- About this Journal ·
- Abstracting and Indexing ·
- Aims and Scope ·
- Annual Issues ·
- Article Processing Charges ·
- Author Guidelines ·
- Bibliographic Information ·
- Citations to this Journal ·
- Contact Information ·
- Editorial Board ·
- Editorial Workflow ·
- Free eTOC Alerts ·
- Publication Ethics ·
- Recently Accepted Articles ·
- Reviewers Acknowledgment ·
- Submit a Manuscript ·
- Subscription Information ·
- Table of Contents
Mathematical Problems in Engineering
Volume 2012 (2012), Article ID 396248, 18 pages
A Simulation-Based Dynamic Stochastic Route Choice Model for Evacuation
School of Transportation, Southeast University, No. 2, Sipailou, Nanjing 210096, China
Received 7 May 2012; Accepted 25 July 2012
Academic Editor: Wuhong Wang
Copyright © 2012 Xing Zhao et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
This paper establishes a dynamic stochastic route choice model for evacuation to simulate the propagation process of traffic flow and estimate the stochastic route choice under evacuation situations. The model contains a lane-group-based cell transmission model (CTM) which sets different traffic capacities for links with different turning movements to flow out in an evacuation situation, an actual impedance model which is to obtain the impedance of each route in time units at each time interval and a stochastic route choice model according to the probit-based stochastic user equilibrium. In this model, vehicles loading at each origin at each time interval are assumed to choose an evacuation route under determinate road network, signal design, and OD demand. As a case study, the proposed model is validated on the network nearby Nanjing Olympic Center after the opening ceremony of the 10th National Games of the People's Republic of China. The traffic volumes and clearing time at five exit points of the evacuation zone are calculated by the model to compare with survey data. The results show that this model can appropriately simulate the dynamic route choice and evolution process of the traffic flow on the network in an evacuation situation.
Evacuation is one of the most important measures adopted in emergency response to protect masses and to avoid both physical and property damages. Reflecting dynamic propagation characteristics of evacuation traffic flow appropriately is the core theory problem in estimating the evacuation time and evaluating evacuation plans reasonably.
In the studies throughout the world that focus on the evacuation route choice problem, modeling methods include static traffic assignment and dynamic network traffic flow theory. The dynamic models can reflect the propagation process of evacuation traffic flow more effectively than the static method. The core problem of the dynamic method is describing the dynamic propagation and stochastic characteristics of evacuation traffic flow.
The urban dynamic network traffic flow theory under normal conditions has been developed for nearly 20 years with the evolution of intelligent transportation systems, and the macrosimulation model in static traffic flow has been imported into the dynamic flow theory. The cell transmission model (CTM) is one of the dynamic traffic performance models. CTM was first proposed by Daganzo to simulate the traffic flow on highways  and was then expanded to network traffic , which compromised the accuracy in simulation and optimized the mathematical resolution reasonably. This model can describe dynamic traffic propagation characteristics and capture the phenomena of shockwaves, queue formation, and queue dissipation effectively. For simulating the dynamic propagation process of network traffic flow more accurately, based on the CTM, Lo and Szeto  established an optimal dynamic route choice model via the variational inequality. Two years later, Szeto and Lo  contributed a DTA variational inequality optimum model considering both choices of route and departing time under the condition of elastic traffic demand. Then, they proposed a disequilibrium DTA model and obtained the route impedance function through CTM simulation in 2005 .
Based on previous studies on the DTA problem, the dynamic propagation characteristics of traffic flow in an evacuation situation were researched further. Tuydes and Ziliaskopoulos  simulated the escape behaviors in fire via a modified CTM model and linear programming. Dixit and Radwan  studied the evacuation problem before typhoon approaches and discussed relevant questions such as evacuation scheduling, route planning, and evacuation destination arrangement based on CTM.
However, during evacuation, road users are not bound to choosing their routes according to the optimum system. To address this problem, some existing models assumed that drivers’ route choices were based on current road and traffic conditions. The NETVAC1 model allowed drivers to choose a turning movement at each intersection at each time interval based on the anterior traffic conditions, while the CEMPS model followed the shortest path-based mechanism  to make decisions. These models were essentially myopia evacuation route choice models. In fact, road users on the network may consider about the whole evacuation route but cannot obtain all of the traffic information exactly, so stochastic route selection is unavoidable. Therefore, the perceived impedance of a route is an estimate of the actual impedance in a practical application. There is a stochastic variable between the actual impedance and the perceptive impedance, which leads to the problem of stochastic user equilibrium (SUE).
