Research Article

Seismic Performance Assessment of Reinforced Concrete Frame-Shear Wall Structures in Hydropower Plants Based on Material Damage

Table 1

Correlation of damage limit states with visual observation [28, 43, 47].

Damage stateDescriptionVisual observation

NoneNo visible damage, either cosmetic or structuralNo visible cracks
InsignificantDamage requires no more than cosmetic repair. No structural repairs are necessaryHairline cracks
Minor spalling
ModerateRepairable structural damage has occurred. The existing element can be repaired essentially in place, without substantial demolition or replacement of elementsExcessive spalling
Exposed reinforcement
No buckling of bars
HeavyDamage is so extensive that repair of elements either is not feasible or requires major demolition or replacementBuckling/fracture of bars