Resonant cavity optoelectronic devices, such as vertical cavity surface emitting lasers (VCSELs), resonant cavity enhanced photodetectors (RCEPDs), and electroabsorption modulators (EAMs), show improved performance over their predecessors by placing the active device structure inside a resonant cavity. The effect of the optical cavity, which allows wavelength selectivity and enhancement of the optical field due to resonance, allows the devices to be made thinner and therefore faster, while simultaneously increasing the quantum efficiency at the resonant wavelengths. However, the narrow spectral bandwidth significantly reduces operating tolerances, which leads to severe problems in applications such as optical communication, imaging, and biosensing. Recently, in order to overcome such drawbacks and/or to accomplish multiple functionalities, several approaches for broadening the spectral bandwidth in resonant cavity optoelectronic devices have been extensively studied. This paper reviews the recent progress in techniques for wide spectral bandwidth that include a coupled microcavity, asymmetric tandem quantum wells, and high index contrast distributed Bragg-reflectors. This review will describe design guidelines for specific devices together with experimental considerations in practical applications.

1. Introduction

Multilayer thin film growth and coatings have been investigated for many years as distributed Bragg-reflector (DBR) or Fabry-Perot cavities to produce resonant enhancement in numerous optoelectronic devices such as light emitting diodes [1], photodetectors [2], low-threshold lasers [3, 4], and modulators [5]. Recently, to achieve multiple functionalities, it is necessary to optimize parameters related to performance such as the spectral bandwidth, angular bandwidth, wavelength selectivity, and polarization. In particular, the wide spectral bandwidth characteristic of optoelectronic devices allows high manufacturing tolerance, wide angular properties, and robust operation. Several studies have demonstrated these characteristics using microcavity structures, asymmetric tandem quantum wells, and high index contrast DBR structures.

In wavelength division multiplexed (WDM) systems, it is desirable to have wavelength selective photodetectors with low channel crosstalk at the channel spacing (<4 nm) [68]. The resonant cavity enhanced photodetector (RCEPD) benefits from wavelength selectivity and a large increase of the resonant optical field introduced by the Fabry-Perot cavity. Thin absorption layers are inserted into a resonant cavity sandwiched by two mirrors, forming a Fabry-Perot cavity. This results in an increased optical field and therefore faster speed, while simultaneously increasing the quantum efficiency at the resonant wavelength [9]. Narrow spectral bandwidth can be achieved by adopting a high- cavity design in the conventional single-cavity RCEPD structure or by employing a narrow-band Fabry-Perot filter. However, it is very important to have a flat-topped passband when the channel-aligning tolerance between the transmitter and the receiver is considered, and thereby the system performance will not be sensitive to wavelength fluctuation in the transmitter or the resonant control in the receiver [10]. During the past two decades, numerous theoretical and experimental methods have been reported to address this crucial need [1013]. The concept underlying the designed structures was realizing a low loss cavity for coupling with different mirrors such as compound semiconductors, dielectric materials, and Au metals.

Another application using a coupled cavity is an electroabsorption modulator (EAM) used as an optical shutter in a three-dimensional (3D) image capturing system based on time of flight. This is a simple and inexpensive method to realize a 3D image with a small system. The basic 3D imaging system consists of an active illumination light source as an optical transmitter and a demodulator and a detector as a receiver. The modulated light source travels toward the object, and the light reflected from the object reaches the detector. A 3D image of an object can be realized by extracting distance information from the phase delay between the illuminated light and reflected light, which is achieved using a large area optical shutter. To obtain high resolution depth image information, it is thus essential that the large area optical shutter has high performance such as high modulation depth [14] and high-speed modulation, which can increase the resolution depth [15]. High-speed modulation is obtained by utilizing the electroabsorption mechanism of a multilayer structure, which has an optical resonance cavity and light absorption in quantum wells. The optical shutter is positioned in front of a standard high resolution complementary metal oxide semiconductor image sensor. The optical shutter modulates the incoming infrared image to acquire the depth image [16]. Despite advances to improve the modulation speed and modulation depth, this approach still suffers from relatively narrow spectral bandwidth due to the high quality factor of the Fabry-Perot cavity. The narrow spectral bandwidth is also problematic since the modulation depth degrades significantly as the emission wavelength of the light source used in the time of flight based 3D imaging system varies according to temperature. Moreover, a narrow spectral bandwidth reduces the manufacturing tolerance of the 3D imaging system and the operating temperature range since the bandgap of a semiconductor material changes as the temperature changes. Thus, in order to improve the operational reliability of 3D imaging systems, the EAM should be capable of operating over a wide spectral bandwidth with high modulation depth.

