Microstructural Evolution in Materials during Thermal Processing
View this Special IssueResearch Article  Open Access
TEM Study of HighTemperature Precipitation of Delta Phase in Inconel 718 Alloy
Abstract
Inconel 718 is widely used because of its ability to retain strength at up to 650^{โ}C for long periods of time through coherent metastable Ni_{3}Nb precipitation associated with a smaller volume fraction of Ni_{3}Al precipitates. At very long ageing times at service temperature, decomposes to the stable Ni_{3}Nb phase. This latter phase is also present above the solvus and is used for grain control during forging of alloy 718. While most works available on precipitation have been performed at temperatures below the solvus, it appeared of interest to also investigate the case where phase precipitates directly from the fcc matrix free of precipitates. This was studied by Xray diffraction and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). TEM observations confirmed the presence of rotationordered domains in plates, and some unexpected contrast could be explained by double diffraction due to overlapping phases.
1. Introduction
Alloy 718 is the most widely used material for turbine disks and it is selected for many other applications as a highstrength material for temperatures up to 650ยฐC. This alloy was developed in the 60s when the former Febased superalloys evolved towards Nibased superalloys. Alloy 718 contains both Fe and Ni alloyed with some Al and Ti, though the most important addition is the refractory element Nb. A typical composition of alloy 718 is reported in Table 1. It contains a small amount of carbon as well as very low levels of other species such as Si, Ta, Mn, Cu, S, B, P, and Mg, not listed in Table 1 but generally controlled.
The strength of alloy 718 comes from coherent solidstate precipitates, which are for a small part Ni_{3}Al but mostly Ni_{3}Nb precipitates [1โ6]. Both of these precipitates are ordered forms of the fccA1 Nirich matrix: L1_{2} in the case of and DO_{22} in the case of . The solvus of these precipitates is at about 900โ920ยฐC as discussed previously [7]. Moreover, precipitates are metastable while the stable form of Ni_{3}Nb is the socalled delta phase which is orthorhombic. Forging of 718 alloy is done at about 980ยฐC slightly below the solvus of the delta phase, in such a way that this phase is sufficiently abundant to be effective in limiting grain growth but not too abundant to avoid significant Nb depletion in the matrix which would affect the subsequent strengthening by precipitation. This latter precipitation is generally obtained after two successive periods of isothermal ageing at 750ยฐC and 650ยฐC, respectively.
Precipitation of delta phase proceeds through a discontinuous reaction starting at grain boundaries and an intragranular precipitation of thin plates. It has been reported that the former reaction predominates at low temperatures whilst the latter is more characteristic of intermediate temperatures [2], but no systematic and quantitative study has been performed on that aspect. At high temperatures, both types of precipitates may be observed as illustrated in Figure 1.
In fully strengthened material, precipitation of delta has been studied for many years at both low and intermediate temperatures as it corresponds to a dramatic decrease of the mechanical properties of alloy 718. Kirman and Warrington [2] showed that the growth of at the expense of precipitates is often associated with the formation of faults within the . By means of dark field imaging, these authors observed that the faults are illuminated together with the related delta plate, and they concluded that the formation of these faults is the first step in the transformation of metastable to stable Ni_{3}Nb precipitates. These observations have been repeated more recently by Sundararaman et al. [10]. Further details on the faults appearing in precipitates have been previously presented by our group [11].
The only report of TEM examination of a material aged at a temperature above the solvus is due to Sundararaman et al. [10]. In a sample held at 950ยฐC, these authors observed only the presence of delta phase as expected but did not give any details and in particular no diffraction diagram was recorded. The present work was intended to pursue the investigation of the growth conditions of delta phase at high temperature. Xray diffraction results and TEM observations are reported.
2. Material and Methods
Two Inconel 718 alloys were used in this investigation, supplied, respectively, by Special Metals Corporation (denoted alloy 1 in the following) and by Aubert and Duval (denoted alloy 2). The amounts of the main elements in their composition are listed in Table 1, further details having been given previously [7, 9].
As described previously [9], alloy 1 in the asreceived state showed a microstructure very similar to that of a fully strengthened material, that is, some residual delta phase precipitates mainly at grain boundaries and a high volume fraction of small precipitates within the grains. Samples of this material were aged for various times at 960ยฐC or 920ยฐC and then air cooled. Alloy 2 was received in the fully strengthened state and the specimens studied here were aged for 3โh at 960ยฐC.
