Research Article  Open Access
Algebraic Properties of First Integrals for Scalar Linear ThirdOrder ODEs of Maximal Symmetry
Abstract
By use of the Lie symmetry group methods we analyze the relationship between the first integrals of the simplest linear thirdorder ordinary differential equations (ODEs) and their point symmetries. It is well known that there are three classes of linear thirdorder ODEs for maximal cases of point symmetries which are 4, 5, and 7. The simplest scalar linear thirdorder equation has sevenpoint symmetries. We obtain the classifying relation between the symmetry and the first integral for the simplest equation. It is shown that the maximal Lie algebra of a first integral for the simplest equation is unique and fourdimensional. Moreover, we show that the Lie algebra of the simplest linear thirdorder equation is generated by the symmetries of the two basic integrals. We also obtain counting theorems of the symmetry properties of the first integrals for such linear thirdorder ODEs. Furthermore, we provide insights into the manner in which one can generate the full Lie algebra of higherorder ODEs of maximal symmetry from two of their basic integrals.
1. Introduction
Ordinary differential equations (ODEs) are a fertile area of study, especially the Lie algebraic properties of such equations and their first integrals have great importance. Initial investigations since the works of Lie [1] were motivated by physical problems, such as the free particle, onedimensional harmonic oscillator, and EmdenFowler equations and classification. Indeed, most of the earlier works dealt with secondorder linear equations (see, e.g., [2–8]). In the investigation by Mahomed and Leach [9], they found that the Lie point symmetries of the maximal cases of scalar linear thorder ODEs, , are , , and . Thus for scalar linear thirdorder equations these correspond to 4, 5, and 7 symmetries. Moreover for scalar thirdorder linear ODEs, Govinder and Leach [10] provided the algebraic structure of the basic first integrals for such equations. They showed that the three equivalence classes each has certain first integrals with a specific number of point symmetries. They followed on the initial investigation of Leach and Mahomed [11] who considered the point symmetries of the basic first integrals of linear secondorder ODEs. Then in the work [12] Flessas et al. attempted the symmetry structure for the first integrals of higherorder equations of maximal symmetry.
The subject of the present paper is the investigation of the Lie algebraic properties of first integrals of scalar linear thirdorder ODEs of the maximal class which is represented by . We remind the reader that for the simplest class there has been some analysis made in Flessas et al. [12]. This is in regards to the maximal algebra possessed by an integral of which is listed in Table II of [12]. However, this is incomplete. We extend this study and provide a complete analysis on the Lie point symmetries and first integrals for the simplest thirdorder ODE including the maximal algebra case. We firstly deduce the classifying relation between the point symmetries and first integrals for this simple class. Then we use this to study the point symmetry properties of the first integrals of which also represents all linearizable by point transformations thirdorder ODEs that reduce to this class.
We begin by noting the condition for symmetries of the first integrals of scalar linear ODEs of order one. Then for completeness we review briefly the results of the paper by Mahomed and Momoniat [13] which discusses the relationship between the point symmetries of the first integrals of scalar linear secondorder ODEs. These two cases are shown to be distinct in terms of their algebraic properties of their integrals when compared to higherorder ODEs of maximal symmetry.
1.1. Linear FirstOrder Equations
Consider the simplest firstorder ODE It is easy to see that is a point symmetry generator of (1) if where with in which is the total differentiation operator and is the first prolongation of the generator . We quickly see that where is an arbitrary function of . Therefore, Thus there is an infinite number of point symmetries. We now show that only are symmetries of the first integral.
This forms an infinitedimensional subalgebra of the Lie algebra of (1).
Now is a first integral of (1). It has point symmetry as in (2) if This implies that which immediately results in There is an infinite number of symmetries of the first integral of (1).
Let be an arbitrary function of , namely, . The symmetry of this general function of the first integral is Therefore as in (9) is a symmetry of and also any function of . Since any scalar firstorder ODE is equivalent to the simplest one (1), this means that a first integral of a nonlinear firstorder ODE has infinitely many symmetries too.
