Research Article | Open Access
Clinical Characteristics of Autism Spectrum Disorder in Israel: Impact of Ethnic and Social Diversities
Despite the increased global prevalence and recognition of autistic spectrum disorder (ASD), it is still scarcely reported in the Arab world. Though Israel has a higher prevalence of ASD, a previous national survey of patients diagnosed between 1972 and 2004, demonstrated that 98% of them were of Jewish ancestry. The disproportional low number of Arab children with ASD in Israel is unclear but may reflect lower awareness and cultural bias. In the present study we collected clinical and demographic characteristics of 200 children with ASD from Arab and Jewish sectors in Israel that were evaluated in two child development centers. We compared the incidence and the medical comorbidity of autism between these two ethnics groups. The medical and psychiatric comorbidity profile in these children was similar to the worldwide published studies. In the present study the prevalence of autism in the Arab sector in Israel was similar to that of the Jewish sector. The Arab patients presented with more severe autistic manifestations and higher incidence of mental retardation, familial members with autism, and consanguinity (), while in the Jewish sector milder forms (such as Asperger syndrome and PDD-NOS) were more frequent. This discrepancy might be explained by both genetic and cultural factors.
Autism is a medical term that encompasses a broad spectrum of neurodevelopmental disorders characterized by impaired reciprocal socialization and communication, often accompanied with stereotyped ritualistic behavior. Despite a strong genetic factor , there are no clear cut biological markers of autism and its diagnosis is purely based upon clinical observation, psychological tests and employment of diagnostic instruments, and standard checklist questionnaires, which are amenable to human bias [2, 3]. The clinical boundaries of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) have been changed over the years by the American Psychiatric Association and at present are based on the 5th edition of the Diagnosis and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM V) . The dramatic worldwide increase in the incidence of ASD during the last two decades might be related to environmental factors but is also a result of more permissive clinical criteria as well as increased worldwide awareness of ASD by both medical and educational personnel [5–7]. This awareness has expanded throughout the whole world, including the Middle Eastern Arab world, where autism was rarely reported in the past [8, 9]. In comparison to other Middle Eastern countries, Israel has a higher prevalence of ASD and, as in the rest of the Western world, the prevalence and incidence of ASD is higher than previously reported, though still lower than in USA . A national survey that included Israeli patients diagnosed with ASD between the years 1972 and 2004 demonstrated that 98% of them were from Jewish ancestry . The disproportional low number of children from Arab communities in Israel is unclear but may reflect lower awareness and cultural bias rather than genuine genetic diversity. Similarly, and probably from similar reasons, studies from USA have shown a lower prevalence of ASD is the Hispanic population in comparison to white Americans .
Studies comparing prevalence in different ethnic groups can provide a better understanding of neurobehavioral disorders such as autism and can further clarify the effect of various factors such as genetic and environmental factors on its pathogenesis. The Arab community comprises approximately twenty percent of the population in Israel and has specific social and environmental characteristics. During the recent decades there has been a change in the social structure of Arab society including alteration of some properties such as the decrease in the number of children in the family, improved economic status with more participation of women in the labor market, and increased awareness of neurobehavioral disorders. We assume that these changes in Arab society can explain the increasing morbidity and comorbidity of various neurobehavioral disorders including autism.
The present study aims to compare the clinical characteristics of children from Arab and Jewish communities in Israel and further assess the effect of genetic versus cultural and social factors.
2. Materials and Methods
Participants were 200 children with ASD diagnosed during the last five years (2008−2013) at two Child Neurology and Development centers in the Haifa and Hadera districts at the northwestern region of Israel (including Hillel-Yaffe Medical Center and Clalit Health Services in Haifa). These two centers cover a population of nearly 1,000,000 persons. All patients underwent a complete work-up and evaluation. Children with additional medical conditions that may contribute to neurologic dysfunction such as Down syndrome, fragile-X syndrome, significant premature birth (<34 weeks of gestation), birth asphyxia, cerebral palsy, Rett syndrome, and children with other chromosomal aberrations were excluded.