Different assumptions of the estimated term generate different SUE models under normal conditions, in which the multinomial logit (MNL) model and Multinomial Probit (MNP) model are the most widely applied. With further study of the SUE problem, the dynamic stochastic user optimal problem (DSUO), which is an extension of the static stochastic user equilibrium problem, was proposed by Daganzo and Sheffi . As implied by Szeto and Lo , it is important to develop and adopt the route choice principle in the DTA model that is consistent with the actual travel behavior. Subsequently, scholars from various countries have paid more attention to the dynamic stochastic user equilibrium theory. Vythoulkas , Cascetta and Cantarella , Cascetta et al. , Lim and Heydecker , Sun et al. , and Han  carried out studies on the DSUO traffic assignment problem, most of which assumed the logit-based model for the route choice behavior of travelers. However, the irrelevant alternatives deficiency of the logit-based model in the modeling is known. Therefore, Zhang et al.  presented a time-dependent stochastic user equilibrium (TDSUE) traffic assignment model within a probit-based path choice decision framework. Meng and Khoo  did a comparison study to investigate the efficiency and accuracy of the Ishikawa algorithm with the method of successive averages for the probit-based dynamic stochastic user optimal (P-DSUO) traffic assignment problem.
Generally speaking, on one hand, previous models of the dynamic evacuation route choice problem did not consider the characteristic of the evacuation traffic flow. In an evacuation situation, the large density of traffic flow makes it difficult for drivers to exchange lanes, while the minimum headway diminishes compared with normal conditions [19, 20]. On the other hand, Cova and Johnson  pointed out that the main delay in evacuation appears with crossing; however, the traditional CTM model could not clearly simulate the transmission process of the traffic flow at an intersection.
Therefore, the objective of this paper is to simulate the evolution process of the traffic flow on the network and the stochastic route choice in an evacuation situation under determinate road network, signal design, and OD demand. The model contains three parts: the lane-group-based cell transmission model (CTM) which sets different traffic capacities for links with different turning movements to flow out, the actual impedance model which is to obtain the impedance of each route in time units at each time interval, and the stochastic route choice model according to the probit-based stochastic user equilibrium. It can be applied to estimate the real-time evacuation traffic condition and provide the basis for evaluating the performance of evacuation plans developed in response to the possibility of an event or a disaster.
2. Model Formulation
The dynamic stochastic route choice model for evacuation contains three parts, the CTM model, the actual impedance model, and the stochastic route choice model, which is applied to simulate a dynamic propagation process, estimate actual impedance in time units of routes, and simulate route choice of vehicles, respectively. The logistic relationships among the three parts and the structure of the synthesis model are shown in Figure 1.
2.1. Lane-Group-Based CTM Model
The traditional CTM model divides one direction of each street on the network into small homogeneous segments, called cells, while the lane-group-based CTM model divides every link into cells to simulate the evolution process of traffic flow. Drivers cannot change lanes easily in evacuation situations given the large traffic density and car-following phenomenon. Hence, it is assumed that each vehicle considers the desired link fully when the vehicle enters into the roadway.
Based on the transmission mechanism of the traditional CTM model, the traffic propagation rule at intersections can be reflected through different constraints of the first and last cells of the link: the first cell may be an ordinary cell or a merging cell , thereinto, the traffic capacity of the merging cell decreases; the end cell may be an ordinary cell or a diverging cell` and has a fixed signal phase . However, compared with the traditional CTM model, the set of cells in the proposed model is divided into subsets more specifically. On the one hand, the proposed model sets different traffic capacities for links with different turning movements to flow out; therefore, the last cells of the link are classified precisely considering flow-out directions; on the other hand, the source cells and sink cells are also divided into subsets in considering if the links connected with them are single or not. The lane-group-based CTM model in evacuation situation that describes the evolution of traffic flow is expressed as follows.
(1) Single Link
The equation of traffic flow propagation can be expressed as
In particular, the number of vehicles in the source cell can be acquired by loading values and outflows at each time interval. Thus, when the first cell of a link is connected with the source cell only:
The sink cell can be considered as a storeroom with infinite capacity. When the last cell of a link is connected with the sink cell only:
(2) Merging Link
The equation of traffic flow propagation of a merging link is
In particular, for a merging link that not only connected with links but also with a source cell, it is supposed that the vehicles in the links have priority over the source cell.
