Review Article | Open Access
Joanna Kolmas, Ewa Groszyk, Dagmara Kwiatkowska-Różycka, "Substituted Hydroxyapatites with Antibacterial Properties", BioMed Research International, vol. 2014, Article ID 178123, 15 pages, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/178123
Substituted Hydroxyapatites with Antibacterial Properties
Reconstructive surgery is presently struggling with the problem of infections located within implantation biomaterials. Of course, the best antibacterial protection is antibiotic therapy. However, oral antibiotic therapy is sometimes ineffective, while administering an antibiotic at the location of infection is often associated with an unfavourable ratio of dosage efficiency and toxic effect. Thus, the present study aims to find a new factor which may improve antibacterial activity while also presenting low toxicity to the human cells. Such factors are usually implemented along with the implant itself and may be an integral part of it. Many recent studies have focused on inorganic factors, such as metal nanoparticles, salts, and metal oxides. The advantages of inorganic factors include the ease with which they can be combined with ceramic and polymeric biomaterials. The following review focuses on hydroxyapatites substituted with ions with antibacterial properties. It considers materials that have already been applied in regenerative medicine (e.g., hydroxyapatites with silver ions) and those that are only at the preliminary stage of research and which could potentially be used in implantology or dentistry. We present methods for the synthesis of modified apatites and the antibacterial mechanisms of various ions as well as their antibacterial efficiency.
Calcium phosphates—mainly hydroxyapatites—have for many years played a key role in biomaterial engineering due to their high biocompatibility and their bioactivity in human mineralized tissues, especially in bones and dental mineralized tissues, such as enamel, dentine, and cement [1, 2]. Biological apatite, being the main component of the inorganic fraction, is a carbonate hydroxyapatite, depleted in hydroxyl groups and rich in small amounts of various ions, including Mg2+, K+, Na+, Mn2+, , and [1–3].
A porous hydroxyapatite material may be used as a substitute bone material that fills tooth sockets after tooth extraction or else as a biomaterial forming a scaffold for newly formed bone (see Figure 2) . Between such material and the bone, the formation of biological fixation takes place: the structure of the living bone tissue penetrates the free space of the material, thus causing the more permanent fixation of the implant in the bone .
Due to its poor mechanical properties (brittleness and inflexibility), the use of hydroxyapatite as a substitute bone material is unfortunately limited to places that are not subject to great tension. On the other hand, a hydroxyapatite material is a perfect component of composite implants with synthetic polymers and biopolymers [8–10]. Dense hydroxyapatite bioceramics, formed into suitable shapes, may be used in the creation of implants for the middle ear and eye (orbital implant), as well as PD implants (Percutaneous Device), and are included in inner dialysis systems [11–13]. Hydroxyapatite is widely used as a coating of metallic implants for bones in order to improve and accelerate the process of osseointegration [14, 15]. Hydroxyapatite powder plays an important role in dentistry (e.g., in the treatment of dental pulp and dentine hypersensitivity) and is associated with the exposure of dentinal tubules [16, 17]. Hydroxyapatite, present in toothpastes and dental gels, reduces the deposition of accretions on teeth. It can also be used as a component of dental cements and fillings . It is also worth mentioning that microporous structures of hydroxyapatite can serve as carriers of drugs supplying medicinal substances directly to a destination. The studies on hydroxyapatite systems for the controlled release of anticancer drugs, antibiotics, and growth factors were reported in several papers [19–21].
Hydroxyapatite is a crystalline calcium phosphate of the general formula: Ca10(PO4)6(OH)2. Stoichiometric and perfectly pure hydroxyapatite crystallizes in the monoclinic system . Broadly, HAp crystallizes most often in the hexagonal system, a space group of P6/3mc.
Important structural features of the stoichiometric hydroxyapatite are its structural hydroxyl groups, arranged at the edges of elementary cells, forming the columns –OH–OH–OH—(see Figure 3). Oxygen atoms of these groups are spaced in such a way that they are unable to form hydrogen bonds . Hydroxyapatite includes two types of calcium cations, referred to as Ca (I) and Ca (II). The atoms of calcium Ca (I) are located at the edges of a hexagonal unit cell, while the atoms of calcium Ca (II) form equilateral triangles with the column of structural hydroxyl groups in the middle. The phosphate ions are the largest ions that build unit cells, being the one to determine its structure .
One of the primary features of hydroxyapatite is its capacity for ion substitution (i.e., ion exchange). This means that the locations for hydroxyl ions may be occupied by ions of a similar size and charge, such as Cl− or F−. In turn, the locations for phosphate ions are occupied by ions, and the locations for calcium cations by the ions Mg2+, Mn2+, or Sr2+ [1, 25, 26].
In some cases, we are talking about the total exchange (this is possible in the case of the exchange of OH–F or Ca–Sr) or partial exchange (limitations are mostly due to the difference in the sizes of the ions, charges, and their spatial structures).
An important aspect is also the possibility of the substitution of ions with different charges. For example, it is possible to exchange phosphate ions (−3) with carbonate ions (−2). Such a situation leads to the creation of a positively charged vacancy, which is compensated for by the simultaneous release of one cation of calcium (Ca2+) and one hydroxyl ion (OH−) .
This capacity for the ion exchange of hydroxyapatites has been used recently in biomaterial engineering. One also uses the fact that the introduction of even small quantities of some ions may cause changes/improvements in biological, physicochemical, or mechanical properties [28, 29]. For example, the introduction of magnesium ions has a positive biological effect and improves the osseointegrational properties of the material . In turn, the introduction of a small amount of Mn2+ ions to the apatite favours osteoblasts proliferation and increases the biocompatibility .
It should be emphasized that infections around bone implants comprise the key problem for modern reconstruction surgery [32, 33]. The defence mechanisms of the body must be supported by the introduction of antibacterial factors, particularly antibiotic therapy. This type of therapy is performed using the oral route and is less effective: the dose of the antibiotic must be high in order to ensure its appropriate concentration around the inserted implant. In turn, local antibiotic therapy applied at the place of infection (e.g., at the location of the implant filled with an appropriate antibiotic) also has its limitations: on the one hand, the concentration of the antibacterial drug must be high in order to ensure the efficiency of the treatment; and on the other hand, it must not exceed a safe level of toxicity to cells.
Therefore, implantation surgery seeks additional factors that increase the antibacterial activity around introduced biomaterials.
At present, a fairly common tendency is to use the antibacterial properties of certain ions, including silver (Ag+), copper (Cu2+), and zinc (Zn2+). In addition, one tries to look for the possibility of using other ions, such as cerium Ce3+, gallium Ga3+, selenium , titanium Ti4+, and strontium Sr2+, among others.
The mechanisms of the antibacterial activity of ions are not fully explained. However, the literature provides information on three hypothetical mechanisms [34–37] (Figure 4). According to the first mechanism, the ions penetrate into the bacterial cell and, by affecting the production of intracellular ATP, they disrupt the process of DNA replication. The second mechanism is associated with the accumulation of ions in the cell membranes of bacteria, and thus with changes in their permeability (the gradual release of proteins and lipopolysaccharides). The transportation of protons through the cell membrane is prevented, and consequently it leads to the destruction of the cell membrane and the death of the bacterial cell. The third mechanism is based on the ion induction of reactive oxygen species (ROSs). Oxygen radicals are able to react with the components of the membrane and cell wall of bacteria, as well as other cell components (e.g., mitochondria), causing irreversible changes in their structure and thus the death of the bacterial cell.
The purpose of this paper is to review the available literature and summarize the various achievements in the field of hydroxyapatites modified by ions with antibacterial properties. We have described the achievements concerning the synthesis and testing of the biological and microbiological activity of these compounds. We have tried to present our own point of view as to the applicatory potential of these materials. We hope that our research will serve as a valuable guide to hydroxyapatite bioceramics with additional antibacterial activity.
2. Ag+-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
For hundreds of years, silver has been widely known for its strong antibacterial properties  of an exceptionally broad spectrum, including both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria, viruses, and fungi [40, 41]. Of all the antibacterial metals, silver has the highest efficiency at concentrations as low as 35 ppb, at which it has no toxic effect on mammalian cells [42, 43]. In addition, microorganisms have a relatively poor ability to develop immunity to silver. Therefore, it is widely used in many forms in order to limit the growth of microorganisms, both in medicine (e.g., for the treatment of flash burns, catheters, the coverage of implant materials, urinary tract infections, dentistry [36, 44] and in other fields [45, 46]).
