Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, Second University of Naples, Via Roma 29, Aversa, 81031 Caserta, Italy
The velocity induced by a plane, uniform vortex is investigated through the use of an integral relation between Schwarz function of the vortex boundary and conjugate of the velocity. The analysis is restricted to a certain class of vortices, the boundaries of which are described through conformal maps onto the unit circle and the corresponding Schwarz functions possess two poles in the plane of the circle. The dependence of the velocity field on the vortex shape is investigated by comparing velocity and streamfunction with the ones of the equivalent Rankine vortex (which has the same vorticity, area, and center of vorticity). By changing the parameters of the Schwarz function (poles and corresponding residues), rather complicated vortex shapes can be easily analyzed, some of them mimicing an incipient filamentation of the vortex boundary.
1. Introduction
The present paper investigates the self-induced
velocity field of a uniform vortex having Schwarz function of its boundary with
two simple poles on a suitable transformed plane. This analysis is viewed as a
first step towards the study of the dynamics of such a vortex in terms of the
related Schwarz function.
The use of the Schwarz function in searching vortex
equilibria and also in investigating their stability properties dates back to
the eighties of the last century (e.g., see the elegant discussion in [1, Section 9.2]). As well known, the Schwarz function of an analytic curve in the plane of the complex variable satisfies the request (a definition is indicated by joining the two
symbols “” and “”, with the first one on the side in which
the new quantity appears) in any point and is defined via analytic continuation on a
suitable neighbourhood of the curve
In general, singularities of the function are found inside and outside
An extensive theoretical background on the Schwarz function can be found in
[2], while an attempt
to summarize the original ideas on the use of such a function in searching
vortex equilibria may be the following one.
The curve is taken as the boundary of a uniform vortex (with unitary vorticity, for the sake of
simplicity) and it is assumed that can be rewritten as the sum of two functions: ,
where and are analytic inside and outside ,
respectively. It is worth noticing that the behavior of for follows just from the above splitting of
Indeed, consider the integral on the path of Figure 1 of the function ,
for fixed away from the vortex. It gives the value
of in terms of the moments of the Schwarz
function: with the integral having in place of vanishing, because is analytic inside
By accounting for that the integral for gives times the area of the vortex, the asymptotic behavior of follows as
Figure 1: Integration path for studying the asymptotic behavior of the function
It can be noticed that the conjugate of the velocity is analytic outside ,
while is analytic inside the vortex (both cases will
be unified in terms of a Cauchy integral of in (2.9) below); it follows that must have the form Indeed, the continuity across
the vortex boundary follows by that on the , behaves at infinity as and the corresponding vorticity is uniform and
unitary inside and vanishes outside. At this stage, it is
also easy to show that the asymptotic behavior of the velocity is related to
the (complex) moments of the Schwarz function, through the power series of (1.1).
The formula (1.2) relates velocity and Schwarz function
in a very appealing way. However, the identification of the functions and is often a quite complicated goal, which is
reached by firstly identifying through its asymptotic behavior (1.1) and then
by taking as
In the present paper, an approach which is alternative to the use of the
relation (1.2) is proposed: and are related through a Cauchy integral, which
is evaluated without splitting the Schwarz function. The two approaches are
completely equivalent: if the Schwarz function is not too complicated, the
splitting (1.2) is still more convenient, but in other cases the present approach
can give some advantage. As an important example, for the class of vortices
investigated in the present paper the use of the integral approach results
in being much easier than the one of the splitting
(1.2).
When the shape of the uniform vortex is not far from a circular one (quasicircular vortex), the identification of and is rather simple and the analysis can go ahead
[3]. The vortex
boundary belongs to a ring inside which the Schwarz function is evaluated via a
Laurent series, with and being the analytic continuations of its
regular and singular parts, respectively. Due to the small differences from a
circle, it is also convenient to use a Laurent series in order to define the
vortex shape through a conformal map between the unit circle and
The coefficients of the series for are nonlinear combinations of the ones of the
map. Configurations of absolute equilibrium in presence of external rotation
and stationary strain (intensity and principal axes of which are kept fixed in
time) have been investigated by imposing that the normal velocity of the fluid
at the vortex boundary vanishes:
This relation is enforced to be identically satisfied in ,
that is, any power of is multiplied times a vanishing coefficient: a nonlinear system in the map coefficients follows, to which conditions concerning the area of the vortex and the position of its center of vorticity are added. The system is numerically solved
via a multidimensional Newton solver. Finally, the linear stability of
stationary solutions also is investigated with the above approach. The
coefficients of the conformal map are taken as functions of time, and
it is enforced that the normal components of the
velocity of the fluid and of the vortex boundary agree:
The above constraint is linearized around a stationary solution, time
dependence is fixed in the form (with being a complex number, the real part of which
determines the stability properties of the vortex) and an eigenvalue problem
is deduced. Several interesting cases of bifurcations of equilibria are
discussed, with particular regard to the energy conservation. Also the dynamics
of quasicircular vortices has been investigated [4], but by using a quite
different approach. The vortex boundary is described in terms of a Fourier series and an equation of evolution for the Fourier coefficients is deduced.