(3) Diverging Link
Each vehicle chooses a route between the OD pair when loaded at the origin and then propagate to the diverging link of the route after some time. Therefore, the proportion of vehicles moving from the diverging link to each downstream link in time interval can be reckoned by the route choice results of vehicles existing in the end cell of this diverging link currently. The equation of traffic flow propagation of a diverging link is
In particular, it is assumed that when the source cell is diverged, vehicles in the source cell follow a uniform distribution to flow into the downstream links of the source cell. The equation can be expressed as
(4) Ordinary Cells within a Link
The equation of traffic flow propagation of ordinary cells within the link is almost the same as the traditional CTM model.
2.2. Actual Impedance Model
Due to the restrictions of the traffic capacity of the first and last cells of a link, the inflow of a link during time interval will be divided into suboutflows of the link during time intervals . Denote the suboutflow during time interval as and ensure that the value of satisfies the FIFO rule : whereThen, the average impedance in time units of a link can be acquired:
The routes between OD pairs are composed of links. Therefore, based on the impedance of links, the actual impedance in time units of route between OD pair at time interval can be calculated as follows:
2.3. Stochastic Route Choice Model
(1) Perceived Impedance in Time Units
As mentioned previously, drivers perceive the route impedance differently. To treat this problem, let the perceived route impedance consist of two parts: the actual impedance and an error term. Assume that Based on the study of Daganzo , the principle of probit-based stochastic user equilibrium, which takes the assumption of a normal distribution, is adopted in this research. Therefore, the distribution of the perceived impedance in time units of path with nonoverlapping links can be obtained, that is: where is the free-flow impedance in time units of route ; could be interpreted as the variance of the perceived impedance over a route at time interval .
The covariance between the perceived impedance of two routes with overlapping links is expressed as follows: where is a 0-1 parameter, which takes a value of 1 if link is on the route of OD pair ; otherwise, it takes a value of 0. is the free-flow impedance in time units of link .
In summary, the perceived route impedance in time units of path between OD pair at time interval follows a multivariate normal distribution, that is: where the diagonal terms of are the variances given in (2.14) and the off-diagonal terms are the covariance described in (2.15).
(2) Probability and Traffic Volume
Each evacuated driver estimates impedance of all routes between the OD pair at the time interval loading at the origin and chooses the route for which the impedance is perceived to be the least of all the optional routes. Hence, the probability that a driver selects between and at time interval can be expressed as
Furthermore, on the basis of normal distribution properties, it can be calculated as follows:
If the routes between OD pair are greater than two, the probability of drivers choosing route at time interval is
A Monte Carlo simulation can be applied to estimate the probability of each route between each OD pair chosen by drivers.
Based on the probability, the traffic volume of route loading at the source cell during time interval : can be acquired: where is the traffic demand between OD pair loading at the source cell during time interval .
(3) Objective Function
The stochastic route choice problem is equivalent to finding vectors satisfying the following equation: where
2.4. Solution Algorithm
Step 1 (Initialization). Calculate the free-flow impedance in time units of each route to find the shortest one of each OD pair and assign all of the traffic demands of the corresponding origins on them in each time interval. Record the initial traffic volume of route between OD pair loading at the source cell during time interval : . Set .
Step 2. The number of iterations is . Update the traffic volume of route between OD pair loading at the source cell at time interval : .
Step 3. Update the actual impedance in time units of route at time interval : using the proposed lane-group-based CTM model and the actual impedance model.
Step 4. Calculate the probability of route between OD pair at time interval chosen by drivers and the auxiliary traffic volume of route between OD pair loading at the source cell at time interval :.
Step 5. If convergence is attained, stop, and . If not, set and go to Step 2.
3. Model Verification
Based on the distribution of parking lots and the road network data,we calculated the evacuation traffic volumes and clearing time of each exit point of the evacuation zone after the opening ceremony of the 10th National Games of China to compare with survey data to verify the model’s effectiveness.
