CDMBE: A Case Description Model Based on Evidence

Table 2

The influence of evidences on final credibility.

The order of proof	CDMBE	Fenton model
Prosecution evidence presented
(1) Motive evidence: maid testifies Vole was present: 12–19	0.45	0.526
(2) Blood matches F evidence: items 25–31	0.60	0.865
(3) Romaine testifies Vole admitted guilt: items 20–24	0.91	0.966
Defense evidence presented
(4) Vole testifies he was not present: item 32	0.86	0.969
(5) Maid evidence accuracy: items 33–39	0.82	0.913
(6) Blood matches Vole: items 40–42	0.55	0.644
(7) Vole shows scar: item 43	0.45	0.404
(8) Letters as evidence: items 44–47	0.11	0.149