Review Article

Phytotherapy and Nutritional Supplements on Breast Cancer

Table 2

The main clinical effects of the most common nutritional supplements used in breast cancer.

Nutritional supplementsDisease phasesTrials versus nontrialsMain effects from clinical studiesType of clinical studyRef.

Multivitamins and antioxidantsRisk0/7(i) Supplementation of multivitamins and antioxidants in postmenopausal women may protect women from developing breast cancerCase control[104]
(ii) High frequency and long duration multivitamins consumption was associated with an increase of breast cancer riskProspective cohort[105]
(iii) Multivitamins consumption was not associated with breast cancer riskCase control[106]
(iv) Little inverse association between the use of multivitamins among white women and no evidence of reduced breast cancer risk among black women were reportedCase control[107]
(v) No association was verified between dietary intake of antioxidant vitamins and breast cancer riskCase control[108]
(vi) Dietary intake of beta-carotene, vitamin C, and vitamin E was not related to breast cancer risk in pre- nor postmenopausal womenProspective cohort[109]
(vii) Dietary antioxidant was associated with a lower risk of breast cancer and reduced mortality rateProspective cohort[110]
Prognostic0/4(i) Use of multivitamins by postmenopausal women with invasive breast cancer had lower breast cancer mortality than nonusersProspective cohort[111]
(ii) Posttreatment use of antioxidant supplements was associated with an improved survival in breast cancer patients from the United States and ChinaMeta-analysis of cohort studies[112]
(iii) Consumption of multivitamins improved outcomes related to breast cancer recurrence and survival after two years after diagnosisCohort[113]
(iv) Breast cancer survival was not improved by multivitamin treatment in nonmetastatic breast cancer diagnosed womenCohort[114]

Vitamin A and carotenoidsRisk0/7(i) No significant association was established between plasma retinol and vitamin A and breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of case-control studies[115]
(ii) Plasma β-carotene was inverse associated with overall cancer risk, including breast cancerNested case control[116]
(iii) High carotenoids consumption may reduce breast cancer risk in premenopausal but not in postmenopausalCase control[117]
(iv) Dietary intake of lycopene, beta-carotene, and beta-cryptoxanthin was associated with a lower breast cancer risk among Chinese women. No association was found for alpha-carotene and lutein/zeaxanthinCase control[118]
(v) Serum alpha-carotene and beta-carotene were inversely associated with breast cancer riskProspective cohort[119]
(vi) Dietary intake of alpha-carotene, beta-carotene, and lycopene are inversely associated with invasive breast cancers risk. No association was observed with the intake of lutein + zeaxanthin and beta-cryptoxanthinProspective cohort[120]
(vii) Higher concentrations of plasma β-carotene and α-carotene were associated with a lower breast cancer riskNested case control[121]
Prognostic0/1(i) Positive relationship was reported between a high plasma carotenoids levels and breast cancer survivalsCohort[122]

Vitamin CRisk0/3(i) High dose vitamin C intake (>1000 mg) was associated with a history of breast cancerCross sectional[123]
(ii) High dietary vitamin C intake was associated with an increased breast cancer risk among postmenopausal womenCross sectional[124]
(iii) Plasma vitamin C was inversely associated with breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of observational studies[115]
Prognostic0/2(i) Prediagnosis intake was positively associated with breast cancer survival while postdiagnosis was notCohort[125]
(ii) Postdiagnosis vitamin C supplement or dietary intake was associated with a reduced risk of breast cancer-specific mortalityMeta-analysis of cohort studies[126]
Side effects1/4(i) Supplementation of vitamin C (500 mg) and vitamin E (400 mg) during tamoxifen treatment reduced the tamoxifen-induced hypertriglyceridemiaCohort[127]
(ii) Supplementation of vitamin C (500 mg) and vitamin E (400 mg) restored antioxidant enzyme status and DNA damage lowered in breast cancer and chemotherapyRandom clinical trial[128]
(iii) The IV administration of 50 g twice a week decreased fatigue and insomnia and increased cognitive function in a woman with recurrent breast cancer undergoing weekly chemotherapyCase report[129]
(iv) The IV administration of 7.5 g resulted in a significant reduction of complaints induced by the disease and chemo/radiotherapy, without side effectsCohort[130]