XRD profiles were all recorded on samples from alloy 1 using a diffractometer with CuK_{ฮฑ} radiation (โร ), with the power fixed at 4โkW (40โkV and 100โmA). The instrument was set up for BraggBrentano geometry with a line focus and a graphite monochromator in diffracted beam arm. During the scans ranged between 10 and 100ยฐ with an angular step of 0.025ยฐ and 30โs counting time at each step. As the volume fraction of the delta phase is low even after heattreatment, the precipitates were also electrolytically extracted from the heattreated specimens for Xray characterization. The solution used to dissolve the matrix consisted of 1โmL ammonium sulfate, 2โmL tartaric acid, and 97โmL water. The current was set at 100โmA/cm^{2} and the time for extraction was 5 to 6โh [12]. From the structural data reported in the literature for the phase [13], and listed in Table 2, an initial set of lattice parameters was obtained by leastsquare refinement using DICVOL software [14]. Then, structure refinement was carried out by Rietveld analysis of the Xray powder diffraction data with FullProf software [15]. An account of the mathematical procedures implemented in the Rietveld analysis [16] is summarized in the appendix.

For microstructural investigation by TEM, thin foils were prepared by cutting, mechanical thinning down to a thickness of about 50โฮผm, and jet polishing in a TenuPol5 at โ10ยฐC and a voltage of 22โV. The electrolyte was one part perchloric acid, two parts butylcellosolve, and nine parts methanol. The samples were investigated using either a Philips CM20 or a JEOL 2100F, both operating at an acceleration voltage of 200 kV.
3. Results
3.1. XRay Diffraction
Figure 2 shows the whole Xray diagram recorded on a sample of alloy 1 aged for 1โh at 960ยฐC. Through leastsquares refinement, the XRD pattern is fully indexed on a cubic lattice (fcc matrix) with unit cell parameter of 3.604โร and a orthorhombic lattice ( phase) with unit cell parameters โร , โร , and โร (volume โร ^{3}). All peaks in Figure 2 are indexed and there is no evidence of any other phase present, such as or .
For further exploitation of the Xray diagrams on bulk samples, the parameters of the delta phase were then evaluated from the Xray pattern acquired on the extracted precipitates. Figure 3 shows the experimental diagram for between 39ยฐ and 49ยฐ, in which the peak at 43.51ยฐ is associated to some remains of the matrix and/or the phase while all other peaks come from the delta phase. To optimally adjust all the delta phase intensities from the initial structural model [13], the atomic positions were refined by Rietveld's method. The refinement was constrained by the space group with its respective Wyckoffโs positions as given in Table 2. Then these atom positions were fixed to allow for the refinement of the site occupancies as a function of one of the following conditions:(A)Nb site occupancy fixed, the sum of the Ni site occupancies is equal to 1;(B)Nb site occupancy fixed, Ni site occupancies are independent;(C)the three site occupancies are independent.
Rietweld refinement gave similar results for all three conditions. The Xray diagram calculated for condition (A) was superimposed on the experimental diagram in Figure 3. The amount of remaining matrix was adjusted so that the height of the calculated peak at 43.51ยฐ corresponds to the experimental value. Similarly, the amount of delta phase was fixed so that the height of its most intense peak at 46.11ยฐ agrees with the experimental value. It is seen that most of the other peaks of the delta phase are well reproduced by calculation apart from the one at 42.99ยฐ which corresponds to the close packed (020) plane of delta phase. This is certainly related to the shape of the delta precipitates that are mainly thin discs grown in the (020) plane after heat treating for 1โh at 960ยฐC [9].
XRD profiles were then recorded on samples aged for various times and temperatures, thus showing various amounts of delta phase. It was found that the change of the parameters of the delta phase was not significant while the matrix parameter clearly proved to be affected. This is illustrated in Figure 4 which presents the (111) peak of the matrix for the three samples investigated. A significant shift is seen in the peak position from one sample to another which could certainly be related to alterations of the volume fraction of delta phase as evaluated by image analysis [9]. Rietveld refinement of the Xray diagrams was also performed to evaluate the volume fraction of delta precipitates in these samples. The structural model for condition (A) obtained from the precipitate extracted from the bulk specimen was used for this purpose. The data obtained are compared in Table 3 to image analysis results and both techniques give values in quite good agreement.

Finally, Figure 5 shows the lattice parameter of the matrix as a function of the volume fraction of delta phase and of the niobium content of the matrix, (at.%), that was evaluated considering that the delta phase is the binary stoichiometric Ni_{3}Nb phase. It is seen that the lattice parameter of the matrix decreases more or less linearly with increasing volume fraction of delta phase, that is, obeying a Vegard law such as: (ร ). The effect of Nb substitution on the fcc matrix agrees well with the value of 0.007โร (at.%)^{โ1} estimated from the data assessed by P. Nash and A. Nash for the binary NiNb system [17].
