Table 3: Statistical analysis of Tables 1 and 2.

Function Deceptive function Rastrigin function
Algorithm RTs CTs ConRa RTs CTs ConRa

DE/best/1 50 8 16% 50 27 54%
CDE-um/best/1 50 50 100% 50 50 100%

DE/rand/1 50 28 56% 50 45 90%
CDE-um/rand/1 50 50 100% 50 50 100%

DE/cur-to-best/1 50 17 34% 50 49 98%
CDE-um/cur-to-best/1 50 50 100% 50 50 100%

DE/best/2 50 29 58% 50 47 94%
CDE-um/best/2 50 50 100% 50 50 100%

DE/rand/2 50 37 74% 50 49 98%
CDE-um/rand/2 50 50 100% 50 50 100%

“RTs” denotes runing times. “CTs” denotes convergence times. “ConRa” denotes convergence ratio.