Review Article

Progress in EEG-Based Brain Robot Interaction Systems

Table 3

Feature classification methods in different EEG paradigms.

EEG paradigmsAuthorsClassification methods

SSVEPChu et al. [125]LDA, 3 classes (20, 15, 12 Hz)
Bi et al. [126]LDA, 2 classes (12, 13 Hz)
Oikonomou et al. [92]LDA, 5 classes (6.66, 7.5, 8.57, 10, 12 Hz)
Maggi et al. [127]RLDA, 5 classes (6, 7, 8, 10 Hz, idle)
Singa and Haseena [128]SVM, 4 classes (7, 9, 11, 13 Hz)
Bi et al. [129]SVM, 3 classes (12, 13 Hz, idle)
Sakurada et al. [130]SVM, 4 classes (6, 7, 8, nonfixation)
Jian and Tang [35]OVO RBF SVM, 5 classes (8, 10, 12, 14, 15 Hz)
Cecotti and Gräser [131]TDNN, 5 classes (13, 14, 15, 16, 17 Hz)
Cecotti [132]CNN, 5 classes (6.66, 7.5, 8.57, 10, 12 Hz)
Hartmann and Kluge [133]HMM, 3 classes (10, 12, 15 Hz)
Ko et al. [134]kNN, 2 classes (15, 20 Hz)
Oikonomou et al. [92]kNN, 5 classes (6.66, 7.5, 8.57, 10, 12 Hz)

P300Gareis et al. [135]LDA, P300 Speller
Onishi and Natsume [136]Ensemble Stepwise LDA, P300 Speller
Elwardy et al. [137]Disjunctive Normal Unsupervised LDA, P300 Speller
Li et al. [31]SVM, P300 speller
Raju et al. [138]Least Square SVM (LS-SVM), Competition III, Dataset II (P300 Speller)
Li et al. [139]Self-Training Semisupervised SVM, P300 Speller
Yang et al. [140]LVQNN, 7 classes (oddball paradigm)
Turnip et al. [141]MNN, raw data in Hoffmann et al.
Cecotti and Gräser [142]CNN, P300 Speller
Helmy et al. [143]HMM, raw data in Hoffmann et al.
Speier et al. [144]HMM, P300 Speller
Syan and Harnarinesingh [80]kNN, P300 Speller, BCI Competition II
Chikara and Ko [145]kNN, 2 classes

MIChen et al. [32]LDA, 2 classes (left or right hand)
Steyrl et al. [146]Shrinkage RLDA, 2 classes (right hand and feet)
Vidaurre et al. [147]KALDA, 2 classes (left or right hand)
Rathipriya et al. [148]SVM, 2 classes, Dataset IVa (right hand, foot) and IVb (left hand, foot), BCI Competition III
Oskoei et al. [149]supervised and unsupervised SVM, 3 classes, Dataset V, BCI Competition III (left or right hand, word association)
Siuly and Li [150]LS-SVM, 2 classes, Dataset IVa and IVb, BCI Competition III
Hamedi et al. [151]BP, 3 classes (left or right hand, tongue)
Wei et al. [152]LVQNN, 2 classes (left or right hand)
Hazrati and Erfanian [153]APNN, 2 classes (left or right hand), BCI competition 2003, data set III
Haselsteiner and Pfurtscheller [154]TDNN, 2 classes (left or right hand)
Siuly et al. [155]Naïve Bayes, 2 classes, Dataset IVa and IVb, BCI Competition III
Obermaier et al. [156]HMM, 2 classes (left or right hand)
Suk and Lee [157]HMM, Dataset IIa, BCI Competition IV (2008),
4 classes (left or right hand, feet, tongue)
kNN, 2 classes (left or right hand),
Bashar et al. [89]BCI Competition 2003 data set (motor imagery III)
Bashar and Bhuiyan [158]BCI Competition II data set (GRAZ motor imagery III)
Diana Eva and Tarniceriu [159]kNN, 2 classes (left or right hand), BCI Competition 2002