The study sought to investigate thermosolutal convection and stability of two dimensional disturbances
imposed on a heated boundary layer flow over a semi-infinite horizontal plate composed of a
chemical species using a self-consistent asymptotic method. The chemical species reacts as it diffuses
into the nearby fluid causing density stratification and inducing a buoyancy force. The existence of
significant temperature gradients near the plate surface results in additional buoyancy and decrease in
viscosity. We derive the linear neutral results by analyzing asymptotically the multideck structure of
the perturbed flow in the limit of large Reynolds numbers. The study shows that for small Damkohler
numbers, increasing buoyancy has a destabilizing effect on the upper branch Tollmien-Schlichting (TS)
instability waves. Similarly, increasing the Damkohler numbers (which corresponds to increasing the
reaction rate) has a destabilizing effect on the TS wave modes. However, for small Damkohler numbers,
negative buoyancy stabilizes the boundary layer flow.
1. Introduction
Convection in which the buoyancy forces are due to
both temperature and chemical concentration gradients are referred to as
thermosolutal or double diffusive convection. Ostrach [1] pointed out that different modes
of such convection exist depending on how the temperature and concentration
gradients are oriented relative to one another. Some natural convection flows
in the atmosphere and micrometeorological phenomena are often thermosolutal.
The heating of the earth by the sun causes atmospheric thermal convection which
is usually modified by the presence of moisture evaporated from the ground.
In lakes and oceans, thermosolutal convection is
caused by stable vertical concentration distribution with heating from the side
or from the top. The stability theory has been used to explain the occurrence
of layered structures observed in oceans as explained by Turner [2].
Studies on natural convection flows caused by the
simultaneous diffusion of thermal energy and chemical species were carried out
by Gebhart and Pera [3]. They considered small species concentration levels
and showed that the species Boussinesq approximation led to similarity
solutions similar in form to those for single buoyancy mechanism flows.
The effect of heat transfer on the upper-branch
stability of Tollmien-Schlichting instabilities (TSIs) in accelerating boundary
layer over a rigid surface in incompressible flows was investigated by Mureithi
et al. [4]. The study
indicated that buoyancy has destabilizing effect on rigid bodies. Their
analysis also showed that in the presence of strong buoyancy forces, the
five-zone asymptotic structure alters but for moderate buoyancy, the five-zone
structure of Smith and Bodonyi [5] remains with very few alterations.
Shateyi et al. [6] considered the effect of fluid buoyancy and chemical
reaction between the chemical species and the fluid on the linear stability of
two dimensional disturbances wave modes. They extended the theory of boundary
layer flows over horizontal surfaces to include a chemical species and the
effect of the Damkohler number. Results showed that when the wave number and
speed number are varied against the scaled Damkohler number, the effect of
increasing buoyancy was destabilizing in agreement with assertions by Motsa et
al. [7]. It was shown
that increasing reaction kinematics (thus, reducing the density and viscosity)
has destabilizing effects on the TS waves.
Pons and Le Quéré [8] showed that Boussinesq equations do not exactly
represent buoyancy—induced natural convection. The study observed that
thermodynamic consistency is retrieved when both the work due pressure forces
and the heat generated by viscous friction are accounted for in the heat
equation. The study recommended that any theoretical study of buoyancy-induced
natural convection should be done with the thermodynamic Boussinesq model and
not with the usual Boussinesq approximations. However, in spite of this
weakness, the usual Boussinesq equations are still very useful (see, e.g.,
Azizi et al. [9]). To that end in this study, we will use the
Boussinesq approximations.
The present work presents an asymptotic analysis of
the flow induced by buoyancy effects due to both temperature and chemical
concentration gradients near the flat surface. This paper is a direct extension
of the earlier work in Shateyi et al. [6] to include the effects of temperature differences
within the boundary-layer. The flow has uniform surface conditions with the
buoyancy effects primarily away from the surface. Our analysis is limited to
processes which occur at low concentration gradients. We give an asymptotic
investigation of the interactions between the reaction kinematics and the fluid
hydrodynamics with the Damkohler number (the ratio of the hydrodynamic time
scale to the reaction time scale) as the parameter of primary interest. In the
limit of large Damkohler numbers, the reaction kinematics proceed at a much
faster rate compared to the fluid hydrodynamics. If the Damkohler number is
close to zero, the chemical reactions are slow compared to the motion of the
fluid. In this case, a nonreactive fluid can be assumed. The greatest
interaction between reaction kinematics and fluid dynamics occurs when the
Damkohler is of .
