Authors Study Device Healthcare provider FPIS OPIS [ 95% CI [ 95% CI Ratajczyk et al., 2013 [48 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 30 27, 90.0 79.3%–100.0% NS — Ozgul et al., 2013 [47 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS II Physicians 80 75, 93.8 88.4%–99.1% 80, 100.0 96.4%–100.0% Russo et al., 2012 [50 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS-D Physicians 40 21, 52.5 37.0%–68.0% 28, 70.0 55.8%–84.2% Esa et al., 2011 [35 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS II Physicians 27 24, 88.9 77.0%–100.0% 27, 100.0 89.6%–100.0% Schalk et al., 2011 [51 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS-D Physicians 105 NS — 84, 80.0 72.3%–87.7% Amini et al., 2010 [23 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS-D/LTS II Physicians 60 54, 90.0 82.4%–97.6% 58, 96.0 92.1%–100.0% Thee et al., 2010 [52 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS-D/LTS II Physicians 60 57, 95.0 89.5%–100.0% 59, 98.3 95.1%–100.0% Klaver et al., 2007 [42 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 82 56, 68.0 58.2%–78.4% NS — Cavus et al., 2009 [29 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 22 18, 82.0 65.7%–97.9% 21, 96.0 86.8%–100.0% Kikuchi et al., 2008 [41 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS II Physicians 50 30, 60.0 46.4%–73.6% 37, 74.0 61.8%–86.2% Zand et al., 2007 [56 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 50 43, 86.0 76.4%–95.6% 49, 98.0 94.1%–100.0% Yildiz et al., 2007 [55 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 66 56, 84.8 76.2%–93.5% 66, 100.0 95.6%–100.0% Genzwuerker et al., 2007 [39 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS II Physicians 50 44, 88.0 79.0%–97.0% 48, 96.0 90.6%–100.0% Amini et al., 2007 [22 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT-D, LT-R Physicians 100 93, 93.0 88.0%–98.0% 98, 98.0 95.3%–100.0% Mihai et al., 2007 [44 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS II Physicians 100 71, 71.0 62.1%–79.9% 100, 100.0 97.1%–100.0% Noor Zairul and Khairul Faizi, 2006 [45 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 20 20, 100.0 86.1%–100.0% 20, 100.0 86.1%–100.0% Turan et al., 2006 [53 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 30 21, 69.0 53.6%–86.4% 23, 76.0 61.5%–91.8% Bein et al., 2005 [27 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 30 28, 93.3 84.4%–100.0% 30, 100.0 90.6%–100.0% Cook and Cranshaw, 2005 [30 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 32 22, 68.8 52.7%–84.8% NS — Roth et al., 2005 [49 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 25 23, 92.0 81.4%–100.0% 25, 100.0 88.8%–100.0% Komatsu et al., 2005 [43 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 51 16, 31.4 18.6%–44.1% 42, 82.4 71.9%–92.8% Gaitini et al., 2004 [38 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 75 60, 80.0 70.9%–89.1% 71, 94.7 89.6%–99.8% Wrobel et al., 2004 [54 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 50 45, 90.0 81.7%–98.3% 47, 94.0 87.4%–100.0% Figueredo et al., 2003 [36 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 35 18, 51.0 34.9%–68.0% 24, 97.0 53.2%–84.0% Cook et al., 2003 [31 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 32 NS — 30, 93.8 85.4%–100.0% Cook et al., 2003 [32 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 36 31, 86.1 74.8%–97.4% 35, 97.2 91.9%–100.0% Genzwürker et al., 2003 [40 ] p, in-hospital, elective LTS Physicians 30 27, 90.0 79.3%–100.0% 29, 96.7 90.2%–100.0% Gaitini et al., 2003 [37 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 175 159, 94.0 86.6%–95.1% 169, 96.6 93.9%–99.3% Asai et al., 2003 [26 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 100 90, 90.0 84.1%–95.9% 97, 97.0 93.7%–100.0% Dörges et al., 2003 [33 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 32 32, 100.0 91.1%–100.0% 32, 100.0 91.1%–100.0% Figueredo et al., 2003 [36 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 35 18, 51.0 34.9%–68.0% 34, 97.0 91.6%–100.0% Ocker et al., 2002 [46 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 25 25, 100.0 88.8%–100.0% 25, 100.0 88.8%–100.0% Brimacombe et al., 2002 [28 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 60 52, 87.0 78.1%–95.3% 55, 92.0 84.7%–98.7% Asai et al., 2002 [24 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 22 19, 86.4 72.0%–100.0% 21, 95.5 86.8%–100.0% Asai et al., 2000 [25 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 50 47, 94.0 87.4%–100.0% NS — Dörges et al., 2000 [34 ] p, in-hospital, elective LT Physicians 30 30, 100.0 90.6%–100.0% 30, 100.0 90.6%–100.0% Cumulative sum ( ) 1897 1452/1760 1594/1703 (%) 82.5 80.7%–84.3% 93.6 92.4%–94.8%