Vitamin EPrognostic0/1(i) Vitamin E appears to be a factor in poor prognosis for breast cancer survivalCohort[131]
Side effects2/5(i) Supplementation of vitamin C (500 mg) and vitamin E (400 mg) during tamoxifen treatment reduced the tamoxifen-induced hypertriglyceridemiaCohort[127]
(ii) Supplementation of vitamin C (500 mg) and vitamin E (400 mg) restored antioxidant enzyme status and DNA damage lowered in breast cancer and chemotherapyRandom clinical trial[128]
(iii) Alpha-tocopherol acetate (400 mg) supplementation increased biomarkers of estrogen-stimulation when coadministrated with tamoxifenCase control[132]
(iv) Association of 400 mg pentoxifylline and 100 mg of vitamin E after radiotherapy in breast cancer women may be used to prevent radiation-induced side effectsRandom placebo-controlled clinical trial[133, 134]

Vitamin D and calciumRisk2/41(i) Vitamin D deficiency is highly prevalent in breast cancer patientsCross-sectional analytical study[135]
(ii) No association was observed between vitamin D supplementation and breast cancer risk in postmenopausal womenMeta-analysis of random clinical trials[136]
(iii) No association was verified between vitamin D supplementation and breast cancer risk in young womenCase control[137]
(iv) No association was established between vitamin D intake and breast cancerCohort[138]
(v) Long-term calcium intake was not related to breast cancer riskProspective cohort[139]
(vi) Calcium intake from several sources was not associated with breast cancer risk in Chinese womenCase control[140]
(vii) No association was found between dietary intake of vitamin D and calcium and breast cancer riskCohort[141]
Case control[142]
(viii) No association was reported between daily use of 1000 mg of calcium carbonate and 400 IU of vitamin D3 and benign proliferative breast disease riskRandom placebo-controlled clinical trial[143, 144]
(ix) No association was verified between vitamin D3 serum levels and breast cancerNested case control[145]
Cohort[146]
(x) No association was established between vitamin D and calcium serum levels and breast cancer riskCohort[147]
(xi) Serum calcium levels was not related to breast cancer in Asian populationCohort[148]
(xii) Dairy products were not associated with breast cancer riskCase control[149]
Cohort[150, 151]
(xiii) UV light combined with dietary vitamin D intake was associated with a lower breast cancer risk in high latitudesCohort[152]
(xiv) Dietary vitamin D was associated with a decrease in breast cancer riskCase control[153]
(xv) Vitamin D supplements demonstrated a protective effect in breast cancer risk compared with nonuser Pakistani womenCase control[154]
(xvi) Vitamin D intake protects from breast cancer risk in premenopausal womenCase control[155]
(xvii) Dietary vitamin D and calcium intakes were associated with a decrease in breast cancer riskCase control[156]
(xviii) Dietary vitamin D and calcium intakes were inversely related to breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of observational studies[157]
(xix) Breast cancer risk presented an inverse relationship between vitamin D intake in premenopausal and calcium intake in postmenopausal womenCase control[158]
(xx) Higher plasma vitamin D3 was associated with a decreased breast cancer risk for women with a lower BMI; in higher alcohol intakes, lower levels of vitamin D3 are associated with an increase in breast cancer riskNested case control[159]
(xxi) Serum vitamin D was associated with a decrease in breast cancer riskCase control[150, 160166]