It is also found that the derivatives along the vortex boundary of the velocity
and of the Schwarz function are related through a Cauchy integral.
In the last ten years, a large research
activity has been devoted to find and analyze
stationary solutions of the Euler equation by using the Schwarz function. The
vortex shape is searched by starting from the following form of the
streamfunction in a corotating frame of reference: The form (1.3) is assumed valid
outside or inside the vortex, while is taken as vanishing on the complementary
part of the physical plane. Multipolar equilibria have been analyzed in
[5], where symmetrical
configurations of point vortices are placed into a uniform one, in such a way
that the total circulation vanishes. In this paper, the form (1.3) is built as an
extension to general shapes of the streamfunction for the shielded Rankine
vortex (see also [6],
in which the discussion is carried out in the framework of the quadrature
domains by using a fundamental theorem of Aharonov and Shapiro). The stability
properties of the above equilibria have been analyzed in [7], both in the framework of a
linear theory and through fully nonlinear numerical simulations with a contour
dynamics approach (see (2.2) below). Quadrupoles, pentapoles, and higher have
been found to be stable equilibria, while the tripoles result in
being linearly unstable. Other interesting equilibria involving a
doubly connected uniform vortex and an internal set of pointwise ones are found
in [8], mimicing the
overlapping of shielded Rankine vortices. An irrotational region remains
trapped at the center of the vortex. In [9], a class of stationary solutions consisting in a
uniform vortex surrounded by a certain number of point corotating vortices
placed on the vertices of a regular polygon is
built and analyzed. This vortex pattern depends on an integer number ,
which specifies the number of satellite vortices, and on a parameter belonging to a lower bounded interval of the
real axis. In correspondence to the minimum value of and for a given ,
called ,
the central uniform vortex exhibits a nonanalytic boundary in which cusps are present. For growing ,
the central uniform vortex becomes smaller and smaller (its area decreasing as ), with its shape going to a circular one. In
[10], the
streamfunction (1.3) is used to generalize to finite-area vortices the ideas of
Aref and Vainchtein [11]
who search asymmetric equilibria of point vortices by inserting new vortices on
points of relative rest (in a corotating reference frame). By such an approach,
growing uniform vortices are inserted in a corotating vortex pair until the
Rankine vortex is reached. The stability of such one-parameter family of
equilibria has been also tested through numerical simulations with a contour
dynamics approach. Other equilibria depending on two parameters and involving
uniform vortices and point vortices are found in [12], still starting from the streamfunction (1.3). A central
uniform vortex is surrounded by an alternate distribution of pointwise and
uniform vortices. Also in this case, vortex shapes with cusps are found for certain
critical values of the parameters and numerical simulations show the formation
of filaments in configurations having large satellite vortices with cusps, as
well as in perturbed (by displacing point vortices) equilibria.
The present paper deals with the self-induced velocity
of any vortex, the boundary of which possesses a Schwarz function with two
simple poles (on a suitable transformed plane). This vortex shape appears to be
the simplest, but nontrivial, possible one: the velocity can be evaluated
analytically by using an integral link with the corresponding function of its boundary. For this reason, it has been
selected by the authors as the starting point of an analysis of the vortex
motion through the dynamics of ,
which satisfies the evolution equation [13]: In order to investigate nontrivial
sample cases, the analytical forms of the velocity are needed in (1.4). The
present analysis achieves the first step of such a way. At the same time, it
shows the advantage of using an integral link between and
The paper is organized as follows. The integral
relation between Schwarz function and velocity is presented in Section 2. In
Section 3, an overall view of the geometrical properties of the vortices having
Schwarz function with two simple poles is given. A classification of this kind
of vortices is proposed in Section 4, while a discussion of several sample
cases follows in Section 5. In Section 6, the inverse map (from the physical
plane to the transformed one) is built and the self-induced velocity is
analytically evaluated. The different velocity fields (together with the
corresponding streamfunctions) are shown and discussed in Section 7, where
we also propose the use of an equivalent Rankine
vortex in order to investigate the dependence of the velocity on the vortex
shape. Conclusions are offered in Section 8, together with a sketch of the
principal research lines under investigation at the present time.