The mechanism of the action of silver on microbial cells depends upon its form and is complex in each case since it remains insufficiently understood in detail . In the case of silver ions, it is based primarily on their interaction with groups–SH (thiolic) of proteins  (see Figure 5), including the exchange of a hydrogen atoms with silver atoms, leading to the formation of S–Ag bonding .
This results in the inactivation of both proteins located in the cell membrane and those within the cytoplasm. Following the denaturing action of silver ions, a number of changes occur in the bacteria cell, including dysfunction of the respiratory chain and membrane pumps; the cell membrane shrinks and separates from the cell wall, and as a result the cell contents leak out and the cell wall is torn apart [47, 50]. Silver ions also interact with DNA molecules, causing their condensation and loss of capacity to replicate . It was also shown that silver ions intensify the production of ROSs , which undoubtedly enhances their antibacterial properties . In turn, silver in its nanoparticle form acts primarily on the basis of the induction of the formation of ROSs that interact with the cell wall and cell membrane of bacteria, causing their depressurization and an increase in permeability. As a result, the cell content flows out and the cell dies [52–54].
Authors studying the mechanism of the action of Ag+ ions suggest that the thickness of the peptidoglycan layer of gram-positive bacteria may—at least to a lesser extent—protect the bacterial cell from the influx of Ag+ ions to the inside, which would explain the higher activity of Ag+ against G− (e.g., Escherichia coli) as opposed to G+ bacteria (e.g., Staphylococcus aureus) [47, 50].
Increasing attention on the part of researchers has been attracted by hydroxyapatite doped with silver ions (Ag-HAp). It has been shown that Ag-HAp exhibits strong antibacterial activity [52–57], and one has proposed two mechanisms for its activity. The first of them suggests that microorganisms are attracted by electrostatic force to the surface of the hydroxyapatite, where there is a direct interaction between the bacterial cell membrane and silver ions. However, according to the second mechanism, silver ions are slowly released from the interior of the hydroxyapatite, which discloses its bactericidal activity throughout the material surrounding it .
There are various methods for the preparation of Ag-HAp:(i)wet method synthesis, using the starting materials in the form of salt [55, 57–61] or acids as well as bases and oxides ;(ii)the sol-gel technique [63, 64];(iii)ion exchange between the pure hydroxyapatite and a silver salt solution [59, 65–67];(iv)ultrasonic spray pyrolysis (USSP) ;(v)the microwave method .
The resulting materials may be then subjected to treatment, such as heat-treating by sintering in an oven or drying with the use of the sublimation method. Depending upon the method of synthesis or the possible treatment, the resulting apatites are characterized mainly by their degree of crystallinity and their specific surface area. It affects the efficiency of the antibacterial activity because the rate and extent of the release of silver ions from the apatite increase along with its surface area, and thus techniques that help in obtaining fine crystals will lead to the obtaining of a material exhibiting stronger antibacterial activity. For example, it was proved that drying the silver-hydroxyapatite using the sublimation method leads to the preparation of a material with finer crystals, thereby also enhancing the activity of antibacterial Ag-HAp . In addition, methods of synthesis (such as USSP, the direct incorporation of Ag+ ions into the structure of HAp, as well as increases in the crystallinity of Ag-HAp by sintering) lead to the preparation of a material with a slower release of Ag+ ions, and thus to prolonged antibacterial activity .
During Ag-HAp synthesis, different amounts of silver are introduced within the range of 0.1% to 10% of weight, usually in several increasing concentrations, allowing a series of tests for the various contents of silver. The aim of such a study is to determine the optimum concentrations, characterized by a high efficiency of action against a broad range of microorganisms.
The broad antibacterial spectrum of Ag-HAp is similar and has the same width as the spectrum of silver ions, including bacteria, viruses, and fungi . Moreover, like the silver ions, it has a more effective influence on gram-negative rather than gram-positive bacteria, due to the differences in the structures of cell walls . Even such a low content of silver as 0.2% of weight in Ag-HAp effectively inhibits the growth of K. pneumoniae and C. krusei. In contrast, antibacterial activity against E. coli and B. subtilis requires a content of 0.5% weight of silver in the apatite  (see Figure 6). The growth of S. aureus and Staphylococcus epidermidis is clearly inhibited with a silver content of 1% of weight .
Excessive silver content in the hydroxyapatite may be toxic, not only to microorganisms but also to mammalian tissues, and may lead to the inhibition of their growth [61, 71, 72]. Therefore, the selection of an appropriate silver content in Ag-HAp is an important issue, since it should be high enough to be able to effectively fight microorganisms, while at the same time it should also be limited in order that it does not adversely affect the condition of mammalian tissues. Numerous toxicological studies have shown that, along with the increase of the content and the rate of release of silver ions from Ag-HAp, we can also observe an increase in their negative impact on tissues, inhibiting their growth and development, and in higher Ag+ concentrations—leading to death of the cells. In order to determine the optimum silver content, one performed in vitro toxicity studies on human osteoblasts [71, 73, 74], human stem cells , and mouse fibroblasts , as well as in vivo studies in rats involving the implantation of Ag-HAp. In vitro studies carried out on human stem cells show that a hydroxyapatite containing 0.3% silver weight has no negative effect on the growth of these cells over the course of seven days of culture, while a content of 0.7% silver slightly inhibits their growth. In contrast, a concentration of 8.3% weight exhibits a significant cytotoxic effect, specifically in inhibiting the growth of human stem cells . In vitro experiments on human osteoblasts have shown that a silver content of 6% weight significantly inhibits the growth of osteoblasts and leads to the death of some of them, while 2% and 4% weights represent contents that enable a good balance between effective antimicrobial and cytotoxic activity . In addition, in vitro studies conducted on rats confirmed the relatively low toxicity of Ag-HAp, containing up to 4.3% weight (see Figure 7) .
The complexity of the problem of the balance between effective antimicrobial activity and cytotoxic activity includes not only the total content of silver in the hydroxyapatite but also the conditions of its synthesis and the method for its drying and heat treating. Nevertheless, one can observe a significant and still growing interest in this promising material.
3. Cu2+-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
Copper is an essential micronutrient of almost all living organisms because it is involved in many metabolic processes. However, higher concentrations of copper ions may have toxic effects, inter alia, because of their ability to generate ROSs. The antibacterial properties of copper were discovered very early on; we know of Egyptian texts written around 2600–2200 BC which present methods for the sterilization of drinking water and wounds to the chest using copper .
The mechanism of the antibacterial activity of hydroxyapatites doped with copper ions is not yet fully understood. It is believed that copper ions form strong bonds with thiolic, imidazole, amine, and carboxylic groups of proteins, causing structural changes and increases in permeability and, hence, membrane transport dysfunction and cell death . In addition, copper ions also form a bonding with amine and amide groups, as well as with the disulphide bridges of proteins and enzymes of bacteria, causing damage to DNA and RNA and resulting in the inhibition of the reproduction of bacteria or their death .
The antibacterial properties of copper are also used by macrophages which, by copper concentration, increase their ability to inactivate microorganisms through the oxygen burst . Therefore, some microorganisms, such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis, S. aureus, and Salmonella enterica, have produced mechanisms protecting them from the toxic effect of copper in order to be able to survive the intervention of macrophages [80–83]. In addition, copper deficiency reduces the bactericidal activity of neutrophils and in vitro macrophages .
Studies have confirmed the antibacterial efficiency of hydroxyapatites doped with copper ions against E. coli bacteria. Hydroxyapatites were synthesized using the wet method. Copper ions were introduced into the structure using copper acetate of Cu (CH3COO)2·H2O. Hydroxyapatites doped with copper ions to the amount 3.3% of weight inhibited the growth of E. coli bacteria, while a content of 0.66% of weight of Cu2+ was deemed to be insufficient to inhibit bacteria .
