 and 0.4 THz. The resonances were characterised by a reduction in the transmittance; an example is shown in Figure 12(d).
In the DSRR case, sleeving was required to increase the outer diameter and help preserve the structure of the two rings. The sleeve was later removed by etching. PMMA and Zeonex sleeves were reported, but the Zeonex here was used not for its transparency but because it could be removed with cyclohexane, a solvent that does not affect the PMMA and PC in the resonators themselves [77]. An example of an etched fibre is shown in Figure 12(c). Such fibres once etched were also assembled into arrays and characterised in terms of transmittance. The final resonator sizes were approximately 100 μm in diameter, and resonances at 0.25 THz were observed. These resonators were smaller relative to the resonant wavelength compared to SRR, meaning a homogenous material would be more easily achieved. This work also showed that fibre drawing could be extended to more complex meta-atoms.
6.3. Future Directions and Limitations
The work on drawn metamaterials is still in its early days. Basic control over the electric and magnetic response has been demonstrated with the wire array and magnetic resonator fibres, within the constraints of the longitudinally invariant fibre geometry. Potential extensions of this work include more complex structures in fibres and combinations of fibres to produce metamaterials composed of multiple meta-atoms. For example, woven metamaterial structures could be realised with magnetic resonator fibres woven perpendicular to wire array fibres. If a negative permeability and permittivity are combined in such a way, a negative refractive index [21] drawn metamaterial fabric could be achieved. The smaller resonator to wavelength ratio observed for DSRR would be advantageous in such cases that require multiple components to be assembled. This work also has the potential to be extended to the various metamaterial devices that are currently being investigated, such as metamaterial lenses and cloaking [26–28, 30].
In addition to metamaterials themselves, recent theoretical work into metamaterial-based waveguides has reported on many designs that would be compatible with the fibre drawing process [164–166]. These offer the potential for relatively small and even subwavelength confinement of radiation. This is particularly relevant to terahertz waveguides discussed in Section 5, where the size of the wavelength is an issue, and provide an alternative approach to investigating thin waveguides.
The limitations of drawn metamaterials have not fully been explored. Investigations thus far have been on the scale of 10 to 100 μm and at terahertz frequencies. Whether the extension to smaller sizes and higher frequencies into the infrared and visible is possible remains unclear. Work in the visible would require 10 to 100 nm scales, which have been fabricated in other material fibre systems [167]. Furthermore, losses due to metals and the potential for introducing gain are a concern for metamaterials research in general. At higher frequencies, gold and silver are known to have preferable optical properties, but their high melting points (~1000°C) make them incompatible with any polymer.
The use of polymer has been a key in this work as it built on the existing fabrication techniques developed for mPOF described in Section 3 and allowed these fabrication methods and metamaterials to be investigated on a short time scale using an inexpensive fabrication and material system. In the case of terahertz metamaterials, polymers offer the additional advantage in the transparency of Zeonex and Topas. Ultimately, metamaterials obtain their properties from their structure; however, one important way in which the constituent materials contribute is through their absorption. At higher frequencies, other material systems with lower loss, particularly metals, may be preferred.
7. Conclusion
The work on microstructured polymer fibres, as outlined previously, has progressed through the three distinct areas of optical fibres, terahertz waveguides, and drawn metamaterials. The optical fibre work, mPOF, is the most developed, having begun the earliest, and has reached the point where specific applications are being pursued. These applications are in sensing, particularly through the use of gratings, and short-distance data transmission. In these cases, the use of microstructure and polymer offers distinct quantified advantages, such as larger elastic limits, versatile fabrication techniques, higher data rates, and significantly lower loss in the simple case of a polymer single-mode fibre for the visible, which in turn enables much of the work on gratings. As a technology, its operation and limitations are largely understood, and other than any possible technological developments, no significant change in this field is expected. Such changes are of course possible, but would need to be triggered by a new research effort and a qualitatively different approach to what has been demonstrated thus far, a good example being the potential widespread use of (currently unavailable) fluorinated materials. These could significantly reduce the loss of mPOF and allow their use at telecommunications wavelengths, as discussed in Section 4.5.
The work on terahertz waveguides and drawn metamaterials is still in its infancy in comparison. Waveguide designs are in the process of being developed and refined for use at terahertz frequencies, and polymers are an excellent material in which to fabricate them. The terahertz field itself is still emerging, and components taken for granted in the visible and infrared, low-loss flexible waveguides in this context, would find immediate uses in research and eventually possibly in real applications.
The drawn metamaterials work has also barely reached beyond the proof of concept stage, with only the basic electric and magnetic metamaterial fibres having been reported. Extensions of this work to more complex fibre geometries, higher frequencies, and to metamaterial devices containing these fibres will surely follow. The potential of the fibre drawing technique is its inherent scalability to large volumes, and this may prove advantageous when metamaterials such as these begin finding applications.