Memetic Algorithm with Local Search as Modified Swine Influenza Model-Based Optimization and Its Use in ECG Filtering

Table 8

Comparison of the experimental results of algorithms used for dimension 10.

10D

F

F1

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

F7

F8

F9

F10

F11

F12

F13

GA-BLX

Mean

7.00𝑒−03

1.37𝑒+02

3.51𝑒+05

5.88𝑒+02

4.28𝑒+02

2.48𝑒+02

3.95𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

2.31𝑒−03

1.72𝑒+01

4.36𝑒+00

2.60𝑒+03

3.63𝑒−01

STD

6.02𝑒−03

5.37𝑒+01

1.71𝑒+05

2.50𝑒+02

1.84𝑒+02

6.58𝑒+02

2.49𝑒+00

4.82𝑒−02

1.90𝑒−03

6.74𝑒+00

1.91𝑒+00

1.61𝑒+03

1.08𝑒−01

GA-SBX

Mean

3.40𝑒−03

2.85𝑒+00

3.04𝑒+05

2.71𝑒+01

4.42𝑒+02

3.98𝑒+02

2.39𝑒+00

2.03𝑒+01

1.28𝑒−03

2.18𝑒+01

7.26𝑒+00

1.23𝑒+03

3.85𝑒−01

STD

5.05𝑒−03

3.33𝑒+00

3.40𝑒+05

2.15𝑒+01

2.52𝑒+02

1.05𝑒+03

1.27𝑒+00

8.32𝑒−02

1.54𝑒−03

7.66𝑒+00

2.11𝑒+00

1.41𝑒+03

1.17𝑒−01

MA-BLX-T

Mean

9.53𝑒−03

1.34𝑒+02

4.51𝑒+05

6.82𝑒+02

3.35𝑒+02

3.69𝑒+02

3.45𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

3.46𝑒−03

2.15𝑒+01

5.09𝑒+00

2.29𝑒+03

3.66𝑒−01

STD

9.93𝑒−03

5.36𝑒+01

3.14𝑒+05

2.59𝑒+02

1.45𝑒+02

1.05𝑒+03

2.56𝑒+00

7.76𝑒−02

2.64𝑒−03

7.31𝑒+00

1.90𝑒+00

1.21𝑒+03

1.03𝑒−01

MA-BLX-V

Mean

8.62𝑒−03

1.63𝑒+02

4.98𝑒+05

6.19𝑒+02

3.73𝑒+02

1.32𝑒+02

4.40𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

3.77𝑒−03

2.29𝑒+01

4.94𝑒+00

3.03𝑒+03

4.32𝑒−01

STD

4.90𝑒−03

5.40𝑒+01

4.47𝑒+05

2.55𝑒+02

1.72𝑒+02

3.09𝑒+02

2.96𝑒+00

7.81𝑒−02

3.77𝑒−03

7.65𝑒+00

2.05𝑒+00

1.89𝑒+03

1.05𝑒−01

MA-BLX-Q

Mean

9.22𝑒−03

1.64𝑒+02

4.94𝑒+05

7.23𝑒+02

4.00𝑒+02

3.63𝑒+02

3.22𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

2.81𝑒−03

2.19𝑒+01

4.70𝑒+00

2.26𝑒+03

3.49𝑒−01

STD

4.85𝑒−03

6.72𝑒+01

3.47𝑒+05

2.51𝑒+02

1.91𝑒+02

1.29𝑒+03

2.08𝑒+00

6.68𝑒−02

2.38𝑒−03

6.32𝑒+00

1.82𝑒+00

1.74𝑒+03

1.24𝑒−01

MA-SBX-T

Mean

5.59𝑒−03

2.10𝑒+00

5.58𝑒+05

2.60𝑒+01

5.17𝑒+02

9.17𝑒+01

2.78𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

2.87𝑒−03

2.26𝑒+01

6.97𝑒+00

9.92𝑒+02

4.04𝑒−01

STD

4.53𝑒−03

1.80𝑒+00

6.25𝑒+05

2.32𝑒+01

4.44𝑒+02

2.26𝑒+02

1.41𝑒+00

6.86𝑒−02

2.79𝑒−03

9.73𝑒+00

2.06𝑒+00

9.02𝑒+02

1.34𝑒−01

MA-SBX-V

Mean

5.07𝑒−03

2.09𝑒+00

4.75𝑒+05

2.33𝑒+01

4.56𝑒+02

9.06𝑒+01

2.11𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

3.39𝑒−03

2.42𝑒+01

6.49𝑒+00

1.29𝑒+03

3.85𝑒−01

STD

2.83𝑒−03

2.25𝑒+00

3.95𝑒+05

1.48𝑒+01

3.68𝑒+02

1.36𝑒+02

7.10𝑒−01

6.26𝑒−02

2.16𝑒−03