In this case, hydroxyapatites were also obtained using the wet method, while the copper ion source was copper oxide (II) CuO. The resulting material more strongly inhibited the growth of fungi than in the case of studies of hydroxyapatites doped with zinc ions. Copper ions do not inhibit the multiplication of S. aureus bacteria, which is probably due to the fact that S. aureus is a gram-positive bacteria.
Cooper ions, in contrast to other divalent metal cations (Zn, Co, Ni, Mn, Fe, and Sn), cause selective changes in the permeability of the cell membrane of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeasts, with no changes in the vacuole membrane permeability .
In the case of hydroxyapatites doped with copper ions, a problem may be caused by the cytotoxic properties of copper, both against bacteria and osteoblasts . Such an effect can be observed in the case of hydroxyapatites with a content of 0.66% of weight of Cu2+.
4. Zn2+-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
Zinc, one of the essential microelements, is present in the active centres of more than 300 enzymes involved in the metabolism of bones. It also exhibits antibacterial activity, the mechanism of which is similar to that of copper ions. Due to its antibacterial properties, one started to introduce zinc ions into the molecule of hydroxyapatite. Moreover, zinc ions have also had a direct impact on the proliferative properties of osteoblasts and an inhibitory effect on bone resorption by osteoclasts.
Some papers have presented studies on hydroxyapatites doped with small amounts of zinc ions (less than 1%), which confirmed effective bioactivity and antibacterial properties [77, 85–90]. In contrast, 1.3% content of zinc ions causes an increase in osteoblast responses . In addition to their biological properties, one has also confirmed the inhibitory effect of hydroxyapatites doped with zinc on the development of bacteria and fungi, including E. coli, S. aureus, C. albicans, and Streptococcus mutans . Studies on a hydroxyapatite doped with zinc, synthesized using the wet method and a hexahydrate zinc nitrate of Zn (NO3)2·6H2O (wherein the zinc ion content was 1.6%), have shown its real impact on the reduction of the numbers of S. aureus bacteria . In addition, it was proved that the small amount of zinc ions introduced into the hydroxyapatite structure plays an important role in the processes of the growth and differentiation of the cells; however, the mechanism of the ions’ impact on biological processes has not yet been discovered.
The use of hydroxyapatites doped with zinc ions as a coating for the remineralization of teeth helps to reduce bacterial adherence and the growth of tartar. Studies confirmed the efficiency of hydroxyapatites doped with zinc ions in reducing the growth of the three most common oral pathogens, including Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans, Fusobacterium nucleatum, and S. mutans  (see Table 1).
Hydroxyapatites are also used in the treatment of bone cancer and chronic osteomyelitis. In these and other diseases of the bones, infections pose serious problems. Unfortunately, the most commonly used antibiotics have very low concentrations in the bone tissue. Therefore, it is crucial to look for a solution which achieves high concentrations of antibiotics in the bone tissue while reducing the toxic effect of drugs on the human body. Studies have been performed on the efficiency of hydroxyapatites doped with zinc ions as carriers for the controlled release of ciprofloxacin, which exhibits antibacterial activity against S. aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (these being the most common pathogens causing diseases of the bones and joints). They have shown that the release of ciprofloxacin by the hydroxyapatite takes place in connection with the release of zinc ions and increases in the drug concentration and number of Zn2+ ions used increases the antibacterial activity . Furthermore, the release of ciprofloxacin from hydroxyapatite doped with zinc ions is greater than the drug released from the “pure” hydroxyapatite. The use of such a solution in the treatment of infections of bone tissue allows for the shortening of therapy—increasing its efficiency—and the reduction of the dose of ciprofloxacin, which contributes to the reduction of the formation of resistant strains. As in the case of hydroxyapatites doped with copper ions, the use of hydroxyapatites containing zinc ions may be limited by the cytotoxicity of zinc, which is revealed when the content exceeds 1.2% .
Due to the possibly identical mechanism of the antibacterial activity of zinc and copper ions and their similar efficiency as regards the treatment of microorganisms, the studies on the simultaneous introduction of the ions of these both metals into the hydroxyapatite structure are conducted.
5. SeO-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
Selenium is one of the microelements necessary for the proper development of the human body. Yet, until recently, it was considered a highly toxic agent [96, 97]. However, studies have shown that it is a component of selenoproteins and the glutathione peroxidase enzyme, responsible for the protection of cell membranes against harmful factors . Many studies have proved that selenium is a factor which protects against oxidative stress and carcinogenesis. Therefore, one performs research on the use of selenium compounds in the production of multifunctional biomaterials which, in addition to the scaffold function, also represent the anticarcinogenic functions . Studies conducted by Tran et al.  and Rodríguez-Valencia et al.  have also shown favourable antibacterial properties. Selenium ions of were introduced into the carbonated hydroxyapatite structure using the pulsed laser deposition method (PLD). The material formed this way was used to create a coating for titanium. Its antibacterial activity on the strains of S. aureus and P. aeruginosa was found . Even at a concentration of 0.6% weight of selenium in the coating, there was an inhibition of biofilm formation by the two bacterial strains. It is worth noting that the concentration of selenium was nontoxic and had no adverse effect on the adhesion of the cells or their proliferation. The literature discusses the antibacterial mechanism of selenium [100–103]. It is most likely associated with oxidative stress, resulting in damage to the cell walls of bacteria. Microorganisms metabolize selenium to a harmless form of elemental selenium of Se0 or HSe− (hydrogen selenide), which in turn can be included in selenocysteine. As a result of metabolic reactions—which are oxidation-reduction reactions—H2O2 or even may be created, which would confirm the theory of the oxidative antibacterial mechanism of selenium.
6. Sr2+-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
Strontium is a microelement that cumulates in the bone mineral, playing an important role in it. A small amount of strontium induces the formation of bone tissue and the inhibition of its resorption. The available literature also contains information about the relief of bone pains and even attempts to treat bone cancer [104, 105]. There are many elaborations devoted to the introduction of strontium ions into the hydroxyapatite structure [106–109]. Due to their similar properties and small differences in size, calcium cations may be completely replaced with strontium cations. The introduction of strontium ions into the hydroxyapatite improves its biocompatibility and bioactivity, streamlining the process of osseointegration. In addition, strontium ions improve the mechanical properties of the hydroxyapatite.
Recent reports also show that strontium can be used as an antibacterial agent. Guida et al.  suggested that the antibacterial activity of glass-ionomer cements is mainly caused by the presence of strontium and not fluoride, as was previously thought. In turn, in the paper of , it was proved that the antibacterial properties of strontium are very poor but that its combination with fluoride improves its antibacterial potential in the treatment of tooth decay.
One also studied the antibacterial activity of hydroxyapatite incorporated with strontium ions. In the elaboration of , where Sr-hydroxyapatite was synthesized using the sol-gel-supercritical fluid drying method (SCFD), it was proved that the material containing strontium ions exhibited antibacterial activity against E. coli, S. aureus, and Lactobacillus. In turn, in the elaboration of , Sr-HAp was prepared using the accelerating action of microwaves. A small amount of strontium in the received materials caused a bactericidal effect on E. coli and S. aureus.
7. Ce3+- and Eu3+-Doped Hydroxyapatite
Cerium and europium are rare earth elements from lanthanides, which are present in the human body only as a result of the cumulative effect of the environment. They have the ability to accumulate in small amounts in the bones and liver. We do not know the biological role of cerium or europium, but recent studies have shown that cerium salts may stimulate metabolism .
In recent years, researchers have begun to investigate the biological properties of the cerium oxide of CeO2. It has been proven that cerium oxide is able to induce angiogenesis through its direct effect on the modulation of oxygen in intracellular environments . In turn, Lord et al.  have studied the impact of cerium oxide on human monocytes, based on its ability to scavenge ROSs. The antibacterial properties of cerium oxide have also been studied in a number of elaborations, especially of strains of E. coli, B. subtilis, Salmonella typhimurium, and Enterococcus faecalis [117, 118].
There are few works devoted to the antibacterial properties of cerium ions and their use in biomaterials engineering. However, the literature contains reports on the synergistic effect of the activity of zinc and cerium ions in nanomaterials of alpha-zirconium phosphate and titanium [119, 120].
