Behavioural Neurology

Review Article

Production of Verb Tense in Agrammatic Aphasia: A Meta-Analysis and Further Data

Table 2

Individual participant data from the studies included in the meta-analysis.


Reference	Language	Task and response	Patient	Age/gender	MPO	Lesion/aphasia	Number correct/total
Reference	Language	Task and response	Patient	Age/gender	MPO	Lesion/aphasia	Neutral	Past	Present	Future

Bastiaanse et al. (2004), page 129 (Table 1) [64]	Dutch	SC, verbal	B1	NR	NR	NR/Broca’s		14/30	18/30
			B2	NR	NR	NR/Broca’s		15/30	21/30
			B3	NR	NR	NR/Broca’s		18/30	10/30

Bastiaanse et al. (2011), pages 671-672 (Appendices 3 and 4) [36]	Chinese	SPP, verbal	C1	42/M	127	LCVA/Broca’s	20/20	11/20	1/20	1/20
			C2	22/M	96	TBI/Broca’s	20/20	12/20	6/20	6/20
			C3	50/M	97	LCVA/Broca’s	19/20	13/20	13/20	18/20
			C4	41/M	180	LCVA/Broca’s	18/20	0/20	1/20	0/20
			C5	55/M	92	LCVA/Broca’s	20/20	10/20	7/20	16/20
			C6	65/M	204	LCVA/Broca’s	20/20	2/20	0/20	0/20
			C7	33/M	125	LCVA/Broca’s	16/20	16/20	20/20	20/20
			C8	55/M	156	LCVA/Broca’s	17/20	5/20	8/20	8/20
			C10	50/M	177	LCVA/Broca’s	20/20	0/20	0/20	0/20
			C11	51/M	212	LCVA/Broca’s	11/20	5/20	6/20	4/20
	English	SPP, verbal	E1	52/M	59	LCVA/Broca’s	16/20	13/20	19/20	19/20
			E2	47/M	55	LCVA/Broca’s	17/20	18/20	16/20	20/20
			E3	64/M	220	LCVA/Broca’s	19/20	3/20	13/20	12/20
			E4	48/F	23	LCVA/Broca’s	3/20	12/20	19/20	12/20
			E5	53/M	108	LCVA/Broca’s	20/20	12/20	18/20	19/20
			E6	60/F	61	LCVA/Broca’s	19/20	6/20	4/20	7/20
			E7	53/M	43	RCVA/Broca’s	20/20	14/20	19/20	19/20
			E8	68/M	180	TBI/Broca’s	3/20	4/20	12/20	4/20
			E9	74/F	36	LCVA/Broca’s	16/20	6/20	20/20	19/20
			E10	54/M	39	LCVA/Broca’s	18/20	17/20	16/20	13/20
			E11	58/M	226	LCVA/Broca’s	16/20	12/20	20/20	20/20
			E12	37/M	34	LCVA/Broca’s	4/20	2/20	12/20	3/20
	Turkish	SPP, verbal	T1	68/M	2	LCVA/Broca’s		6/20	17/20	17/20
			T2	54/M	5	LCVA/Broca’s		4/20	9/20	7/20
			T3	49/F	84	LCVA/Broca’s		11/20	15/20	18/20
			T4	43/F	4	LCVA/Broca’s		10/20	20/20	15/20
			T5	68/M	1	LCVA/Broca’s		11/20	16/20	18/20
			T6	39/F	7	LCVA/Broca’s		10/20	16/20	18/20
			T7	65/M	12	LCVA/Broca’s		6/20	4/20	17/20
			T8	59/M	2	LCVA/Broca’s		13/20	18/20	18/20

Clahsen and Ali (2009), page 446 (Table 6) [11]	English	SC, pointing	BG	36/M	60	NR/Broca’s		8/10	10/10
			JS	65/M	96	NR/Broca’s		2/10	8/10
			KC	78/M	96	NR/Broca’s		3/10	6/10
			RC	77/M	24	NR/Broca’s		8/10	6/10
			JP	68/M	60	NR/Broca’s		10/10	7/10
			KS	66/M	18	NR/Broca’s		9/10	6/10
			PB	82/M	36	NR/Broca’s		6/10	5/10
			BM	52/M	36	NR/Broca’s		9/10	5/10
			BR	82/M	36	NR/Broca’s		6/10	3/10
		GJ, verbal	BG			NR/Broca’s		15/20	15/20
			JS			NR/Broca’s		11/20	12/20
			KC			NR/Broca’s		13/20	12/20
			RC			NR/Broca’s		12/20	11/20
			JP			NR/Broca’s		18/20	16/20
			KS			NR/Broca’s		13/20	14/20
			PB			NR/Broca’s		17/20	11/20
			BM			NR/Broca’s		11/20	11/20
			BR			NR/Broca’s		15/20	14/20

