Morphological and Pathogenic Variability among Macrophomina phaseolina Isolates Associated with Mungbean (Vigna radiata L.) Wilczek from Pakistan
Table 2
Morphological variations among different isolates of M. phaseolina
Isolates
Radial growth (mm)
Sclerotial size (μm)
Sclerotial weight (mg)
1
2
3
4
MP-1
63.17 i-r
26.67 a-d
0.10 h-l
MP-2
65.33 i-p
23.50 b-l
0.12 e-l
MP-3
75.17 a-i
27.33 ab
0.10 h-l
MP-4
71.67 f-m
19.67 g-o
0.13 d-l
MP-5
72.33 e-m
20.67 f-o
0.15 a-k
MP-6
78.00 a-h
20.33 f-o
0.16 a-h
MP-7
87.17 a
24.17 a-j
0.15 a-k
MP-8
32.00 t
20.83 f-o
0.11 g-l
MP-9
52.83 q-s
24.67 a-h
0.13 d-l
MP-10
83.00 a-f
23.00 b-m
0.13 d-l
MP-11
54.67 o-s
19.67 g-o
0.15 a-k
MP-12
64.33 i-r
18.17 l-o
0.16 a-h
MP-13
68.33 h-n
21.17 e-o
0.15 a-k
MP-14
84.67 a-e
19.33 h-o
0.13 d-l
MP-15
74.50 b-k
19.00 i-o
0.14 c-l
MP-16
68.00 h-n
21.83 c-o
0.14 b-l
MP-17
82.17 a-g
24.50 a-i
0.18 a-f
MP-18
74.83 a-j
26.83 a-c
0.19 a-d
MP-19
85.33 a-c
21.17 e-o
0.19 a-d
MP-20
62.50 j-r
29.00 a
0.21 a
MP-21
78.00 a-h
20.33 f-o
0.17 a-g
MP-22
71.83 f-m
20.17 f-o
0.19 a-d
MP-23
65.17 i-q
17.50 m-o
0.20 ab
MP-24
64.00 i-r
22.50 b-o
0.20 a-c
MP-25
66.33 h-o
22.67 b-n
0.18 a-f
MP-26
86.67 ab
23.33 b-l
0.17 a-g
MP-27
82.83 a-f
21.67 c-o
0.18 a-f
MP-28
43.83 s
17.33 no
0.17 a-g
MP-29
43.67 s
18.00 l-o
0.13 d-l
MP-30
44.00 s
22.67 b-n
0.13 d-l
MP-31
53.83 p-s
26.33 a-e
0.15 a-k
MP-32
83.33 a-f
19.83 g-o
0.12 f-l
MP-33
84.17 a-f
17.67 m-o
0.12 f-l
MP-34
53.17 p-s
21.83 c-o
0.10 h-l
MP-35
72.50 d-m
24.67 a-h
0.13 d-l
MP-36
61.50 m-r
22.17 b-o
0.10 h-l
MP-37
52.33 rs
19.33 h-o
0.13 d-l
MP-38
73.00 c-m
17.50 m-o
0.09 kl
MP-39
67.33 h-n
17.00 o
0.09 i-l
MP-40
74.17 b-l
25.00 a-g
0.10 h-l
MP-41
71.83 f-m
23.50 b-l
0.12 e-l
MP-42
73.17 c-m
24.33 a-j
0.13 d-l
MP-43
81.33 a-g
18.83 j-o
0.12 e-l
MP-44
85.00 a-d
19.00 i-o
0.12 e-l
MP-45
86.17 ab
22.50 b-o
0.13 d-l
MP-46
84.83 a-e
17.50 m-o
0.08 l
MP-47
65.17 i-q
21.33 d-o
0.09 kl
MP-48
81.17 a-g
18.50 k-o
0.10 h-l
MP-49
64.17 i-r
22.33 b-o
0.09 j-l
MP-50
81.83 a-g
20.33 f-o
0.18 a-f
MP-51
56.50 n-r
21.67 c-o
0.17 a-g
MP-52
78.00 a-h
25.67 a-f
0.20 ab
MP-53
67.17 h-n
23.50 b-l
0.18 a-f
MP-54
78.50 a-h
23.50 b-l
0.19 a-d
MP-55
63.83 i-r
24.17 a-j
0.20 a-c
MP-56
62.17 k-r
27.50 ab
0.16 a-i
MP-57
71.83 f-m
22.83 b-n
0.18 a-e
MP-58
74.17 b-l
24.00 a-k
0.15 a-k
MP-59
78.17 a-h
26.67 a-d
0.16 a-i
MP-60
61.17 m-r
19.33 h-o
0.18 a-e
MP-61
69.67 g-m
19.67 g-o
0.18 a-f
MP-62
84.50 a-e
21.50 c-o
0.17 a-g
MP-63
61.67 l-r
24.17 a-j
0.15 a-k
MP-64
78.67 a-h
19.83 g-o
0.15 a-j
MP-65
54.50 o-s
24.17 a-j
0.16 a-i
Values are means of five replicates in case of radial growth and sclerotial weight and ten replicates in case of sclerotial size. Values sharing common letters in each column do not differ significantly at according to Fisher’s protected least significant difference test.