2. An Integral Relation between Schwarz Function and Velocity
The velocity induced by a uniform vortex (inside which the vorticity is unitary, for
the sake of simplicity) depends only on the shape of its boundary :
if it is smooth and its length is finite, then in any point of the plane the velocity is given by where is the Green function of the Laplace operator,
that is, (the modulus of a vector is represented with
the same symbol, but without using the bold character, e.g., ), and is the curve element. The motion of such a
kind of vortex is defined by the time evolution of its boundary, starting from
a smooth and finite-length boundary at the initial time (). In order to numerically investigate that
motion, the form (2.1) of the velocity is used as briefly described below.
Consider a parameter on at time
With the vortex motion being a material one, it is
possible to write as a function of the corresponding parameter at the initial time () and of the time itself:
The Lagrangian representation of the position on the vortex boundary becomes natural and the velocity (2.1) evaluated
on that point, that is ,
gives the Lagrangian velocity
It follows that the motion of is the solution of the Cauchy problem: The above approach is known as contour dynamics [14, 15], a powerful tool to
investigate the inviscid, incompressible two-dimensional vortex motion.
Obviously, in the numerical practice a certain number of nodes are selected on
the initial boundary and their motion is followed in time. In the discrete
framework, the velocity (2.1) is evaluated through an interpolation procedure
which rebuilds an approximation of
By starting from the contour dynamics form of the
velocity (2.1), in the present section an integral relation between Schwarz
function and velocity is deduced, which is equivalent to the form (1.2) but it
does not require the splitting of the Schwarz function in the sum
The key observation about (2.1) lies in considering that if the point is not on the vortex boundary, an integration
by parts enables us to write with the dot indicating a scalar product. By
conjugating both sides of the above relation, it may be rewritten in the
following complex form: Notice that the first integral
in the right-hand side of the above equation holds if lies inside the vortex (), while it vanishes when is external to the vortex (). Equation (2.4) relates velocity and Schwarz
function in any point which does not lie on the vortex boundary,
while if the point belongs to that curve, the discussion must be
carried out in a more sophisticated way.
The tangent derivative of the conjugate of the
velocity on the vortex boundary has been investigated in a previous paper
[4], where it has
been shown that it is related to the tangent derivative of the Schwarz
function, that is, to the function ,
with being the unit vector which is tangent to
The relation is through a Cauchy integral (see [4, equation (18)], rewritten here for reader's convenience): By changing with ,
an integration by parts gives in which the second integral in
the last side holds ,
it follows that In this way, the conjugate of
the velocity in the point belonging to the patch boundary becomes
Equations (2.4) and (2.8) are summarized by introducing
the characteristic function of the domain ,
which holds inside , outside ,
and on the boundary, in the following new form of
the self-induced velocity: with the position that the
integral must be a Cauchy one if the point lies on the curve
It is worth noticing that the velocity (2.9) is a function of both and inside the vortex, while it depends on only on (through the Schwarz function) and outside the
vortex. The velocity (2.9) is a continuous function across :
indeed if approaches from the inside of the vortex, goes to and the integral to plus continuous terms (given by the
singularities of the Schwarz function), while if reaches from the outside, the first term vanishes and
only the above continuous contribution remains. On the vortex boundary, holds ,
while the integral must be considered as Cauchy's
one and it leads to a contribution plus the continuous contribution due to the
singularities of
The above form of the velocity gives also the correct asymptotic behavior: for going to infinity, being the area of the vortex. It is also
important to notice that once the splitting is inserted into the integral at the
right-hand side of (2.9), the original formulation (1.2) is recovered.
As a first sample case for the use of (2.9), consider an
elliptical vortex having center of vorticity on the origin and semiaxes along and () along (the related quantities , , ,
and will be also used below). By using the angle ,
the curve is parametrized as ,
which is rewritten in terms of as Equation (2.10) defines a
conformal map between the plane of the unit circle () and the physical one (). Due to the fact that the ellipse is a
simple curve, the equation in cannot have another solution on unless Indeed, it also possesses the solution (notice that ). The solutions and are expressed in terms of in the following way: If the point belongs to the vortex,
then
and the same holds also for ,
while for , lies outside the unit circle and
By conjugating both sides of (2.10) for ,
the Schwarz function follows naturally as the function of : The velocity is evaluated by
rewriting (2.9) in the transformed plane : If ,
then both poles and are internal to and the above equation gives while if , lies outside the unit circle and ,
so that the velocity becomes However, in the present case the
splitting of the Schwarz function (2.12) can be easily performed: which still gives the fields
(2.14) and (2.15) through the relation (1.2). As discussed above, when the functional
form of the Schwarz function is rather simple, as in (2.12), the old formulation
(1.2) is convenient with respect to the new one (2.9). This is not the case of the
class of vortices investigated in the present paper.