The diagnosis of ASD (autism, pervasive developmental disorders-not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS), or Asperger disorder) was based on fulfilling the required criteria of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) and usage of additional diagnostic instruments, primarily the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) questionnaire . Eligibility for diagnosis of ASD requires clinical evaluations by both a pediatric neurologist experienced in neurodevelopmental disorders and a developmental psychologist.
The clinical data was collected retrospectively from the medical records of these patients. Where necessary for completion of missing data, we contacted the parents and caregivers of the patients. The questionnaires included information about the medical and social background of the patients including ethnic identity, socioeconomic status, and educational and medical data retrieved from developmental rehabilitation institutions (as shown in Study Questionnaire).
In respect to the data that was summarized, developmental regression was defined as loss of any skill that was used consistently for at least 2 weeks and subsequently lost. These skills included all features of language and speech, eye contact, gestures, pointing, and fine motor skills.
In this study comorbid psychiatric disorders included mood disorders and aggressive/self-injurious behavior. Identification of mood disorders in individuals with autism spectrum disorders was based on clinical features of mood fluctuation and somatic signs of affect disorders according to DSM IV criteria. The symptoms of mood disorder must have been present intermittently or persistently for an estimated period of at least 6 months. Aggressive/self-injurious behaviors were defined as unprovoked kicking, biting, pinching, hitting, or head-banging toward self or others that occurred daily and were persistent for an estimate of 6 months or more.
The database was created in Access software (Microsoft Inc, Redmond, Washington). The data were subject to random spot-checking and verification and were imported into SPSS software (SPSS Inc, Chicago, Illinois) for statistical analysis. Frequency tallies were performed on all categorical variables, prevalence rates determined, and tests carried out as appropriate.
Approximately 4,300 pediatric patients are referred annually to both child development and pediatric neurology centers for assessment of neurodevelopmental difficulties. Out of them 69% are Jews, while the rest (31%) are Arabs. Among them, within the last five years (2008–2013) 200 children were diagnosed with ASD and were included in the current study. In this context, data retrieved from the official website of the Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics (ICBS) showed that during 2011-2012 the number of children aged 0–7 years in our study area was 120,822 (73,900 Jews, 46,922 Arabs) . Taking into consideration that approximately 40% are referred to our two child development centers (the rest belong to different healthcare insurance corporations) means that in reality our centers provide medical service for 29,560 Jewish children and 18,768 Arab children. Subjects were grouped into two groups according to their ethnicity: a Jewish group (, 65%) and an Arab group (, 35%). Accordingly, the calculated estimated prevalence of ASD in our area was 4.3/1000 in the Jewish sector and 3.8/1000 in the Arab sector.
Table 1 contains selected characteristics of the 200 children with ASD and for the each group separately. The male to female ratio of the total sample was 7.3 : 1. Among Jews this ratio was higher (10.76 : 1) than among Arabs (4.4 : 1) (). The mean age of diagnosed patients was months (range 30.9 to 53.5) with no significant difference between Arabs and Jews. In both communities, most children were diagnosed with ASD before school entry, indicating an increased awareness of autistic disorders at early age. The data showed that there is a significant difference between Arabs and Jews regarding relatives with Autism (17% versus 8.5%) and consanguinity (21.1% versus 2.3%), respectively. The course of pregnancy and birth were also investigated and we found that while vaginal delivery was more common in Arab women, caesarian section and vacuum extraction were more commonly among Jewish women (Table 1).
The different subtypes of ASD according to the DSM IV classification among Jewish and Arab patients are shown in Table 2. While the prevalence of “classic” autistic disorder was relatively higher among Arab patients, both Asperger’s disorder and PDD-NOS were relatively more prevalent in the Jewish patients. The majority of our patients were diagnosed as a primary autism (68.5%) with the others as secondary regression. Additionally, there was no significant difference between Jewish and Arab patients according to this type of diagnoses. In this study the mean CARS scale was quite high (35.38), with Arab patients getting higher score on the scale than Jewish patients, indicating more severe autistic manifestations in the former group.
