Review Article | Open Access
Ilaria Gamba, "Biomimetic Approach to CO2 Reduction", Bioinorganic Chemistry and Applications, vol. 2018, Article ID 2379141, 14 pages, 2018. https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/2379141
Biomimetic Approach to CO2 Reduction
The development of artificial photosynthetic technologies able to produce solar-fuels from CO2 reduction is a fundamental task that requires the employment of specific catalysts being accomplished. Besides, effective catalysts are also demanded to capture atmospheric CO2, mitigating the effects of its constantly increasing emission. Biomimetic transition metal complexes are considered ideal platforms to develop efficient and selective catalysts to be implemented in electrocatalytic and photocatalytic devices. These catalysts, designed according to the inspiration provided by nature, are simple synthetic molecular systems capable of mimic features of the enzymatic activity. The present review aims to focus the attention on the mechanistic and structural aspects highlighted to be necessary to promote a proper catalytic activity. The determination of these characteristics is of interest both for clarifying aspects of the catalytic cycle of natural enzymes that are still unknown and for developing synthetic molecular catalysts that can readily be applied to artificial photosynthetic devices.
The employment of devices based on artificial photosynthetic technologies may be the most convincing strategy for generating enough clean energy to satisfy the needs of the expanding world [1, 2]. However, the development of such devices is not an easy task. Different fundamental components, each one committed to a specific function, must be matched together to mimic the ultimate functionality of the natural photosynthetic apparatus . Thus, inspired by natural photosynthesis, the crucial components of an artificial photosynthetic device should be a light harvester for the absorption of sunlight and the generation of charge-separation (e.g., semiconductor or molecular dye) and a reduction active reaction site and an oxidation active reaction site, where the redox processes occur . Such a design is represented by the so called “hybrid photocatalytic” devices, in which semiconductors are employed as light harvesters and transition metal complexes as molecular catalysts to assist specific redox reactions: the carbon dioxide reduction and the water oxidation [5–7]. Indeed, the setting exploited for hybrid photocatalytic devices presents significant advantages. The use of semiconductors as light harvesters, in fact, ensures a broad spectral absorption associated with a good robustness of the materials. Also, the involvement of specific transition metal complexes as catalysts assists and facilitates both the occurrence of redox reactions and the generation of charge separation through fast charge transfers between the semiconductor and the molecular complexes. In particular, the coupling between semiconductors and biomimetic complexes (i.e., hydrogenase, formate dehydrogenases, and carbon monoxide dehydrogenases mimics) may reveal to be an efficient strategy for aiding the CO2 reduction, improving the current solar fuel technologies and stimulating the applications of these devices.
Besides the development of artificial photosynthetic devices, aimed to stimulate “solar fuels” production, the investigation focused on the activation and conversion of CO2 is also of main interest to improve the strategies nowadays used for the treatment of its constantly increasing emissions . Indeed, the rising of CO2 emissions has led to serious greenhouse effects and global warming, facing the necessity to adopt CO2 conversion technologies, able to transform this greenhouse gas into value-added products, to ensure an equilibrate global carbon cycle, and to mitigate the global warming through the reduction of atmospheric CO2 .
However, the CO2 activation, reduction, or conversion is not easy to accomplish. CO2 is a thermodynamically stable molecule and kinetically inert. Indeed, the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction demands high over-potentials to occur and results in poor selectivity of product formation (mixtures of CO and formate are generally obtained). Furthermore, CO2 reduction is typically characterized by low faradaic efficiency due to the competition with the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), which takes place at the same range of potentials . In this context, the development of novel, specific, and efficient catalysts to perform CO2 activation, reduction, or conversion is nowadays a major challenge to be faced. Transition metal compounds can be used as ideal platform to realize these tasks, both considering homogeneous and heterogeneous (thus, associated to an electrode) applications [11–14].
The present review aims to focus the attention on the progresses achieved employing transition metal complexes, designed according to the inspiration devoted to the bioinorganic approach, as catalysts to promote carbon dioxide (CO2) two-electron reduction. Furthermore, the active site structures and the mechanistic features associated with the CO2 reduction activities of natural enzymatic systems (in particular carbon monoxide dehydrogenases, CODH, and formate dehydrogenases, FDH, and enzymes) are herein described, with the aim of highlighting fundamental principles of their efficient catalytic activity. These aspects are of main importance to inspire the design of simple synthetic molecular systems able to reproduce the enzymes functionality.
Moreover, the development of electrocatalysts, able to perform the two-electron reduction of CO2 to CO and/or formate, closely related to the enzymatic activity, are here listed. Particular attention is paid to the description of proposed reaction mechanisms and the general structural features that can dictate the selectivity of the products generated from CO2 reduction. On the other hand, photoelectrocatalytic systems, which represent attractive alternatives to develop efficient catalysts, [12, 15], were not included in the present discussion.
2. CO2 Activation and Reduction by Enzymes and Transition Metal Complexes
Nature is widely known to be a source of efficient catalysts: the enzymes and metalloenzymes, which are natural machines that can be esteemed for performing extremely difficult chemical processes with elegant selectivity, fast rates, and low activation energies. Furthermore, metalloenzymes present the advantage of being constructed exclusively from copious bioavailable materials and typically employ only metals abundant in the Earth’s crust, such as first row transition metals [16, 17].
However, when considering applications that require sustainability and scalability, enzymes have the major drawback of being quite unstable and work normally only over the limited range of conditions in which the proteins remain correctly folded. Thus, they are not suitable for use directly in all applications, especially when compared to synthetic compounds that can mimic enzymes structure and functionality. All in all, if not directly considered for applications, enzymes serve as inspiration to discover fundamental principles of fast catalysis that can be executed by simple synthetic molecules. In particular, the enzymes that have inspired the development of biomimetic synthetic catalysts for CO2 reduction are the carbon monoxide dehydrogenases and the formate dehydrogenases [18, 19].
Key structural and mechanistic features related to these enzymes are herein summarized in the following paragraphs, included in the section dedicated to “carbon dioxide reduction enzymes.”
3. Carbon Dioxide Reduction Enzymes
3.1. Carbon Monoxide Dehydrogenases (CODHs)
There are two types of known carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) enzymes, which are the MoCu-CODHs and the Ni-CODHs, respectively, characterized by different metals (MoCu or Ni) contained in their active sites . Both enzymes are able to catalyze the oxidation of CO to CO2, albeit Ni-CODHs upkeep the process at much higher turnover frequencies (kcat values: 4 × 104 s−1) than MoCu-CODHs (100 s−1). Under certain circumstances, CO2 reduction activity has also been observed in case of Ni-CODHs (although with lower turnover frequencies compared to CO oxidation, approximately 45 s−1) but never detected to date for MoCu-CODHs [20, 21].