As an example, we consider the nonlinear firstorder Riccati equation the first integral of which is A symmetry of the first integral (12) is In fact, we have an infinite number of symmetries given by where is an arbitrary function in its arguments.
Therefore we note here that the symmetries of the first integrals of a firstorder equation form a proper subalgebra of the Lie algebra of the equation itself. We cannot generate the full algebra as is the case for linear scalar secondorder ODEs [11] by use of the algebra of the basic integral alone.
The symmetries of the first integrals of scalar linear secondorder ODEs have interesting properties [11, 13]. The first integrals of such linear equations can have 0, 1, 2, and the maximum 3 symmetries [13]. The Lie algebra of the maximum case is unique. Peculiar to such equations is the other remarkable property that their Lie algebra is generated by the symmetry properties of the basic integrals and their quotient [11].
Below we study the symmetry properties of first integral for the simplest scalar linear thirdorder ODEs of maximal point symmetry. In the case of the basic first integrals, the algebraic properties are known from the work [10]. Here we pursue the relationship between symmetries and first integrals of scalar linear thirdorder ODEs for the simplest and maximal class. We obtain the classifying relation for this class and invoke this to arrive at counting theorems and the result on the maximal case of symmetries of the first integrals.
In the following we look at algebraic properties of first integrals for the seven point symmetry case by deriving the classifying relation between the symmetries and their first integrals. We use this relation to arrive at interesting properties which appear for the first time in the literature.
2. Algebraic Properties of the First Integrals of
We consider the simplest thirdorder ODE which as is well known has the seven symmetries (Lie [1] and e.g., [4]) We have listed the symmetries in the order of the solution symmetries being first, then the homogeneity symmetry, and the remaining three which form the algebra . This ODE (15) also represents all linearizable thirdorder ODEs reducible to it via point transformation. The order in which the symmetries appear in (16) is used in what follows. It is obvious that (15) has three functionally independent first integralsWe use the ordering of the integrals as given in [10]. The first integral (17a) has four symmetries [10] from which we observe that there are two solution symmetries, one translation in symmetry and a scaling symmetry. The translation in symmetry is a subset of the symmetries with being a combination of the uniform scaling symmetry in both variables contained in the symmetries together with the homogeneity symmetry. Part of this fact was also noted in [12]. The second first integral (17b) has three symmetries [10] with two solution symmetries and being part of the symmetries. The third first integral (17c) also has four symmetries [10] Again one can see the solution symmetries, scaling, and the symmetry which is contained in the symmetries. Note further that the symmetries in (20) are found by multiplying those of (18) by the factor . In fact these two sets are equivalent via a point transformation [10]. The other important properties are discussed in the next section.
Below we obtain the classifying relation.
2.1. Classifying Relation for the Symmetries and Integrals
Now let be an arbitrary function of the integrals (17a), (17b), and (17c), , , and , namely, The symmetry of this general function of the first integrals is where The coefficient functions , , , and are These are obtained by setting where the are the symmetry generators as given in (16) and the are constants. The reason being that the symmetries of the first integrals are always the symmetries of the equation (see [14]).
After substitution of the values of , , and as in (23), with , , , and given in (24), as well as by use of the first integrals , , and in (22), we arrive at the classifying relation The relation (26) explicitly provides the relationship between the symmetries and the first integrals of the simple thirdorder equation (15). We invoke this to classify the first integrals according to their symmetries in what follows.
We use the classifying relation (26) to establish the number and property of symmetries possessed by the first integrals of the simplest thirdorder equation (15).
There arise five cases. We deal with each below.
Case 1 (no symmetry). If is any arbitrary function of , , and , then , , and are not related to each other. In this case we have from (26) that
It is easy to see from (27) that all the ’s are zero. Therefore there exists no symmetry for this case.
As an illustrative example, if we take , then (26) straightforwardly yields
This easily results in all the ’s being zero.