The prevalence of associated disorders that are found in children with ASD in the present study is shown in Table 3. The most common comorbid disorder is sleep disturbance (40.5%) without difference between Arab and Jewish patients. Interestingly, among Jewish patients the second and third common concurrent disorders were found to be anxiety (36.4%) and behavioral difficulties (19.4%), whereas among Arab patients behavioral difficulties (32.4%) and anxiety (16.9%) were observed as the second and third comorbid disorders, respectively. Furthermore, mental retardation and epilepsy were found to be the fourth and the last concurrent disorders with autism among all patients with significant differences between Jew and Arab patients. Jewish autistic patients have more incidence of epilepsy (9.3% versus 4.2%) than the Arab autistic patients whereas Arab autistic patients have more incidence of mental retardation (14% versus 8.5%).
Table 4 shows the persons who first raised the possibility of the children having an autistic disorder and selected clinical presentation among our patients. It demonstrates that parents were the first to suspect that their children have autistic disorder (69%) in both Jewish and Arab communities. Among Jewish patients, kindergarten teachers more commonly suspected the autistic disorder before the patient reached a physician, whereas among Arab patients this was not the case. Interestingly, it was found that the first and the second common symptoms of ASD among Jewish patients were language delay (35.5%) and communication deficits (25%), whereas among Arab patients communication deficits (35.21%) and language delay (29.75%) were found to be the first and the second common symptoms of ASD, respectively. Additionally, a significant difference was found between both groups regarding communication deficits symptoms. Other clinical symptoms did not show any significant differences between the two groups.
Study Questionnaire: Autistic Spectrum Disorder—Clinical Data
(A) General Information
Date: …/…/…(I)Subject ID: … Date of birth/Age: … Gender: M/F(II)Birth history: Week of gestation: …, Birth weight: … (Grams), Mode of delivery: … Apgar score: 1′ … 5′ …(III)Gestational complications: □ No □ Yes If yes, specify: …(IV)Delivery complications: □ No □ Yes If yes, specify: …(V)Neonatal medical complications: □ No □ Yes If yes, specify: …
(B) Diagnosis of Autism(I)Age of onset of symptoms: …(II)Age of diagnosis: …(III)The diagnosis was determined by:(1)Professional physician(2)Professional psychologist(3)Other(IV)The diagnostic instruments:(1)□ DSM IV(2)□ CARS(3)□ ADOS(4)□ Other (IVa) DSMIV Score: … (IVb) CARS Score: …
(C) Symptoms and Clinical Comorbidity of the Autistic Child
(I)PDD subtype:(1)□ Autism(2)□ Asperger syndrome(3)□ PDD-NOS(4)□ Other(II) (1)Primary autism(2)Secondary regression(3)Unknown(III)Mental retardation: □ No □ Yes If yes: (1) Mild, (2) Moderate, (3) Severe, (4) Unknown(IV)Sleep disorder/insomnia: □ No □ Yes If yes: (1) Difficulties in falling asleep, (2) Difficulties during sleep, (3) Excessive night arousals, (4) Difficulties in morning arousal, (5) Unknown(V)Gastrointestinal symptoms: □ No □ Yes If yes: (1) Diarrhea, (2) Constipation, (3) Vomiting, (4) Food intolerance, (5) Abdominal pain, (6) Other(VI)Epilepsy or seizures: □ No □ Yes If yes:(1)Age of onset: …(2)Epilepsy type:(2a)Generalized(2b)Simple partial(2c)Complex partial(2d)Partial with secondary generalization(2e)Single episode(2f)Others: specify: …(VII)Behavioral and psychiatric disorders(1)Anxiety: □ No □ Yes □ Unknown If yes please details: …(2)Depression: □ No □ Yes □ Unknown If yes please details: …(3)Obsessive compulsive disorder: □ No □ Yes □ Unknown If yes please specify: …(4)ADHD: □ No □ Yes □ Unknown If yes please specify: …(5)Other psychiatric disorder: □ No □ Yes □ Unknown If yes please specify: …(VIII)Other chronic diseases: □ No □ Yes □ Unknown
(D) Ethnic Group(II)Jewish Subgroup: …(III)Arab Subgroup: …(IIII)Other: …