In the study, we focus attention on the case when the
Damkohler number is small (that is, less than
unity). The case for large Damkohler numbers was investigated
by Shateyi et al. [6]. The aim is to determine the influence of small
Damkohler numbers on the stability characteristics of the upper-branch TS
instability waves. The major difference between the current work and that of
Mureithi et al. [4]
arises from the introduction of reaction kinematics. The absence of wall
compliance and the presence of a chemical species makes
the current work different from that of Motsa et al. [7]. The presence of wall
heating or cooling and small Damkohler numbers makes the current work different
from Shateyi et al. [6]. The current approach provides asymptotic solutions
to the linearised Navier-Stokes rather the numerical solution of the
Orr-Sommerfeld equation.
2. Mathematical Formulation
We consider a
two-dimensional, incompressible fluid flow over a heated horizontal plate which
is composed of a chemical species maintained at a fixed concentration. The
chemical species diffuses into the nearby fluid inducing a buoyancy force. A
change in the temperature of the fluid near the plate surface due to exogenous
heating effects also results in additional buoyancy.
The governing nondimensional unsteady Navier-Stokes
equations for an incompressible fluid under a Boussinesq-type approximation are
as follows: However, (2.1)–(2.5) have been
nondimensionalised such that the space coordinates are given by ,
the velocity components are ,
the pressure is ,
and the time is ,
where is the characteristic length scale (e.g., the
distance measured from the leading edge of the plate). The species chemical
concentration and the temperature are, respectively, where the asterisks in these
relations denote dimensional quantities and the subscripts “" and “" refer to the conditions at the wall and the
free stream values, respectively. For purposes of this study, the important
parameters are the Damkohler number that is defined as the ratio of the flow time
scale to the chemical time scale and the buoyancy terms and ,
where and are, respectively, the Grashof numbers for
mass and thermal diffusion, is the coefficient of expansion with respect
to mass transfer, and is the volumetric coefficient of thermal
expansion
The other parameters and variables in (2.1)–(2.5) are
the Prandtl number ,
the flow Reynolds number ,
and the Schmidt number ,
where is the binary diffusion coefficient, is the coefficient of dynamic viscosity, is the density of the fluid, is the coefficient of kinematic viscosity, and is the acceleration due to gravity.
The momentum boundary conditions are the no-slip
conditions: We assume that the horizontal plate is maintained at a
prescribed temperature and uniform concentration .
In the far field, we assume that the fluid temperature, species chemical
concentration, and the fluid velocity approach their free stream values.
The basic boundary-layer flow is given
by where is the boundary coordinate. For general
pressure gradient boundary layers, the following properties
hold: The coefficients and are, respectively, the skin friction and
curvature of the basic flow profile. The coefficients and are the heat transfer coefficients and and are the concentration transfer coefficients.
Disturbances to the basic flow of amplitude factor are introduced and these spread through the
boundary layer. The Reynolds number is large while the amplitude of the
spatially growing disturbances is assumed to be sufficiently small for linear
theory to hold. The TSI grows by extracting energy from the mean flow to the
disturbance within the boundary layer (see, e.g., Carpenter and Gajjar
[10]).
The asymptotic structure of the boundary layer is now
well known and described (e.g., Smith and Bodonyi [5] and Mureithi et al.
[4]). It consists of
the five regions (see Figure 1) where is the main part of the boundary layer with
thickness , is a thinner inviscid adjustment region of
thickness containing the viscous critical layer the wall layer of thickness ,
and the outer potential flow of thickness .
Consistent with earlier work on linear analysis, the viscous critical layer is
ignored in the present theory except in so far as it produces a phase shift in
the boundary layer pressure and velocity.
Figure 1: Schematic sketch of flow structure
showing the multilayered nature of the boundary layer and the relative
positioning of the five regions.
The disturbances are taken to be in the form of a
modulated wave train periodic in where, for the upper branch of the neutral
stability curve, the scaled streamwise and temporal variables are , ,
and is a small parameter. The neutral wave number and phase speed of the disturbances are and ,
respectively. We thus expand and as where and are the scaled real wave number and real phase
speed of the travelling wave disturbances. The derivatives and are then replaced by and ,
respectively. The other important scalings (see also Shateyi et al. [6]) are and when the TS eigenrelation is significantly
altered for the first time by the effects of fluid buoyancy.