3.2. TEM Observation
It has been shown previously that nucleation of delta phase is difficult in a material free of precipitates [7]. We therefore investigated the first stage of delta phase growth by TEM. The first TEM observations were performed on a sample of alloy 1 aged for 1โh at 960ยฐC. A typical bright field micrograph showing a platelike precipitate is shown in Figure 6. Two areas labeled as 1 and 2 were selected for electron diffraction and the selected area diffraction (SAD) patterns corresponding to the , zone axis of the matrix were recorded.
The SAD patterns along the zone axis obtained on the matrix and on the precipitate in location 1 are shown in Figures 7(a) and 7(b). The pattern in Figure 7(b) was easily indexed as the one corresponding with the zone axis. The orientation relationship between the matrix and the phase is thus and . This relationship is the same as the one that has been reported after ageing at lower temperatures [18], and simply corresponds to the alignment of compact planes and dense directions in both structures. The SAD pattern obtained with the same conditions in location 2 is presented in Figure 7(c). The additional spots observed in this latter SAD pattern, arise from a mirror image of the pattern in Figure 7(b) with respect to the plane. These spots can also be indexed as belonging to a second variant of the phase with an orientation relationship to the matrix given by and . In fact, close observation of the pattern in Figure 7(b) also shows faint dots from this second variant.
(a)
(b)
(c)
A striking figure was obtained when looking at the SAD of the plate along the zone axis of the matrix. Figure 8(a) shows the pattern recorded on the matrix, Figures 8(b) and 8(c) show those obtained on the plate in locations 1 and 2, respectively. The presence of two variants is again observed in location 2, with one of them being as before the variant showing up in location 1. Astonishingly enough, the pattern in Figure 8(b) is indexed according to the metastable phase with the usual orientation relationship to the matrix: and . Apparently, this pattern cannot be directly related to the delta phase. In location 2, the pattern is thus apparently the superposition of two variants of the phase along the and zone axes, respectively.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Using the CaRIne Crystallography software [19] to simulate the SAD patterns, it was noticed that the reflections of are superimposed on the phase for and those of are superimposed on the phase for for both variants. These results suggest that the platelike precipitate may contain both phases, namely, and . Dark field images with spots seemed to indicate that this phase surrounds the plate. However, these images were not clear and it appeared necessary to resort to highresolution TEM (HRTEM) to decide whether that precipitation of delta from the gamma matrix involves an intermediate precipitate even at temperatures where it is not expected to appear.
This second part of the TEM investigation was carried out on a sample of alloy 2 aged for 3โh at 960ยฐC and then quenched. This sample thus contained phase that precipitated at the grain boundaries and in the grains, both in the form of plates. By selecting appropriate areas in the thin foil we successively studied the two phenomena illustrated in the plate observed in Figure 6: the existence of different variants of the ordered phases and the concomitant presence of and within the same precipitate.
Figure 9 shows TEM images of a platelet lying parallel to the plane and observed along the direction. In the lowmagnification image, Figure 9(a), different areas can be seen in the platelet, for example, those labeled and . The borders between these areas are shown with solid lines in Figure 9(a). A closer observation of this boundary is reported in Figure 9(b) showing lattice imaging of the different phases. Examination of these images and the corresponding Fourier transforms (obtained with ImageJ software [20]) indicated that the platelet is a coherent precipitate in the matrix, with the habit plane . The Fourier transform patterns showed that the areas labeled and correspond to different orientations of the orthorhombic phase along and , respectively. In the structure, the axis is rotated away from , so that the latter orientation relationship corresponds to and . The two areas observed in Figure 9 thus confirmed the existence of two variants of the phase in a given precipitate. Such variants have been previously reported by Zhang et al. [21] and described in terms of orientation twins or antiphase domain structures. Indeed the variants only differ by the orientation of the direction in the plane with respect to different directions of the plane.
(a)
(b)
Further HRTEM investigation of the same sample showed that the boundary between delta precipitates and the matrix could present unexpected contrast. This is illustrated in Figure 10 that was obtained along the zone axis of the matrix and shows the extremity of a precipitate. The interfaces between precipitate and matrix parallel to and planes are sharply defined and show ledges. The third interface shows a very different contrast with the occurrence of fringes parallel to the plane. These fringes repeat every six planes which recalls the stacking sequence of six compact planes in the phase (A_{1}B_{1}C_{1}A_{2}B_{2}C_{2} โฆ as described by Paulonis et al. [1]). Fourier transforms of the image in the different areas labeled a, b, and c in Figure 10 are shown in Figure 11. The first two correspond, respectively, to the SAD pattern of the matrix along zone axis and delta phase along zone axis, as shown by the schematic illustration of the indexation in Figure 11.