(E) Familial Status(I)Parental consanguinity: □ No □ Yes(II)Consanguinity degree: …(III)Adopted child(IV)Parental status: (1) Married, (2) Divorced, (3) Uniparental family(V)Number of children in the family: …(VI)The serial number of the autistic child in the family: …(VII)Is there any neurologic, genetic, or developmental disorder/disease in the family? □ No □ Yes If yes, please specify: …
(F) Socioeconomic Status(I)Father education: …(II)Mother education: …(III)Father employment status/occupation: …(IV)Mother employment status/occupation: …
(G) The Educational Status of the Autistic Child(I)Private day-care center(II)Private regular kindergarten(III)Public regular kindergarten(IV)Special education kindergarten(V)Regular school class(VI)Regular school class with assistance(VII)Special education school class(VIII)Other: …(IX)None(X)Unknown
ASD is a complex neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by qualitative impairments in three domains: social interaction, communication, and repetitive, stereotyped behavior. As a rule, these impairments begin in early childhood (before the age of three years), persist throughout the full life span, and often cast a detrimental impact on the well-being of affected individuals . Similarly to other developmental brain disorders it is commonly associated with other medical and psychiatric comorbidities including behavioral difficulties, sleep disorders, gastrointestinal disorders, and epilepsy.
In the recent years there has been a significant global increase in the incidence of ASD though most reports come from the Western world. This phenomenon is attributed to environmental and genetic factors [16–18]. More genes are being discovered and considered as contributing to the development of autistic disorders and recent studies indicate a form of complex genetic inheritance . In addition, increased parental age, specially the paternal age, may also contribute to the increased incidence of ASD .
In contrast to the global increase in the awareness and prevalence of autism, publications in this field in the Arab world over a 25-year period were found to be underrepresented . Relatively little is known about the clinical correlation and comorbidity of autism in Middle Eastern and Arab countries [22, 23]. In Saudi Arabia, one study investigated 49 patients with autism and found that females were older than males at the time of referral, 11 patients had a history of seizure disorder, 25 patients were taking psychotropic medications, and 14 patients were the product of consanguineous marriages . In a study from the United Arab of Emirates (UAE), a representative random sample of 694 three-year-old children with ASD was evaluated in a two-stage study in the community. The weighted prevalence was estimated to be 29–58 per 10,000 for a DSM-IV diagnosis of pervasive developmental disorder (PDD). The presence of autistic features was associated with male gender, the presence of behavioral problems, and a family history of developmental delay . A recent study of ASD in Arab Countries recruited a total number of 37 boys and 23 girls from three Arab countries (Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan) and found that the boys had poor emotional responsiveness and the girls had more cognitive problems . In this study the mean age of diagnosis was relatively high (8.6 years in the Egyptian patients, 8.2 years in the Saudi patients, and 7.9 years in the Jordanian patients) the percentage of the female patients was relatively high (52% in the Egyptian patients, 21% in the Saudi patients, and 40% in the Jordanian patients). Another recent study from Lebanon investigated the association of autism with several factors in 86 children of autism from specialized schools for children with developmental disabilities and 172 control children from regular public school in the same regions . They found that male sex, older age, living close to industrial compounds, previous childhood infection, and maternal depression during pregnancy were all associated with autism.
