Identification of Alcoholism Based on Wavelet Renyi Entropy and Three-Segment Encoded Jaya Algorithm

Table 10

Results of 10 × 10-fold cross validation of four training algorithms.

MOGA [11]	Sen	Spc	Acc	PSO [12]	Sen	Spc	Acc
R1	78.07	75.21	76.60	R1	90.35	90.91	90.64
R2	76.32	79.34	77.87	R2	87.72	87.60	87.66
R3	72.81	77.69	75.32	R3	87.72	90.08	88.94
R4	75.44	77.69	76.60	R4	92.98	93.39	93.19
R5	76.32	76.86	76.60	R5	88.60	90.08	89.36
R6	75.44	75.21	75.32	R6	89.47	87.60	88.51
R7	78.95	80.99	80.00	R7	88.60	87.60	88.09
R8	76.32	73.55	74.89	R8	93.86	90.91	92.34
R9	73.68	81.82	77.87	R9	90.35	92.56	91.49
R10	79.82	80.17	80.00	R10	92.98	94.21	93.62
Avr	76.32 ± 2.19	77.85 ± 2.72	77.11 ± 1.83	Avr	90.26 ± 2.28	90.50 ± 2.41	90.38 ± 2.18
BCO [13]	Sen	Spc	Acc	MACS [14]	Sen	Spc	Acc
R1	87.72	85.12	86.38	R1	84.21	85.95	85.11
R2	92.11	90.91	91.49	R2	86.84	89.26	88.09
R3	87.72	88.43	88.09	R3	81.58	85.95	83.83
R4	85.96	90.91	88.51	R4	84.21	79.34	81.70
R5	84.21	86.78	85.53	R5	80.70	83.47	82.13
R6	87.72	87.60	87.66	R6	82.46	85.12	83.83
R7	91.23	90.08	90.64	R7	83.33	84.30	83.83
R8	91.23	85.12	88.09	R8	84.21	86.78	85.53
R9	84.21	85.12	84.68	R9	86.84	86.78	86.81
R10	84.21	91.74	88.09	R10	88.60	86.78	87.66
Avr	87.63 ± 3.05	88.18 ± 2.61	87.91 ± 2.09	Avr	84.30 ± 2.50	85.37 ± 2.64	84.85 ± 2.19
RCBBO [15]	Sen	Spc	Acc
R1	84.21	90.08	87.23
R2	88.60	90.91	89.79
R3	88.60	90.08	89.36
R4	93.86	93.39	93.62
R5	91.23	90.91	91.06
R6	92.11	93.39	92.77
R7	90.35	88.43	89.36
R8	91.23	90.08	90.64
R9	90.35	89.26	89.79
R10	88.60	87.60	88.09
Avr	89.91 ± 2.62	90.41 ± 1.88	90.17 ± 1.95