High index contrast DBR structures are used in a wide range of applications such as vertical cavity surface emitting lasers (VCSELs), filtering, and wavelength division multiplexing. The reflectivity and spectral bandwidth directly depend on the refractive index contrast between the high and low index materials. Moreover, a higher index contrast guarantees higher tolerance during the fabrication process of the DBRs because the deposition rate dramatically affects the quality of the optical reflective wavelength, and highly tolerant DBRs are required for low-cost fabrication. Holonyak and coworkers have established a technique involving wet oxidation of AlAs [1719] and have shown that AlAs can be oxidized without considerably affecting the GaAs/AlAs DBR system. Since the refractive index of oxidized AlAs is low (1.5), the combination of oxidized AlAs and GaAs shows favorable properties of broad spectral bandwidth [19]. Recently, it was shown that oblique-angle deposition (OAD) of materials, for example, SiO2, TiO2, ITO, and amorphous silicon (a-Si), can be used to fabricate DBR structures with optical properties that can be controlled by the oblique angle [2022]. By controlling the angle of deposition and thereby the layer porosity and refractive index, OAD allows easy fabrication of a DBR composed of a single material chosen for its optical properties in which each layer has a different refractive index that is individually tuned to a specific desired value. A novel subwavelength high index contrast grating (HCG) as a surface-normal broadband reflector was later proposed by Chang-Hasnain [23, 24]. An HCG has been shown to replace conventional DBRs for VCSELs and offers desirable attributes, including lithographically defined polarization [25] and wavelength [26], a large aperture while maintaining a single transverse mode [25, 27], and a large fabrication tolerance [28].

Here, we summarize recent approaches to achieve wide spectral bandwidth using a coupled microcavity, asymmetric tandem quantum wells, and high index contrast distributed Bragg-reflector and assess the trends in this field. We first address two light absorption optoelectronic devices, RCEPDs and EAMs, using a coupled cavity structure for wide response and transmittance, respectively. Next, absorption coupling using quantum wells of different thickness, called asymmetric tandem quantum wells, in an EAM for wide transmittance change is described. Finally, wide spectral bandwidth using oblique-angle deposition and high index contrast grating techniques is discussed.

2. Flat Top Response of RCEPD

WDM is a key technology for increasing the transmission capacity of optical fiber communication systems [29, 30]. A high-speed and high-gain demultiplexing receiver is a crucial part of these systems. A monolithic multiple wavelength demultiplexing device with a narrow interchannel wavelength spacing and low crosstalk between channels is essential for effective use of the available bandwidth.

Since 1991, the RCEPD, which is constructed by inserting an absorption layer into an integrated Fabry-Perot resonant cavity, has been established as a promising device for WDM applications because of its wavelength selectivity as well as its high-speed response. In particular, monolithic integration of VCSEL and RCEPD can reduce alignment time, lower packaging cost, and provide design flexibility (Figure 1(a)) [31, 32]. The problem of misalignment of the cavity-mode wavelength of the emitter and RCEPD, however, significantly affects the system performance [30, 3335]. As shown in Figure 1(b), misaligned operating wavelengths between the VCSEL and RCEPD can be changed by etching the top most layer of RCEPD [33, 36]. However, the conventional RCEPD spectral response shapes are triangular, which affects the sensitivity of system performance because of the extremely narrow spectra of the VCSELs (Figure 1(c)). As shown in Figure 1(d), there is also a tradeoff between the quantum efficiency and the interchannel crosstalk parameter in the conventional RCEPD [37]. To solve this issue, low loss cavity is added to the top mirror and optically coupled in series with the absorptive cavity of the conventional single resonant cavity design [10, 11, 38]. This flat top response with sharp edges reduces the interchannel crosstalk and improves the accuracy and stability of the system, although lasing wavelength is changed.