In the available literature, only two elaborations are devoted to hydroxyapatite doped with cerium ions [121, 122]. Feng et al. synthesized hydroxyapatite containing a maximum of 10% weight of cerium using the hydrothermal method . The introduction of cerium ions to the hydroxyapatite structure was manifested by the reduction in the crystal size to about 20 nm. Unfortunately, this elaboration did not consider research into the antibacterial properties of the resulting material. Lin et al.  synthesized hydroxyapatite containing cerium ions using the sol-gel-supercritical fluid drying method (SCFD). The introduction of cerium ions into the structure resulted in the reduction of the crystallinity of the materials and a change in crystal morphology: from rod-shaped HAp to needle-shaped Ce-HAp. The elaboration was devoted to the antibacterial activity of the resulting materials based on the following bacterial strains: E. coli, S. aureus, and Lactobacillus. It turned out that the materials were characterized by a high antibacterial capacity—the greater the degree of the substitution of calcium ions by cerium ions, the higher the antibacterial capacity. At a low content of cerium in a sample, the antibacterial activity was based only on the dynamic contact of the material with bacteria at a concentration of 0.1 g/mL.
When it comes to the antibacterial activity of europium ions in the context of biomaterials, it has been described in [123, 124]. One studied the antibacterial activity of materials synthesized using the coprecipitation method (i.e., the wet method) on the following strains of bacteria and fungi: S. aureus, E. coli, P. aeruginosa, E. faecalis, and C. albicans  (see Figure 9). These studies have shown that even with a low content of Eu3+, the materials had an antibacterial effect on strains of P. aeruginosa, S. aureus, and E. faecalis. In contrast, these materials showed no bactericidal capacity in relation to the E. coli strain. Fungicidal activity was exhibited by the materials with a higher content of europium.
8. Ga3+-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
Gallium is an element from the group of semimetals. Its efficacy in the treatment of many types of disorders has been developed in the late 20th century. A wide range of potential applications have been described in an extensive review of Bernstein . Gallium inhibits bone resorption and thus lowers the calcium concentration in plasma. In addition, it induces osteoblasts and helps bone formation. It has a positive effect on the adoption of implants. Numerous studies have also proved its immunomodulatory activity. In addition, gallium—due to its antiproliferative and antimitotic effect—may positively influence the treatment of certain types of cancer .
Due to the high similarity of Fe3+ ions (i.e., similar ionic radius, electronegativity, coordination number, etc.), gallium ions of Ga3+ may replace them in a variety of metabolic reactions. With this property, gallium is used as a diagnostic and therapeutic agent in metabolic disorders of soft and hard tissues .
Recent studies have also proved the antibacterial activity of gallium ions, which is based on the exchange of iron ions in protein metabolism [126, 127]. One showed the antibacterial activity of phosphorus, silica, and phosphorus glass containing gallium.
The available literature contains information on hydroxyapatite synthesis, enriched with gallium ions III . The content in the material amounted to 11% of weight. However, one has not examined the antibacterial activity of this material. In our opinion, such studies should be carried out.
9. Ti4+-Containing Hydroxyapatite
In recent years, a lot of attention has been given to titanium oxide TiO2, due to its photocatalytic properties [129, 130]. One uses its photooxidative activity on organic materials, such as proteins and lipids. The mechanism of photocatalysis of titanium oxide is described in the elaboration of . It takes place according to the following reactions: Free electrons () and positively charged holes () have strong oxidizing and reducing properties. When electrons and vacancies migrate to the surface, TiO2 can participate in the reactions of oxidation/reduction with molecules absorbed on the surface (i.e., water, oxygen, and organic and inorganic molecules) (Figure 10). Electrons may reduce Ti(IV) to Ti(III), which in turn reacts with the oxygen to form radicals. Vacancies may react with water or ions of OH− and form radicals of : In turn, the radicals of and may react together, causing the formation of H2O2.
These factors, the so-called “reactive oxygen species” (ROSs), may react with the wall or membrane of the cell of bacteria. Unsaturated phospholipids—contained in these cell elements—participate in reactions with ROS, causing the death of the bacterial cell.
The antibacterial properties of Ti(IV) are used in biomaterials engineering. In addition to the use of titanium oxide as a component of biomaterial components, the literature describes hydroxyapatites doped with Ti4+ ions [133, 134]. Wakamura  proved that Ti4+ in hydroxyapatite—where there are small amounts of Ti (molar ratio of Ca/P to 100)—forms divalent cations [Ti(OH)2]2+ and [TiHPO4]2+, which replace calcium cations. Titanium contained in hydroxyapatite crystals has a similar antibacterial mechanism to titanium oxide. Hydroxyapatite has a high affinity for proteins; therefore, hydroxyapatite modified with Ti4+ ions has an antibacterial effect not only after UV irradiation.
10. Co2+-Substituted Hydroxyapatite
Cobalt is an essential element for the proper functioning of the human body. First of all, it is a component of vitamin B12, which is necessary for the regulation of the production of red blood cells, DNA synthesis in cells, and the formation of the myelin sheath, protecting the cells of nerves and neurotransmitters .
The literature presents information on the use of Co (II) ions as an antibacterial and antiviral agent in various organic complexes [136, 137]. In 2013, two elaborations were developed concerning hydroxyapatites partly doped with cobalt ions (II) [138, 139]. In their work, Ignjatović et al.  presented the hydrothermal method for obtaining hydroxyapatite containing Co2+ at the amount of 5–15% of weight. Unfortunately, so far, nobody has conducted studies on the antibacterial activity of the resulting materials. In turn, Stânila et al.  have synthesized nanocrystalline hydroxyapatite enriched with Co2+ ions using the wet method and obtained the materials containing between 0.46% and 3.79% of cobalt weight. The resultant cobalt ion concentrations were lower than expected before the synthesis, which was most likely related to differences in the constant bonding and chemical affinity of the ions of cobalt (II) and calcium (II). The antibacterial activity was tested on the basis of strains of the following bacteria: S. aureus, Micrococcus luteus, P. aeruginosa, and Shigella flexneri. Nanocrystalline hydroxyapatite was used as a comparative material, obtained under the same conditions. In studies carried out in the elaboration of , it turned out that all the tested materials (even nanocrystalline HAp) exhibited antibacterial activity against the studied strains, with the exception of P. aeruginosa and with the proviso that this activity strongly increased along with an increase of the cobalt content of the material. It is also worth noting that the materials were not toxic (according to haemolysis assay), which gives hope for their use in medicine as biomaterials with additional antibacterial properties.
Hydroxyapatite plays a key role in bioceramic and biomaterial composites and is commonly used in reconstruction medicine and dental implantology. However, we can observe a trend of a broadening of the spectrum of the apatite materials, with additional biological, physicochemical, or biomechanical properties, despite the scaffold for the newly formed bone. It seems very reasonable to look for the possibility of the substitution of ions with antibacterial properties. So far, the best-known and most commonly used material is hydroxyapatite enriched with silver ions. Much is also known about the antibacterial activity of hydroxyapatites substituted by the ions of copper and zinc. On the other hand, it seems that the other materials still require a great deal of research. In our opinion, one should also examine the relationship between the method of the preparation of the substituted apatite material with its antibacterial activity and its efficiency. Such studies remain very rare or else incomplete.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Joanna Kolmas thanks the Foundation for Polish Science for supporting her with the Parent-Bridge Programme that was cofinanced by the EU European Regional Development Fund. Ewa Groszyk and Dagmara Kwiatkowska-Różycka thank the Medical University of Warsaw for the financial support (FW23/NM1/13).
- S. V. Dorozhkin, “Calcium orthophosphates in nature, biology and medicine,” Materials, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 399–498, 2009.
- S. J. Omelon and M. D. Grynpas, “Relationships between polyphosphate chemistry, biochemistry and apatite biomineralization,” Chemical Reviews, vol. 108, no. 11, pp. 4694–4715, 2008.
- Q. Liu, S. Huang, J. P. Matinlinna, Z. Chen, and H. Pan, “Insight into biological apatite: physiochemical properties and preparation approaches,” BioMed Research International, vol. 2013, Article ID 929748, 13 pages, 2013.