3.1. Building of Evacuation Network
The 10th National Games of China, which were held in Nanjing Olympic Sports Center, led to many traffic needs. According to the usage data supplied by Traffic Administration Bureau, streets on the northern side of the Olympic Center were used for inside driveway parking lots, which parked 1100 vehicles; it also provided two inside driveway parking lots on the eastern side, which parked 465, 385 vehicles separately, and there was an underground parking on the southern side that was not only for the audience but also for players and servicers, which had been used in 439 parking spaces.
The managers conducted some traffic management such as contraflow in the evacuation zone nearby the Olympic Sports Center to handle the large-scale demand of short-term traffic evacuation. All roads within the region applied one-way access during evacuation to compose a closed area allowing traffic to flow out only. Thus, the parking lots are set as origins for evacuation, and the exit links of the northern side and eastern side are assumed to connect to a virtual sink cell separately, which means the whole evacuation network has two destinations. The evacuation network with origins and destinations is shown in Figure 2(a). According to survey data, the evacuation traffic demand between originals and destinations is known, and the OD demand table and the dynamic loading conditions of each origin are shown in Figure 2(b). The specific lane-group-based cell structure is shown in Figure 3.
Specific information of each link is listed in Table 1.
3.2. Evacuation Route Choice
The solution algorithm presented previously is coded in Microsoft visual C++ and run on a desktop personal computer with CPU of Intel Core(TM)2 2.2 GHz and RAM of 2 GB. The computing time to converge is about 16.9 minutes. The long computing time can be reduced by diminishing sampling size for Monte Carlo simulation. When the traffic demand gets larger, the computing time will not elongate obviously unless the loading time intervals become more.
Figure 4 depicts the convergent trend of the algorithm for solving the network of Figure 3 with the aforementioned data. According to Figure 4 it can be seen that convergence at iteration 13th with an average absolute error of 1.4 satisfies the stop criterion.
According to the proposed model, the evacuation route choice result and other important calculations are as follows.
(1) Clearing Time of the Evacuation Network
This is defined as the evacuating time from when the opening ceremony finishes to when the last evacuees arrive at a virtual sink cell. This indicator is the most important one to reflect the performance of evacuation and to evaluate the evacuation plans. Figures 2(a) and 3 show that the links lc, nc, pc are connected with exit D1, while ea, kc, qc are connected with exit D2. In this case, the clearing time of the evacuation network is the maximum value of all route evacuation times, 2940 s. The model result of the detailed clearing time of each exit link is shown in Table 3.
(2) Evacuation Route Choice Result
The evacuation route choice result at each time interval can deduce the total traffic volume of each route during the whole evacuation period which is shown in Table 4.
(3) The Dynamic Traffic Volume
We can obtain the number of vehicles in each cell and outflow of each cell at each time interval by solving and . Figure 5 shows that the traffic volume of point 1 is the sum of the outflows of links qc and kc, while the traffic volume of point 5 is the outflow of link pc. The calculation of the time-sharing traffic volumes of points 1 and 5 during each time interval are shown in Figure 5.
3.3. Results Comparison
We compare the Previous computed results with the field survey data to verify the validity of the dynamic stochastic route choice model.
The survey collected traffic volumes of the exit points (1~5) of the evacuation zone from 22:00–23:30. The distribution of these points is shown in Figures 2(a) and 3. Among them, traffic volumes of points 1 and 5 are recorded at intervals of three minutes. The comparison result between the model calculations and the survey data of traffic volume of five exit points during the whole evacuating process is shown in Table 5, and the comparison results of the time-sharing traffic volumes of points 1 and 5 are shown in Figure 5.
In Table 5, the values of traffic volumes of the proposed model of each point during the whole evacuation process are calculated by the corresponding route's traffic volume in Table 4. The comparison result shows that model results of the total traffic volumes of exit points are similar to the survey data. Among the five points, the exit points of the routes between the OD pairs O2D1, O3D1, O2D2, and O4D2 are certain. Between the OD pair O1D1, compared to the chosen route aa-ca-ea, the impedance of other routes increases by 40% or more, so the traffic demand between this OD pair is all evacuated from this route. Therefore, the values of the total traffic volumes of the model at points 1, 2, and 5 are fully consistent with the survey data. However, the values of the total traffic volume at point 3 and point 4 have some errors because the value of traffic volume of the route ga-xa-mc-lc tends to be smaller, and the sum of the traffic volumes of routes ga-wa-gc-nc, ba-ia-cc-nc, fa-ma-cc-nc tends to be larger compared to the survey data. Figure 5 shows that the average values of absolute values of time-sharing traffic volume error at points 1 and point 5 are 3.83 veh/3 min and 2.82 veh/3 min, respectively, which fit the distribution of the evacuation process of traffic flow in reality properly.
