A Systematic and Meta-Analysis Survey of Whale Optimization Algorithm

Table 11

Comparison results of WOA-BAT and WOA CEC2019.

Function	WOA		WOA-BAT
	avg	std	avg	Std
1	2.10E + 10	3.57E + 10	7.60E + 07	4.16E + 08
2	1.84E + 01	1.61E − 02	1.75E + 01	1.21E − 01
3	1.37E + 01	7.23E − 15	1.27E + 01	9.53E − 04
4	3.48E + 02	1.72E + 02	2.12E + 03	1.01E + 03
5	3.03E + 00	4.86E − 01	2.44E + 00	6.67E − 01
6	1.03E + 01	1.39E + 00	1.11E + 01	1.55E + 00
7	6.14E + 02	2.98E + 02	6.06E + 02	3.90E + 02
8	6.03E + 00	5.66E − 01	5.72E + 00	7.18E − 01
9	5.93E + 00	6.85E − 01	2.28E + 01	4.92E + 01
10	2.13E + 01	1.35E − 01	2.12E + 01	2.26E − 01