Analyzing the Synergy between HCI and TRIZ in Product Innovation through a Systematic Review of the Literature

Table 3

Approaches of the synergy of HCI and TRIZ supported in the considered proposals. Grouped by the three main design phases proposed by Michailidou et al., i.e., analysis (A), creation (C), and evaluation (E) as well as integration strategy by authors, i.e., merge-type (M), combine-type (C), and suggest-type (S).

Approaches	HCI					TRIZ				Phases (analysis, creation, and evaluation)	Type (merge, combine, and suggest)
	Interaction Pattern Libraries	Laws of Interaction Design	Usability	Interaction Paradigms	Contradiction Matrix	Inventive Principles	Ideal Final Result (IFR)	Trends	Effects Database
Design with intent (DWI) method [61]		✓							✓	C	S
Innovation-oriented ID approach [39]				✓			✓			A,C,E	M
Interaction trends of evolution (ITRE) [62]			✓					✓		A	C
User experience principles [63]	✓					✓				C	S
Interaction design guidelines (IDGLs) framework [12]			✓		✓					A, C	M
Multimodal interaction framework [64]			✓			✓				A, C	C
Interaction design-integrated method (IDIM) [65]			✓			✓				A,C,E	M
Integrating user information method [13]		✓			✓					A	C
Human-centered innovation process method [66]		✓			✓					C	C
Ergonomic product design model [67]			✓					✓		A, C	C