(xxii) Daily intake of 600 mg calcium + 400 IU vitamin D and 30 ng/ml of serum vitamin D adequate to lower breast cancer riskDose-response meta-analysis of observational studies[156]
(xxiii) Higher plasma vitamin D and moderate physical activity are protective factor while family history and menopause are a risk factorCase control[167]
(xxiv) Serum vitamin D levels > 27 ng/ml may reduce breast cancer risk in postmenopausal women but not in premenopauseDose-response meta-analysis of prospective studies[168]
(xxv) Serum calcium were inversely associated with breast cancer in premenopausal women and the opposite occurred in overweight postmenopausal womenProspective cohort[169]
(xxvi) Serum calcium and vitamin D3 levels were inversely associated with breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of prospective studies[170, 171]
(xxvii) U-shape association between vitamin D plasma levels and cancer risk and inverse association with calcium serum levels were establishedCohort[172]
(xxviii) U-shape association was reported between vitamin D3 plasma levels and cancer risk and prognosisNested case control[173]
Polymorphism0/5(i) Presence of BB genotype of vitamin D receptor was associated with a significantly lower risk of advanced breast cancerCase control[174]
(ii) GC and vitamin D receptor gene polymorphism relationship with breast cancer may be altered by menopausal status and type of cancerCase control[175]
(iii) VDR polymorphism determines breast cancer riskCase control[176178]
Prognostic0/8(i) Vitamin D intake was not associated with breast cancer recurrenceNested case control[179]
(ii) High calcium/magnesium ratio was related to an improved breast cancer survivalCohort[180]
(iii) Breast cancer women with deficient vitamin D levels had an increased risk of recurrence and deadCohort[181]
(iv) Higher vitamin D serum levels may be associated with improved breast cancer survival but without statistical significanceCohort[182]
(v) Lower serum vitamin D level was associated with aggressive subtypes of cancerCase control[177, 183, 184]
(vi) Calcium serum levels was positively related to breast tumour aggressivenessProspective cohort[185]
Side effects5/9(i) Daily dose 400 UI vitamin D3 for 1 year during and after chemotherapy was not sufficient to increase vitamin D deficiency in breast cancerCohort[186]
(ii) No differences in aromatase inhibitors side effects were found between vitamin D3 daily doses of 600 UI and 4000 UIRandom double-blind clinical trial phase III[187]
(iii) Daily 10000 IU of vitamin D3 and 1000 mg of calcium supplementation in breast cancer patients with bone metastasis reduced elevated parathyroid hormone levels but had no beneficial palliative or bone resorptionNonrandom clinical trial phase II[188]
(iv) Doses of 500–1500 mg calcium and 200–1000 IU vitamin D were insufficient to prevent bone lossSystematic review of clinical trials[189]
(v) Vitamin D supplementation (50,000 IU/week) may reduce side effects of aromatase inhibitorsCohort[190]
(vi) Weekly dose of vitamin D reduced aromatase inhibitor side effectsRandom placebo-controlled clinical trial[191]
(vii) Vitamin D3 and calcium supplementation (2000 IU/1000 mg and 4000 IU/1000 mg) increased serum vitamin D3 concentrations and improved arthralgia induced by aromatase inhibitorsNonrandom clinical trial[192]
(viii) Serum vitamin D3 target of 40 ng/ml reduced arthralgia related to aromatase inhibitorsCohort[193]
(ix) Vitamin D supplementation may improve bone loss if target serum levels achieve 30 ng/mlCohort[194]