Case 2 (one symmetry). If satisfies the relation (26), then there exists one symmetry. For the simple symmetries of (15) one obtains further symmetries except for which we consider below.
If we take or any function of this product, then the relation (26) becomes
In (29), to are zeros except which gives the one symmetry
Consider and . Now let (cf. [12]). Then relation (26) becomes
We see here that all the ’s are zero except . Therefore there exists one symmetry which again is (30).
In fact similar to the free particle equation [13], there are many one symmetry cases.
Case 3 (two symmetries). Here there are many cases as well. We begin by utilizing the Lie table for the classification of the twodimensional algebras in the plane which are given, for example, in [6]. They are
These form subalgebras of the Lie algebra of symmetries of (15) as can clearly be observed.
We take the first realization listed above. If is arbitrary in (26), then implies that is independent of . Further yields that does not depend on as well. Since we require that , we have
from which it follows that and . Thus we end up with two more symmetries and . These turn out to be the four symmetries of the integral given in (18).
Likewise for the second realization we obtain (18) again. For the third realization listed above we find the symmetries of as in (19).
Hence the first three realizations listed do not provide maximal two symmetries for the first integrals of (15).
In fact the fourth realization results in a two symmetry case as and are arbitrary and give rise to
which has the solution
The further substitution of this form into the relation (26) constrains all the ’s to be zero except for and . This result prompts the following simple products and quotients that do give two symmetries.
If , then relation (26) yields
Here we observe that , , , and are zeros whereas is arbitrary and , and therefore we obtain the two symmetries
which form a twodimensional algebra with
If we set , then we end up getting , , , , and equal to zero. Since and are arbitrary so they result in two symmetries
with Lie bracket
If we take , then we see that is arbitrary and which then give rise to the two symmetries
with
Consider now . This shows that and are arbitrary, and the resulting two symmetries are
with commutation relation
If we let , then here and are arbitrary, and therefore the two symmetries are
with
If , , and (cf. [12]), then we have from the relation (26)
This results in , , , and being zero whereas is arbitrary, and , which give rise to the two symmetries
with
If , , and (cf. [12]), then relation (26) yields
The above relation shows that , , , and are zeros, is arbitrary, and . This imply two symmetries
together with
There are thus many two symmetry cases. One could obtain more. Also they could arise as different combinations of the seven symmetries (16). So one concludes that the twodimensional algebra cases are not unique. We have seen the occurrence of both Abelian and nonAbelian Lie algebras.
Case 4 (three symmetries). Here we use the threedimensional real realizations of Mahomed and Leach [7]. The notation used is that given in [4]. Since we adapt these realizations as symmetries of thirdorder equations, the entries for the first entry and the nonsolvable algebra are those which are symmetries of such equations.
Note that for , , and one can use the realizations as given in Table 1 or the ones obtained by interchanging and in the realizations given. The reason for this is that one still obtains thirdorder representative equations for the latter realizations.
As is the first threedimensional algebra in Table 1, we start with that. We want this Abelian algebra to be admitted by a first integral of (15). We utilize the classifying relation (26). Therefore , , and are arbitrary which imply that is constant. Hence this algebra is not admitted by any first integral of (15) although, if it is admitted by a nonlinear thirdorder ODE, it implies linearization (see Mahomed and Leach [6]).

It is not difficult to deduce that the same applies to the algebras , , , , , , , and when and when . If for , then one ends up with four symmetries of which are (18). The same applies to , . For both these cases, the algebras , and , are admitted by a first integral but these are not maximal and contained in a fourdimensional algebra, spanned by operators (18).
Now we focus on the three symmetry case which is admitted by . These three symmetries are given in (19). The Lie algebra of the generators (19) has nonzero commutators with the elements thus forming the Lie algebra , . In fact the transformation maps it to the canonical form of Table 1, namely, Therefore the symmetries of has the Lie algebra , .
