Review Article

Diagnostic Accuracy of the Xpert MTB/RIF Assay for Lymph Node Tuberculosis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Characteristics of the included studies. FNA: fine needle aspiration. CRS: composite reference standard. TP: true positive. FP: false positive. FN: false negative. TN: true negative.

AuthorYearCountyTPFPFNTNSpecimen typeReference standardDecontaminate methodSample conditionLocationHomogenisationSample ratioPatient selection method

Causse, M.2011Spain160170TissueCutureNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralNo2:1consecutive

Vadwai, V.a2011India321712127TissueCutureNoFreshPeripheralMechanical2:1consecutive

Vadwai, V.b2011India49117122TissueCRSNoFreshPeripheralMechanical2:1consecutive

Armand, S2011France8082TissueCutureNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralMechanical3:1Convenience

Hillemann, D.2011Germany63452TissueCutureNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralMechanical3:1Consecutive

Zeka, A. N.a2011Turkey112310TissueCutureNoFrozenPeripheralNo3:1Consecutive

Zeka, A. N.b2011Turkey13049TissueCRSNoFrozenPeripheralNo3:1Consecutive

Ligthelm, L. J.a2011South Africa292116FNACRSNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Consecutive

Ligthelm, L. J.b2011South Africa283116FNACutureNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Consecutive

Malbruny, B.2011France60017FNACutureNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralMechanical3:1Convenience

Moure, R.2012Spain240104TissueCutureNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralMechanical2:1Convenience

Tortoli, E.a2012Italy244585TissueCutureNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralMechanical2:1Convenience

Tortoli, E.b2012Italy280585TissueCRSNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralMechanical2:1Convenience

Van Rie, A.a2013South Africa1392310172FNACutureNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Consecutive

Van Rie, A.b2013South Africa160242144FNACRSNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Consecutive

Ablanedo-Terrazas, Y.2014Mexico150053FNACutureNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralNo2:1Convenience

Biadglegne, F.2014Ethiopia29563132FNACutureNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralNo3:1Convenience

Coetzee, L.2014South Africa2113434FNACRSNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Convenience

Dhasmana, D. J.2014United Kingdom2431277FNACRSNoFreshMediastinalNoUnknowConvenience

Scott, L. E.2014South Africa1614450FNACutureNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralNo2:1Convenience

Salvador, F.a2015Spain5622FNACutureNoFreshPeripheralNoUnknowConvenience

Salvador, F.b2015Spain6034TissueCutureNoFreshPeripheralNoUnknowConvenience

Tadesse, M.2015Ethiopia7671142FNACRSNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralMechanical3:1Consecutive

Bholla, M.2016Tanzania113840FNACRSNoFreshPeripheralNo3:1Convenience

Dhooria, S.2016India2622792FNACRSNoFreshMediastinalNo2:1Convenience

Suzana, S.a2016India1919127TissueCutureNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Consecutive

Suzana, S.b2016India3801811TissueCRSNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Consecutive

Wang Xiao2016China12407FNACutureNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Convenience

Nataraj, G.2016India291987FNACutureNoFreshPeripheralNo2:1Convenience

Xu Meili2016China730740FNACRSNoFreshPeripheral/MediastinalMechanical2:1Convenience

Huang Shaojun.a2016China480213FNACRSNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralMechanical2:1Convenience

Huang Shaojun.b2016China260513TissueCRSNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralMechanical2:1Convenience

Pandey, S.a2017Australia9113FNACutureNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralNo3:1Convenience

Pandey, S.b2017Australia5231TissueCutureNALC-NaOHFreshPeripheralNo3:1Convenience

Jorstad, M. D.2018Zanzibar601620FNACRSNoFreshPeripheralNoUnknowConvenience

Perez-Risco, D.2018Spain16018FNACutureNALC-NaOHFrozenPeripheralNo2:1Convenience