The dynamic stochastic evacuation route choice model is established to simulate the evolution process of the traffic flow on the network and the stochastic route choice in an evacuation situation under determinate road network, signal design, and OD demand. It contains three parts: the lane-group-based CTM model, the actual impedance model, and the stochastic route choice model.
Considering the large traffic density which makes it difficult for vehicles to exchange lanes in an evacuation situation, this paper established a lane-group-based CTM model, which detailed the propagation process of the traffic flow with different flowing-out turning movements on the basis of the car-following phenomenon in an evacuation situation. This part obtains the inflow and outflow of each cell. Because evacuation in an instant time is of the essence, a realistic model of traffic network performance under a dynamic load is necessary.
Based on the lane-group-based CTM model for evacuation, the piecewise function was established to obtain the actual impedance of each link at each time interval and the dynamic route impedance; then, combined with the principle of stochastic user equilibrium, we confirmed the error term of the route impedance and acquired the perceived impedance which is taken to be the main criterion for the decision of evacuation route choice.
To verify the effectiveness of this model, this paper applies the proposed model to calculate the evacuation traffic volumes and clearing time of each exit point of the evacuation zone after the opening ceremony of the 10th National Games of China based on the distribution of parking lots and traffic data of the road network. The comparison between the computed results of the proposed model and field survey data proves that this model can reflect the dynamic propagation characteristics of evacuation traffic flow appropriately.
In an emergency evacuation, the OD demand table is not known a priori. Traffic route choice model needs to reflect the emergency circumstances; therefore the estimation of OD demand should be constructed as part of the modeling effort—a subject for further research.
Further studies in the calibration for each parameter in the proposed model under different familiarity of drivers to evacuation network and different levels of emergency evacuation situation are necessary. Design and development of the user interface of this model could simplify the cellular process of the traffic networks and enhance the practicality and operability of the model.
|Set of discrete time intervals|
|:||Set of source cell (origin)|
|:||Set of sink cell (destination)|
|:||Set of links, a link equivalent to a link with a unique turning movement at intersection|
|:||Maximum number of vehicles that can flow out (traffic capacity) of cell at time interval|
|:||Traffic capacity of the end cell of a through link/left-turn link/right-turn link at time interval|
|:||Traffic capacity of merging cell|
|:||Ratio of the free-flow speed and backward speed of cell at time interval|
|:||Set of successor cells or link|
|:||Set of predecessor cells to cell or link|
|:||Maximum number of vehicles in cell at time interval|
|:||Signal and priority control parameter of link|
|:||Evacuation demand generated from source cell at time interval|
|:||Evacuation demand of path between OD pair loading at the source cell at time interval|
|:||Number of lanes of link|
|:||Number of vehicles in cell at time interval|
|:||Number of vehicles in link at time interval|
|:||Number of vehicles moving from cell to cell at time interval|
|:||Number of vehicles moving from link to link at time interval|
|:||Number of vehicles moving out of link at time interval|
|:||Number of vehicles moving into at time interval and moving out of link at time interval ()|
|Accumulative number of vehicles moving out of link during time interval |
|:||Proportion of vehicles moving from link to its downstream link at time interval|
|:||The average impedance in time units of a link at time interval|
|:||The actual impedance in time units of route between OD pair at time interval|
|:||The perceived impedance in time units of route between OD pair at time interval|
|:||A random error term of impedance of route between OD pair at time interval .|
This research is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (no. 51078086) and (no. 51278101). The authors appreciate the Jiangsu Provincial Key Laboratory of Transportation Planning and Management of Southeast University.
- C. F. Daganzo, “The cell transmission model: a dynamic representation of highway traffic consistent with the hydrodynamic theory,” Transportation Research B, vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 269–287, 1994.
- C. F. Daganzo, “The cell transmission model, part II: network traffic,” Transportation Research B, vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 79–93, 1995.
- H. K. Lo and W. Y. Szeto, “A cell-based variational inequality formulation of the dynamic user optimal assignment problem,” Transportation Research B, vol. 36, no. 5, pp. 421–443, 2002.