Dickey et al. (2008) [61]	English	GJ, keyboard	A01	60/F	180	NR/Broca’s	27/30	26/60	16/30	11/30
			A02	63/F	132	NR/Broca’s	28/30	44/60	29/30	29/30
			A03	56/F	168	NR/Broca’s	26/30	36/60	14/30	15/30
			A04	57/F	48	NR/Broca’s	21/30	27/60	14/30	15/30
			A05	50/M	108	NR/Broca’s	18/30	24/60	14/30	14/30
			A06	36/F	36	NR/Broca’s	19/30	30/60	14/30	14/30
			A07	68/F	144	NR/Broca’s	23/30	32/60	14/30	16/30
			A08	66/F	84	NR/Broca’s	23/30	39/60	16/30	18/30
			A09	57/M	48	NR/Broca’s	7/30	4/60	4/30	4/30
			A10	36/F	24	NR/Broca’s	24/30	37/60	14/30	14/30

Dragoy and Bastiaanse (2013), page 127 (Appendix 3) [29]	Russian	SPP, verbal	1	31/F	35	NR/nonfluent		27/40	15/20	8/20
			2	32/F	29	NR/nonfluent		31/40	11/20	10/20
			3	33/F	20	NR/nonfluent		20/40	12/20	5/20
			4	35/M	70	NR/nonfluent		23/40	17/20	5/20
			5	36/F	29	NR/nonfluent		19/40	17/20	10/20
			6	46/M	16	NR/nonfluent		20/40	14/20	15/20
			7	68/M	29	NR/nonfluent		20/40	15/20	18/20

Duman and Bastiaanse (2008), page 9 (Appendix A)[37]	Turkish	SC, verbal	B1	66/F	2.5	LCVA/agrammatic		16/30		15/30
			B2	70/M	6	LCVA/agrammatic		4/30		18/30
			B3	44/F	16	LCVA/agrammatic		14/30		13/30
			B4	47/F	26	LCVA/agrammatic		11/30		12/30
			B5	40/M	28	LCVA/agrammatic		13/30		15/30
			B6	26/F	120	TBI/agrammatic		16/30		16/30
			B7	75/M	20	LCVA/agrammatic		3/30		19/30

Faroqi-Shah and Thompson (2004), page 492 (Figure 3) [42]	English	SPPi, verbal	CH	56/M	90	LCVA/Broca’s		2/17	14/17	1/17
			MK	54/M	12	LCVA/Broca’s		3/17	0/17	7/17
			MR	44/F	45	LCVA/Broca’s		3/17	13/17	2/17
			JP	65/M	30	LCVA/Broca’s		1/17	2/17	10/17
			MD	62/M	120	LCVA/Broca’s		3/17	9/17	3/17
			JO	69/M	88	LCVA/Broca’s		7/17	3/17	7/17
			RH	64/M	100	LCVA/Broca’s		9/17	2/17	0/17
			LD	52/F	14	LCVA/Broca’s		6/17	0/17	10/17

Faroqi-Shah and Thompson (2007), pages 139-140 (Figures 2 and 3) [12]	English	SC, verbal	B1	55/M	156	LCVA/Broca’s	11/15	19/30	14/15
			B2	58/M	48	LCVA/Broca’s	15/15	18/30	14/15
			B3	59/M	168	LCVA/Broca’s	13/15	17/30	5/15
			B4	64/M	60	LCVA/Broca’s	10/15	17/30	8/15
			B5	55/F	108	LCVA/Broca’s	11/15	14/30	5/15
			B6	68/M	120	LCVA/Broca’s	9/15	11/30	5/15
			B7	59/F	96	LCVA/Broca’s	12/15	12/30	10/15
			B8	63/M	108	LCVA/Broca’s	12/15	20/30	5/15
			B9	66/M	60	LCVA/Broca’s	14/15	14/30	8/15
			B10	55/F	72	LCVA/Broca’s	15/15	11/30	5/15
		SC, verbal	B1			LCVA/Broca’s		3/15	10/15	7/15
			B2			LCVA/Broca’s		5/15	8/15	8/15
			B3			LCVA/Broca’s		10/15	8/15	9/15
			B4			LCVA/Broca’s		5/15	9/15	10/15
			B5			LCVA/Broca’s		7/15	10/15	7/15
			B6			LCVA/Broca’s		8/15	7/15	7/15
			B7			LCVA/Broca’s		8/15	5/15	8/15
			B8			LCVA/Broca’s		8/15	8/15	9/15
			B9			LCVA/Broca’s		3/15	9/15	8/15

