[Retracted] Outcomes of Renal Stone Surgery Performed Either as Predonation or Ex Vivo Bench Procedure in Renal Grafts from Living Donors: A Systematic Review

Table 1

Study features and baseline characteristics of living kidney donors and recipients.

Author, year of publication	Study period	Study design	Sample size ()	Donor’s age (years), mean (range)	Donor’s gender M : F	Graft side Ri : Le	Stone location (n)	Stone size, mm mean (range)	Recipient’s age (years), mean (range)	Recipient’s gender M : F
Rashid et al., [18]	1996-2000	R	10	45.0 (27-58)	4 : 6	n/a	3^uc; 3^mc; 4^lc	5.2 (1-8)	41.5 (18-72)	6 : 4
Yiğit et al., [21]	1999-2003	P	2	29.5 (30-49)	2 : 0	n/a	n/a	6.0 (5-7)	n/a	n/a
Trivedi et al., [19]	2007	CR	1	n/a	n/a	n/a	1^lc	5.0 (n/a)	n/a	n/a
Schade et al.,[23]	1996-2010	R	23	44.0 (24-67)	8 : 15	n/a	5^uc; 10^mc; 13^lc	3.9 (3-6)	41.5 (3-72)	13 : 10
Vasdev et al.,[9]	2004-2008	R	3	47.6 (46-50)	n/a	0 : 3	1^mc; 2^lc	3.6 (3-5)	29.3 (22–51)	n/a
Olsburgh et al., [13]	2005-2011	R	17	45.0 (22-67)	n/a	8 : 12	5^uc; 5^mc; 10^lc	2.5 (2-12)	39.0 (1-66)	n/a
Ganpule et al., [20]	n/a	R	12	52.3 (38-71)	4 : 8	3 : 3	2^mc; 5^lc	4.9 (1.8-6)	n/a	n/a
Pushkar et al., [22]	2013-2014	P	14	44.8 (27-64)	5 : 9	4 : 10	7^uc; 5^mc; 4^lc	6.3 (4-10)	n/a	n/a
Lin et al., [10]	2010-2015	R	10	48.8 (28-58)	4 : 6	0 : 10	1^uc; 3^mc; 6^lc	5.8 (2-9)	n/a	n/a
Sarier et al., [11]	2009-2016	R	13	52.3 (40-72)	6 : 7	n/a	3^uc; 5^mc; 4^lc; 1^p	9.1 (5-15)	n/a	n/a
Barki et al., [8]	2020	CR	1	60.0 (n/a)	0 : 1	0 : 1	1^uc	9.0 (n/a)	22.0 (n/a)	1 : 0

CR: case report; F: female; Le: left; M: male; n/a: not available; P: prospective; R: retrospective; Ri: right; ^ucUpper calyx; ^mcmiddle calyx; ^lclower calyx; ^ppelvis.