Structural and mechanistic aspects, related in particular to Ni-CODHs, are of main interests also for the development of synthetic catalysts. However, the extreme sensitivity of Ni-CODHs to the presence of dioxygen (indeed, they are found only in anaerobic bacteria) made difficult mechanistic investigation and structural study. In fact, organisms growth, purification, and all manipulation related to these enzymes require definitely strictly anaerobic and often low temperature conditions . Despite these difficulties, the X-ray structures of five Ni−CODHs have been solved to date [23–33], clearly showing the presence of different types of metal clusters: [NiFe3S4], called the C-clusters, and [Fe4S4], called B- and D-clusters . The reversible CO/CO2 conversion is believed to occur at the C-clusters [22, 34, 35], whereas the B- and D-cluster would be part of the electrons-transporting chain of the protein system. The structure of these C-clusters can be described as a distorted [Fe4S4] cluster with a nickel atom replacing one of the iron atoms and an iron atom pendent to the cluster, called the “dangling iron” (Figure 1). The metal atoms, which coordinate to cysteine residues and inorganic sulfide ligands are ordinated in a cubane structure, like the one described for [Fe4S4] clusters. The dangling iron of the [NiFe3S4] clusters is coordinated by a cysteine and a sulfide ligand of the cubane structure and by a histidine and a hydroxyl ligands (Figure 1) .
Four distinct oxidation states of the C-cluster were identified on the basis of spectroscopic studies: Cox, Cred1, Cint, and Cred2. Cox (Ni2+, Fe3+) is an oxidized state of the cluster considered inactive. Cred1 (Ni2+, Fe2+) and Cred2 (Ni0, Fe2+), which have one and three electrons more reduced than Cox, respectively, are proposed to be the active states of the enzyme, directly involved in the catalytic cycle of reversible CO/CO2 conversion. Finally, Cint (Ni+, Fe2+) is described as the intermediate state between Cred1 and Cred2, thus, two electrons less than Cox, and it seems to be an inactive state as well as Cox .
The catalytic mechanism proposed, for the reversible CO/CO2 conversion assisted by Ni−CODHs, suggests that the reaction site should be located between the Ni atom and the dangling Fe atom. Thus, during the first step of CO oxidation (as depicted in Figure 2), the Ni atom is the center responsible for the initial CO binding, when the cluster is in the Cred1 state. Upon CO binding, the C-cluster undergoes reduction to the Cred2 state and then transfers the electrons through the B- and D-clusters in the enzyme, generating the intermediate Cred1-CO state. Afterwards, the hydroxyl group, which is coordinated to the dangling Fe atom, attacks the bounded CO molecule at the carbon atom, leading to the Cred1-CO2 form. At this stage, upon binding of water, a CO2 molecule and a proton are released, reducing the C-cluster at the Cred2. The C-cluster starting state, Cred1, is recovered upon oxidation of Cred2 mediated by the B- and D-clusters. Finally, the presence of a histidine residue located in the protein near to the C-cluster is proposed to facilitate the transfer of protons during the reaction and stabilize the intermediate steps providing hydrogen bonds to the coordinated CO and CO2.
3.2. Formate Dehydrogenase (FDH)
The metal-dependent formate dehydrogenase (FDHs) enzymes are able to reversibly catalyze the two-electron reduction of CO2 to formate. Between different classes of known FDH enzymes, the NAD+-independent FDHs are the ones recognized as responsible for CO2 reduction reaction. Like the Ni-CODHs, the NAD+-independent FDHs are also extremely sensitive to atmospheric dioxygen, and their manipulation also requires strictly anaerobic conditions. The structures of several of these enzymes were resolved (by a combination of both X-ray crystallographic and EXAFS measurements) and show the presence in their active sites of molybdenum or tungsten atoms, displaying common active sites architecture . According to these data, the reaction site can be described by Mo (or W) center in a trigonal-bipyramidal geometry coordinated by two pyranopterins, one Se-cysteine residue, and one sulfido ligand (Figure 3).
The mechanism proposed for the FDH-catalyzed formate reversible oxidation is currently still under discussion. In case of Mo-FDHs, the Mo atom contained in the active site would assume during the catalytic cycle the Mo(VI), Mo(V), and Mo(IV) formal oxidation states, also supported by the contribution of the redox noninnocent ligand pyranopterin. In this scenario, the Mo(VI) state is responsible for formate oxidation and the Mo(IV) state is used for CO2 reduction . Early attempts to propose a reaction mechanism envisioned the possibility of generating of a vacant coordination site, meant for formate binding, upon Se-cysteine dissociation (Figure 4). Thus, initially formate binds at the Mo(VI) center (oxidized form) in the vacant site generated by the released of the Se-cysteine. Subsequently, the α proton of the formate is removed, probably by the nearby selenide anion. Reduction of the Mo(VI) to the Mo(IV) state is finally associated with CO2 release. The catalytic cycle closes with the regeneration of the initial Mo(VI) state, upon two-electron oxidation of the reduced Mo(IV) form (electrons are transferred from Mo(IV) via a [4Fe–4S] cluster center to an external electron acceptor) and deprotonation of the Se atom that recover its coordination at the metal center .
More recently, Reisner and Hirst have suggested a mechanistic proposal supporting that the formate oxidation occurs through a five-membered transition state. In this scenario, formate coordinate to the Mo(VI) by its oxygen lone pairs and then, upon formate oxidation, CO2 and Mo(IV)-SH products are generated. The five-membered transition intermediate can either undergo proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) reaction or as a hydride-transfer (HT) reaction (Figure 5, mechanism B) .
Besides these formulations that picture the dissociation of the Se-cysteine ligand, a scenario, in which the saturated coordination environment at the Mo atom is preserved, has been also considered [39, 40]. In this latter case, the direct hydride transfer of the formate α-hydrogen to the terminal sulfido group of the Mo(VI)=S moiety, without substrate binding at the metal, is proposed (Figure 5, mechanism C) .