3. The Schwarz Function with Two Pole Singularities
The present paper deals with a uniform vortex having
Schwarz function of its boundary with two pole singularities
(it is worth noticing that the vortex having
Schwarz function of its boundary with only the pole : is a circular, with center in and radius ) on a suitable transformed plane, with the aim
to investigate the corresponding self-induced velocity field. For ,
the Schwarz function is considered. The residues , in (3.1) are assumed to be nonvanishing complex
numbers (notice that one of them, e.g. ,
can be assumed unitary without loss of generality), while the poles , are chosen outside and the origin (). It is also assumed that their conjugates
with respect to ,
that is, and ,
satisfy the two conditions and
The Schwarz function (3.1) gives the position in the point as The point given by (3.2) can move counterclockwise or
clockwise along ,
even if runs always counterclockwise on
In order to specify the direction in which moves on ,
a parameter is introduced, which holds when runs counterclockwise and in the other case. It will be evaluated in
Section 4.
Analytic continuations of the Schwarz function (3.1)
and of the map (3.2) outside will be considered in the following, so that
the definition of the inverse map outside the vortex boundary needs also to be
discussed (see Section 6). It is shown that exists almost everywhere, unless on a closed
curve ,
the inside of which has a vanishing area (see Figure 2).
Figure 2: Sketch of the invariant circle in the planes of the variables and and its image in the physical plane. The points and their images are represented with green dots. The same
colours (blue and red) are used for the arcs that are images through the maps and of the two arcs in which is divided by the points
For running on ,
the point moves on the closed curve ,
first in a direction and then in the reverse one. is composed by two superimposed arcs of the
circle (yellow line)
between the points and : its inside has a vanishing area.
3.1. Constants , , and
In the
following, the poles and the corresponding residues of the Schwarz function (3.1)
will often appear combined into the constants: moreover the related quantities: , , and will be also employed. In terms of the above
constants, for example, the compact form of a vector which is tangent to the vortex boundary on its
point : is obtained. The function (3.4)
suggests a first constraint on the Schwarz one (3.1): cannot vanish on
The nonvanishing zeros of are given by ,
with being the branch of the square root of for which (see also Appendix
D. Notice that and its modulus verifies the relation ,
with being the phase difference ). As a
consequence, in order to enforce on the unit circle, the points are hereafter assumed external to
Other important constraints will be discussed in the next section.
3.2. Map and Constraints on Schwarz Function
The Schwarz function (3.1) cannot be assigned in an
arbitrary way: for the curve is the boundary of a uniform
vortex, it must be simple. This constraint can be enforced by requiring that
for any ,
the equation in has no other solutions on ,
unless
The only solution of that equation which differs from is so that the above condition
results to be equivalent to the one: for each
Equation (3.5) implies also that the points and go on the same point :
the analytic continuation of the function (3.2) cannot be defined on the whole -plane, but only on a suitable subset of it
including (see Section 5).
It is worth noticing here that the function (3.5) maps
the points and (on which goes to the infinity) one in the other one and
viceversa: for this reason these points and will be called hereafter as “conjugate”
through the map
Moreover, goes in and viceversa is mapped in ;
the same occurs for ,
which goes in and viceversa is transformed in
More details about the map can be found in Appendix A, in particular the
“viceversa” parts of the above statements are trivial consequences of the
property (A.1). As well known and summarized also in that appendix, transforms any circle in another circle. In
the important example of the unit circle, its image is for the circle having center and radius given by the following relations: while becomes a straight line in the case of
As discussed below, the position of relative to will be one of the key-points in order to
understand the analytical structure of the velocity (see Section 4).
Coming back to the constraint on ,
the condition with leads from the definition (3.5) to the
following equation in : which has no solutions if and
only if where
If the constraint (3.8) is verified, cannot intersect
:
this fundamental property, implying that is a simple curve, depends only on the
function (3.5), or on the constants , ,
and (3.3). Hereafter, it will be assumed always
satisfied.