3. Stability Analysis
Information on
the disturbance expansions relevant to the upper-branch stability of boundary
layers is now well documented in the literature (see, e.g., Gajjar and Smith
[11], Motsa et al.
[7], and the
references therein). Only the details necessary to obtain the linear dispersion
relations will be given. In the main part of the boundary layer, region ,
we define the coordinate ,
where ,
and introduce a small disturbance of size into the basic flow. The expand disturbance
quantities are then expanded as where ,
and so forth are functions of the boundary layer variable and of the scaled streamwise variable ,
and is the amplitude of the disturbance which is
very much smaller than unity so that terms quadratic in are ignored thereby restricting the analysis
to linear stability theory. Substituting (3.1)–(3.5) into the governing equations and
solving the resulting system of leading-order equations yields the following
first-order solutions: At the next order, we obtain the solutions where and are unknown functions representing the
displacement and the pressure amplitudes. In the results above, we set (where denotes the complex conjugate). The lower
limit of the integrals, ,
is a non-zero constant introduced for convenience, whose value does not alter
the eventual results for wave numbers and frequencies.
In region ,
we define with and the expansions follow from : Substituting these equations
into the governing equations and solving the resulting equations yield the
following first-order solutions: where .
At the next order, the velocity and pressure terms are The solutions in this region
possess both logarithmic and algebraic singularities as .
These singularities are smoothed out by the introduction of the critical layer
consisting of a thin viscous region situated in the neighbourhood of the
critical level where and are the phase-shift terms introduced to
connect the solutions in the normal velocity and pressure, respectively, on
either side of the critical layer.
Solutions in the other regions (namely, the wall layer and the outer potential-flow layer follow in a straightforward manner, and the important solutions of the wall layer are given by where , ,
and is an coordinate.
In region ,
we set ,
where .
The leading-order solutions are given by where is an unknown function which describes the
disturbance pressure at the outer extreme of the boundary layer. At the next
order, the important solutions are where is an unknown function which describes the
disturbance pressure at the outer extreme of the boundary layer.
4. Linear Neutral Results and Eigenrelations
In this
section, we asymptotically match the solutions in their respective overlap
regimes. We will be matching the normal velocities and pressures of the same
orders in these respective overlapping regions. The first eigenrelation is
found by matching the first-order solutions across the entire boundary layer flow
regime to be The matching of second-order
pressure components between (as ) and (as ) yields where and .
The constants and for are defined in the appendix.
Matching the pressure terms across (as ) and (as ) gives where and .
Matching the pressure terms across (as ) and (as ) gives Matching the normal velocity
components between (as ) and (as ) at the second order gives Matching the normal velocity
across regions and yields where the constants and for are defined in the appendix. Lastly, a
matching of the normal velocity between and gives The relations (4.1)–(4.7)
above may be used to eliminate , , , to obtain a relation which determines the
higher-harmonic components of .
If we restrict our attention to the components, then, after some algebra,
(4.1)–(4.7) lead to where and are defined in the appendix. The results for
linear theory are now well known and are derived by taking the jump across the
critical layer, to be equal to .
Taking the real parts of equation (4.8) then gives where .
However, (4.1) and (4.9) are the crucial eigenvalue relations which fix the
neutral wave number to the neutral wave speed.
5. Results and Discussion
To obtain a
clearer understanding of the effects of fluid buoyancy and the chemical
reaction on the linear stability of the two-dimensional disturbance wave modes,
we consider a number of limiting cases when the fluid buoyancy parameters are
either large and small and the Damkohler numbers are small. This allows for a
detailed examination of the linear eigenrelations (4.1) and (4.9).
We first investigate the limiting behaviour of the
neutral eigenrelations as the buoyancy parameters This limiting case corresponds to the increase
in the buoyancy force due to an increase in the density difference caused by
temperature and chemical concentration differences. Solving the eigenrelations
(4.1) and (4.9), we obtain, in the limit with , These results agree with those
obtained by Motsa et al. [7] for the case and with those of Shateyi et al. [6] when and help to quantify the effects of the
combined buoyancy on the normal modes. The results show that, depending on
whether the buoyancy terms reinforce or cancel out (e.g., in the case of an
endothermic reaction), the normal modes may grow without limit thus hastening
the transition to turbulence. A viable transition delay mechanism would be to
ensure that the buoyancy terms act contrary to each other so as to reduce the
growth of the disturbances.
Solving the eigenrelations (4.1) and (4.9) in the
limit with