4. Carbon Dioxide Reduction Mediated by Synthetic Catalysts
4.1. CO2 Coordination Modes at Metal Centers
The transformation of carbon dioxide mediated by transition metal catalysts is a research area that is captivating the attention of the scientific community [11, 41, 42]. Diverse products, including CO, formate, methanol, and methane, can be derived from CO2 reduction catalyzed by transition metal complexes. In this context, a recent review published by Grice details and collects the more recent achievements in the field of CO2 reduction with homogeneous early transition metal complexes (group 3–7). The review focuses the attention on the stoichiometric and catalytic reductions to formate, methanol, and similar products, which have been more frequently observed when early transition metal complexes are employed as catalysts . Besides this report, several publications recently appear highlighting the opportunities to take advantage of transition metal complexes to reduce CO2 and to convert it in value-added products [43–47]. For most of these transformations, the CO2 activation and reduction is initiated by its coordination at a metal center.
The regulation of the CO2 binding mode at metal complexes is of major importance for the development of catalysts that can selectively reduce CO2, because it can dictate the distribution of the reaction products [45, 48, 49]. In this regard, a recent reevaluation of known CO2-metal complex adducts displays the presence of several binding modes, allowing their complete and accurate classification, as well as the rationalization of the oxidation states assumed by carbon and metal atoms involved in the CO2 binding .
The possible CO2 metal binding modes are categorized according to the number of directly bonded metal centers and depending on the connectivity (how the atoms are attached to one another). The principal adducts derived from the simplest CO2 monometallic complexes are summarized in Figure 6.
At a mononuclear transition metal center, CO2 can either coordinate through the C or the O atom, where ηO exhibits a richer variety of coordination possibilities than the ηC, including η1 and η2-(C,O) side-on binding fashions.
The η1-binding mode is represented by the coordination of one of the CO2 oxygen atom at the metal center. Different types of η1-binding modes can be distinguished depending on the kind of interaction that determines the nature of the binding. On the basis of these data, it is possible to define the existence of η1- , η1- , and η1-  adducts. In case of η1- , CO2 datively bound through one of its oxygen atoms to the metal centers. η1-  adducts are characterized by metal-O interaction of electrostatic nature, involving the positively charged metal and the induced negative quadrupole moments at the CO2 oxygen atom. Finally, η1-  adducts represent the patterns in which the binding situation is better described by the interaction developed between the one-electron oxidize metal center and the reduced CO2− ligand, where the metal would have a positive charge and a negative charge would be located at the non-coordinated oxygen atom. The radical carbon would form a double bond to the datively coordinated oxygen atom (Figure 6).
Besides, the CO2 binding mode of η2-(C,O) side-on adducts can be described by two limiting situations: one in which CO2 binds by π-donation to the metal, identified as η2-(C,O) , and another in which the bound order of the double C=O bond is reduced as results of the π-back donation of the metal center, with concomitant formation of metal-C and metal-O bonds, recognized as η2-(C,O)  (Figure 6).
Cases in which the CO2 binding is shared between two, three, or four metal atoms result in an even wider variety of interaction types. A detailed description of these situations can be found in the recent review published by Paparo and Okuda .
4.2. Structural Models of CODHs
Attempts to mimic the Ni-CODH active sites have been focused either on the preparation of monometallic Ni and heterobimetallic Ni-Fe complexes or on the construction of [NiFe3S4] clusters.
Few examples appear in the literature describing mononuclear Ni-CO2η2-adducts, which present spectroscopic characteristics in close relation to the Ni center of the C-cluster found in Ni-CODHs enzymes. The first structurally characterized Ni-CO2η2-adduct, ((PCy3)2Ni(η2-CO2)), was reported in 1975 by Aresta and co-workers, [51, 52], followed by the more recent example presented by Hillhouse, the (dtbpe)Ni(η2-CO2) (dtbpe = 1,2-bis(di-tert-butylphosphino)ethane) adduct  (Figures 7(a) and 7(b)). Both the compounds are based on tetracoordinated nickel centers, with two phosphorus donor atoms and one η2-CO2 ligand.
More recently, another interesting Ni-CO2η2-adduct was structurally characterized by Lee et al., the (PPMeP)Ni(η2-CO2) adduct (where PPMeP is the PMe[2-PiPr2-C6H4]2 ligand, Figure 7(c)) . In this latter case, the Ni center is 5-coordinated by three phosphorus donor atoms and one CO2 ligand in a η2-binding mode. Besides the same group, taking advantage of the similar but anionic PNP ligand (PNP− = -N[2-PiPr2-4-Me-C6H3]2) reported the synthesis and characterization of novel nickel-carboxylate adducts. The carboxylate ligand, at the Ni center of these compounds, is stabilized by Lewis acids, such as a proton (nickel hydroxycarbonyl, (PNP)NiCOOH), sodium (nickel sodium carboxylate, (PNP)NiCOONa), or another metal ion.
Using this strategy, also a dinuclear nickel-iron carboxylate species, (PNP)Ni-μ-CO2-κC:κ2O,O′-Fe(PNP), was prepared and characterized . This latter complex represents the first example of nickel-iron hetero-bimetallic complex equipped with a bridging CO2 ligand, structurally reminiscent of the NiFe-binuclear active site of CODH enzymes.
In parallel to these studies, the synthetic effort spent for mimicking the unique [NiFe3S4] core structure resulted in the biomimetic compounds reported by Holm and coworkers, which represent the closest synthetic analogues of the C-cluster found in anaerobic CODHs [55, 57–59]. The approach used satisfies fundamental structural requirements of the CODHs-active site modeling, as the incorporation of a Ni atom at the apex of an iron-sulfur cubane . Also, rational synthetic modifications forced the planarization of the tetrahedral nickel center, upon breaking of one Ni-S bond, attaining square planar Ni(II) in a Ni-Fe-S cubanoid cluster, as owned by the enzyme (Figure 7(d)) [55, 58]. Unfortunately, the presence of a pending iron atom in a synthetic complex was not ever realized. Neither of these compounds, however, was found able of promoting CO2 reduction or CO oxidation activities.
4.3. Functional Models for CODHs: Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to CO Mediated by Molecular Complexes
A great research effort was dedicated to the development of molecular catalysts able to act as CODHs functional models. The transformation of CO2 in solution and in particular its reduction to CO through the assistance the of transition metal complexes as electrocatalysts have been comprehensively studied and reviewed [42, 45, 60–65]. These compounds have no structural relation with the active site of the CODHs and cannot be considered structural mimics of these enzymes. However, metal electrocatalysts can reproduce the CODHs activity of CO2 reduction to CO, thus resulting in fundamental interests to elucidate aspects of the catalytic mechanism of these enzymes that are still unknown.
