Memetic Algorithm with Local Search as Modified Swine Influenza Model-Based Optimization and Its Use in ECG Filtering

Table 10

Comparison of the experimental results of algorithms using statistical test.

F	MASBX_T versus GASBX						MASBX_V versus GASBX						MASBX_Q versus GASBX
	02D	02D	02D	10D	10D	10D	02D	02D	02D	10D	10D	10D	02D	02D	02D	10D	10D	10D
	𝑃 value	SL = 0.05	SL = 0.01	𝑃 value	SL = 0.05	SL = 0.01	𝑃 value	SL = 0.05	SL = 0.01	𝑃 value	SL = 0.05	SL = 0.01	𝑃 value	SL = 0.05	SL = 0.01	𝑃 value	SL = 0.05	SL = 0.01
F1	3.09𝑒−01	0	0	1.73𝑒−04	1	1	3.27𝑒−01	0	0	2.64𝑒−02	1	0	3.27𝑒−01	0	0	1.14𝑒−01	0	0
F2	1.53𝑒−01	0	0	4.23𝑒−02	1	0	3.27𝑒−01	0	0	4.72𝑒−03	1	1	8.06𝑒−08	1	1	8.85𝑒−01	0	0
F3	1.04𝑒−01	0	0	2.55𝑒−04	1	1	2.32𝑒−01	0	0	1.61𝑒−09	1	1	3.43𝑒−01	0	0	5.91𝑒−03	1	1
F4	3.19𝑒−01	0	0	5.92𝑒−01	0	0	3.18𝑒−01	0	0	8.56𝑒−02	0	0	2.14𝑒−01	0	0	6.91𝑒−02	0	0
F5	4.26𝑒−03	1	1	9.73𝑒−02	0	0	4.54𝑒−02	1	0	6.92𝑒−01	0	0	9.03𝑒−08	1	1	9.76𝑒−01	0	0
F6	4.33𝑒−01	0	0	9.45𝑒−02	0	0	1.49𝑒−01	0	0	1.14𝑒−01	0	0	3.20𝑒−02	1	0	1.11𝑒−01	0	0
F7	1.76𝑒−04	1	1	2.26𝑒−05	1	1	7.61𝑒−04	1	1	3.37𝑒−02	1	0	2.47𝑒−01	0	0	1.51𝑒−04	1	1
F8	2.29𝑒−05	1	1	2.44𝑒−02	1	0	1.06𝑒−04	1	1	3.03𝑒−08	1	1	5.82𝑒−03	1	1	3.24𝑒−04	1	1
F9	3.28𝑒−01	0	0	1.44𝑒−05	1	1	3.26𝑒−01	0	0	1.99𝑒−08	1	1	2.84𝑒−01	0	0	3.17𝑒−05	1	1
F10	1.36𝑒−01	0	0	2.55𝑒−01	0	0	1.74𝑒−01	0	0	2.80𝑒−05	1	1	7.50𝑒−01	0	0	6.51𝑒−06	1	1
F11	3.21𝑒−01	0	0	1.34𝑒−01	0	0	4.41𝑒−01	0	0	1.08𝑒−03	1	1	1.76𝑒−01	0	0	1.69𝑒−01	0	0
F12	4.99𝑒−02	1	0	8.57𝑒−02	0	0	9.26𝑒−03	1	1	4.50𝑒−01	0	0	4.98𝑒−02	1	0	5.51𝑒−01	0	0
F13	7.54𝑒−04	1	1	2.84𝑒−03	1	1	2.42𝑒−03	1	1	9.34𝑒−01	0	0	1.30𝑒−04	1	1	7.76𝑒−03	1	1
F14	1.22𝑒−01	0	0	9.69𝑒−06	1	1	4.64𝑒−03	1	1	2.01𝑒−06	1	1	1.70𝑒−02	1	0	1.55𝑒−07	1	1
F15	3.27𝑒−01	0	0	1.88𝑒−01	0	0	1.61𝑒−01	0	0	3.21𝑒−01	0	0	1.61𝑒−01	0	0	8.09𝑒−02	0	0
F16	1.98𝑒−02	1	0	7.62𝑒−01	0	0	4.71𝑒−04	1	1	7.11𝑒−04	1	1	3.03𝑒−01	0	0	1.29𝑒−02	1	0
F17	3.78𝑒−02	1	0	1.30𝑒−02	1	0	6.25𝑒−03	1	1	8.87𝑒−03	1	1	5.54𝑒−03	1	1	4.27𝑒−01	0	0
F18	1.70𝑒−03	1	1	5.11𝑒−01	0	0	1.21𝑒−02	1	0	6.98𝑒−02	0	0	2.14𝑒−01	0	0	1.87𝑒−01	0	0
F19	2.60𝑒−03	1	1	7.27𝑒−01	0	0	6.02𝑒−01	0	0	7.54𝑒−02	0	0	7.36𝑒−01	0	0	1.61𝑒−01	0	0
F20	9.68𝑒−03	1	1	4.39𝑒−03	1	1	1.37𝑒−02	1	0	1.18𝑒−01	0	0	5.85𝑒−04	1	1	8.69𝑒−01	0	0
F21	1.15𝑒−01	0	0	1.13𝑒−02	1	0	1.35𝑒−02	1	0	8.12𝑒−02	0	0	2.24𝑒−01	0	0	4.44𝑒−02	1	0
F22	5.88𝑒−03	1	1	9.39𝑒−01	0	0	5.40𝑒−02	0	0	5.46𝑒−02	0	0	3.59𝑒−04	1	1	9.71𝑒−02	0	0
F23	8.80𝑒−01	0	0	1.24𝑒−03	1	1	4.38𝑒−02	1	0	5.66𝑒−04	1	1	1.57𝑒−03	1	1	6.18𝑒−03	1	1
F24	1.64𝑒−01	0	0	7.67𝑒−01	0	0	1.64𝑒−01	0	0	2.07𝑒−10	1	1	1.64𝑒−01	0	0	2.39𝑒−03	1	1
F25	5.25𝑒−02	0	0	8.21𝑒−02	0	0	3.27𝑒−01	0	0	2.85𝑒−01	0	0	9.08𝑒−02	0	0	7.23𝑒−01	0	0