B complex vitaminsRisk1/31(i) Superior plasma folate levels may be associated with an increased breast cancer risk in women with a BRCA1/2 mutationProspective Cohort[195]
(ii) Daily supplementation of folic acid (2.5 mf of folate), vitamin B6 (50 mg), and vitamin B12 (1 mg) had no effect on overall risk of total invasive cancer or breast cancer among women during the folic acid fortification eraRandom, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial[196]
(iii) Dietary folate intake has no significant effect on the breast cancer risk. Daily 220 μg increment in dietary folate intake was not associated with the risk of breast cancerSystematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies[197]
(iv) Dietary folate intake and blood folate levels did not associate with breast cancer risk and this did not vary by menopausal status or hormonal receptor statusMeta-analysis of prospective and case-control studies[198]
(v) Weak evidence of an inverse relationship between breast cancer risk and riboflavin intake and a positive association with vitamin B12 were established. No association varied by tumour hormone receptor statusProspective cohort[199]
(vi) No evidence that high folate intakes (dietary and supplementation) before diagnosis adversely affect breast cancer survival after chemotherapyProspective cohort[200]
(vii) Scientific evidence does not support the hypothesis that higher dietary folate intakes reduce the risk for breast cancerSystematic review of clinical studies[201]
(viii) Little or no association was reported between of plasma folate, pyridoxal 5-phosphate (i.e., the principal active form of vitamin B6), and vitamin B12 levels and breast cancer riskProspective cohort[202]
(ix) Unclear association between plasma folate and vitamin B12 levels and overall breast cancer riskProspective cohort[203]
(x) The red blood cell folate levels were not associated with breast cancer riskCase control[204]
(xi) Little or no association was shown between dietary folate intake and breast cancer risk; in addition, a dose-response meta-analysis suggested a J-shaped relationship between folate intake and breast cancer riskDose-response meta-analysis of prospective studies[205]
(xii) Dietary folate intake was not associated with breast cancer risk but may be inversely associated with ER-positive /PR-negative tumours in Swedish patientsCase control[206]
(xiii) Weak association was reported between dietary vitamin B2 intake and reduced breast cancer riskSystematic review and meta-analysis of epidemiologic studies[207]
(xiv) Dietary folate and vitamin B6 intakes were inversely associated with breast cancer risk by both ER and PR status in Chinese womenCase control[208]
(xv) High dietary vitamin B6 intake is associated with a lower risk of developing ER-negative breast cancer in Taiwanese womenCase control[209]
(xvi) High dietary folate intake was associated with a lower incidence of postmenopausal breast cancerProspective cohort[210]
(xvii) High dietary folate intake was associated with a reduced breast cancer risk in French women. Vitamin B12 intake may alter this associationProspective cohort[211]
(xviii) Dietary folate intake was inversely associated with breast cancer risk. Dietary methionine, vitamin B12, and vitamin B6 (i.e., folate cofactors) intakes were not independently related to risk of breast cancer; however, they may modify the effect of folateCase control[212]
(xix) Higher dietary folate intake is slightly associated with a lower risk for ER-negative breast cancer, and high vitamin B12 and methionine intakes are marginally associated with a lower risk of ER-positive breast cancer among Hispanic and non-Hispanic white women in the southwestern USMulticentered, population-based case control[213]
(xx) High dietary folate intake may diminish breast cancer risk and this relationship may differ by menopausal and ER/PR status in Chinese patientsProspective cohort[214]
(xxi) Adequate folate intake may reduce the increased breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of prospective and case-control studies[215]
(xxii) Inverse association was verified between plasma folate levels and breast cancer risk was highly among women consuming at least 15 g/day of alcohol. Plasma vitamin B12 levels were inversely associated with breast cancer risk among premenopausal women but not among postmenopausal women. Plasma homocysteine levels was not associated with breast cancer riskNested case control[216]
(xxiii) Serum pyridoxal 5-phosphate (i.e., the principal active form of vitamin B6) levels and dietary methionine intakes are associated with a reduced breast cancer risk, especially in postmenopausal womenDose-response meta-analysis[217]
(xxiv) High plasma vitamin B6 levels may diminish the breast cancer risk, particularly of ER-positive breast cancer; high plasma riboflavin levels may decrease the risk of breast cancer in premenopausal but not postmenopausal women; and plasma homocysteine and the other B vitamins (e.g., folate and vitamin B12) levels do not appear to influence breast cancer riskNested case control[218]
Polymorphism0/7(i) Association between MTHFR C667T polymorphism and breast cancer risk and no association between dietary folate intake and MTHFR C677T polymorphisms were establishedCase control[219]
(ii) Neither dietary folate and related B vitamins intakes nor MTHFR or MTR genotypes were overall associated with breast cancer risk in Japanese women. Associations of nutrients with breast cancer risk did not differ by hormone receptors statusCase control[220]
(iii) Association was observed between MTHFR C677T and MTR A2756G polymorphisms and breast cancer risk. Dietary folate, vitamin B6, and vitamin B12 intakes influence these associationsCase control[221]
(iv) Significant association was observed between MTHFR C667T polymorphism, dietary folate, and vitamin B6 intake and breast cancer risk and an interaction between MTHFR C667T polymorphism and folate intake on the breast cancer riskCase control[222]
(v) Vitamin B12 seems to reduce the risk of breast cancer, and MTHFR 665TT was associated with an increased breast cancer risk. Folate and vitamin B12 intakes and MTHFRC677T and MTHFR A1298C polymorphisms showed no association with breast cancer risk. THFR C665T genotype and low vitamin B6 intake are associated with an increased in breast cancer risk among Chinese populationCase control[223]
(vi) Neither dietary folate, vitamin B6, or vitamin B12 intakes nor MTHFR polymorphisms were independently associated with breast cancer risk. Increased breast cancer risk was observed in MTR 2756GG genotype and in premenopausal women with high folate intake among Brazilian womenCase control[224]
(vii) Dietary folate and cobalamin intakes are inversely associated with methylated retinoic acid receptor-beta (RARB) and breast cancer-1 (BRCA1) genes. High dietary riboflavin and pyridoxine intakes are associated with increased methylation in the RARB promoter in Iranian patientsProspective cohort[225]
Prognostic(i) Dietary vitamins B1 and B3 intake was associated with improved survival among women with breast cancer. MTHFR 677T polymorphism reduced all-cause mortality and breast cancer-specific mortalityCohort[226]
(ii) Superior prophylactic effect of niacinamide compared to standard care for avoiding cutaneous symptoms and maintaining life quality of breast cancer patients while undergoing cytostatic treatmentMulticentre randomized crossover trial[227]