In this context, the catalytic model systems more closely related to the CODHs activity are herein described by detailing in the following paragraphs the most representative examples of transition metal compounds based on phosphine or macrocyclic ligands.
4.3.1. Transition Metal Complexes Bearing Phosphine Ligands
Transition metal phosphine complexes have crucially contributed to the understanding of the possible intermediates involved in the CO2 reduction reactions. In this context, palladium complexes bearing polydentate phosphine ligands, of the type [Pd(triphosphine)(solvent)]2+, represent the most extensively studied catalysts for the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction.
As represented in Figure 8, the proposed catalytic mechanism began with the Pd(II) (1) electrochemical reduction to Pd(I) (2), performing the reaction in DMF and in presence of acid. Following this initial reduction, CO2 coordinate at the Pd(I) center and the metal-carboxylate intermediate (3) is generated upon oxidation of Pd(I) to Pd(II). Subsequent protonation of the carboxylate ligand affords a metallocarboxylic acid intermediate (4). The second electroreduction of Pd(II) to Pd(I) (5) causes the release of the coordinated solvent molecule (6). Then, additional protonation of the carboxylic acid ligand allows the formation of ‘‘dihydroxy carbene’’ intermediate (7). CO would be generated at this intermediate, by dehydration of the dihydroxy carbene species with concomitant oxidation of Pd(I) to Pd(II) (8). The regeneration of the initial catalysts is achieved by solvent coordination and CO release.
The catalytic current observed was found to depend on the acid concentration and the pH dependence observed is consistent with two protonation steps being involved in the transition state .
These studies have highlighted the importance of having a weakly bounded molecule coordinated at the metal center in order to develop a proper catalytic activity. Thus, a vacant coordination site would be required for the reaction to occur. In particular, the production of CO from CO2, which involves the cleavage of a C-O bond, would be favored by the presence of a vacant coordination site adjacent to the dihydroxy carbene ligand. This specific structural characteristic allows the formation of a metal-O bond upon cleavage of the C-O bond, resulting in the formal migration of a water molecule as depicted in Figures 8 and 9.
The requisite of having a vacant coordination site at a specific position to the CO2-bounded ligand, featured in case of these transition metal catalysts, can be found also of biological importance to enlighten aspects of the catalytic mechanism proposed for natural enzymes.
On the other hand, inspired by the bimetallic active site of CODHs, dinuclear analogues of such mononuclear [Pd(triphosphine)(solvent)]2+ complexes were designed, with the aim of enhancing the CO2-binding properties through the creation of a bifunctional active site . The activity of homobimetallic catalysts was found much improved compared to their monometallic analogues. However, rapid formation of a Pd-Pd bond inactivates the catalyst, resulting in a relatively low TON. Such an inactivation step is prevented in the native Ni-Fe CODH enzymes due to the difference in redox potentials of Ni and Fe centers, which results in a slight tendency to promote metal-metal bound formation.
4.3.2. Transition Metal Complexes Bearing Macrocyclic Ligands
(1) N4-Macrocyclic Ligands. The first report about N4-macrocyclic transition metal catalysts, which efficiently performed the electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO, appeared in 1980 was published by Eisenberg (Figure 10) .
In this work, cobalt and nickel N4-macrocyclic complexes were demonstrated to be able to reduce CO2 to CO, albeit at high overpotentials (ranging from −1.3 to −1.6 V versus SCE). Furthermore, at such potentials, these systems suffer the competing production of molecular hydrogen.
More recently, Sauvage and coworkers have extensively studied the reduction of CO2 mediated by Ni-cyclam (cyclam = 1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane) complexes (Figure 11) [48, 72]. Interestingly, CO2 reduction catalyzed by Ni-cyclam complexes, performed in water, leads exclusively to the formation of CO as product. Whereas, using mercury electrodes, CO2 conversion mediated by transition metal complexes displays normally the formation of CO together with formate and oxalate as common products . Furthermore, CO2 reduction catalyzed by Ni-cyclam complexes, performed in water-DMF (dimethylformamide) mixture, leads to the formation of both CO and formate in different ratio depending on the reduction potential applied.
[Ni(cyclam)]+ generated by one-electron reduction from [Ni(cyclam)]2+ is the species responsible for the initial CO2 binding and the active species of the catalytic cycle. The mechanism proposed envisions that the CO2 reduction likely proceeds through an inner-sphere electron transfer mechanism. The formation of an adduct, upon CO2 coordination to the catalyst, should represent the initial step of the catalytic cycle. However, [Ni(CO2)(cyclam)]+ has never been trapped at sufficiently high concentration to be fully spectroscopically characterized.
In early study by Collin, it was suggested that CO2 can actually bind to [Ni(cyclam)]+ through three possible coordination modes, in equilibrium between each others.
The reaction pathway followed after the formation of the initial CO2 adduct would be dictated by the adopted binding mode. Thus, upon uptake of an electron and a proton, η1-CO2 species yield to a carboxylate intermediate, [Ni(C(O)OH)(cyclam)]+, that subsequently undergoes heterolytic C−O bond cleavage to generate CO in the presence of a proton. Instead, the η1-OCO complexes evolve into nickel-formate species, [Ni(OCOH)(cyclam)]+.
The selectivity for CO generation observed in case of the reaction mediated in water by Ni(cyclam) catalysts was recently elegantly explained by the aid of computational calculations. The formation of η1-CO2 adducts was indeed found energetically favored by 14 kcal/mol compare to η1-OCO. Thus, under the studied conditions, the reaction pathway proposed to result in formate generation would be blocked .
(2) Porphyrin Ligands. A remarkable example of macrocyclic metal complex employed as CO2 reduction catalysts is represented by the iron porphyrin FeTDHPP complex, where TDHPP is the 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(2′,6″-dihydroxylphenyl)-porphyrin ligand (Figure 12(a)). FeTDHPP was reported to catalyze the CO2 reduction to CO, in acidic dimethylformamide (DMF) solutions, with modest overpotential of less than 0.5 V and 90% faradaic yield for CO production through 50 million turnovers over 4 hours (3500 s−1) . The authors suggested that this notable activity could be due to the presence of pendant hydroxyl group that assists the cleavage of the C-O bond by either favoring the proton transfer to the CO2 bounded at the metal center or stabilizing the Fe-CO2 adduct by hydrogen bounding.