- W. Y. Szeto and H. K. Lo, “A cell-based simultaneous route and departure time choice model with elastic demand,” Transportation Research B, vol. 38, no. 7, pp. 593–612, 2004.
- W. Y. Szeto and H. K. Lo, “Non-equilibrium dynamic traffic assignment,” in Proceedings of the 16th International Symposium on Transportation and Traffic Theory (ISTTT '05), pp. 427–445, Maryland, USA, 2005.
- H. Tuydes and A. Ziliaskopoulos, “The network evacuation problem and solution algorithms,” in INFORMS Annual Meeting, San Francisco, Calif, USA, 2005.
- V. V. Dixit and E. Radwan, “Hurricane evacuation: origin, route, and destination,” Journal of Transportation Safety and Security, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 74–84, 2009.
- S. An, J. X. Cui, and J. Wang, “An international review of road emergency transport and evacuation,” Journal of Transportation Systems Engineering and Information Technology, vol. 8, no. 16, pp. 38–45, 2008.
- C. F. Daganzo and Y. Sheffi, “On stochastic models of traffic assignment,” Transportation Science, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 253–274, 1977.
- W. Y. Szeto and H. K. Lo, “Dynamic traffic assignment: properties and extensions,” Transportmetrica, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 31–52, 2006.
- P. C. Vythoulkas, “A dynamic stochastic assignment model for the analysis of general networks,” Transportation Research B, vol. 24, no. 6, pp. 453–469, 1990.
- E. Cascetta and G. E. Cantarella, “A day-to-day and within-day dynamic stochastic assignment model,” Transportation Research A, vol. 25, no. 5, pp. 277–291, 1991.
- E. Cascetta, F. Russo, and A. Vitetta, “Stochastic user equilibrium assignment with explicit route enumeration: comparison of models and algorithms,” in Proceedings of International Federation of Automatic Control, Transportation Systems, pp. 1078–1084, Chania, Greece, 1997.
- Y. Lim and B. Heydecker, “Dynamic departure time and stochastic user equilibrium assignment,” Transportation Research B, vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 97–118, 2005.
- D. Sun, R. F. Benekohal, and S. T. Waller, “Bi-level programming formulation and heuristic solution approach for dynamic traffic signal optimization,” Computer-Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering, vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 321–333, 2006.
- S. Han, “Dynamic traffic modelling and dynamic stochastic user equilibrium assignment for general road networks,” Transportation Research B, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 225–249, 2003.
- K. Zhang, H. S. Mahmassani, and C. C. Lu, “Probit-based time-dependent stochastic user equilibrium traffic assignment model,” Transportation Research Record, no. 2085, pp. 86–94, 2008.
- Q. Meng and H. L. Khoo, “A computational model for the probit-based dynamic stochastic user optimal traffic assignment problem,” Journal of Advanced Transportation, vol. 46, no. 1, pp. 80–94, 2012.
- H. Hu, X. M. Liu, and X. K. Yang, “Car-following model of emergency evacuation based on minimum safety distance,” Journal of Beijing University of Technology, vol. 33, no. 10, pp. 1070–1074, 2007.
- W. Wang, W. Zhang, H. Guo, H. Bubb, and K. Ikeuchi, “A safety-based approaching behavioural model with various driving characteristics,” Transportation Research C, vol. 19, pp. 1202–1214, 2011.
- T. J. Cova and J. P. Johnson, “A network flow model for lane-based evacuation routing,” Transportation Research A, vol. 37, no. 7, pp. 579–604, 2003.
- H. K. Lo, “A dynamic traffic assignment formulation that encapsulates the cell transmission model,” in Proceedings of the 14th International Symposium on Transportation and Traffic Theory, pp. 327–350, Jerusalem, Israel, 1999.
- C. Wright and P. Roberg, “The conceptual structure of traffic jams,” Transport Policy, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 23–35, 1998.
- A. P. Lian, Z. Y. Gao, and J. C. Long, “Dynamic user optimal assignment problem of link variables based on the cell transmission model,” Acta Automatica Sinica, vol. 33, no. 8, pp. 852–859, 2007.
- A. Z. Li, Research on Lane Distribution Conditions and Capacity of Urban Road Intersections [Ph.D. thesis], Southeast University, Nanjing, China, 2008.