- M. Vallet-Regi, Biomimetic Nanoceramics in Clinical Use: From Materials to Applications, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1st edition, 2008.
- R. Z. LeGeros, “Calcium phosphate-based osteoinductive materials,” Chemical Reviews, vol. 108, no. 11, pp. 4742–4753, 2008.
- N. A. Zakharov, I. A. Polunina, K. E. Polunin et al., “Calcium hydroxyapatite for medical applications,” Inorganic Materials, vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 641–648, 2004.
- J. J. Yoo, H. J. Kim, S. M. Seo, and K. S. Oh, “Preparation of hemiporous hydroxyapatite scaffold and evaluation as a cell-mediated bone substituted,” Ceramics International, vol. 40, no. 2, pp. 3079–3087, 2014.
- E. Tayton, M. Purcell, A. Aarvold et al., “A comparison of polymer and polymer-hydroxyapatite composite tissue engineered scaffolds for use in bone regeneration. An in vitro and in vivo study,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research A, 2013.
- X. Xiao, R. Liu, and Q. Huang, “Preparation and characterization of nano-hydroxyapatite/polymer composite scaffolds,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 19, no. 11, pp. 3429–3435, 2008.
- D. A. Wahl and J. T. Czernuszka, “Collagen-hydroxyapatite composites for hard tissue repair,” European Cells & Materials, vol. 11, pp. 43–56, 2006.
- O. Lukáts, P. Bujtár, G. K. Sándor, and J. Barabás, “Porous hydroxyapatite and aluminium-oxide ceramic orbital implant evaluation using CBCT scanning: a method for in vivo porous structure evaluation and monitoring,” International Journal of Biomaterials, vol. 2012, Article ID 764749, 9 pages, 2012.
- B. Kundu, M. K. Sinha, M. K. Mitra, and D. Basu, “Fabrication and characterization of porous hydroxyapatite ocular implant followed by an in vivo study in dogs,” Bulletin of Materials Science, vol. 27, no. 2, pp. 133–140, 2004.
- X. Ge, Y. Leng, C. Bao, S. L. Xu, R. Wang, and F. Ren, “Antibacterial coatings of fluoridated hydroxyapatite for percutaneous implants,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research A, vol. 95, no. 2, pp. 588–599, 2010.
- K. Kuroda and M. Okido, “Hydroxyapatite coating of titanium implants using hydroprocessing and evaluation of their osteoconductivity,” Bioinorganic Chemistry and Applications, vol. 2012, Article ID 730693, 7 pages, 2012.
- B. Sandén, C. Olerud, M. Petrén-Mallmin, and S. Larsson, “Hydroxyapatite coating improves fixation of pedicle screws. A clinical study,” The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery B, vol. 84, no. 3, pp. 387–391, 2002.
- L. Rimondini, B. Palazzo, M. Iafisco et al., “The remineralizing effect of carbonate-hydroxyapatite nanocrystals on dentine,” Materials Science Forum, vol. 539–543, no. 1, pp. 602–605, 2007.
- P. Mehta, N. Vimala, and L. Mandke, “An insight into dentin desensitizing agents—in vivo study,” Indian Journal of Dental Research, vol. 24, no. 5, pp. 571–574, 2013.
- J. S. Al-Sanabani, A. A. Madfa, and F. A. Al-Sanabani, “Application of calcium phosphate materials in dentistry,” International Journal of Biomaterials, vol. 2013, Article ID 876132, 12 pages, 2013.
- J. H. Lee, I. H. Ko, S.-H. Jeon, J. H. Chae, E. J. Lee, and J. H. Chang, “Localized drugs delivery hydroxyapatite microspheres for osteoporosis therapy,” in Biosensing and Nanomedicine IV, vol. 8099 of Proceedings of SPIE, 80990K, San Diego, Calif, USA, August 2011.
- J. M. Rogers-Foy, D. L. Powers, D. A. Brosnan, S. F. Barefoot, R. J. Friedman, and M. LaBerge, “Hydroxyapatite composites designed for antibiotic drug delivery and bone reconstruction: a caprine model,” Journal of Investigative Surgery, vol. 12, no. 5, pp. 263–275, 1999.
- R. Rohanizadeh and K. Chung, “Hydroxyapatite as a carrier for bone morphogenetic protein,” Journal of Oral Implantology, vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 659–672, 2011.
- G. Ma and X. Y. Liu, “Hydroxyapatite: hexagonal or monoclinic?” Crystal Growth & Design, vol. 9, no. 7, pp. 2991–2994, 2009.
- N. H. de Leeuw, “Local ordering of hydroxy groups in hydroxyapatite,” Chemical Communications, no. 17, pp. 1646–1647, 2001.
- J. C. Elliott, Structure and Chemistry of Apatites and Other Calcium Orthophosphates, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1st edition, 1994.
- S. Kannan, F. Goetz-Neunhoeffer, J. Neubauer, and J. M. F. Ferreira, “Ionic substitutions in biphasic hydroxyapatite and β-tricalcium phosphate mixtures: structural analysis by Rietveld refinement,” Journal of the American Ceramic Society, vol. 91, no. 1, pp. 1–12, 2008.
- V. Aina, G. Lusvardi, B. Annaz et al., “Magnesium- and strontium-co-substituted hydroxyapatite: the effect of doped ions on the structure and chemico-physical properties,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 2867–2879, 2012.
- J. Barallet, S. Best, and W. Bonefield, “Carbonate substitution in precipitated hydroxyapatite: an investigation into the effects of reaction temperature and bicarbonate ion concentration,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 79–86, 1998.
- J. H. Shepherd, D. V. Shepherd, and S. M. Best, “Substituted hydroxyapatites for bone repair,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 23, no. 10, pp. 2335–2340, 2012.
- Z. Noor, “Nanohydroxyapatite application to osteoporosis management,” Journal of Osteoporosis, vol. 2013, Article ID 679025, 6 pages, 2013.
- T. J. Webster, C. Ergun, R. H. Doremus, and R. Bizios, “Hydroxylapatite with substituted magnesium, zinc, cadmium, and yttrium. II. Mechanisms of osteoblast adhesion,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 59, no. 2, pp. 312–317, 2002.
- E. Palcevskis, A. Dindune, Y. Dekhtyar, N. Polyaka, D. Veljović, and R. L. Sammons, “The influence of surface treatment by hydrogenation on the biocompatibility of different hydroxyapatite materials,” IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, vol. 23, no. 1, Article ID 012032, 2011.
- R. S. Namba, M. C. Inacio, and E. W. Paxton, “Risk factors associated with deep surgical site infections after primary total knee arthroplasty: an analysis of 56,216 knees,” The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, vol. 95, no. 9, pp. 775–782, 2013.
- S. Nagano, M. Yokouchi, T. Setoguchi et al., “Analysis of surgical site infection after musculoskeletal tumor surgery: risk assessment using a new scoring system,” Sarcoma, vol. 2014, Article ID 645496, 9 pages, 2014.
- J. Diaz-Visurraga, C. Gutiérrez, C. von Plessing, and A. Garcia, “Metal nanostructures as antibacterial agents,” in Science against Microbial Pathogens: Communicating Current Research and Technological Advances, A. Méndez-Vilas, Ed., Formatex, Badajoz, Spain, 2011.
- R. Dastjerdi and M. Montazer, “A review on the application of inorganic nano-structured materials in the modification of textiles: focus on anti-microbial properties,” Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces, vol. 79, no. 1, pp. 5–18, 2010.
- A. Simchi, E. Tamjid, F. Pishbin, and A. R. Boccaccini, “Recent progress in inorganic and composite coatings with bactericidal capability for orthopaedic applications,” Nanomedicine: Nanotechnology, Biology, and Medicine, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 22–39, 2011.
- M. J. Hajipour, K. M. Fromm, A. A. Ashkarran et al., “Antibacterial properties of nanoparticles,” Trends in Biotechnology, vol. 30, no. 10, pp. 499–511, 2012.
- M. J. Hajipour, K. M. Fromm, A. A. Ashkarran et al., “Erratum: antibacterial properties of nanoparticles,” Trends in Biotechnology, vol. 31, no. 1, pp. 61–62, 2013.