Inspired by the Ni-Fe containing metalloenzymes, cofacial Fe(0) tetraphenyl porphyrin dimers and ortho- and meta-Fe2DTPP (Figure 12(b)) were also reported [13, 78]. These compounds were demonstrated to be effective catalysts for CO2 electroreduction. The catalysts exhibited excellent selectivity for CO generation and improved faradaic yield (95%) and turnover frequencies (4300 s−1), at a moderate overpotential (0.66 V).
The electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 mediated by the cobalt complex produces CO with high efficiency and selectivity. On the other hand, the process mediated by the Fe complex generates mainly formic acid.
The mechanisms proposed for the two different reaction pathways are depicted in Figure 14.
The authors suggested that the selectivity of products formation through the two-electron reduction of CO2, CO, or HCOOH could be attributed to distinct protonation and reduction steps for the reactions mediated by cobalt or iron, respectively. The breaking of the C-O bond would be favored at the cobalt-based catalysts (Figure 14(a)), whereas the iron-based catalysts support the formation of a η1-OCOH intermediate, which would evolve into formic acid release upon protonation (Figure 14(b)).
4.4. Functional Models for FDHs: Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to Formate Mediated by Molecular Complexes
Homogeneous transition metal catalysts were certainly found able to reduce CO2 to formate through diverse reaction pathways; for example, as previously mentioned, η1-OCOH or η1-OCO intermediates upon protonation would evolve into formic acid or formate release, respectively. In particular, the electrocatalytic systems more closely related to the activity of FDH enzymes actuate the CO2 reduction to formate following mechanistic paths that involve the CO2 insertion into a metal-H bond.
An important breakthrough in the field of functional FDH enzymes modeling came in 1981, when Darensbourg et al. reported that anionic metal hydrides react readily with CO2 to generate metal-formate species . The research of Darensbourg and coworkers showed for the first time that CO2 can be inserted into a Ni-H bond of a nickel-triphosphine complex, the trans-[(H)2Ni(PCy3)2], to generate trans-[(H)(HCO2)Ni(PCy3)2] species .
The presence of two adjacent sites, one destined to coordinate a hydride ligand and the second for CO2 binding, likely facilitate C-H bond formation and subsequent formate production, as depicted in Figure 15 .
Since the finding by Darensbourg and coworkers, numerous research groups have studied this reaction mediated by transition metal catalysts (especially employing late transition metal as Ru, Rh, Ir, Ni, and Pd).
On the basis of these studies, it was highlighted that the insertion of CO2 into the M-H bond could actually occur following two possible pathways.
Thus, CO2 can either coordinate in a η2-fashion to the metal center and receive the migration of the hydride ligand at the carbon atom or develop a weak H···CO2 interaction, which leads to M-H bond cleavage and formate generation (Figures 16 and 17) .
The former mechanistic path is the generally accepted (Figure 16 and Intermediate A in Figure 17) , while the latter alternative (Intermediate B, Figure 17) has been supported essentially by theoretical studies [83–85].
The addition of a base to generate formate salt (as highlighted in Figure 16) is aimed at facilitating the catalysts regeneration. In fact, precipitation of formate salts allowed the easy separation of products and catalysts.
5. Final Remarks
The design of biomimetic transition metal complexes can decisively contributed to elucidate aspects that concern enzymes structure and reactivity. The statement of both the structural and functional characteristics, mandatory to develop a proper enzymatic activity, is critical from a fundamental point of view and may result in key-importance for the construction of synthetic catalysts employable for industrial applications.
As product of this mutual convenience, efficient transition metal catalysts and electrocatalysts, mimicking the enzymatic CO2 two-electrons reduction to CO and/or formate, have been developed, and the more significant related examples are reviewed herein. Special emphasis is given to define the structural characteristics that have been highlighted to be compulsory for achieving a fruitful catalytic activity. The development of novel compounds that satisfy these features can lead to their readily application for electrocatalytic devices and to a better understanding of the mechanism of action of both natural and synthetic systems.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest.
- P. A. Owusu, S. Asumadu-Sarkodie, P. Ameyo, and S. Dubey, “A review of Ghana’s water resource management and the future prospect,” Cogent Engineering, vol. 3, no. 1, p. 1167990, 2016.
- S. Sorrell, “Reducing energy demand: a review of issues, challenges and approaches,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 47, pp. 74–82, 2015.
- G. O. Larrazábal, A. J. Martín, and J. Pérez-Ramírez, “Building blocks for high performance in electrocatalytic CO2 reduction: materials, optimization strategies, and device engineering,” Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, vol. 8, no. 16, pp. 3933–3944, 2017.
- J. Barber, “Photosynthetic energy conversion: natural and artificial,” Chemical Society Reviews, vol. 38, no. 1, pp. 185–196, 2009.
- F. Wen and C. Li, “Hybrid artificial photosynthetic systems comprising semiconductors as light harvesters and biomimetic complexes as molecular cocatalysts,” Accounts of Chemical Research, vol. 46, no. 11, pp. 2355–2364, 2013.
- C. Liu, B. C. Colón, M. Ziesack, P. A. Silver, and D. G. Nocera, “Water splitting–biosynthetic system with CO2 reduction efficiencies exceeding photosynthesis,” Science, vol. 352, no. 6290, pp. 1210–1213, 2016.
- P. D. Tran, L. H. Wong, J. Barber, and J. S. C. Loo, “Recent advances in hybrid photocatalysts for solar fuel production,” Energy and Environmental Science, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 5902–5918, 2012.
- D. C. Thomas, “Carbon dioxide mitigation: a challenge for the twenty-first century,” in Carbon Management: Implications for R&D in the Chemical Sciences and Technology: A Workshop Report to the Chemical Sciences Roundtable, pp. 33–43, N.R.C.U.C.S. Roundtable, National Academies Press (US), Washington, DC, USA, 2001.
- T. R. Anderson, E. Hawkins, and P. D. Jones, “CO2, the greenhouse effect and global warming: from the pioneering work of Arrhenius and Callendar to today’s Earth System Models,” Endeavour, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 178–187, 2016.
- R. Kortlever, J. Shen, K. J. P. Schouten, F. Calle-Vallejo, and M. T. M. Koper, “Catalysts and reaction pathways for the electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide,” Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, vol. 6, no. 20, pp. 4073–4082, 2015.