When two or more Fabry-Perot cavities are placed in series, a double-peak transmittance curve can be obtained, which has a more promising response shape. This multiple half-wave cavities structures with three mirrors can be made of quarter-wave stacks of semiconductor compounds or dielectric materials. A theoretical analysis of the quantum efficiency of an InGaAs/GaAs RCEPD was presented by using this microcavity in place of the top DBR (Figure 2). The quantum efficiency can amount to 100% with a sufficiently large quantity of bottom mirror pairs in a conventional RCEPD (gray curve). On the other hand, the flat-topped quantum efficiency spectrum has been obtained in a coupled cavity RCEPD (black curve). This response can be explained in consideration of phase conditions in the resonator. The electromagnetic field between the mirrors almost does not depend on wavelength when the slope of the phase change is zero on the wavelength. When the thickness of coupled cavity is thicker than quarter-wave resonant thickness, the phase change for the wavelength is zero. As a result, the reflectivity shows the flatness near the resonance wavelength [13].

The location of the absorption layer affects the response curve. Two cavities have the same optical lengths, as integral times of half resonant wavelength. When the absorption layer is on the coupled cavity, the quantum efficiency curve is hollow and much deeper for the top-illuminated device (Figure 3). Because the light from the top of the device is significantly absorbed, there is no coupling effect of electric fields by the coupled cavity. Therefore, the coupled cavity is placed above the absorption cavity for a flat-topped response.

3. Wide Spectral Bandwidth Electroabsorption Modulator

Surface-normal EAMs based on the quantum confined Stark effect are prime candidates for applications such as three-dimensional (3D) imaging systems [16, 39]. The development of an optical shutter using an EAM to obtain high resolution depth information in a time of flight based 3D imaging system was recently reported as shown in Figure 4 [16, 40]. Despite improving the modulation speed and depth, EAMs still have relatively narrow spectral bandwidth produced by the Fabry-Perot cavity. A narrow spectral bandwidth reduces the manufacturing tolerance of the 3D imaging system and the operating temperature range, because the bandgap and refractive index of a semiconductor material change as a function of the temperature. Thus, the EAM should be able to operate over a wide spectral bandwidth with high modulation depth in order to improve the reliability of 3D imaging systems. A thick absorption region results in wide spectral bandwidth of the EAM, but this results in a high operating voltage. To solve this issue, a coupled Fabry-Perot cavity structure used in band-pass filters [4143] allows the realization of a rectangular transmittance band, leading to a broad and flat spectrum for high transmittance. And the measured transmittances of the EAM for single-cavity and coupled microcavity structures are shown in Figures 5(a) and 5(b), respectively. Under zero bias, the spectral bandwidth of the coupled microcavity is about 8 nm, which is two times wider than that of the single-cavity structure. Furthermore, the transmittance change for the coupled microcavity EAM is comparable with that of the single-cavity structure. However to achieve 50% transmittance change in coupled microcavity structure, the pairs of QWs are increased, which result in high operating voltage. There is a tradeoff between transmittance contrast and operating voltage in EAM structure.

Another approach to broaden the spectral bandwidth is to use asymmetric tandem quantum wells (ATQWs). Whereas the above techniques use coupling of the electric field in a DBR structure under zero bias, ATQWs use coupling of light absorption in the active region under reverse bias. Figure 6 shows the contour plots and transmittance changes as a function of DBR pairs for a 7- single-cavity (SC) structure of 8 nm thick single quantum wells (SQWs) and 8/8.5 nm thick ATQWs. The transmittance of the EAM decreases under reverse bias because of absorption of the quantum well. As shown in Figure 6(d), there are two absorption resonances transmittance peaks under bias with ATQWs. It is noteworthy that the quantum wells with different thickness absorb broad wavelength. As a result, the spectral bandwidth of the transmittance change for a single cavity with ATQWs was improved in comparison with the single-cavity structure with SQWs.

4. Wide Stop Band of DBR

Normally DBRs consist of low index layers alternating with high index layers. The semiconductor DBRs are grown by molecular beam epitaxy or metal organic chemical vapor deposition equipment for single crystal quality. For high reflectivity, semiconductor DBR pairs must be repeated many times, in excess of 20 pairs, because of the low index contrast of the semiconductor DBR. Thickness control is thus an important parameter because it can change the spectral stop band and reflectivity. To address this, dielectric materials with high index contrast are used for a wide stop band of reflectivity. These dielectric DBRs demonstrate a wide stop band with high reflectivity using relatively few layers.

Figure 7 shows a-Si layers deposited on a Si substrate by an e-beam evaporator using inclined sample holders for tilted angle evaporation. The refractive index of the deposited film decreases as the oblique angle increases in the OAD process [44, 45]. First, a low index layer was deposited with a tilted angle. The nanocolumnar layers have a separate pattern, as shown in a cross-sectional scanning electron microscope (SEM) image. The interface between the low and high index layers is relatively good in terms of distinguishing the interface, as seen in the TEM image; hence, the refractive index of the layers was decreased in a controllable manner.

