A Transition Control Mechanism for Artificial Bee Colony (ABC) Algorithm

Table 18

Average execution times for ABC algorithms for evaluations.

Function		ABC	p-ABC	tlABC	p-tlABC
	Mean	3.750697	2.237923	2.736264	2.046743
	Std. dev.	1.452007e − 02	1.226359e − 01	8.310174e − 02	1.215219e − 01
	Mean	9.256972	2.915909	7.893101	2.871335
	Std. dev.	1.598457e − 01	1.366038e − 01	2.330977e − 01	1.312227e − 01
	Mean	21.025269	6.374496	19.874767	6.265583
	Std. dev.	1.046854e + 00	5.996401e − 01	5.232140e − 02	2.698154e − 01
	Mean	7.578933	2.513816	6.203705	2.477468
	Std. dev.	2.244815e − 01	1.114650e − 01	6.575150e − 02	1.411108e − 01
	Mean	12.976374	4.107876	11.483484	4.201704
	Std. dev.	7.728847e − 01	1.818864e − 01	4.867455e − 01	2.448148e − 01
	Mean	17.730652	5.094427	16.961526	5.453327
	Std. dev.	5.746598e − 01	2.274524e − 01	1.999204e − 01	4.123372e − 01
	Mean	39.306712	13.101851	36.686701	13.032504
	Std. dev.	1.757894e − 01	1.643728e + 00	3.302583e − 01	1.533142e + 00
	Mean	22.354618	6.571634	21.359891	7.268796
	Std. dev.	1.330038e + 00	5.170688e − 01	8.313849e − 02	9.220289e − 01
	Mean	53.017629	48.477193	49.387006	19.334184
	Std. dev.	5.860643e − 01	4.389076e − 01	2.572918e + 00	3.126027e + 00