Abstract
Measurement of photons number in a quantum cavity is very difficult and the photons number is changed after each measurement. Recently, many efforts have been done for the nondemolition measurement methods. Haroche et al. succeed in recognizing existence or nonexistence of one photon in a quantum cavity. In this paper, we employ their experimental setup for a quantum nondemolition measurement and pump a coherent state in their quantum cavity. In this case, we could detect more photons in the quantum cavity by a measurement of a displaced Wigner function. It is also shown that the measurement of more than one photon is possible by the Haroche method by measuring just one point of displaced Wigner function. Furthermore, if the cavity field is filled by a superposition of two number states, the average number of photons within the cavity would be measurable. We show that their setup is also suitable to apply for the measurement of the squeezing parameter for the squeezed state of photons number in the quantum cavity successfully.
1. Introduction
The formulation of quantum mechanics in phase space was proposed by Wigner [1]. This formulation is very useful in various fields of physics including quantum mechanics [2, 3], quantum optics [4–6], and condensate matter [7, 8]. The physical concepts are extractable from Wigner function. Wigner function may take negative value for a quantum state. The existence of negative or interference of Wigner function is a nonclassicality indicator for quantum systems [9–11]. On the other hand, Wigner function is a measurable quantity. Many authors introduced methods to measure Wigner function for trapped ions [12], photonic number states in quantum cavity [13–15], Schrodinger cat state, and coherent state [16]. Bertet et al. measure a complete Wigner function for the vacuum and a single photon state [17]. Lutterbach and Davidovich presented a method to measure the Wigner distribution function of photonic state in a quantum cavity field [18, 19]. They used an experimental ingenious setup which was made by one high Q-factor and two low Q-factor cavities.
Nogues et al. (members of Haroche group) measured the Wigner distribution functions of electromagnetic fields in a cavity with the number states and at origin of phase space [20]. The Wigner distribution function at the origin of phase space is positive for and negative for . Therefore, the sign of measured Wigner distribution function, itself, gives us the number of photons in the cavity and its value is not important [20]. So, if there are more than one photon, it would not be possible to recognize the number of photons. In this paper we used the Haroche method to measure the larger number of photons by measuring just one point of the displaced Wigner distribution function in a quantum cavity. We use an experimental setup for the measurement of displaced Wigner function proposed by Deléglise et al. [16] (Haroche group). It is shown that their experimental setup is useful for the measurement of number of photons, even for . This method is also suitable to measure the average number of superpositions of two number states. The development of method to an arbitrary superposition of states needs more measurement for many more points of Wigner function which is not discussed in this paper. Furthermore this method is also applied to measure the squeezing parameter for squeezed number state of photons.
In the next section, the Wigner distribution function is calculated for four values of and their plot in phase space is illustrated. It would be shown that Wigner functions at the origin of phase space have positive value for the even and negative value for the odd number of photons. So, by measuring the Wigner function at the origin we only find whether the number of photons is even or odd. The value of the displaced Wigner function depends on the photons number. We find a point in phase space in which Wigner functions have different values for different photons number. Therefore we determine the photons number (or the average of photons number) by measuring the displaced Wigner function. In this section Lutterbach and Davidovich method is developed for displaced Wigner function and its experimental setup will be introduced. The measurement of displaced Wigner function in a quantum cavity is compared with the value of the Wigner function of different number states. Then the number of photons is obtained. In Section 3 a quantum cavity field is set to be in a superposition of two number states. In this case the average number of photons in the cavity is measured by calculating the Wigner function in the quantum cavity field by comparing the result with the Wigner function measured by the Latterbach and Davidovich proposed experimental setup. Section 4 is devoted to the measurement of squeezing parameter for the squeezed number states in a quantum cavity. The displaced Wigner function is measured for the squeezed field by developed Lutterbach and Davidovich experimental setup. The squeezed parameter is measurable by calculating the displaced Wigner function, for any value of . Finally, the last section is devoted to the conclusions.
2. Measuring Number of Photons in a Quantum Cavity
2.1. Calculating the Wigner Function
The Wigner function for a number state is given by [21] where is the density operator, is the parity operator, and is the displacement operator in phase space [21, 22]. The operation of the parity and displacement operators on is given by [21] where is the displaced number state [21]. Equation (1) can be written as [21] where is a number state. By (2) and (3) the Wigner function is obtained as follows:
The value of for and is written versus Laguerre polynomials as respectively. By the above relations the Laguerre polynomials for are given by where . Let us consider a cavity with photons. The exact value of is not definite, but suppose there is a few number of photons, for example, between 0 and 3. From (4) to (6) the Wigner function is calculated for number states as
In Figure 1, and are the axes of phase space. The cross section of the Wigner functions for the number states is plotted in terms of for . These Wigner functions have just two values in the origin; for even number states they are positive, while for odd number states they are negative. Thus, the value of the Wigner function at the origin is not sufficient to specify the number of photons in the quantum cavity. For other points of phase space these values are not the same for different states of photon numbers. One can apply this feature to specify the number of photons in the cavity.
