Research Article

Selection and Configuration of Sorption Isotherm Models in Soils Using Artificial Bees Guided by the Particle Swarm

Table 7

Performance of different solvers for the selection of appropriate algorithm based on mean solution.

#PSOPCPSOABCMABC

1Two-site Langmuir
(0.1375)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.1294)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.1288)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.1282)

2Two-site Langmuir
(0.1870)
Freundlich
(0.1119)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0975)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0928)

3Freundlich-Langmuir (0.1168)Freundlich
(0.0311)
Freundlich
(0.0233)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0211)

4Freundlich
(0.2045)
Freundlich
(0.0819)
Freundlich
(0.0827)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0796)

5Freundlich
(0.0614)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0376)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0357)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0290)

6Two-site Langmuir
(0.0775)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0746)
Freundlich-Langmuir
(0.0743)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0742)

7Two-site Langmuir
(0.0432)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0471)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0438)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0418)

8Two-site Langmuir
(0.1035)
Freundlich
(0.0853)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0843)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0777)

9Freundlich (0.1537)Freundlich (0.1330)Freundlich (0.1330)Freundlich (0.1330)

10Two-site Langmuir (0.1010)Two-site Langmuir (0.1010)Two-site Langmuir (0.1010)Freundlich/Two-site Langmuir (0.1010)

11Two-site Langmuir
(0.0888)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0873)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0791)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0706)

12Two-site Langmuir
(0.0513)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.0536)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0331)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0310)

13Two-site Langmuir (0.0776)Two-site Langmuir (0.0535)Two-site Langmuir (0.0379)Two-site Langmuir (0.0351)

14Two-site Langmuir (0.1240)Two-site Langmuir (0.0760)Two-site Langmuir (0.0746)Two-site Langmuir (0.0721)

15Two-site Langmuir (0.0487)Two-site Langmuir (0.0440)Freundlich-Langmuir
(0.0405)
Freundlich-Langmuir/Two-site Langmuir (0.0396)

16Freundlich
(0.1155)
Two-site Langmuir
(0.1156)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0756)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.00652)

17Two-site Langmuir
(0.1318)
Freundlich
(0.1019)
Freundlich
(0.0677)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0638)

18Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0578)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0483)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0344)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0321)

19Two-site Langmuir (0.0251)Two-site Langmuir (0.0290)Two-site Langmuir (0.0190)Two-site Langmuir (0.0160)

20Two-site Langmuir (0.0162)Two-site Langmuir (0.0270)Two-site Langmuir (0.0173)Two-site Langmuir (0.0148)

21Two-site Langmuir (0.0220)Two-site Langmuir (0.0140)Two-site Langmuir (0.0136)Two-site Langmuir (0.0079)