Our study is a unique epidemiological and clinical research in several ways. It is a comparative study that characterizes the clinical features and comorbidities of two different ethnic groups, Jews and Arabs, living in the same region with access to the same medical services. These ethnic groups have different social and cultural features with different genetic background. Comparing these two ethnic populations can underscore the effect of genetic versus cultural or environmental factors in the prevalence of ASD and its comorbidities. Our results show that the prevalence of the ASD among the Arab population in Israel is proportional to that within the Jewish population. While the estimated prevalence of ASD in our area (4.3/1000 and 3.8/1000 among Jewish and Arab, resp.) is still lower than in the Western world, it is in accordance with, though somewhat lower than, the prevalence that was recently found by Davidovitch et al. . These results contradict a previous national survey that included Israeli patients diagnosed with ASD between the years 1972 and 2004 demonstrating that 98% were from Jewish ancestry and only 2% were Arab . Hence, the present study shows a sharp increase of ASD diagnosis in the Arab population during the last decade. Several factors contributed to this increase including a raised social awareness in parents and school and kindergarten staff and increased accessibility to pediatricians, pediatric neurologists, and pediatric psychiatrists specializing in childhood neurodevelopmental disorders. These results also indicate that the social, environmental, and cultural factors interplay a critical role in the etiology of ASD. We assume that during the last decade fundamental social changes occurred in the Arab population including paternal age, women labor, socioeconomic status, and lifestyle. All of these factors can contribute to the increase of the ASD. It is implausible that genetic factors are responsible for this increase because it is unlikely that significant genetic alterations occurred during such a short time (10 years).
We also investigated the question of who was the first to suspect the diagnosis of ASD in the child. Jews and Arab parents alike were the first to raise this suspicion. For Jewish patients kindergarten staff suspected ASD while in Arabs patients this was not the case and only their physicians raised the issue. These results suggest that the awareness of ASD is higher among the teaching staff in the Jewish community than in the Arab community. More efforts are required in order to raise the awareness among the school and education staff within the Arab community.
Limitation of the Study. The main drawback of the study is its retrospective nature. Hence the data was collected from medical files and parents interviews. Although all patients reside in the Haifa and Hadera districts, not all of them were referred to our two Child Development centers. Furthermore, the children that are referred to the Child Development centers are mostly preschool children. Thus there is a possibility that a substantial number of children, who were diagnosed as autistic later in life (during school years), were not included. Though we made an effort to calculate the estimated prevalence of ASD in our regional area, this is still not a national population-based survey and therefore does not allow us to accurately estimate the prevalence of ASD in Israel in either the Jewish or the Arab sectors of the population. There is a need to conduct a more comprehensive national survey of all the patients with autism in Israel, particularly in older age, in order to study the role of genetic, environmental, and social effects on the diagnosis of ASD.
The present study demonstrates that while the prevalence of ASD is similar in both Arabs and Jews, Arabs were more commonly diagnosed with autistic disorder (including cases with severe autism who received a higher clinical CARS score). In contrast, milder subtypes of ASD (such as Asperger syndrome and PDD-NOS) were more commonly found in Jewish patients. Likewise, mental retardation was also more commonly found among the Arab patients. The reason for this discrepancy is not entirely clear but is conceivable that parental consanguinity and perhaps lower index of suspicion in milder cases contribute to this phenomenon. In this respect, despite the increase in the socioeconomic status and education of the Arab community in Israel consanguinity is still relatively common . We believe that it also plays a major role in the fact that ASD was more frequently found in siblings and family relatives among the Arab patients.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare no conflict of interests.
- S. E. Levy, D. S. Mandell, and R. T. Schultz, “Autism,” The Lancet, vol. 374, no. 9701, pp. 1627–1638, 2009.
- A. Le Couteur, M. Rutter, and A. Le Couteur, The Autism Diagnostic Interview V Revised (ADI-R), Western Psychological Services, Los Angeles, Calif, USA, 2003.
- E. Schopler, R. Reichler, and B. R. Renner, Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS), Western Psychological Services, Los Angeles, Calif, USA, 1993.
- American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, Va, USA, 5th edition, 2013.
- L. A. Croen, J. K. Grether, J. Hoogstrate, and S. Selvin, “The changing prevalence of autism in California,” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 207–215, 2002.
- E. Webb, J. Morey, W. Thompsen, C. Butler, M. Barber, and W. I. Fraser, “Prevalence of autistic spectrum disorder in children attending mainstream schools in a Welsh education authority,” Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 377–384, 2003.
- E. Fombonne, “Epidemiology of autistic disorder and other pervasive developmental disorders,” Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, vol. 66, supplement 10, pp. 3–8, 2005.
- V. Eapen, A. A. Mabrouk, T. Zoubeidi, and F. Yunis, “Prevalence of pervasive developmental disorders in preschool children in the UAE,” Journal of Tropical Pediatrics, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 202–205, 2007.
