Research Article

Immune Centroids Oversampling Method for Binary Classification

Table 3

The Shaffer test for the oversampling techniques with NN using the AUC measure.

NoneSMOTESMOTE + ENNSL-SMOTEADASYNICOTEICOTE + ENN

NoneX−(0.001)=(0.000)=(0.009)=(0.957)−(0.000)−(0.000)
SMOTE+(0.001)X=(0.633)=(0.441)+(0.001)−(0.000)−(0.000)
SMOTE + ENN=(0.000)=(0.633)X=(0.212)+(0.000)−(0.000)−(0.000)
SL-SMOTE=(0.009)=(0.441)=(0.212)X=(0.010)−(0.000)−(0.000)
ADASYN=(0.957)−(0.001)−(0.000)=(0.010)X−(0.000)−(0.000)
ICOTE+(0.000)+(0.000)+(0.000)+(0.000)+(0.000)X=(0.167)
ICOTE + ENN+(0.000)+(0.000)+(0.000)+(0.000)+(0.000)=(0.167)X