Omega 3 PUFAsRisk4/16(i) Comparable doses of marine ω-3 in dietary fish or in supplement provided increased plasma EPA and DHA in plasma, erythrocyte membranes, and breast adipose in women with a high risk of breast cancer. Increases in breast adipose EPA and DHA were the same for both groupsRandom clinical trial[228]
(ii) Total PUFAs were associated with increased overall and breast cancer risk in the placebo group, whereas this relationship was not observed in the antioxidant-supplemented group (antioxidants preserve essential PUFAs from peroxidation)Nested case control[229]
(iii) No association was observed between EPA and DHA intake from fish oil supplements and breast cancer outcomes. Marine fatty acids from food reduced risk of additional breast cancer events and all-cause mortality in breast cancer survivorsCohort[230]
(iv) No association was established between dietary total fat and fatty acids, including ω-3 PUFAs and breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of prospective cohort studies[231]
(v) No association was reported between total or individual marine -3 PUFA in adipose tissue and breast cancer riskCase cohort[232]
(vi) No association was observed between fish consumption and breast cancer riskMeta-analysis of observational studies[233]
Prospective cohort[234]
(vii) Current use of fish oil may be inversely associated with ductal breast cancer risk in postmenopausal womenCohort[235]
(viii) Fish oil consumption had a protective effect in breast cancerCase control[236]
(ix) Omega 3 PUFAs presented a preventive action in postmenopausal womenCase control[236]
Cohort[237]
(x) Inverse relationship was established between dietary marine -3 PUFA and breast cancer riskMeta-analysis and systematic review of prospective cohort studies[238]
(xi) Higher omega 3 : omega 6 ratio intake and breast cancer risk had an inverse associationMeta-analysis of prospective studies[239]
Prospective cohort[240]
(xii) Consumption of high levels of ω-3 and low levels of ω-6 had a reduced breast cancer risk, compared to women who consume low levels of ω-3 and high levels of ω-6 among Long Island, New York, residentsCase control[241]
(xiii) A minimum daily dose of 2.52 g EPA + DHA is required to increase their concentrations in breast adipose tissue. Daily doses up to 7.56 g of DHA and EPA were well tolerated with optimal compliance. BMI and baseline fatty acid concentrations modulated the dose-response outcomes of ω-3 PUFAs supplements on serum EPA and DHA and breast adipose tissue DHA in women at high risk of breast cancerRandom open-label dose-finding study
[242]
(xiv) Primary prevention trial of high dose EPA and DHA ethyl esters at a daily dose of 3.36 g (1860 mg EPA +1500 mg DHA) resulted in a good uptake, excellent tolerability, and retention in postmenopausal women. Increase ω-3 PUFAs (EPA+DHA): ω-6 AA ratio in erythrocyte and benign breast tissue phospholipids provided a favourable modulation in several biomarkers of breast cancer risk and inflammatory processPhase II pilot study[243]
(xv) Increase in plasma DHA was associated with a decrease in absolute breast density (i.e., a validated biomarker of breast cancer risk) but only in obese women (BMI > 29)Open-label random clinical trial[244]
Treatment3/3(i) Combination of omega 3 (4 g) and raloxifene (30 mg) reduced IGF-1 levels and improved serum lipids, antioxidant, and anti-inflammatory activitiesRandom controlled placebo clinical trial[245, 246]
(ii) Combination of DHA to an ROS-generating chemotherapy regime was safe and retained significant antitumour activity in metastatic breast cancer patients with high plasma DHA incorporationPilot open-label single-arm phase II clinical trial[247]
(iii) High dose EPA and DHA supplementation (4 g/day) for 3 months increased serum EPA and DHA levels and total and long-chain ω-3 PUFAs and decreased arachidonic acid, total and long-chain ω-6 PUFAs, and the ω-6 : ω-3 PUFAs ratio compared to placebo. This dose also reduced bone resorptionRandom, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study[248]

AA: arachidonic acid; BMI: body mass index; BRCA1: breast cancer-1 gene; DHA: docosahexaenoic acid; EPA: eicosapentaenoic acid; ER: oestrogen receptor; GC: gene encoding vitamin D binding protein; IGF-1: insulin-like growth factor; IV: intravenous; MTHFR: 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase; MTR: methionine synthase; PR: progesterone receptor; PUFAs: polyunsaturated fatty acids; RARB: retinoic acid receptor-beta gene; VDR: vitamin D receptor.