Research Article

Comparing Evolutionary Strategies on a Biobjective Cultural Algorithm

Table 7

Comparison among our BOCA with circumstantial knowledge and NSGA-II and PAES.

Instance

−1.35 −3532.43 −18.18 −1.35 −905.41 −18.18
−0.02 −5496.30 −10.00 −0.02 −1359.26 −10.00
−0.01 −5533.33 0.00 −0.01 −887.88 0.00
−0.02 −11278.57 −66.67 −0.02 −989.29 −66.67
0.02 −5362.50 0.00 0.02 −1081.25 0.00
−0.64 −4752.94 −12.50 −0.64 −1029.41 −12.50
−10.56 14.41 −50.00 −6.78 73.85 −33.33
−13.00 −11.99 −43.33 −11.64 48.21 −36.67
−6.20 −6.82 −48.28 −4.03 53.79 0.00
−24.14 −29.24 −33.33 −21.40 63.79 −33.33
−9.96 18.09 −42.86 −6.98 65.51 −17.86
4.76 −230.49 −28.57 24.39 −14.57 57.14
−10.83 31.49 −2.38 −3.52 60.18 40.48
−22.53 53.40 −21.88 −8.53 77.25 28.13
−7.05 41.69 −25.93 3.63 67.80 3.70
−5.56 24.69 15.00 −1.60 63.94 25.00
−12.77 10.89 −14.29 −6.04 54.43 34.29
−11.68 19.64 20.83 8.22 56.67 43.75