Fyndanis et al. (2012), page 1140 (Table 4) [31]	Greek	SC, verbal	GT	44/M	4.5	LCVA/agrammatic		8/21	12/16	12/19
Fyndanis et al. (2012), page 1140 (Table 4) [31]	Greek	SC, verbal	GL	59/M	38	LCVA/agrammatic		2/21	8/16	9/19

Jonkers and de Bruin (2009), page 1265 (Appendix 2) [65]	Dutch	SC, verbal	B1	80/M	26	NR/Broca’s		16/20	14/20
			B2	70/M	12	NR/Broca’s		2/20	16/20
			B3	41/F	4	NR/Broca’s		10/20	19/20
			B4	55/M	3	NR/Broca’s		19/20	19/20
			B5	41/M	49	NR/Broca’s		5/20	2/20
			B6	78/M	42	NR/Broca’s		11/20	20/20
			B7	41/F	4	NR/Broca’s		16/20	13/20

Nanousi et al. (2006), pages 220, 223, and 226 (Tables 6, 8, and 10) [21]	Greek	SPP, verbal	DS	66/M	48	LCVA/Broca’s		31/60	25/60	15/30
			PA	61/M	48	LCVA/Broca’s		29/60	32/60	13/30
			ZA	41/M	36	LCVA/Broca’s		25/60	19/60	9/30
			AS	38/M	96	LCVA/Broca’s		28/60	28/60	15/30
			AJ	55/M	72	LCVA/Broca’s		23/60	19/60	10/30
			RS	46/M	108	LCVA/Broca’s		25/60	25/60	12/30
		SPP, verbal	DS			LCVA/Broca’s		19/60		21/60
			PA			LCVA/Broca’s		23/60		32/60
			ZA			LCVA/Broca’s		11/60		20/60
			AS			LCVA/Broca’s		23/60		33/60
			AJ			LCVA/Broca’s		2/60		18/60
			RS			LCVA/Broca’s		15/60		25/60
		SC, verbal	DS			LCVA/Broca’s		26/48	34/48	13/24
			PA			LCVA/Broca’s		34/48	35/48	11/24
			ZA			LCVA/Broca’s		25/48	27/48	12/24
			AS			LCVA/Broca’s		30/48	32/48	16/24
			AJ			LCVA/Broca’s		26/48	30/48	10/24
			RS			LCVA/Broca’s		29/48	27/48	14/24

Wenzlaff and Clahsen (2004), page 64 (Table 4) [15]	German	SC, verbal	DB	58/F	276	LCVA/Broca’s		14/20	14/20
			EL	49/F	264	LCVA/Broca’s		19/20	14/20
			KM	84/F	24	LCVA/Broca’s		12/20	17/20
			MH	59/M	180	LCVA/Broca’s		12/20	15/20
			HM	66/M	144	LCVA/Broca’s		17/20	13/20
			WH	70/M	192	LCVA/Broca’s		8/20	17/20
			OP	69/M	24	LCVA/Broca’s		12/20	7/20
		GJ, verbal	DB			LCVA/Broca’s		10/20	10/20
			EL			LCVA/Broca’s		10/20	10/20
			KM			LCVA/Broca’s		12/20	11/20
			MH			LCVA/Broca’s		12/20	11/20
			HM			LCVA/Broca’s		18/20	17/20
			WH			LCVA/Broca’s		10/20	10/20
			OP			LCVA/Broca’s		10/20	10/20

GJ: grammaticality judgment; LCVA: left cerebrovascular accident; MPO: months post onset; NR: not reported; RCVA: right cerebrovascular accident; SC: sentence completion; SPP: sentence production priming; SPPi: sentence production with picture description; TBI: traumatic brain injury; months post onset calculated from years in the original study.