- R. J. Lim, M. Xie, M. A. Sk et al., “A review on the electrochemical reduction of CO2 in fuel cells, metal electrodes and molecular catalysts,” Catalysis Today, vol. 233, pp. 169–180, 2014.
- P. Sutra and A. Igau, “Emerging Earth-abundant (Fe, Co, Ni, Cu) molecular complexes for solar fuel catalysis,” Current Opinion in Green and Sustainable Chemistry, vol. 10, pp. 60–67, 2018.
- D.-M. Feng, Y.-P. Zhu, P. Chen, and T.-Y. Ma, “Recent advances in transition-metal-mediated electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction: from homogeneous to heterogeneous systems,” Catalysts, vol. 7, no. 12, pp. 373–391, 2017.
- P. C. Sahoo, M. Kumar, S. K. Puri, and S. S. V. Ramakumar, “Enzyme inspired complexes for industrial CO2 capture: opportunities and challenges,” Journal of CO2 Utilization, vol. 24, pp. 419–429, 2018.
- B. Kumar, M. Llorente, J. Froehlich, T. Dang, A. Sathrum, and C. P. Kubiak, “Photochemical and photoelectrochemical reduction of CO2,” Annual Review of Physical Chemistry, vol. 63, no. 1, pp. 541–569, 2012.
- A. Warshel, P. K. Sharma, M. Kato, Y. Xiang, H. Liu, and M. H. M. Olsson, “Electrostatic basis for enzyme catalysis,” Chemical Reviews, vol. 106, no. 8, pp. 3210–3235, 2006.
- W. J. Albery and J. R. Knowles, “Free-energy profile for the reaction catalyzed by triosephosphate isomerase,” Biochemistry, vol. 15, no. 25, pp. 5627–5631, 1976.
- L. J. Gan, J. Laureanti, and A. K. Jones, “Biomimetic complexes for production of dihydrogen and reduction of CO2,” in Homo- and Heterobimetallic Complexes in Catalysis. Topics in Organometallic Chemistry, P. Kalck, Ed., Springer International, Berlin, Germany, 2015.
- M. Can, F. A. Armstrong, and S. W. Ragsdale, “Structure, function, and mechanism of the nickel metalloenzymes, CO dehydrogenase, and acetyl-coa synthase,” Chemical Reviews, vol. 114, no. 8, pp. 4149–4174, 2014.
- V. Svetlitchnyi, C. Peschel, G. Acker, and O. Meyer, “Two membrane-associated NiFeS-carbon monoxide dehydrogenases from the anaerobic carbon-monoxide-utilizing eubacterium carboxydothermus hydrogenoformans,” Journal of Bacteriology, vol. 183, no. 17, pp. 5134–5144, 2001.
- B. Zhang, C. F. Hemann, and R. Hille, “Kinetic and spectroscopic studies of the molybdenum-copper CO dehydrogenase from oligotropha carboxidovorans,” Journal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 285, no. 17, pp. 12571–12578, 2010.
- C. V. Kumar and E. H. Asuncion, “DNA binding studies and site selective fluorescence sensitization of an anthryl probe,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 115, no. 19, pp. 8547–8553, 1993.
- T. I. Doukov, T. M. Iverson, J. Seravalli, S. W. Ragsdale, and C. L. Drennan, “A Ni-Fe-Cu center in a bifunctional carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase,” Science, vol. 298, no. 5593, pp. 567–572, 2002.
- C. Darnault, A. Volbeda, E. J. Kim et al., “Ni-Zn-Fe4-S4 and Ni-Ni-Fe4-S4 clusters in closed and open α subunits of acetyl-CoA synthase/carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Nature Structural Biology, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 271–279, 2003.
- C. L. Drennan, J. Heo, M. D. Sintchak, E. Schreiter, and P. W. Ludden, “Life on carbon monoxide: X-ray structure of Rhodospirillum rubrum Ni-Fe-S carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 98, no. 21, pp. 11973–11978, 2001.
- H. Dobbek, V. Svetlitchnyi, L. Gremer, R. Huber, and O. Meyer, “Crystal structure of a carbon monoxide dehydrogenase reveals a Ni-4Fe-5S cluster,” Science, vol. 293, no. 5533, pp. 1281–1285, 2001.
- H. Dobbek, V. Svetlitchnyi, J. Liss, and O. Meyer, “Carbon monoxide induced decomposition of the active site Ni−4Fe−5S cluster of CO dehydrogenase,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 126, no. 17, pp. 5382–5387, 2004.
- J.-H. Jeoung and H. Dobbek, “Carbon dioxide activation at the Ni,Fe-cluster of anaerobic carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Science, vol. 318, no. 5855, pp. 1461–1464, 2007.
- T. I. Doukov, L. C. Blasiak, J. Seravalli, S. W. Ragsdale, and C. L. Drennan, “Xenon in and at the end of the tunnel of bifunctional carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase,” Biochemistry, vol. 47, no. 11, pp. 3474–3483, 2008.
- Y. Kung, T. I. Doukov, J. Seravalli, S. W. Ragsdale, and C. L. Drennan, “Crystallographic snapshots of cyanide- and water-bound C-clusters from bifunctional carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA synthase,” Biochemistry, vol. 48, no. 31, pp. 7432–7440, 2009.
- J.-H. Jeoung and H. Dobbek, “Structural basis of cyanide inhibition of Ni, Fe-containing carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 131, no. 29, pp. 9922-9923, 2009.
- J.-H. D. Jeoung and H. Dobbek, “n-Butyl isocyanide oxidation at the NiFe4S4OH(x) cluster of CO dehydrogenase,” Journal of Biological Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 167–173, 2012.
- W. Gong, B. Hao, Z. Wei et al., “Structure of the alpha2epsilon2 Ni-dependent CO dehydrogenase component of the Methanosarcina barkeri acetyl-CoA decarbonylase/synthase complex,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 105, no. 28, pp. 9558–9563, 2008.
- J. Heo, C. R. Staples, C. M. Halbleib, and P. W. Ludden, “Evidence for a ligand CO that is required for catalytic activity of CO dehydrogenase from Rhodospirillum rubrum,” Biochemistry, vol. 39, no. 27, pp. 7956–7963, 2000.
- J. Heo, C. M. Halbleib, and P. W. Ludden, “Redox-dependent activation of CO dehydrogenase from Rhodospirillum rubrum,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 98, no. 14, pp. 7690–7693, 2001.