9.16𝑒+00

2.45𝑒+00

1.28𝑒+03

1.02𝑒−01

MA-SBX-Q

Mean

4.26𝑒−03

2.81𝑒+00

4.08𝑒+05

2.90𝑒+01

4.41𝑒+02

6.98𝑒+01

1.88𝑒+00

2.04𝑒+01

3.18𝑒−03

2.59𝑒+01

7.49𝑒+00

1.18𝑒+03

3.73𝑒−01

STD

3.11𝑒−03

2.29𝑒+00

4.53𝑒+05

1.80𝑒+01

3.39𝑒+02

6.86𝑒+01

7.89𝑒−01

7.73𝑒−02

3.30𝑒−03

1.00𝑒+01

1.75𝑒+00

1.18𝑒+03

1.23𝑒−01

10D

F

F14

F15

F16

F17

F18

F19

F20

F21

F22

F23

F24

F25

GA-BLX

Mean

3.66𝑒+00

4.42𝑒+01

1.25𝑒+02

1.88𝑒+02

8.10𝑒+02

8.10𝑒+02

8.10𝑒+02

1.15𝑒+03

4.25𝑒+02

1.17𝑒+03

3.59𝑒+02

9.60𝑒+02

STD

2.08𝑒−01

1.45𝑒+02

1.50𝑒+01

5.92𝑒+01

5.27𝑒+00

5.22𝑒+00

4.81𝑒+00

2.01𝑒+02

2.26𝑒+02

1.91𝑒+02

3.17𝑒+02

4.81𝑒+02

GA-SBX

Mean

4.10𝑒+00

2.07𝑒+01

1.31𝑒+02

1.33𝑒+02

7.82𝑒+02

7.52𝑒+02

8.04𝑒+02

6.75𝑒+02

7.21𝑒+02

7.97𝑒+02

4.24𝑒+02

4.19𝑒+02

STD

1.92𝑒−01

8.47𝑒+01

1.71𝑒+01

2.69𝑒+01

2.28𝑒+02

2.48𝑒+02

1.96𝑒+02

3.31𝑒+02

1.91𝑒+02

2.39𝑒+02

1.88𝑒+01

1.24𝑒+01

MA-BLX-T

Mean

3.59𝑒+00

8.24𝑒+01

1.26𝑒+02

1.59𝑒+02

8.10𝑒+02

7.95𝑒+02

8.30𝑒+02

1.06𝑒+03

4.78𝑒+02

1.19𝑒+03

4.31𝑒+02

9.84𝑒+02

STD

1.81𝑒−01

1.93𝑒+02

2.40𝑒+01

4.44𝑒+01

3.13𝑒+01

9.60𝑒+01

6.95𝑒+01

2.72𝑒+02

2.47𝑒+02

1.39𝑒+02

3.66𝑒+02

4.49𝑒+02

MA-BLX-V

Mean

3.60𝑒+00

1.87𝑒+02

1.41𝑒+02

1.49𝑒+02

8.04𝑒+02

7.84𝑒+02

7.96𝑒+02

1.10𝑒+03

6.09𝑒+02

1.17𝑒+03

4.12𝑒+02

1.03𝑒+03

STD

1.60𝑒−01

2.47𝑒+02

2.47𝑒+01

5.71𝑒+01

7.04𝑒+00

1.01𝑒+02

1.12𝑒+02

2.63𝑒+02

2.57𝑒+02

1.41𝑒+02

3.16𝑒+02

4.45𝑒+02

MA-BLX-Q

Mean

3.53𝑒+00

1.55𝑒+02

1.23𝑒+02

1.69𝑒+02

7.81𝑒+02

8.27𝑒+02

8.20𝑒+02

1.14𝑒+03

4.75𝑒+02

1.20𝑒+03

3.86𝑒+02

9.92𝑒+02

STD

1.93𝑒−01

2.49𝑒+02

1.76𝑒+01

5.68𝑒+01

1.27𝑒+02

4.18𝑒+01

7.82𝑒+01

1.58𝑒+02

2.41𝑒+02

1.13𝑒+02

3.45𝑒+02

4.80𝑒+02

MA-SBX-T

Mean

4.00𝑒+00

4.02𝑒+01

1.31𝑒+02

1.37𝑒+02

7.89𝑒+02

7.61𝑒+02

7.31𝑒+02

7.47𝑒+02

7.21𝑒+02

8.46𝑒+02

4.24𝑒+02

4.45𝑒+02

STD

2.21𝑒−01

1.25𝑒+02

1.53𝑒+01

2.65𝑒+01

2.21𝑒+02

2.56𝑒+02

2.42𝑒+02

3.38𝑒+02

1.89𝑒+02

2.77𝑒+02

2.44𝑒+01

7.77𝑒+01

MA-SBX-V

Mean

4.03𝑒+00

2.30𝑒+01

1.36𝑒+02

1.42𝑒+02

8.27𝑒+02

8.08𝑒+02

7.86𝑒+02

7.27𝑒+02

6.58𝑒+02

7.26𝑒+02

4.18𝑒+02

4.35𝑒+02

STD

1.63𝑒−01

9.61𝑒+01

2.10𝑒+01

2.79𝑒+01

1.62𝑒+02

1.74𝑒+02

2.14𝑒+02

3.41𝑒+02

2.29𝑒+02

2.03𝑒+02

1.97𝑒+01

7.67𝑒+01

MA-SBX-Q

Mean

3.97𝑒+00

6.22𝑒+01

1.34𝑒+02

1.36𝑒+02

7.96𝑒+02

7.81𝑒+02

8.07𝑒+02

7.30𝑒+02

7.16𝑒+02

8.42𝑒+02

4.16𝑒+02

4.25𝑒+02

STD

2.18𝑒−01

1.51𝑒+02

2.23𝑒+01

1.82𝑒+01

2.20𝑒+02

2.15𝑒+02

1.69𝑒+02

3.21𝑒+02

1.86𝑒+02

2.60𝑒+02

1.01𝑒+01

9.00𝑒+01