[Retracted] Outcomes of Renal Stone Surgery Performed Either as Predonation or Ex Vivo Bench Procedure in Renal Grafts from Living Donors: A Systematic Review

Table 4

Bench stone surgery: technique and outcomes.

Author, year of publication

Type of surgery ()

Instrumentation for access to the pyelocaliceal system type ()

Instrumentation for stone fragmentation/extraction type ()

OT min, mean (range)

Success : failed

Bench surgery complication, type ()

Donors’ follow-up (months), mean (range)

Donors’ late postoperative complications ()

Recipients’ early postoperative complication type, (grade)

Recipients’ follow-up (months), mean (range)

Recipients’ late postoperative complication type ()

Stone recurrence in the graft ()

Rashid et al., [18]

URS (10)

6.9 Fr su (9); 9.5 Fr fu (1)

Holmium laser lithotripsy (6); Basketing (3); Negative ureteroscopy (1)

6.5 (3-28)

10 : 0

0

36.4 (8-60)

0

0

33.2 (18-60)

Ischemic fistula (1)

0

Yiğit et al., [21]

PLT (1)

n/a

n/a

n/a

1 : 0

0

n/a

0

0

n/a

n/a

0

Trivedi et al., [19]

URS (1)

8.5 Fr su (1)

Pneumatic+forceps (1)

n/a

1 : 0

0

n/a

0

0

24.0 (n/a)

0

0

Schade et al., [23]

URS (23)

6.9 Fr su (21); 9.5 Fr fu (2)

Holmium laser lithotripsy (6); Basketing (12); Negative ureteroscopy (4)

6.2 (3-16)

22 : 1

0

63.0 (n/a)

n/a

Ureteroneocystostomy stenosis, 1 (n/a); Wound cellulitis, 1 (II); Lymphocele, 3 (>II); Death, 1 (V)

63.0 (16-110)

Transplant nephrectomy (1); Hemodialysis (1)

0

Vasdev et al., [9]

URS (3)

7.5 Fr fu (3)

Basketing (3)

n/a

3 : 0

0

64.0 (48-84)

0

0

64.0 (48-84)

0

0

Olsburgh et al., [13]

URS (17)

7.5 Fr fu (17)

Holmium laser lithotripsy (4); Basketing (5); Laser and basketing (1); Negative ureteroscopy (6)

n/a (10-45)

16 : 1

0

26.0 (12-49)

0

0

10.0 (1-24)

0

0

Ganpule et al., [20]

URS (1)

6 Fr pc (1)

Basketing (1)

20.0 (n/a)

3 : 0

0

36.0 (10-58)

0

0

36.0 (10-58)

0

0

PLT (2)

12 Fr nephroscope (2)

Basketing (2)

n/a

Pushkar et al., [22]

URS (7) URS+PLT (7)

6/7.5 Fr su (11); 5.3 Fr fu (3)

Laser+basketing (3); Pneumatic+forceps (2); Basket only (1)

28.0 (22-49)

13 : 1

0

12.0 (6-18)

0

Mild graft dysfunction, 2 (n/a)

16.0 (12-24)

0

0

Sarier et al., [11]

URS (6)

6/7.5 Fr su (6); 7.5 Fr fu (1); 8/9.8 Fr 12° pc (6)

Laser and basketing (6)

12.5 (9-20)

12 : 1

0

0

n/a

0

49.6 (14-101)

0

0

PLT (7)

8/9.8 Fr 12° pc (1)

Laser and basketing (1)

3.1 (1-8)

Urinary leakage, 1 (IIIb)

Lin et al., [10]

URS (10)

6.5/8.5 Fr su (3); 6.5/8.5 Fr fu (7)

Forceps (3); Laser+basketing (7)

21.2 (14-31)

10 : 0

0

12.0 (n/a)

0

0

12.0 (n/a)

0

0

Barki et al., [8]

URS (1)

fu (1)

Laser (1)

17.0 (n/a)

1 : 0

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Fr: French; fu: flexible ureteroscope; OT: operative time; pc: pediatric cystoscope; PLT: pyelolithotomy; su: semirigid ureteroscope; URS: ureteroscopy. According to the Clavien-Dindo Classification System.