To select a point in the phase space in which the Wigner function and consequently the number of photons are going to be measured, we note that the values of the Wigner function for each should have the maximum difference as much as possible. In order to have exact and significant measurement the discrepancy should be much more than measuring errors. In Figure 2 the value of Wigner functions versus the number of photons has been plotted for .
2.2. The Measurement of Photons Number
In this section we apply the Lutterbach and Davidovich method for measuring the Wigner function of the electromagnetic field in the cavity, where the number of photons is one of the values (e.g. , and ).
As shown in Figure 3, the experimental setup is made of 3 cavities. The quantum field in cavity is determined by an eigenstate of number states, but and cavities contain classical fields. Each cavity is a Fabry-Perot resonator which is made of two spherical super conductor mirrors [20].
In this experiment, a beam of Rydberg rubidium atoms pass through the cavities and interact with their electromagnetic fields. If one of the electrons of the atoms (usually the valence electron) is excited and jumps to a level with a higher quantum number, the atom would settle in a Rydberg state. Here, two Rydberg levels with quantum numbers, 50 and 51, are investigated and their states denoted by and , respectively (see Figure 4). The frequency of the field of each cavity is set to be close to the transition frequency between these two levels. So, the rubidium atom interacts with the field as a two-level atom. The interaction of the rubidium atom with the field of and cavities is performed in a resonant state. In the cavity , the atom in the state emits a photon during the interaction with the field and jumps to state. The atom may absorb this photon and come back to the state again. This happens over and over and the atom oscillates between the two levels. These oscillations are called Rabi oscillations. The Rabi frequency is denoted by . In general, during interaction, the state of atom evolves to a superposition of states [23] as follows: where is a phase which is obtained by the atom while passing through the cavity . Here we consider ; then In the cavity , by applying a uniform electric field, the Stark effect causes a small difference between the cavity field frequency and the two-level atom transition frequency , which is called detuning . In a nonresonance interaction, there is no transition between the atomic levels. Such nonresonance interaction applies a phase shift to the atomic state. This phase shift is given by [23] for and states, respectively. In these relations, is the interaction Hamiltonian, depends on which is equal to the electric field amplitude, and [23]. In order to measure the displaced Wigner function a coherent electromagnetic field is pumped into the cavity . The effect of this coherent field on the number state of photon is a displacement which is shown by . The state of the atom outgoing the cavity is given by
The relative phase between the cavities and is [18]. The atom makes also an interaction with a phase in the cavity resonantly. Thus each part of states in (11) changes as follows: Therefore, after going out of the last cavity the total state of the system is given by
By (13) the atom-field density matrix of the whole system is obtained as where . Then outgoing state of atom is detected by ionization detector in the or states. This experiment should be repeated many times and the probabilities of detecting the atoms in each or state are described with and , respectively. Here and are the numbers of detected atoms in and states, respectively. By (14), these probabilities and also the difference between them versus the Wigner function [18] are obtained as where . If we set , then would be proportional to a displaced Wigner function:
The number of photons in the cavity is obtained by a comparison between the measured Wigner function at the point , (16), and the value of the displaced Wigner functions for . We can develop this method to measure a large number of photons, although the accuracy of our measurement is our main limitation.
3. Measuring the Average Number of Photons in a Quantum Cavity
In the previous experimental setup the cavity was in a number state and the proposed experiment reveals integer photons number within the cavity. In this section we show if cavity can be in a superposition state; the average of photons number is also measurable by the same experimental method. This method is applied for different superpositions of number states. For example, consider the field of quantum cavity to be in a superposition state of and : where . The average number of photons is independent of the phase : In the next subsection we show that the measurement of the displaced Wigner function for a superposition of states gives us the average photon numbers and the phase .
3.1. Calculating the Wigner Function for a Superposition of Number States
Suppose the cavity field is given by a superposition state . By substituting the density operator in (3) the Wigner function for the field in the cavity is obtained as Equations (5) are utilized to determine the value of in the above equations for as follows: where . By substituting (18) in (20) the Wigner function is obtained in terms of average photons number and the phase : The value of Laguerre polynomials is calculated by for [24]. By (21) and (22) the Wigner distribution function for is obtained as Clearly, the measurement of the Wigner function is more difficult for the large value of because increasing the value of gives a decrease in the value of the Wigner function. For , (23) reduces to , which is a linear in terms of as shown in Figure 5. For this example our method gives us the value of the average number of photons even for .