- H. J. Klasen, “A historical review of the use of silver in the treatment of burns. I. Early uses,” Burns, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 117–130, 2000.
- H. H. Lara, E. N. Garza-Trevino, L. Ixtepan-Turrent, and D. K. Singh, “Silver nanoparticles are broad-spectrum bactericidal and virucidal compounds,” Journal of Nanobiotechnology, vol. 9, article 30, pp. 30–38, 2011.
- J. B. Wright, K. Lam, D. Hansen, and R. E. Burrell, “Efficacy of topical silver against fungal burn wound pathogens,” American Journal of Infection Control, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 344–350, 1999.
- J. Hardes, H. Ahrens, C. Gebert et al., “Lack of toxicological side-effects in silver-coated megaprostheses in humans,” Biomaterials, vol. 28, no. 18, pp. 2869–2875, 2007.
- G. Gosheger, J. Hardes, H. Ahrens et al., “Silver-coated megaendoprostheses in a rabbit model—an analysis of the infection rate and toxicological side effects,” Biomaterials, vol. 25, no. 24, pp. 5547–5556, 2004.
- R. O. Darouiche, I. I. Raad, S. O. Heard et al., “A comparison of two antimicrobial-impregnated central venous catheters,” The New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 340, no. 1, pp. 1–8, 1999.
- T. M. Benn and P. Westerhoff, “Nanoparticle silver released into water from commercially available sock fabrics,” Environmental Science & Technology, vol. 42, no. 11, pp. 4133–4139, 2008.
- P. Jain and T. Pradeep, “Potential of silver nanoparticle-coated polyurethane foam as an antibacterial water filter,” Biotechnology and Bioengineering, vol. 90, no. 1, pp. 59–63, 2005.
- Q. L. Feng, J. Wu, G. Q. Chen, F. Z. Cui, T. N. Kim, and J. O. Kim, “A mechanistic study of the antibacterial effect of silver ions on Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 52, no. 4, pp. 662–668, 2000.
- S. Y. Liau, D. C. Read, W. J. Pugh, J. R. Furr, and A. D. Russell, “Interaction of silver nitrate with readily identifiable groups: relationship to the antibacterial action of silver ions,” Letters in Applied Microbiology, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 279–283, 1997.
- K. Mijnendockx, N. Leys, J. Mahillon, S. Silver, and R. van Houdt, “Antimicrobial silver: uses, toxicity and potential for resistance,” Biometals, vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 609–621, 2013.
- W. K. Jung, H. C. Koo, K. W. Kim, S. Shin, S. H. Kim, and Y. H. Park, “Antibacterial activity and mechanism of action of the silver ion in Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli,” Applied and Environmental Microbiology, vol. 74, no. 7, pp. 2171–2178, 2008.
- O. Gordon, T. V. Slenters, P. S. Brunetto et al., “Silver coordination polymers for prevention of implant infection: thiol interaction, impact on respiratory chain enzymes, and hydroxyl radical induction,” Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, vol. 54, no. 10, pp. 4208–4218, 2010.
- A. J. Kora and J. Arunachalam, “Assessment of antibacterial activity of silver nanoparticles on Pseudomonas aeruginosa and its mechanism of action,” World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology, vol. 27, no. 5, pp. 1209–1216, 2011.
- J. S. Kim, E. Kuk, K. N. Yu et al., “Antimicrobial effects of silver nanoparticles,” Nanomedicine: Nanotechnology, Biology, and Medicine, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 95–101, 2007.
- I. Sondi and B. Salopek-Sondi, “Silver nanoparticles as antimicrobial agent: a case study on E. coli as a model for Gram-negative bacteria,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, vol. 275, no. 1, pp. 177–182, 2004.
- S. Samani, S. M. Hossainalipour, M. Tamizifar, and H. R. Rezaie, “In-vitro antibacterial evaluation of sol-gel-derived Zn-, Ag-, and (Zn + Ag)-doped hydroxyapatite coatings against methycillin-resistant S. aureus,” Journal of Biomedical Material Research A, vol. 101, no. 1, pp. 222–230, 2013.
- C. Guo, X. Li, and Y. Dong, “Preparation and characterization of silver/hydroxyapatite nanoparticles,” Advanced Materials Research, vol. 311–313, pp. 1746–1750, 2011.
- K.-S. Oh, K.-J. Kim, Y.-K. Jeong, and Y.-H. Choa, “Effect of fabrication processes on the antimicrobial properties of silver doped nano-sized HAp,” Key Engineering Materials, vol. 240–242, pp. 583–586, 2003.
- B. H. Su and Z. X. Xiong, “Preparation of antibacterial ceramics with silver-carrying nano-hydroxyapatite,” Key Engineering Materials, vol. 336–338, pp. 1563–1566, 2007.
- C. L. Shi, I. Ren, and Z. X. Xiong, “Preparation and effectiveness of antibacterial hydroxyapatite powder containing silver,” Key Engineering Materials, vol. 280–283, pp. 1529–1532, 2005.
- C. S. Ciobanu, S. L. Iconaru, M. C. Chifiriuc, A. Costescu, P. le Coustumer, and D. Predoi, “Synthesis and antimicrobial activity of silver-doped hydroxyapatite nanoparticles,” BioMed Research International, vol. 2013, Article ID 916218, 10 pages, 2013.
- E. S. Thian, P. N. Lim, Z. Shi, B. Y. Tay, and K. G. Neoh, “Silver-doped apatite as a bioactive and an antimicrobial bone material,” Key Engineering Materials, vol. 493-494, pp. 27–30, 2012.
- V. Stanić, D. Janaćković, S. Dimitrijević et al., “Synthesis of antimicrobial monophase silver-doped hydroxyapatite nanopowders for bone tissue engineering,” Applied Surface Science, vol. 257, no. 9, pp. 4510–4518, 2011.
- R.-J. Chung, M.-F. Hsieh, K.-C. Huang, L.-H. Perng, F.-I. Chou, and T.-S. Chin, “Anti-microbial hydroxyapatite particles synthesized by a sol-gel route,” Journal of Sol-Gel Science and Technology, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 229–239, 2005.
- S. L. Iconaru, P. Chapon, P. le Coustumer, and D. Predoi, “Antimicrobial activity of thin solid films of silver doped hydroxyapatite prepared by sol-gel method,” The Scientific World Journal, vol. 2014, Article ID 165351, 8 pages, 2014.
- Q. L. Feng, T. N. Kim, J. Wu et al., “Antibacterial effects of Ag-HAp thin films on alumina substrates,” Thin Solid Films, vol. 335, no. 1-2, pp. 214–219, 1998.
- M. Honda, Y. Kawanobe, K. Ishii et al., “In vitro and in vivo antimicrobial properties of silver-containing hydroxyapatite prepared via ultrasonic spray pyrolysis route,” Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 33, no. 8, pp. 5008–5018, 2013.
- N. Rameshbabu, T. S. S. Kumar, T. G. Prabhakar, V. S. Sastry, K. V. Murty, and K. P. Rao, “Antibacterial nanosized silver substituted hydroxyapatite: synthesis and characterization,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research A, vol. 80, no. 3, pp. 581–591, 2007.
- K. S. Oh, K. J. Kim, Y. K. Jeong et al., “Cytotoxicity and antimicrobial effect of Ag doped hydroxyapatite,” Key Engineering Materials, vol. 264–268, pp. 2107–2110, 2004.
- A. Costescu, C. S. Ciobanu, S. L. Iconaru et al., “Fabrication, characterization and antimicrobial activity, evaluation of low silver concentrations in silver-doped hydroxyapatite nanoparticles,” Journal of Nanomaterials, vol. 2013, Article ID 194854, 9 pages, 2013.
- W. Chen, S. Oh, A. P. Ong et al., “Antibacterial and osteogenic properties of silver-containing hydroxyapatite coatings produced using a sol gel process,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research A, vol. 82, no. 4, pp. 899–906, 2007.
- J. W. Choi, H. M. Cho, E. K. Kwak et al., “Effect of Ag-doped hydroxyapatite as a bone filler for inflamed bone defects,” Key Engineering Materials, vol. 254–256, pp. 47–50, 2004.