- W. E. Robinson, A. Bassegoda, E. Reisner, and J. Hirst, “Oxidation-state-dependent binding properties of the active site in a Mo-containing formate dehydrogenase,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 139, no. 29, pp. 9927–9936, 2017.
- H. C. A. Raaijmakers and M. J. Romão, “Formate-reduced E. coli formate dehydrogenase H: the reinterpretation of the crystal structure suggests a new reaction mechanism,” Journal of Biological Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 11, no. 7, pp. 849–854, 2006.
- M. Tiberti, E. Papaleo, N. Russo, L. De Gioia, and G. Zampella, “Evidence for the formation of a Mo–H intermediate in the catalytic cycle of formate dehydrogenase,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 51, no. 15, pp. 8331–8339, 2012.
- L. B. Maia, L. Fonseca, I. Moura, and J. J. G. Moura, “Reduction of carbon dioxide by a molybdenum-containing formate dehydrogenase: a kinetic and mechanistic study,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 138, no. 28, pp. 8834–8846, 2016.
- D. Niks, J. Duvvuru, M. Escalona, and R. Hille, “Spectroscopic and kinetic properties of the molybdenum-containing, NAD+-dependent formate dehydrogenase from Ralstonia eutropha,” Journal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 291, pp. 1162–1174, 2016.
- M. Cokoja, C. Bruckmeier, B. Rieger, W. A. Herrmann, and F. E. Kühn, “Transformation of carbon dioxide with homogeneous transition-metal catalysts: a molecular solution to a global challenge?” Angewandte Chemie International Edition, vol. 50, no. 37, pp. 8510–8537, 2011.
- K. A. Grice, “Carbon dioxide reduction with homogenous early transition metal complexes: Opportunities and challenges for developing CO2 catalysis,” Coordination Chemistry Reviews, vol. 336, pp. 78–95, 2017.
- D. Yu, S. P. Teong, and Y. Zhang, “Transition metal complex catalyzed carboxylation reactions with CO2,” Coordination Chemistry Reviews, vol. 293-294, pp. 279–291, 2015.
- Q. Liu, L. Wu, R. Jackstell, and M. Beller, “Using carbon dioxide as a building block in organic synthesis,” Nature Communications, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 5933–5948, 2015.
- E. E. Benson, C. P. Kubiak, A. J. Sathrum, and J. M. Smieja, “Electrocatalytic and homogeneous approaches to conversion of CO2 to liquid fuels,” Chemical Society Reviews, vol. 38, no. 1, pp. 89–99, 2009.
- W. Zhang, Y. Hu, L. Ma et al., “Progress and perspective of electrocatalytic CO2 reduction for renewable carbonaceous fuels and chemicals,” Advanced Science, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 1700275–1700299, 2018.
- P. Braunstein, D. Matt, and D. Nobel, “Reactions of carbon dioxide with carbon-carbon bond formation catalyzed by transition-metal complexes,” Chemical Reviews, vol. 88, no. 5, pp. 747–764, 1988.
- J. Song, E. L. Klein, F. Neese, and S. Ye, “The mechanism of homogeneous CO2 reduction by Ni(cyclam): product selectivity, concerted proton–electron transfer and C–O bond cleavage,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 53, no. 14, pp. 7500–7507, 2014.
- M. Rakowski Dubois and D. L. Dubois, “Development of molecular electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction and H2 production/oxidation,” Accounts of Chemical Research, vol. 42, no. 12, pp. 1974–1982, 2009.
- A. Paparo and J. Okuda, “Carbon dioxide complexes: bonding modes and synthetic methods,” Coordination Chemistry Reviews, vol. 334, pp. 136–149, 2017.
- M. Aresta, C. F. Nobile, V. G. Albano, E. Forni, and M. Manassero, “New nickel–carbon dioxide complex: synthesis, properties, and crystallographic characterization of (carbon dioxide)-bis(tricyclohexylphosphine)nickel,” Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications, no. 15, pp. 636-637, 1975.
- M. Aresta and C. F. Nobile, “(Carbon dioxide)bis(trialkylphosphine)nickel complexes,” Journal of the Chemical Society, Dalton Transactions, no. 7, pp. 708–711, 1977.
- J. S. Anderson, V. M. Iluc, and G. L. Hillhouse, “Reactions of CO2 and CS2 with 1,2-Bis(di-tert-butylphosphino)ethane complexes of Nickel(0) and Nickel(I),” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 49, no. 21, pp. 10203–10207, 2010.
- Y.-E. Kim, J. Kim, and Y. Lee, “Formation of a nickel carbon dioxide adduct and its transformation mediated by a Lewis acid,” Chemical Communications, vol. 50, no. 78, pp. 11458–11461, 2014.
- R. Panda, C. P. Berlinguette, Y. Zhang, and R. H. Holm, “Synthesis of MFe3S4 clusters containing a planar MIISite (M = Ni, Pd, Pt), a structural element in the C-Cluster of carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 127, no. 31, pp. 11092–11101, 2005.
- C. Yoo and Y. Lee, “Carbon dioxide binding at a Ni/Fe center: synthesis and characterization of Ni(η1-CO2-κC) and Ni-μ-CO2-κC:κ2O,O′-Fe,” Chemical Science, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 600–605, 2017.
- J. Wilkie and I. H. Williams, “Transition-state structural variation in a model for carbonyl reduction by lactate dehydrogenase: computational validation of empirical predictions based upon Albery-More O’Ferrall-Jencks diagrams,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 114, no. 13, pp. 5423–5425, 1992.
- R. Panda, Y. Zhang, C. C. McLauchlan et al., “Initial structure modification of tetrahedral to planar Nickel(II) in a nickel−iron−sulfur cluster related to the C-Cluster of carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 126, no. 20, pp. 6448–6459, 2004.
- J. Sun, C. Tessier, and R. H. Holm, “Sulfur ligand substitution at the Nickel(II) sites of cubane-type and cubanoid NiFe3S4 clusters relevant to the C-clusters of carbon monoxide dehydrogenase,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 46, no. 7, pp. 2691–2699, 2007.
- A. Gennaro, A. A. Isse, and E. Vianello, “Electrochemical reduction of CO2 catalysed by transition metal complexes,” in Molecular Electrochemistry of Inorganic, Bioinorganic and Organometallic Compounds, A. J. L. Pombeiro and J. A. McCleverty, Eds., pp. 311–316, Springer, Dordrecht, Netherlands, 1993.