3.3. Invariant Circles for the Map
An interesting issue about the map (3.5) lies in searching a circle which is
transformed in itself by :
such a circle will be called invariant. Two families at one parameter () of invariant circles have been found. In the
first (and most important) one, center and radius, indicated with , in the -plane and with , in the -plane, are the following
functions of : (the branch of the square root affects the sign of ,
but not the definition of the center). Centers (3.9)
move along a straight line parallel to and passing on the point for running on the real axis. The importance of
the circles of the first family lies in the fact that one of them (called hereafter, see Figure 2) will be used in order
to define the inverse map
It divides the complex plane in two parts which are mapped one in the other by
the function (3.5), one of them being the image of the
physical plane. As shown in Figure 2, another interesting feature of is that its image ,
called ,
results from the overlapping of two equal arcs of a circle (see Appendix E for details): for running on , moves along first in a direction and then in the reverse
one. The branch of the inverse map, as well as the geometry of the two arcs on (unless their endpoints, which do not change
with ), will depend on the value of the parameter (see Appendix D).
Centers of the second family lie along the straight
line orthogonal to the one of the first family, but still passing through the
point
Center and radius of a circle are in that case the functions of : being larger than
An inspection of the formulae (3.9) and (3.10) shows that circles of the first
family intersect on the points
Notice also that is divided into two complementary arcs by the
points : if the point runs on from to in the counterclockwise sense, its image moves on the same circle and between the same
points, but in the reverse direction. Finally, it is found that the function maps the points in the endpoints of the two arcs of which form
4. Vortex Classification
A classification of the vortices having the Schwarz
function of their boundaries of the form (3.1) will be proposed below. It is
based on two important properties of the maps (3.5) and (3.2) and allows us
to build the inverse map and then the analytical velocity field.
The first property specifies the relative position of
the curve with respect to the unit circle
(hereafter, the case ,
in which the circle becomes a straight line, is
excluded): can be internal to (the vortex is classified of kind ), or external and including (kind ), or external and not including (kind ). Vortices of the first kind have the inside
of ,
say ,
naturally decomposed as joined with an annular set external to
In order to use compact notations, this annular set or the whole (for vortices of kind or ) will be hereafter indicated with
In turn, vortices of the second kind have the inside of naturally decomposed as joined with an annular subset external to ,
that will be indicated with
For vortices of kind ,
the same symbol will indicate the unbounded region external to both circles and
Appendix B is devoted to a comprehensive discussion of the first property, the
results of which are summarized in Table 1. The above classification enables us
to specify where goes through the function : it is found (see Appendix C for details) that is mapped onto itself for vortices of kind ,
while it goes onto the outside or the inside of for vortices of kind or ,
respectively.
Table 1: Behaviour with respect to the first property,
consequences on the position of the circle
and corresponding constraints on
,
and
The quantities
and
are defined in (
B.1).
A second property specifies where goes via the other map : it can go onto the inside of the vortex (which is classified of kind ) or onto its outside (kind ), depending on the values of the constants , and on the positions of the poles and with respect to the unit circle. This issue is
investigated by evaluating if the image of the origin in the -plane (which is still the origin in the
physical one) lies or not inside
To this aim, the logarithmic index of the point with respect to the curve is considered. The residues
(times ) of the integral (4.1) on the poles and (if they lie in ) hold ,
while those on and (if they lie in ) hold (notice that both pairs of points are
conjugate through the map ). Results of the discussion of the
logarithmic index (4.1) are summarized in Table 2.
Table 2: Behaviour with respect to the second property,
consequences on the map and corresponding constraints on the poles ,
In our classification, the vortices belonging to a
given class are of the same kind with respect to
both properties: a class is identified by the couple of numbers which indicate
the kinds with respect to the first and second properties. As an example,
vortices in the class have the circle external and not including and is the outside of the vortex.
The last issue about the map concerns the orientation of the vortex
boundary, that is, the evaluation of
To this aim, the logarithmic index of the point with respect to has to be evaluated: it holds when is oriented counterclockwise and in the other case. In the last integral, the
residue (multiplied times ) on the point holds ,
the ones on and (if they lie in ) give and the residue on (if it lies inside ) holds
By accounting for the behaviour with respect to the second property summarized
in Table 2, it can be easily shown that any vortex of kind has a counterclockwise () oriented boundary, while the orientation of
the boundary of any vortex of kind is clockwise ().
5. Geometrical Discussion
In the present section, the information about the maps and given in Sections 3 and 4 are joined to give a
comprehensive picture of their geometrical properties. In order to reach an
intuitive representation of the behaviour of these functions, in Figures 3, 4,
and 5 families of circles will be transformed through these two maps. Hence,
the circles and their images are drawn with the same colour.
Figure 3: Planes of the
variables: (first column), (second), and (third) for vortices of kind with respect to the first property. In the
first row, a vortex of kind (, , , ) and in the second one a vortex of kind (, , , ) are investigated. Two families of circles
are considered in the -plane: one inside (yellow lines) and the other one outside