- M. Roy, G. A. Fielding, H. Beyenal, A. Bandyopadhyay, and S. Bose, “Mechanical, in vitro antimicrobial, and biological properties of plasma-sprayed silver-doped hydroxyapatite coating,” Applied Materials & Interfaces, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 1341–1349, 2012.
- G. A. Fielding, M. Roy, A. Bandyopadhyay, and S. Bose, “Antibacterial and biological characteristics of silver containing and strontium doped plasma sprayed hydroxyapatite coatings,” Acta Biomaterialia, vol. 8, no. 8, pp. 3144–3152, 2012.
- S. Brajendra, A. K. Dubey, S. Kumar, N. Saha, B. Basu, and R. Gupta, “In vitro biocompatibility and antimicrobial activity of wet chemically prepared hydroxyapatites,” Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 31, no. 7, pp. 1320–1329, 2011.
- I.-S. Lee, C.-N. Whang, K.-S. Oh et al., “Formation of silver incorporated calcium phosphate film for medical applications,” Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research B, vol. 242, no. 1-2, pp. 45–47, 2006.
- H. Dollwet and J. Sorenson, “Historic uses of copper compounds in medicine,” Trace Elements in Medicine, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 80–87, 1985.
- V. Stanić, S. Dimitrijević, J. Antić-Stanković et al., “Synthesis, characterization and antimicrobial activity of copper and zinc-doped hydroxyapatite nanopowders,” Applied Surface Science, vol. 256, no. 20, pp. 6083–6089, 2010.
- H. Yang, L. Zhang, and K.-W. Xu, “Effect of storing on the microstructure of Ag/Cu/HA powder,” Ceramics International, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 1595–1601, 2009.
- C. White, J. Lee, T. Kambe, K. Fritsche, and M. J. Petris, “A role for the ATP7A copper-transporting ATPase in macrophage bactericidal activity,” The Journal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 284, no. 49, pp. 33949–33956, 2009.
- D. Osman, K. J. Waldron, H. Denton et al., “Copper homeostasis in Salmonella is atypical and copper-CueP is a major periplasmic metal complex,” The Journal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 285, no. 33, pp. 25259–25268, 2010.
- O. Soutourina, S. Dubrac, O. Poupel, T. Msadek, and I. Martin-Verstraete, “The pleiotropic CymR regulator of Staphylococcus aureus plays an important role in virulence and stress response,” PLoS Pathogens, vol. 6, no. 5, article e1000894, 2010.
- F. Wolschendorf, D. Ackart, T. B. Shrestha et al., “Copper resistance is essential for virulence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 108, no. 4, pp. 1621–1626, 2011.
- U. Babu and M. L. Failla, “Respiratory burst and candidacidal activity of peritoneal macrophages are impaired in copper-deficient rats,” Journal of Nutrition, vol. 120, no. 12, pp. 1692–1699, 1990.
- Y. Li, J. Ho, and C. P. Ooi, “Antibacterial efficacy and cytotoxicity studies of copper (II) and titanium (IV) substituted hydroxyapatite nanoparticles,” Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 30, no. 8, pp. 1137–1144, 2010.
- Y. Ohsumi, K. Kitamoto, and Y. Anraku, “Changes induced in the permeability barrier of the yeast plasma membrane by cupric ion,” Journal of Bacteriology, vol. 170, no. 6, pp. 2676–2682, 1988.
- X. Wang, A. Ito, Y. Sogo, X. Li, and A. Oyane, “Zinc-containing apatite layers on external fixation rods promoting cell activity,” Acta Biomaterialia, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 962–968, 2010.
- Y. Sogo, T. Sakurai, K. Onuma, and A. Ito, “The most appropriate (Ca+Zn)/P molar ratio to minimize the zinc content of ZnTCP/HAP ceramic used in the promotion of bone formation,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 62, no. 3, pp. 457–463, 2002.
- A. Ito, K. Ojiima, H. Naito, N. Ichinose, and T. Tateishi, “Preparation, solubility, and cytocompatibility of zinc-releasing calcium phosphate ceramics,” Journal of Biomedical Material Research, vol. 50, no. 2, pp. 178–183, 2000.
- Y. Yamada, A. Ito, H. Kojima et al., “Inhibitory effect of Zn2+ in zinc-containing β-tricalcium phosphate on resorbing activity of mature osteoclasts,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research A, vol. 84, no. 2, pp. 344–352, 2008.
- H. Kawamura, A. Ito, S. Miyakawa et al., “Stimulatory effect of zinc-releasing calcium phosphate implant on bone formation in rabbit femora,” Journal of Biomedical Material Research, vol. 50, no. 2, pp. 184–190, 2000.
- T. J. Webster, E. A. Massa-Schlueter, J. L. Smith, and E. B. Slamovich, “Osteoblast response to hydroxyapatite doped with divalent and trivalent cations,” Biomaterials, vol. 25, no. 11, pp. 2111–2121, 2004.
- R.-J. Chung, M.-F. Hsieh, C.-W. Huang, L.-H. Perng, H.-W. Wen, and T.-S. Chin, “Antimicrobial effects and human gingival biocompatibility of hydroxyapatite sol-gel coatings,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research B, vol. 76, no. 1, pp. 169–178, 2006.
- E. S. Thian, T. Konishi, Y. Kawanobe et al., “Zinc-substituted hydroxyapatite: a biomaterial with enhanced, bioactivity and antibacterial properties,” Journal of Materials Science, Materials in Medicine, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 437–445, 2013.
- X. Chen, Q. L. Tang, Y. J. Zhu, C. L. Zhu, and X. P. Feng, “Synthesis and antibacterial property of zinc loaded hydroxyapatite nanorods,” Materials Letters, vol. 89, pp. 233–235, 2012.
- G. D. Venkatasubbu, S. Ramasamy, V. Ramakrishnan, and J. Kumar, “Nanocrystalline hydroxyapatite and zinc doped hydroxyapatite as carrier material for controlled delivery of ciprofloxacin,” 3 Biotech, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 173–186, 2011.
- D. H. Holben and A. M. Smith, “The diverse role of selenium within selenoproteins: a review,” Journal of the American Dietetic Association, vol. 99, no. 7, pp. 836–843, 1999.
- M. P. Rayman, “The importance of selenium to human health,” The Lancet, vol. 356, no. 9225, pp. 233–241, 2000.
- Y.-C. Chen, D. M. Sosnoski, U. H. Gandhi, L. J. Novinger, K. S. Prabhu, and A. M. Mastro, “Selenium modifies the osteoblast inflammatory stress response to bone metastatic breast cancer,” Carcinogenesis, vol. 30, no. 11, pp. 1941–1948, 2009.
- P. L. Tran, A. A. Hammond, T. Mosley et al., “Organoselenium coating on cellulose inhibits the formation of biofilms by Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus,” Applied and Environmental Microbiology, vol. 75, no. 11, pp. 3586–3592, 2009.
- C. Rodríguez-Valencia, M. López-Álvarez, B. Cochón-Cores, I. Pereiro, J. Serra, and P. González, “Novel selenium doped hydroxyapatite coatings for biomedical applications,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research A, vol. 101, no. 3, pp. 853–861, 2013.
- P. A. Tran and T. J. Webster, “Selenium nanoparticles inhibit Staphylococcus aureus growth,” International Journal of Nanomedicine, vol. 6, pp. 1553–1558, 2011.
- P. A. Tran and T. J. Webster, “Antimicrobial selenium nanoparticle coatings on polymeric medical devices,” Nanotechnology, vol. 24, no. 15, Article ID 155101, 2013.
- R. K. Dutta, B. P. Nenavathu, and S. Talukdar, “Anomalous antibacterial activity and dye degradation by selenium doped ZnO nanoparticles,” Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces, vol. 114, pp. 218–224, 2014.
- S. G. Dahl, P. Allain, P. J. Marie et al., “Incorporation and distribution of strontium in bone,” Bone, vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 446–453, 2001.
- R. G. Robinson, J. A. Spicer, D. F. Preston, A. V. Wegst, and N. L. Martin, “Treatment of metastatic bone pain with strontium-89,” International Journal of Radiation Applications and Instrumentation, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 219–222, 1987.