There is yet another threedimensional algebra which is admitted by a first integral of (15). This occurs for . We use the classifying relation (26). Here , , and are arbitrary. Making these constants one at a time unity and the rest zero yield is The solution to this system (56) yields Thus the basic first integral has the algebra .
The Lie algebras , , and are not admitted by any first integral of (15) as these are subalgebras of the maximal sixdimensional algebras (see Ibragimov and Mahomed [3]) which are admitted by nonlinear thirdorder ODEs not reducible to the simplest equation (15).
In the case of the algebra one has the situation that this algebra is not a subalgebra of the sevendimensional algebra of (15) (Wafo Soh and Mahomed [15]).
In conclusion of this discussion, we have two threedimensional algebras admitted by a first integral of (15) which are and , .
We state the following theorem.
Theorem 1. If a first integral of the simplest thirdorder ODE, , admits a threedimensional algebra, then it is one of the two threedimensional algebras , , or .
The proof follows from the previous discussions. Note here that the threedimensional algebra admitted is not unique.
Case 5 (four symmetries). In the four symmetry case we have that only and possess four symmetries. They are given by (18) and (20). Both are similar by a point transformation [10]. The Lie algebra of (18) is (see [12]). This can be seen by interchanging and in (18). Thus the nonzero commutation relations are We have the following theorem.
Theorem 2. The maximum dimension of the Lie algebra admitted by any first integral of the simplest thirdorder ODE, , or any thirdorder ODE linearizable by point transformation to the simplest ODE is .
Proof. Any first integral of or thirdorder ODE reducible to the simplest ODE by point transformation cannot admit a maximal algebra of dimension greater than four since the basic integrals and have the unique four dimension algebra . The other integrals have lower dimensional Lie algebras in the classification obtained above.
Finally, we have the following counting theorem.
Theorem 3. A first integral of the simplest thirdorder ODE, , or any linearizable thirdorder ODE by point transformation to the simplest ODE can have 0, 1, 2, 3, or the maximum 4 symmetries. The four symmetry case is unique.
3. Symmetry Properties of First Integrals of HigherOrder ODEs: Some Remarks
In the case of symmetries of the simplest firstorder ODE we have seen that the algebra of any first integral constitutes a proper subalgebra of the equation itself. One cannot generate the full algebra of via the algebras of any integral. This result also applies to any scalar firstorder ODE due to equivalence of this with the simplest equation.
What occurs for scalar linear secondorder ODEs is very different to the firstorder ODE case. Here as has been shown in [11], the Lie algebra of which represents any linear or linearizable secondorder ODE can be generated by the threedimensional algebras of the triplets of the basic integrals and their quotient which are isomorphic to each other. Thus in this case one requires not only the basic integrals, say and , but also a functionally dependent quotient integral .
Another important point to make is that the full Lie algebra of the simplest thirdorder equation (15) is generated by the four symmetries (18) as well as the three symmetries , , and of (20). Hence one requires only the symmetries of the basic integrals and to generate the full algebra of our equation (15). One should contrast this with what happens for and discussed above. So one has the seven symmetries of our equation (15) being generated by four symmetries of together with three symmetries of . The natural question then is as follows: what occurs for higherorder ODEs of maximal symmetry? Patterns emerge, some of which are discussed in the three propositions in the paper of Flessas et al. [12]. We discuss another important property, namely, that of generation of the full algebra via integrals now.
Consider the thorder ODE of maximal symmetry This ODE (59) has symmetries as is well known. The first integrals of (59) are easily constructible and we focus on the first and last which are The first integral (60) has symmetries which are This forms an dimensional subalgebra of (59). Now the first integral (61) has symmetries which one can see comes from multiplying the symmetries of (62) by . We can observe from these two sets (62) and (63) that the full Lie algebra of our equation (59) is generated from the symmetries of (62) and 3 symmetries of (63), namely, , , and . Further the two sets (62) and (63) are equivalent to each other by means of the point transformation This is an extension of the transformation given in [10] and is for higherorder ODEs. In [10] it was given for thirdorder ODEs.