(a)
(b)
3.2. Measuring the Average Number of Photons
Before running the experiment, the field of the cavity is set initially to be by applying a coherent beam of light. The state of incoming atom is which is resonantly (nonresonantly) interacted with the cavities and (with the cavity ) with a phase factor (with a phase factor). Outgoing atom-field state is obtained as Furthermore, the atom-field density matrix is obtained as where and The probability of finding the outgoing atom state in the states or is measured by an ionized detector. The difference between these probabilities is given by (15). By (15) and (27) and for , similar to (16), the measured Wigner function is obtained as
The Wigner function, obtained with an experimental measurement of , is compared to the value of displaced Wigner function, shown in Figure 5, to obtain the average of photons number . The development of this method to different superposition of two number states is straightforward. Figure 5 shows the Wigner function for a superposition of and number states which has many applications in the construction of a GHZ state [25]. As expected from (18), the average number of photons is independent of the phase . Therefore by measuring the Wigner function in the point (or ) we can obtain the average number of photons and consequently the superposition coefficient . Then by replacing the average number of photons in (23), the Wigner function is obtained in terms of the phase . Measuring the Wigner function that is shown in Figure 6 leads us to obtain the phase for each superposition.
4. Measuring the Squeezing Parameter
4.1. Measuring the Squeezed Wigner Function
Usually the squeezed lights are produced by a nonlinear interaction of light and matter [26, 27]. Almeida et al. used two-photon interactions to produce the squeezed states [28]. If the field of the cavity is set to be in a displaced squeezed number state , where [6], we show that it is possible to determine the squeezing parameter by the proposed experimental setup. The states and of rubidium atoms resonantly interacted with the and cavities, where the phase is . Similar to Section 2, due to the nonresonance interaction of atom and field in the quantum cavity , the state of atom is changed by a phase factor . The density operator for such a system is given by , where is a squeezing operator. Our main aim in this section is the measurement of the squeezed parameter at . The outgoing of state atom after passing through the cavities , , and is The density matrix of the atom-field system before any measurement is obtained as follows: Detecting the atomic states with an ionized detector gives us the electromagnetic field state. Performing the experiment over and over the probabilities of finding atoms in or states are obtained. By (30) is obtained as where . It is very similar to (15) except which is replaced by . If the phase is set to , we have Clearly, the above equation is proportional to the squeezed displaced Wigner function: Equation (33) shows a relation between the experimental value and the squeezed displaced Wigner function (or squeezing parameter ), which is given theoretically. Therefore the squeezing parameter is obtained by the measurement of .
4.2. Calculating the Squeezed Wigner Function
As shown in Section 2, the Wigner function is written in terms of the Laguerre polynomials for a number state. It is also possible to write the Wigner function for a squeezed number state in terms of the Laguerre polynomials. For a squeezed number state, the Wigner function can be obtained by replacing and with and , for the Wigner function at [27], respectively. Therefore the Wigner function of a squeezed displaced number state is given by In (34) the squeezed Wigner function is obtained by replacing and with and . For a number state, the Wigner functions versus the squeezing parameter are plotted for 0 to 3 number states versus in Figure 7. In order to set in the best point for the measurement of the squeezing parameter , we partitioned the horizontal axis into three domains.(1)The A-B domain is relevant to small . This domain is started from the origin to the first intersection point of the curves. Near the middle, the difference between the Wigner functions is almost larger than that of the other points. So selecting in the middle of this domain is a more suitable selection for the measuring of the squeezing parameter . In Figure 8 the Wigner functions are plotted versus for 0 to 3 photon number in the domain A-B. It has been shown that for a single value of a Wigner function and a specific number state, the value of squeezing parameter is unique. The sensitivity of Wigner function is higher for larger . We conclude that smaller values of are more suitable for measuring larger squeezing parameters.(2)The B-C domain is relevant to the middle value of . This domain is from the first intersection point of the two curves and extends out till the last intersection. Usually selection of in this domain is not suitable at all, since for a single value of a Wigner function the value of squeezing parameter is not unique. Figure 9 shows this nonuniqueness of the squeezing parameter for any Wigner function.(3)The domain greater than is relevant to the bigger values of . In this domain squeezing parameter is unique for any Wigner function. It should be noticed that for bigger values of squeezing parameter the Wigner functions are very small. Figure 10 illustrates the Wigner functions versus squeezing parameter for and . It decreases for bigger and the sensitivity of the Wigner functions is higher for smaller . Therefore, the domain is more suitable for the measurement of small . Here, the value of the Wigner function for bigger is very small, so it is not a suitable measurable value. Therefore, we choose to be not very far from the point .
(a)
(b)
(a)
(b)
(a)
(b)
5. Conclusion
In this paper we use measurement of the displaced Wigner function for the measuring of photons number in a quantum cavity. In this method a two-level Rydberg Rubidium atom is used to make a nondemolition measurement of the average number of photons in cavities. Detection of the atom states gives us and . It is shown that the difference between and gives us the displaced Wigner function and further gives us the average number of photons in the cavity in a nondemolition measurement method. This setup has also been used to the nondemolition measurement of the squeezing parameter in the field of quantum cavity. One may measure the squeezing parameter by measuring the displaced squeezed Wigner function. In order to obtain either a unique for each measured Wigner function or to increase the sensitivity of our measurements, the value of displacement should be set. We find that for larger values of squeezing parameter the displacement should be small and for smaller values of squeezing parameter the displacement should be large.