- D. L. Dubois, “Development of transition metal phosphine complexes as electrocatalysts for CO2 and CO reduction,” Comments on Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 19, no. 5, pp. 307–325, 1997.
- J. Shen, R. Kortlever, R. Kas et al., “Electrocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide to carbon monoxide and methane at an immobilized cobalt protoporphyrin,” Nature Communications, vol. 6, no. 1, p. 8177, 2015.
- D. S. Laitar, P. Müller, and J. P. Sadighi, “Efficient homogeneous catalysis in the reduction of CO2 to CO,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 127, no. 49, pp. 17196-17197, 2005.
- H. Yoshio, K. Katsuhei, and S. Shin, “Production of Co and Ch4 in electrochemical reduction of CO2 at metal electrodes in aqueous hydrogencarbonate solution,” Chemistry Letters, vol. 14, no. 11, pp. 1695–1698, 1985.
- J. A. Ramos Sende, C. R. Arana, L. Hernandez, K. T. Potts, M. Keshevarz, and H. D. Abruna, “Electrocatalysis of CO2 reduction in aqueous media at electrodes modified with electropolymerized films of vinylterpyridine complexes of transition metals,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 34, no. 12, pp. 3339–3348, 1995.
- D. L. DuBois and A. Miedaner, “Mediated electrochemical reduction of CO2. Preparation and comparison of an isoelectronic series of complexes,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 109, no. 1, pp. 113–117, 1987.
- D. L. DuBois, A. Miedaner, and R. C. Haltiwanger, “Electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide catalyzed by Pd(triphosphine)(solvent)(BF4)2 complexes: synthetic and mechanistic studies,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 113, no. 23, pp. 8753–8764, 1991.
- A. Majumdar, “Bioinorganic modeling chemistry of carbon monoxide dehydrogenases: description of model complexes, current status and possible future scopes,” Dalton Transactions, vol. 43, no. 32, pp. 12135–12145, 2014.
- J. W. Raebiger, J. W. Turner, B. C. Noll et al., “Electrochemical reduction of CO2 to CO catalyzed by a bimetallic palladium complex,” Organometallics, vol. 25, no. 14, pp. 3345–3351, 2006.
- J. Hawecker, J.-M. Lehn, and R. Ziessel, “Efficient photochemical reduction of CO2 to CO by visible light irradiation of systems containing Re(bipy)(CO)3X or Ru(bipy)32+–Co2+ combinations as homogeneous catalysts,” Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications, no. 9, pp. 536–538, 1983.
- B. J. Fisher and R. Eisenberg, “Electrocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide by using macrocycles of nickel and cobalt,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 102, no. 24, pp. 7361–7363, 1980.
- J. D. Froehlich and C. P. Kubiak, “The homogeneous reduction of CO2 by Ni(cyclam)+: increased catalytic rates with the addition of a CO scavenger,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 137, no. 10, pp. 3565–3573, 2015.
- R. Angamuthu, P. Byers, M. Lutz, A. L. Spek, and E. Bouwman, “Electrocatalytic CO2 conversion to oxalate by a copper complex,” Science, vol. 327, no. 5963, pp. 313–315, 2010.
- J. P. Collin, A. Jouaiti, and J. P. Sauvage, “Electrocatalytic properties of (tetraazacyclotetradecane)nickel(2+) and Ni2(biscyclam)4+ with respect to carbon dioxide and water reduction,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 27, no. 11, pp. 1986–1990, 1988.
- M. Beley, J. P. Collin, R. Ruppert, and J. P. Sauvage, “Electrocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide by nickel cyclam2+ in water: study of the factors affecting the efficiency and the selectivity of the process,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 108, no. 24, pp. 7461–7467, 1986.
- M. Beley, J.-P. Collin, R. Ruppert, and J.-P. Sauvage, “Nickel(II)-cyclam: an extremely selective electrocatalyst for reduction of CO2 in water,” Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications, no. 19, pp. 1315-1316, 1984.
- C. Costentin, S. Drouet, M. Robert, and J.-M. Savéant, “A local proton source enhances CO2 electroreduction to CO by a molecular Fe catalyst,” Science, vol. 338, no. 6103, pp. 90–94, 2012.
- E. A. Mohamed, Z. N. Zahran, and Y. Naruta, “Efficient electrocatalytic CO2 reduction with a molecular cofacial iron porphyrin dimer,” Chemical Communications, vol. 51, no. 95, pp. 16900–16903, 2015.
- L. Chen, Z. Guo, X.-G. Wei et al., “Molecular catalysis of the electrochemical and photochemical reduction of CO2 with earth-abundant metal complexes. selective production of CO vs HCOOH by switching of the metal center,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 137, no. 34, pp. 10918–10921, 2015.
- D. J. Darensbourg, A. Rokicki, and M. Y. Darensbourg, “Facile reduction of carbon dioxide by anionic Group 6b metal hydrides. Chemistry relevant to catalysis of the water-gas shift reaction,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 103, no. 11, pp. 3223-3224, 1981.
- D. J. Darensbourg, M. Y. Darensbourg, L. Y. Goh, M. Ludvig, and P. Wiegreffe, “Reaction of (Cy3P)2Ni(H)(CH3) with carbon dioxide. Formation of an hydridonickel formate complex, HNi(O2CH)(Cy3P)2,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 109, no. 24, pp. 7539-7540, 1987.
- Y. Musashi and S. Sakaki, “Theoretical study of ruthenium-catalyzed hydrogenation of carbon dioxide into formic acid. Reaction mechanism involving a new type of σ-bond metathesis,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, vol. 122, no. 16, pp. 3867–3877, 2000.
- A. Urakawa, M. Iannuzzi, J. Hutter, and A. Baiker, “Towards a rational design of ruthenium CO2 hydrogenation catalysts by Ab initio metadynamics,” Chemistry–A European Journal, vol. 13, no. 24, pp. 6828–6840, 2007.
- C. Bo and A. Dedieu, “Carbon dioxide interaction with pentacarbonylhydridochromate(1-): theoretical study of the thermodynamic aspects,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 304–309, 1989.
- S. Sakaki and K. Ohkubo, “Ab initio MO study of carbon dioxide insertion into a copper(I)-hydrogen bond. Semiquantitative understanding of changes in geometry, bonding, and electron distribution during the reaction,” Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 28, no. 13, pp. 2583–2590, 1989.
Copyright © 2018 Ilaria Gamba. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.