Minimum Cost Multicast Routing Using Ant Colony Optimization Algorithm

Table 3

Comparison results of the tree cost for the dynamic experiment.

No.	v	Φ𝑣^(𝑀)	𝛿^(𝑅)	𝛿^(𝐺)
1	1	16381	1.33%	0.00%
	4	12570	0.99%	0.00%
	6	10426	0.55%	0.00%
2	1	17345	1.32%	0.00%
	6	17553	1.88%	0.01%
	10	14399	1.51%	0.03%
3	1	25656	0.27%	0.00%
	12	23588	0.45%	0.01%
	22	17162	0.41%	0.02%
4	1	10756	1.78%	0.01%
	4	9243	1.36%	0.02%
	6	7736	1.31%	0.00%
5	1	12687	1.14%	0.00%
	6	10374	1.33%	0.03%
	10	8320	0.91%	0.02%
6	1	22206	0.43%	0.04%
	12	18168	0.62%	0.04%
	22	13142	0.69%	0.02%
7	1	22392	0.64%	0.02%
	6	18322	1.66%	0.04%
	10	14574	1.22%	0.06%
8	1	25664	1.48%	0.00%
	9	22945	1.16%	0.02%
	16	17236	0.68%	0.02%
9	1	44687	0.41%	0.01%
	18	38390	0.51%	0.02%
	35	26371	0.40%	0.04%
10	1	16525	1.11%	0.11%
	6	13361	2.63%	0.08%
	10	10803	2.02%	0.19%
11	1	16823	0.81%	0.08%
	9	15501	1.90%	0.19%
	16	11748	2.03%	0.14%
12	1	31642	0.63%	0.02%
	18	27443	0.89%	0.08%
	35	19069	0.79%	0.06%
13	1	30795	1.90%	0.25%
	8	25326	3.03%	0.08%
	14	21049	2.91%	0.11%
14	1	40368	0.97%	0.13%
	12	33929	1.45%	0.18%
	22	24475	1.03%	0.24%
15	1	62009	0.84%	0.09%
	24	52308	1.13%	0.10%
	47	35118	0.81%	0.06%
16	1	19557	1.71%	0.25%
	8	17001	2.06%	0.38%
	14	13228	1.81%	0.26%
17	1	24107	1.08%	0.17%
	12	18215	1.18%	0.15%
	22	13003	1.12%	0.20%
18	1	45115	0.68%	0.23%
	24	36000	0.67%	0.27%
	47	24589	0.69%	0.15%