(a)
(b)
(c)
The third pattern, obtained by the Fourier transformation of the interfacial area c in Figure 10, cannot be indexed as a diffraction pattern of phase along the various possible directions (either or type) that would have been compatible with the orientation relation between and . In the corresponding schematic indexation, it is seen that the pattern consists of the superimposition of the two first patterns plus additional points.These points could in fact all be deduced by translations of or spots by a vector. Such a vector is given for instance by connecting and as illustrated in Figure 11(c). This corresponds to double diffraction phenomena and leads to the conclusion that the fringes observed are due to the superimposition of and phases. Such a superimposition and the associated fringes have been reported by Chen et al. [22] in TiAl alloys where the phases involved were the L1_{0}gamma and DO_{19}alpha phases.
This analysis allowed us to reconsider the interpretation of the SAD patterns presented in Figure 8. Indeed the orientation relationship between the matrix and the phase indicates that the direction is parallel to the direction. The corresponding diffraction patterns are shown in Figures 12(a) and 12(b), respectively. The superimposition of these two patterns which is given in Figure 12(c) shows that, when considering double diffraction (e.g., the arrows in Figure 12(c)), all the spots observed in Figure 8(b) could be explained solely by the presence of and phases. For completeness, we may remark that the diffraction pattern in Figure 8(c) is simply explained in the same way by the mirror symmetry about the plane, already noted in Figure 7.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Similar observations were conducted on specimens of the 718 alloy after different heat treatments. When extra spots were observed on SAD patterns they could always be explained by such double diffraction. Accordingly, it may be stated that was not present on the edges of the delta precipitates as could have been erroneously guessed from the SAD patterns in Figure 8.
4. Conclusion
The precipitation of phase at high temperature from a supersaturated matrix (i.e., without phase) was studied by XRD and TEM. Rietveld refinement proved to be very efficient to study precipitation. The volume fraction of precipitates was determined and allowed us to calculate the alterations occurring in the cell parameter with the amount of dissolved Nb. The results confirm the close correlation between precipitate growth kinetics and the evolution of the niobium content in the matrix. Detailed TEM studies of the platelets confirmed the existence of antiphase domains related by a rotation around the axis. Some diffraction contrast observed at the edges of delta precipitates could lead to the erroneous conclusion that delta phase grows through the formation of an intermediate phase. Examination of the Fourier transforms from the images showed that the contrast observed is due to a double diffraction phenomenon occurring when and phases overlap. The present investigations thus indicate that phase may grow directly from the supersaturated matrix.
Appendix
Considering the integrated intensity of the peaks to be a function of the refined structural parameters, a leastsquares procedure was used to minimize the difference between the observed and simulated powder diffraction patterns. The progress of the minimization was monitored through the usual reliability parameters, (weighted residual factor) and (expected residual factor) defined as: where () and () are the experimental and calculated intensities at angles, are weight factors, is the number of experimental observations, and is the number of refined parameters. Also, we used the socalled goodness of fit (GoF) factor given as Refinements were carried out until convergence was reached and the value of the GoF factor became close to 1 (usually, the final GoF varies from 1.1 to 1.3). The parameters that were refined using FullProf are the following:(i)background;(ii)unit cell parameters;(iii)breadth of peaks (a Pearson VII profile function was found to be best suited to fit the experimental peaks);(iv)scale factors (), which are related to the mass fraction () of the phase in the mixture by where is the number of formula units per unit cell for phase , is the mass of the formula unit, is the unit cell volume, and is the Brindley coefficient that accounts for microabsorption effects.Then, the volume fraction () of phase can be calculated from the mass fraction as: where is the density of phase .
Acknowledgment
The authors very much appreciated the possibility of using transmission electron microscopes at CEMES and TEMSCAN in Toulouse.
