Comparison of Uplift Capacity and Nonlinear Failure Surfaces of Single-Belled Anchor in Homogeneous and Layered Sand Deposits

Table 4

Values of experimental uplift capacities in S_I and S_II/S_I (Q_u(S_I) and Q_u(S_II/S_I)), analytical uplift capacities in S_I and S_II/S_I (Q_u.anlyl.(S_I) and Q_u.anlyl.(S_II/S_I)), error (%) on Q_u.anlyl.(S_I) based on Q_u(S_I), and error (%) on Q_u.anlyl.(S_II/S_I) based on Q_u(S_II/S_I).

3D model designations in SI	Qu(SI) (N)	Qu.anlyl.(SI) (N)	Error (%) in (iii) based on (ii)	3D model designations in SII/SI	Qu.(SII/SI) (N)	Qu.anlyl.(SII/SI) (N)	Error (%) in (vii) based on (vi)
(i)	(ii)	(iii)	(iv)	(v)	(vi)	(vii)	(viii)
3D:45-0.28-3-(SI)	123.98	125.28	−01.05	3D:45-0.28-3-(0.39SII/0.61SI)	151.15	149.60	+01.03
3D:45-0.28-4-(SI)	234.84	226.65	+03.50	3D:45-0.28-4-(0.54SII/0.46SI)	297.90	276.30	+07.25
3D:45-0.28-5-(SI)	347.56	383.70	−10.40	3D:45-0.28-5-(0.63SII/0.37SI)	523.51	481.68	+08.00
3D:45-0.33-3-(SI)	82.30	80.85	+01.76	3D:45-0.33-3-(0.30SII/0.70SI)	89.76	95.97	−06.92
3D:45-0.33-4-(SI)	154.75	154.75	−00.00	3D:45-0.33-4-(0.47SII/0.53SI)	189.53	187.57	+01.03
3D:45-0.33-5-(SI)	235.75	251.07	−06.50	3D:45-0.33-5-(0.58SII/0.42SI)	294.28	325.84	−10.72
3D:45-0.38-3-(SI)	48.10	50.63	−05.30	3D:45-0.38-3-(0.18SII/0.82SI)	50.71	52.34	−03.22
3D:45-0.38-4-(SI)	93.38	95.23	−01.98	3D:45-0.38-4-(0.38SII/0.62SI)	112.92	115.80	−02.54
3D:45-0.38-5-(SI)	134.35	147.90	−10.08	3D:45-0.38-5-(0.51SII/0.49SI)	179.73	188.64	−04.96
3D:45-0.46-3-(SI)	25.70	28.45	−10.70	3D:45-0.46-3-(SI)	25.70	28.45	−10.70
3D:45-0.46-4-(SI)	47.11	47.24	−00.28	3D:45-0.46-4-(0.25SII/0.75SI)	50.54	54.50	−07.82
3D:45-0.46-5-(SI)	71.56	71.77	−00.30	3D:45-0.46-5-(0.40SII/0.60SI)	85.16	84.44	+00.85
3D:63-0.28-3-(SI)	115.17	106.51	+07.52	Qu:63-0.28-3-(0.39SII/0.61SI)	138.05	128.56	+06.88
3D:63-0.28-4-(SI)	204.65	199.90	+02.33	Qu:63-0.28-4-(0.54SII/0.46SI)	271.30	247.51	+08.77
3D:63-0.28-5-(SI)	313.90	321.46	−02.41	3D: 63-0.28-5-(0.63SII/0.37SI)	480.16	447.44	+06.82
3D:63-0.33-3-(SI)	74.54	73.83	+00.95	3D:63-0.33-3-(0.30SII/0.70SI)	81.30	84.66	−04.13
3D:63-0.33-4-(SI)	142.40	136.42	+04.20	3D:63-0.33-4-(0.47SII/0.53SI)	170.71	167.42	+01.93
3D:63-0.33-5-(SI)	218.68	213.21	+02.50	3D:63-0.33-5-(0.58SII/0.42SI)	273.15	269.43	+01.36
3D:63-0.38-3-(SI)	43.83	43.82	+00.02	3D:63-0.38-3-(0.18SII/0.82SI)	47.04	48.21	−02.48
3D:63-0.38-4-(SI)	85.20	79.26	+06.96	3D:63-0.38-4-(0.38SII/0.62SI)	103.81	100.80	+02.91
3D:63-0.38-5-(SI)	121.18	117.97	+02.65	3D:63-0.38-5-(0.51SII/0.49SI)	166.48	166.85	−00.22
3D:63-0.46-3-(SI)	21.71	25.77	−18.72	3D:63-0.46-3-(SI)	21.71	25.77	−18.72
3D:63-0.46-4-(SI)	42.53	41.42	+02.60	3D:63-0.46-4-(0.25SII/0.75SI)	45.77	48.71	−06.43
3D:63-0.46-5-(SI)	64.33	63.38	+01.48	3D:63-0.46-5-(0.40SII/0.60SI)	78.02	74.10	+05.02
3D:72-0.28-3-(SI)	95.14	89.81	+05.61	3D:72-0.28-3-(0.39SII/0.61SI)	112.38	104.71	+06.82
3D:72-0.28-4-(SI)	177.06	166.48	+05.98	3D:72-0.28-4-(0.54SII/0.46SI)	221.14	191.08	+13.60
3D:72-0.28-5-(SI)	257.56	251.10	+02.51	Qu:72-0.28-5-(0.63SII/0.37SI)	370.34	347.20	+06.25
3D:72-0.33-3-(SI)	60.86	63.00	−03.52	3D:72-0.33-3-(0.30SII/0.70SI)	66.61	68.52	−02.87
3D:72-0.33-4-(SI)	112.20	105.46	+06.00	3D:72-0.33-4-(0.47SII/0.53SI)	136.13	122.74	+09.83
3D:72-0.33-5-(SI)	170.15	155.67	+08.51	3D:72-0.33-5-(0.58SII/0.42SI)	219.37	198.94	+09.31
3D:72-0.38-3-(SI)	36.93	40.00	−08.32	3D:72-0.38-3-(0.18SII/0.82SI)	38.91	42.40	−08.97
3D:72-0.38-4-(SI)	70.76	66.95	+05.39	3D:72-0.38-4-(0.38SII/0.62SI)	84.14	78.70	+06.46
3D:72-0.38-5-(SI)	98.94	99.40	−00.46	3D:72-0.38-5-(0.51SII/0.49SI)	132.12	118.74	+10.12
3D:72-0.46-3-(SI)	19.65	22.88	−16.46	3D:72-0.46-3-(SI)	19.65	22.88	−16.46
3D:72-0.46-4-(SI)	33.60	36.01	−07.18	3D:72-0.46-4-(0.25SII/0.75SI)	37.57	39.48	−05.08
3D:72-0.46-5-(SI)	51.16	52.70	−03.01	3D:72-0.46-5-(0.40SII/0.60SI)	63.76	60.88	+04.52