We have the following theorem, the proof of which is evident from the above.
Theorem 4. The full Lie algebra of the thorder ODE , , is generated by two subalgebras, namely, the dimensional algebra of and the threedimensional subalgebra of .
Hence the picture is quite distinct for the manner in which the full Lie algebra is generated for the ODEs , and, , . This is also consistent with the properties of their symmetry algebra which are different (see, e.g., [4]).
Acknowledgments
K. S. Mahomed is thankful to the University of the Witwatersrand and the NRF (South Africa) for financial support. E. Momoniat thanks the NRF (South Africa) for financial support.
References
 S. Lie, “Klassifikation und Integration von gewöhnlichen differentialgleichungen zwischen x, y, die eine Gruppe von Transformationen gestatten,” Archiv der Mathematik, vol. 8, no. 9, p. 187, 1883. View at: Google Scholar
 P. G. L. Leach, “First integrals for the modified Emden equation $\ddot{q}+\alpha (t)\dot{q}+{q}^{n}=0$,” Journal of Mathematical Physics, vol. 26, no. 10, pp. 2510–2514, 1985. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 N. H. Ibragimov and F. M. Mahomed, “Ordinary differential equations,” in CRC Handbook of Lie Group Analysis of Differential Equations, N. H. Ibragimov, Ed., vol. 3, p. 191, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fla, USA, 1996. View at: Google Scholar
 F. M. Mahomed, “Symmetry group classification of ordinary differential equations: survey of some results,” Mathematical Methods in the Applied Sciences, vol. 30, no. 16, pp. 1995–2012, 2007. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 F. M. Mahomed and P. G. L. Leach, “The linear symmetries of a nonlinear differential equation,” Quaestiones Mathematicae, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 241–274, 1985. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 F. M. Mahomed and P. G. L. Leach, “Lie algebras associated with scalar secondorder ordinary differential equations,” Journal of Mathematical Physics, vol. 30, no. 12, pp. 2770–2777, 1989. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 F. M. Mahomed and P. G. L. Leach, “The Lie algebra sl(3, R) and linearization,” Quaestiones Mathematicae, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 121–139, 1989. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 F. M. Mahomed, A. H. Kara, and P. G. L. Leach, “Lie and Noether counting theorems for onedimensional systems,” Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 178, no. 1, pp. 116–129, 1993. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 F. M. Mahomed and P. G. L. Leach, “Symmetry Lie algebras of $n$th order ordinary differential equations,” Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 151, no. 1, pp. 80–107, 1990. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  MathSciNet
 K. S. Govinder and P. G. L. Leach, “The algebraic structure of the first integrals of thirdorder linear equations,” Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 193, no. 1, pp. 114–133, 1995. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 P. G. L. Leach and F. M. Mahomed, “Maximal subalgebra associated with a first integral of a system possessing sl(3, R) algebra,” Journal of Mathematical Physics, vol. 29, no. 8, pp. 1807–1813, 1988. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 G. P. Flessas, K. S. Govinder, and P. G. L. Leach, “Characterisation of the algebraic properties of first integrals of scalar ordinary differential equations of maximal symmetry,” Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 212, no. 2, pp. 349–374, 1997. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  Zentralblatt MATH  MathSciNet
 K. S. Mahomed and E. Momoniat, “Symmetry classiffcation of first integrals for scalar linearizable secondorder ODEs,” Journal of Applied Mathematics, vol. 2012, Article ID 847086, 14 pages, 2012. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 A. H. Kara and F. M. Mahomed, “A basis of conservation laws for partial differential equations,” Journal of Nonlinear Mathematical Physics, vol. 9, supplement 2, pp. 60–72, 2002. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar  MathSciNet
 C. Wafo Soh and F. M. Mahomed, “Contact symmetry algebras of scalar ordinary differential equations,” Nonlinear Dynamics, vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 213–230, 2002. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 K. S. Mahomed and E. Momoniat. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.