References
 D. F. Paulonis, J. M. Oblak, and D. S. Duvall, โPrecipitation in nickelbase alloy 718,โ Trans. ASM, vol. 62, no. 3, pp. 611โ622, 1969. View at: Google Scholar
 I. Kirman and D. H. Warrington, โThe precipitation of Ni3Nb phases in a NiFeCrNb alloy,โ Metallurgical Transactions, vol. 1, no. 10, pp. 2667โ2675, 1970. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 R. Cozar and A. Pineau, โMorphology of y' and y" precipitates and thermal stability of inconel 718 type alloys,โ Metallurgical Transactions, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 47โ59, 1973. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 J. M. Oblak, D. F. Paulonis, and D. S. Duvall, โCoherency strengthening in Ni base alloys hardened by DO22 γ′ precipitates,โ Metallurgical Transactions, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 143โ153, 1974. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 M. Sundararaman, P. Mukhopadhyay, and S. Banerjee, โSome aspects of the precipitation of metastable intermetallic phases in INCONEL 718,โ Metallurgical transactions. A, vol. 23, no. 7, pp. 2015โ2028, 1992. View at: Google Scholar
 C. Slama, C. Servant, and G. Cizeron, โAging of the Inconel 718 alloy between 500 and 750 °C,โ Journal of Materials Research, vol. 12, no. 9, pp. 2298โ2316, 1997. View at: Google Scholar
 A. Niang, B. Viguier, and J. Lacaze, โSome features of anisothermal solidstate transformations in alloy 718,โ Materials Characterization, vol. 61, no. 5, pp. 525โ534, 2010. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 L. Yang, K. M. Chang, S. Mannan, and J. D. Barbadillo, โSuperalloys 718, 625, 706 and various derivatives,โ in Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium on Superalloys 718, 625, 706 and Derivatives, E. A. Loria, Ed., pp. 353โ365, TMS, 1997. View at: Google Scholar
 V. Beaubois, J. Huez, S. Coste, O. Brucelle, and J. Lacaze, โShort term precipitation kinetics of delta phase in strain free Inconel* 718 alloy,โ Materials Science and Engineering, vol. 20, no. 8, pp. 1019โ1026, 2004. View at: Google Scholar
 M. Sundararaman, P. Mukhopadhyay, and S. Banerjee, โPrecipitation of the δNi3Nb phase in two nickel base superalloys,โ Metallurgical Transactions A, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 453โ465, 1988. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 A. Niang, J. Huez, J. Lacaze, and B. Viguier, โCharacterizing precipitation defects in nickel based 718 alloy,โ Materials Science Forum, vol. 636637, pp. 517โ522, 2010. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 R. B. Li, M. Yao, W. C. Liu, and X. C. He, โIsolation and determination for δ, γ′ and γ″ phases in Inconel 718 alloy,โ Scripta Materialia, vol. 46, no. 9, pp. 635โ638, 2002. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 T. Fang, S. J. Kennedy, L. Quan, and T. J. Hicks, โThe structure and paramagnetism of Ni3Nb,โ Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, vol. 4, no. 10, article no. 007, pp. 2405โ2414, 1992. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 A. Boultif and D. Loueer, โIndexing of powder diffraction patterns for lowsymmetry lattices by the successive dichotomy method,โ Journal of Applied Crystallography, vol. 24, no. 6, pp. 987โ993, 1991. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 J. RodriguezCarvajal, M. T. FernandezDiaz, and J. L. Martinez, โNeutron diffraction study on structural and magnetic properties of La 2NiO4,โ Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, vol. 3, no. 19, article no. 002, pp. 3215โ3234, 1991. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 H. M. Rietveld, โA profile refinement method for nuclear and magnetic structures,โ Journal of Applied Crystallography, vol. 2, p. 65, 1969. View at: Google Scholar
 P. Nash and A. Nash, โThe NbNi (NiobiumNickel) system,โ Bulletin of Alloy Phase Diagrams, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 124โ130, 1986. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 I. Kirman, โPrecipitation in the FeNiCrNb system,โ Journal of the Iron and Steel Institute, vol. 12, pp. 1612โ1618, 1969. View at: Google Scholar
 C. Boudias and D. Monceau, โCaRine Crystallography,โ (1989–2003), http://pro.wanadoo.fr/carine.crystallography/. View at: Google Scholar
 http://imagej.nih.gov/.
 J. P. Zhang, H. Q. Ye, K. H. Kuo, and S. Amelinckx, โHighresolution electron microscopy study of the domain structure in Ni//3Nb. II. Orientation and general domains,โ Physica Status Solidi (A), vol. 93, no. 2, pp. 457โ462, 1986. View at: Google Scholar
 C. L. Chen, W. Lu, Y. Y. Cui, L. L. He, and H. Q. Ye, โHighresolution image simulation of overlap structures in TiAl alloy,โ Journal of Alloys and Compounds, vol. 468, no. 12, pp. 179โ186, 2009. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
Copyright
Copyright © 2011 Moukrane Dehmas et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.