For comparison, the reflectivity values of DBRs with other general material systems were calculated, and the results are shown in Figure 8(a). The spectral bandwidth and reflectivity of a dielectric SiO2/TiO2 DBR () are broader and higher than those of a semiconductor GaAs/AlAs DBR (). In an a-Si/a-Si DBR () structure, almost 100% reflectivity was observed in a wavelength range from 1400 nm to 1800 nm, and good agreement between the calculated and measured results was observed. Figure 8(b) shows the reflectivity spectra of fabricated a-Si/a-Si DBRs as a function of the number of periods. A three-period a-Si/a-Si DBR was sufficient to ensure high reflectivity that exceeded 97%.

The reflective property of the 2′′ full-wafer a-Si/a-Si DBR with five periods was investigated experimentally [46]. The relative reflectivity mapping was measured at a center wavelength of 1550 nm (Figure 9(a)). There is only a small variation in the measured relative reflectivity with relatively uniform reflectivity over the full-wafer. The measured reflectivity of each position is marked in Figure 9(b) by spectrophotometry measurement. There was little difference in the measured reflectivity of each position. A wide stop band (800 nm) with only a five-period a-Si/a-Si DBR was achieved experimentally. Therefore, a-Si/a-Si DBR is practical and innovative for cost-effective optical components capable of high levels of reflection.

Recent innovations of one-dimensional and high-contrast gratings (HCG) as a surface-normal broadband reflector were reported. This grating provides a high contrast in the refractive indices for the grating medium and its surrounding materials. This HCG can replace conventional DBRs for VCSELs, as shown in Figure 10 [26, 28, 45, 4752], tunable VCSELs [47, 5355], and high- optical resonators [56]. Also, by removing the quantum wells and turning the device such that it is totally passive, all-pass filters can be constructed as phase tuners [57]. These tunable devices can be further fabricated via large scale photonic integration. By replacing the DBR with HCG, the manufacturing cost can be reduced due to thinner epitaxial layers and the microelectromechanical structure (MEMS) footprint also can be reduced, leading to a more compact structure and higher integration capability.

The design parameters for the structure include the indices of refraction of the high and low index materials, grating period, thickness, and duty cycle [25, 5860]. When the period of the grating becomes smaller than the incident wavelength, which is known as a subwavelength grating, only the zeroth diffraction order exists in the reflected and transmitted waves and all the higher diffraction orders are evanescent modes [58]. This subwavelength grating will basically operate as a simple mirror. When the reflective index of grating material has high contrast to surroundings, the high and broad reflectivity are possible [59]. The broad reflectivity can be optimized for one E-field orientation as shown in Figure 11. This characteristic of polarization control can be designed with simple HCG structure.

5. Summary

Recently developed techniques for wide spectral bandwidth that make it possible to realize multiple functionalities are reviewed. The flat-topped response of a RCEPD with a coupled cavity can reduce the channel crosstalk and is not sensitive to wavelength fluctuation in the transmitter or resonant control in the receiver in a WDM system. Meanwhile, an EAM with a coupled cavity as an optical shutter shows a wide transmittance spectrum without a bias state. Moreover, ATQWs that consist of quantum wells with different thickness coupling light absorption under reverse bias result in a wide transmittance change. These two structures help the EAM in 3D imaging systems which require operation with high reliability over a wide temperature range. To increase the reflectivity over a wide wavelength range, the use of high index contrast materials in tandem with oblique-angle deposition, which is independent of size, features, and substrate, will provide an interesting new method that may achieve improved performance in practical applications such as light emitting diodes, VCSELs, and photovoltaics. Also, by replacing the DBR with HCG, manufacturing costs can be reduced due to thinner epitaxial layers and the MEMS footprint can be reduced, leading to a more compact structure and higher integration capability. Furthermore an HCG could be a key component for producing devices that require particularly pure polarization characteristics. The reviewed approaches and design guidelines for wide spectral bandwidth in resonant cavity optoelectronic devices can be readily merged with a variety of other optoelectronic devices.

Conflict of Interests

The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.


This work was partly supported by the Center for Integrated Smart Sensors funded by the Ministry of Science, ICT & Future Planning as Global Frontier Project (CISS-2013M3A6A6073718) and by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Science, ICT & Future Planning (2014R1A1A1005945) and by BK21PLUS, Creative Human Resource Development Program for IT Convergence.