Three-Phase Methodology Incorporating Scatter Search for Integrated Production, Inventory, and Distribution Routing Problem

Table 3

Results for 100 customers instances.

Instance	MAPM	RTS	SS
	Obj.	Obj.	Obj.	(MAPM)	RTS	Vehicles
1	714401	711671	714768	0.05	0.44	9
2	722047	694694	706531	−2.15	1.70	9
3	677598	683270	702056	3.61	2.75	9
4	710552	718252	715081	0.64	−0.44	9
5	733040	731260	709207	−3.25	−3.02	9
6	696146	744927	704383	1.18	−5.44	9
7	705322	695728	701951	−0.48	0.89	9
8	679210	706058	709180	4.41	0.44	9
9	699518	705035	721338	3.12	2.31	9
10	705778	696521	721714	2.26	3.62	9
11	709122	711895	705973	−0.44	−0.83	9
12	755726	703162	747220	−1.13	6.27	9
13	695466	721066	707786	1.77	−1.84	9
14	718260	698548	728132	1.37	4.24	9
15	736041	711506	729536	−0.88	2.53	9
16	715209	714873	709663	−0.78	−0.73	9
17	737832	702314	702391	−4.80	0.01	9
18	723413	720238	727677	0.59	1.03	9
19	720218	748734	728944	1.21	−2.64	9
20	724727	729099	738669	1.92	1.31	9
21	724328	738746	712796	−1.59	−3.51	9
22	701506	702849	717464	2.27	2.08	9
23	710033	712717	723209	1.86	1.47	9
24	734327	727741	726290	−1.09	−0.20	9
25	725446	725869	730997	0.77	0.71	9
26	718939	700719	722588	0.51	3.12	9
27	715068	686382	719054	0.56	4.76	9
28	685117	700980	695956	1.58	−0.72	9
29	722571	725030	717728	−0.67	−1.01	9
30	721850	698942	701024	−2.89	0.30	9