- A. Bigi, E. Boanini, C. Capuccini, and M. Gazzano, “Strontium-substituted hydroxyapatite nanocrystals,” Inorganica Chimica Acta, vol. 360, no. 3, pp. 1009–1016, 2007.
- S. Okayama, M. Akao, S. Nakamura, Y. Shin, M. Higashikata, and H. Aoki, “The mechanical properties and solubility of strontium-substituted hydroxyapatite,” Biomedical Materials and Engineering, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 11–17, 1991.
- Z. H. Li, J. M. Wu, S. J. Huang, J. Guan, and X. Z. Zhang, “Strontium hydroxyapatite synthesis, characterization, and cell cytotoxicity,” Advanced Materials Research, vol. 160–162, pp. 117–122, 2010.
- W. Liu, T. Wang, Y. Shen, H. Pan, S. Peng, and W. W. Lu, “Strontium incorporated coralline hydroxyapatite for engineering bone,” ISRN Biomaterials, vol. 2013, Article ID 649163, 11 pages, 2013.
- A. Guida, M. R. Towler, J. G. Wall, R. G. Hill, and S. Eramo, “Preliminary work on the antibacterial effect of strontium in glass ionomer cements,” Journal of Materials Science Letters, vol. 22, no. 20, pp. 1401–1403, 2003.
- D. S. Brauer, N. Karpukhina, G. Kedia et al., “Bactericidal strontium-releasing injectable bone cements based on bioactive glasses,” Journal of the Royal Society Interface, vol. 10, no. 78, pp. 1–8, 2012.
- Y. Lin, Z. Yang, J. Cheng, and L. Wang, “Synthesis, characterization and antibacterial property of strontium half and totally substituted hydroxyapatite nanoparticles,” Journal of Wuhan University of Technology-Materials Science Education, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 475–479, 2008.
- N. D. Ravi, R. Balu, and T. S. Sampath Kumar, “Strontium-substituted calcium deficient hydroxyapatite nanoparticles: synthesis, characterization and antibacterial properties,” Journal of the American Ceramic Society, vol. 95, no. 9, pp. 2700–2708, 2012.
- Toxicological Review of Cerium Oxide and Cerium Compounds, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, USA, 2009, http://www.epa.gov/iris/.
- S. Das, S. Singh, J. M. Dowding et al., “The induction of angiogenesis by cerium dioxide nanoparticles through the modulation of oxygen in intracellular environments,” Biomaterials, vol. 33, no. 31, pp. 7746–7755, 2012.
- M. S. Lord, B. Tsoi, C. Gunawan, W. Y. Teoh, R. Amal, and J. M. Whitelock, “Anti-angiogenic activity of heparin functionalized cerium oxide nanoparticles,” Biomaterials, vol. 34, no. 34, pp. 8808–8018, 2013.
- Y. Kuang, X. He, Z. Zhang et al., “Comparison study on the antibacterial activity of nano-or bulk-cerium oxide,” Journal of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, vol. 11, no. 5, pp. 4103–4108, 2011.
- D. A. Pelletier, A. K. Suresh, G. A. Holton et al., “Effects of engineered cerium oxide nanoparticles on bacterial growth and viability,” Applied and Environmental Microbiology, vol. 76, no. 24, pp. 7981–7989, 2010.
- G. Dai, A. Yu, X. Cai, Q. Shi, Y. Ouyang, and S. Tan, “Synthesis, characterization and antimicrobial activity of zinc and cerium co-doped α-zirconium phosphate,” Journal of Rare Earths, vol. 30, no. 8, pp. 820–825, 2012.
- Y. Z. Wang, X. X. Xue, and H. Yang, “Preparation and characterization of zinc and cerium co-doped titania nano-materials with antibacterial activity,” Journal of Inorganic Materials, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 117–122, 2013.
- Z. Feng, Y. Liao, and M. Ye, “Synthesis and structure of cerium-substituted hydroxyapatite,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. 417–421, 2005.
- Y. Lin, Z. Yang, and J. Cheng, “Preparation, characterization and antibacterial property of cerium substituted hydroxyapatite nanoparticles,” Journal of Rare Earths, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 452–456, 2007.
- S. L. Iconaru, M. Motelica-Heino, and D. Predoi, “Study on europium-doped hydroxyapatite nanoparticles by fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and their antimicrobial properties,” Journal of Spectroscopy, vol. 2013, Article ID 284285, 10 pages, 2013.
- R. J. Wiglusz, A. Kedziora, A. Lukowiak, W. Doroszkiewicz, and W. Strek, “Hydroxyapatite and europium (III) doped hydroxyapatite as a carrier for silver nanoparticles and their antimicrobial activity,” Journal of Biomedical Nanotechnology, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 605–612, 2012.
- L. R. Bernstein, “Mechanisms of therapeutic activity for gallium,” Pharmacological Reviews, vol. 50, no. 4, pp. 665–682, 1998.
- M. Franchini, G. Lusvardi, G. Malavasi, and L. Menabue, “Gallium-containing phospho-silicate glasses: synthesis and in vitro bioactivity,” Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 1401–1406, 2012.
- S. P. Valappil, D. Ready, E. A. Abou Neel et al., “Controlled delivery of antimicrobial gallium ions from phosphate-based glasses,” Acta Biomaterialia, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 1198–1210, 2009.
- P. Melnikov, A. R. Teixeira, A. Malzac, and M. D. B. Coelho, “Gallium-containing hydroxyapatite for potential use in orthopedics,” Materials Chemistry and Physics, vol. 117, no. 1, pp. 86–90, 2009.
- O. Carp, C. L. Huisman, and A. Reller, “Photoinduced reactivity of titanium dioxide,” Progress in Solid State Chemistry, vol. 32, no. 1-2, pp. 33–177, 2004.
- K. Nakata and A. Fujishima, “TiO2 photocatalysis: design and applications,” Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology C: Photochemistry Reviews, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 169–189, 2013.
- Y. Cai, Titanium Dioxide Photocatalysis in Biomaterials Applications, vol. 1033 of Digital Comprehensive Summaries of Uppsala Dissertations from the Faculty of Science and Technology, Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis, 2013.
- M. Wakamura, “Photocatalysis by calcium hydroxyapatite modified by Ti (IV),” Fujitsu Scientific and Technical Journal, vol. 41, no. 2, pp. 181–190, 2005.
- A. Hu, M. Li, C. Chang, and D. Mao, “Preparation and characterization of a titanium-substituted hydroxyapatite photocatalyst,” Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical, vol. 267, no. 1-2, pp. 79–85, 2007.
- S. Daou, A. El Chemaly, P. Christofilopoulos, L. Bernard, P. Hoffmeyer, and N. Demaurex, “The potential role of cobalt ions released from metal prosthesis on the inhibition of Hv1 proton channels and the decrease in Staphyloccocus epidermidis killing by human neutrophils,” Biomaterials, vol. 32, no. 7, pp. 1769–1777, 2011.
- K. P. Tank, K. S. Chudasama, V. S. Thaker, and M. J. Joshi, “Cobalt-doped nanohydroxyapatite: synthesis, characterization, antimicrobial and hemolytic studies,” Journal of Nanoparticle Research, vol. 15, pp. 1644–1655, 2013.
- K. Singh, Y. Kumar, P. Puri, C. Sharma, and K. R. Aneja, “Thermal, spectral, fluorescence, and antimicrobial studies of cobalt, nickel, copper, and zinc complexes derived from 4-[(5-bromo-thiophen-2-ylmethylene)-amino]-3-mercapto-6-methyl-5-oxo-[1,2,4]triazine,” International Journal of Inorganic Chemistry, vol. 2012, Article ID 873232, 9 pages, 2012.
- N. Ignjatović, Z. Ajduković, V. Savić et al., “Nanoparticles of cobalt-substituted hydroxyapatite in regeneration of mandibular osteoporotic bones,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 343–354, 2013.
- A. Stânila, C. Braicu, S. Stânila, and R. M. Pop, “Antibacterial activity of copper and cobalt amino acids complexes,” Notulae Botanicae Horti Agrobotanici Cluj-Napoca, vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 124–129, 2011.
Copyright © 2014 Joanna Kolmas et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.