- H. Hussein, G. R. A. Taha, and A. Almanasef, “Characteristics of autism spectrum disorders in a sample of Egyptian and Saudi patients: transcultural cross sectional study,” Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health, vol. 5, article 34, 2011.
- M. Davidovitch, B. Hemo, P. Manning-Courtney, and E. Fombonne, “Prevalence and incidence of autism spectrum disorder in an Israeli population,” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, vol. 43, no. 4, pp. 785–793, 2013.
- Y. Senecky, G. Chodick, G. Diamond, D. Lobel, R. Drachman, and D. Inbar, “Time trends in reported autistic spectrum disorders in Israel, 1972–2004,” Israel Medical Association Journal, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 30–33, 2009.
- A. Pedersen, S. Pettygrove, F. J. Meaney et al., “Prevalence of autism spectrum disorders in hispanic and non-hispanic white children,” Pediatrics, vol. 129, no. 3, pp. e629–e635, 2012.
- E. Schopler, R. J. Reichler, R. F. DeVellis, and K. Daly, “Toward objective classification of childhood autism: Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS),” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 91–103, 1980.
- Israel Central Bureau of Statistics, 2012, http://www.cbs.gov.il/.
- I. Kamp-Becker, J. Schröder, H. Remschmidt, and C. J. Bachmann, “Health-related quality of life in adolescents and young adults with high functioning autism-spectrum disorder,” Psycho-Social Medicine, vol. 7, Article ID Doc03, 2010.
- M. Rutter, “Autism research: lessons from the past and prospects for the future,” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, vol. 35, no. 2, pp. 241–257, 2005.
- M. Elsabbagh, G. Divan, Y. J. Koh et al., “Global prevalence of autism and other pervasive developmental disorders,” Autism Research, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 160–179, 2012.
- R. Muhle, S. V. Trentacoste, and I. Rapin, “The genetics of autism,” Pediatrics, vol. 113, no. 5, pp. e472–e486, 2004.
- J. T. Glessner, K. Wang, G. Cai et al., “Autism genome-wide copy number variation re-veals ubiquitin and neuronal genes,” Nature, vol. 459, no. 7246, pp. 569–573, 2009.
- J. F. Shelton, D. J. Tancredi, and I. Hertz-Picciotto, “Independent and dependent contributions of advanced maternal and paternal ages to autism risk,” Autism Research, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 30–39, 2010.
- M. M. Afifi, “Mental health publications from the Arab world cited in PubMed, 1987–2002,” Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 319–328, 2005.
- Y. M. Al-Farsi, M. M. Al-Sharbati, O. A. Al-Farsi, M. S. Al-Shafaee, D. R. Brooks, and M. I. Waly, “Brief report: prevalence of autistic spectrum disorders in the Sultanate of Oman,” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 821–825, 2011.
- A. Okasha, “Focus on psychiatry in Egypt,” British Journal of Psychiatry, vol. 185, pp. 266–272, 2004.
- S. M. Al-Salehi, E. H. Al-Hifthy, and M. Ghaziuddin, “Autism in Saudi Arabia: presentation, clinical correlates and comorbidity,” Transcultural Psychiatry, vol. 46, no. 2, pp. 340–347, 2009.
- M. Amr, W. Bu Ali, H. Hablas et al., “Sociodemographic factors in Arab children with autism spectrum disorders,” The Pan African Medical Journal, vol. 13, article 65, 2012.
- A. Hamadé, P. Salameh, M. Medlej-Hashim, E. Hajj-Moussa, N. Saadallah-Zeidan, and F. Rizk, “Autism in children and correlates in Lebanon: a pilot case-control study,” Journal of Research in Health Sciences, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 119–124, 2013.
- R. Sharkia, A. Azem, Q. Kaiyal, N. Zelnik, and M. Mahajnah, “Mental retardation and consanguinity in a selected region of the Israeli Arab Community,” Central European Journal of Medicine, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 91–96, 2010.
Copyright © 2015 Muhammad Mahajnah et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.