Research Article

Systematic Comparison of Brain Imaging Meta-Analyses of ToM with vPT

Table 1

Predictions of overlap of vPT with theory of mind according to various proposals.

ProposalmPFCRight TPJ/IPLLeft TPJ/IPLTPJ/pSTSIFG

(1)Amodio & Frith [31]Yes
(2)Gallagher et al. (2003)(Yes)
(3)Schurz et al. [14]YesYesYesYes
(4)Van Overwalle [32]NoYesYes
(5)Gobbini et al. [33]NoNoNo
(6)Mar [34]NoNo
(7)Saxe et al. [35]
 (a) Propositional content(Yes)
 (b) Belief & thoughtsNo
(8)Perner & Leekam [36](Yes)No
(9)C. D. Frith & U. Frith [37]No
(10)Samson & Apperly [38]possiblyYesYes: right
ObservedNoNoYesNoYes: left

Note: for predictions in parenthesis it is assumed that vPT tasks engage level 2 perspective taking processes.